Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by Retric on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:20PM
(#20861852)
Now it’s true the article used refused, but it does not actually back that up. ESA does not have the authority to tell satellite operateors to do something.
“we informed SpaceX” They where informed of a 1/1,000 risk and declined to take action. Refused implies someone was telling them to do something rather than notifying them of the situation.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by cdubzzz on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:39PM
(#20861950)
The "informed" bit really is telling here. It seems to imply that the author knows ESA didn't "ask" for anything from SpaceX. That or the author doesn't actually know what the communication was.
Either way this is sensationalist and worth a flag.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by BurningFrog on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:53PM
(#20862012)
Not if they declined because (1) it was impossible for them to do it or (2) they explained it wasn't needed.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by FireBeyond on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:32PM
(#20862502)
If 1, they should be absolutely liable for any damages, considering they actively moved INTO the orbit of the ESA weather satellite in the first place (for their own "testing").
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by mcguire on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:02PM
(#20862056)
"...they explained it wasn't needed."
Well, somebody seems to have needed to maneuver.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by cdash on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:21PM
(#20862141)
So? They have that right, what they don't have a right is to demand someone else take action. Just because one party believes something to be necessary does not actually make it so.
Re:SpaceX Refused to Move Satellite at Risk of Collision wit...
by ClumsyPilot on Monday September 02, 2019 @09:06PM
(#20862917)
So they endanger billion dollar satellites and the space station, and not care cause their stuff is cheap?
So, they refused. That's what that word means.