Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by tempay on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:19PM
(#20861844)
Refuse does imply a certain level of impoliteness or malice. The article only states that spaceX said they wouldn’t be taking any action and later states
> Krag suspected it could be something to do with SpaceX’s electric propulsion system, which “maybe is not reacting so fast” as the chemical propulsion on board Aeolus.
Not acting because you don’t have choice doesn’t count as refusing.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by ixf on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:28PM
(#20861895)
"unable to avoid existing satellites in orbit being entered into" is, in my book, worse than "we just cba"
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by manicdee on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:04PM
(#20862908)
You need to update your book to reflect the reality of deorbiting a dead satellite.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by perl4ever on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:27PM
(#20861893)
Well, it counts as refusing, but it doesn't have the same connotation as when you omit context.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by a3n on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:17PM
(#20862975)
> Not acting because you don’t have choice doesn’t count as refusing.
It does beg the question whether you should be there at all.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by adventured on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:57PM
(#20863124)
It doesn't beg that question at all.
By that premise every space organization should shut down. Nothing should ever go up again. What if something went wrong? What if every mission wasn't perfect? What if someone lost control of a satellite or space station (eg Tiangong-1)? What if people died? (NASA, Soviet Space Program)
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by greglindahl on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:57PM
(#20863126)
Every deorbiting satellite passes through lower orbits. Many of them passively.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by a3n on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @02:33AM
(#20864139)
They are are where they are by choice. It's a de-orbiting exercise. If they can't maneuver where they are now because of their propulsion design, they have the same problem in a normal orbit. So I wonder whether this design enables them to be a good and safe neighbor.
> they ... declined for reasons
"Declined" and "refused" are synonyms. SpaceX did refuse to move the satellite.