News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by duxup on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:09PM (#20763984)
Can someone explain what I just read?
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by tptacek on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:11PM (#20763991)
A McSweeney's piece about Bentham vs. Mill utilitarianism.

If you're interested, they also have some interesting things to say about the upcoming decorative gourd season.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by sitkack on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:31PM (#20764095)
Vi vs Emacs for a branch of philosophy.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by _iyig on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:43PM (#20764169)
The idea is that the reader - briefly acquainted with Bentham and Mill as part of their undergraduate education - has a smug, knowing chuckle when they recognize these references. (Similar to “clapter,” I’d call this a “snuckle” piece.) The quality of the satire itself is irrelevant. Substantive satire is actually impossible: the author briefly recaps Mill and Bentham’s differences for that “oh yeah, I remember now” feel-good reader moment, but can’t get too far into the details as this would alienate the reader, reminding them just how much of their education they’ve forgotten (if they ever did the assigned readings in the first place).

Cynical attitude aside, I’m not sure why this is on HN. It doesn’t seem particularly insightful, interesting, or funny.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by Throw_Away_9812 on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:40AM (#20765301)
Not sure why you were down-voted. That's obviously the main value of the thing. Maybe you've hit a wound spot.

>Cynical attitude aside, I’m not sure why this is on HN. It doesn’t seem particularly insightful, interesting, or funny.

The average HN reader does probably know enough about philosophy to know the differences between Bentham and Mill but not enough to make that seem trivial.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by tomlock on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:57AM (#20765367)
As a smug postgraduate I find it kinda odd I'd be called out as an undergraduate, since I found the article funny. Cheers.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by _iyig on Thursday August 22, 2019 @03:54AM (#20765674)
I’m generalizing based on my own experience here (and taking some polemic license), but that’s all one can do.

If I’ve misjudged the HN audience and enough do appreciate this link, I can’t/won’t argue with their upvotes!

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by dr_dshiv on Thursday August 22, 2019 @12:27PM (#20769757)
The article is an enjoyable and novel intro to philosophies regarding the underlying value systems that we optimize for as a society. That is intellectually interesting to me.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by onemoresoop on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:23PM (#20764051)
It’s satire
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by paggle on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:30PM (#20764089)
It’s a satire illustrating the phenomenon of people getting into the most acrimonious fights with the people ideologically closest to them. It’s likely specifically directed at American liberals and their tendency to viciously claw at each other over whether Bernie’s record on race is ideologically pure enough or Hillary is too “establishment,” weakening the pursuit of their common interests against opponents who are a million times farther from them than the gap between them.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by tomlock on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:33PM (#20764107)
I think a more straightforward reading is that it is satire directed at religious people.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by paggle on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:34PM (#20764114)
Of course that’s the more straightforward reading. An even more straightforward reading is the literal one. Different readers choose different levels of indirection.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by jacobolus on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:17AM (#20765167)
More realistically it was written by someone who once as a bored undergraduate (apparently at Princeton) sat through a philosophy course where he read Bentham and Mill (and also Hegel and Kant), thought that the differences between Bentham and Mill were a bit blown out of proportion, and had an amusing idea about how to write a satirical letter where this got taken to an extreme.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by paggle on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:35AM (#20768493)
So you choose the totally literal reading. Not what I’d choose, but also an understandable choice given that this is a technology and programming-oriented website.

I won’t say that the allegorical reading is more “correct,” but if you’d like some clues leading to it, look for the breadcrumbs like this: “And, even though Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill are ideologically similar, I refuse to let my son believe in Bentham’s very-slightly-different version of ethics.”

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by jacobolus on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:15PM (#20772422)
Yes, the whole thing is obviously a joke.

My point is, don’t take it too seriously.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by tomlock on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:50AM (#20768694)
The totally literal reading would be that someone actually got chewed out by their father for being a Benthamite.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by paggle on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:11PM (#20770854)
LOL, good point.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by tomlock on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:37PM (#20764133)
That's a very postmodern take! I personally think that most people will read this as a criticism of religious schisms, particularly considering the obvious implication that it's a parent talking to a child, rather than peers within an ideology. Also interesting it'd supposedly be taken as a criticism of a particular political ideology when all ideologies have schisms.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by viraptor on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:54PM (#20764230)
> considering the obvious implication that it's a parent talking to a child

This made me wonder how many kids are switching to a different branch of religion. I've seen a bit of moving to a completely different faith / no religion, but almost changes of denomination.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by yew on Thursday August 22, 2019 @04:26AM (#20765856)
I would expect it depends on personal experience. All ideologies have schisms, as you say.

The first thing that came to my mind was the local liberal and "materialist" (that is, Marxist) contingents fighting over definitions. (And that does involve a few parents!) But it's equally reminiscent of childhood Catholic versus Protestant conflicts. I only have more recent experience of one to privilege it over the other.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by tomlock on Thursday August 22, 2019 @07:45AM (#20766975)
Sure, but the idea that texts have different readings depending on perspective is a pretty postmodern one. I was criticizing the claim that the text was likely specifically directed at American liberals.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by Noumenon72 on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:19PM (#20764039)
A parody of how religious parents raise their children so that churches who allow adult baptism or female pastors barely even count as Christian, presenting these differences as though no good person doubts them.

I may be projecting a little bit.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by pjm331 on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:30PM (#20764088)
Hah seems pretty spot on to me. Was raised RC and always marveled at certain family members’ ability to become irate over small differences like these.

Religion/Philosophy (really many parts of the human experience), is often like DNA - 99.9% the same but it’s the 0.01% difference that gets all the attention

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by sterlind on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:43PM (#20764167)
Reminds me of what little I know of the split between the Salafi Muslims and the Sunni. IIRC, despite Salafi Islam developing from the teachings of Sunni cleric al-Wahhab, they view other Muslims as apostates, practicing shirk and therefore unforgivable sinners.

On the Christian side, some Seventh-Day Adventists apparently see the Catholic church as the "Whore of Babylon" and the pope as the antichrist. [0]

Maybe the closeness between two groups just means they can be really detailed and exact about why they hate each other.

0. https://www.catholic.com/tract/seventh-day-adventism

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by jacobolus on Thursday August 22, 2019 @01:53AM (#20765057)
> some Seventh-Day Adventists apparently see the Catholic church as the "Whore of Babylon"

That’s probably not too far off. My impression is that the Hebrew Bible was written by nomadic shepherds who despised cosmopolitan city-dwellers who they thought had loose morals. And similarly for the authors of the New Testament, who despised the Roman Empire of the day (“Babylon” here is thought to be a stand-in for Rome).

It is quite ironic that this became the holy teaching of the state religion of the Roman Empire a few centuries later.

(Disclaimer: I am not a religious person and am by no means an expert on the Bible.)

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by duxup on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:49PM (#20764198)
>9.9% the same but it’s the 0.01% difference that gets all the attention

Ah the good old:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism_of_small_difference...

Also:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WboggjN_G-4

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by waterhouse on Thursday August 22, 2019 @03:05AM (#20765401)
Once I saw this guy on a bridge about to jump. I said, "Don't do it!" He said, "Nobody loves me." I said, "God loves you. Do you believe in God?"

He said, "Yes." I said, "Are you a Christian or a Jew?" He said, "A Christian." I said, "Me, too! Protestant or Catholic?" He said, "Protestant." I said, "Me, too! What franchise?" He said, "Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Baptist or Southern Baptist?" He said, "Northern Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist or Northern Liberal Baptist?"

He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region, or Northern Conservative Baptist Eastern Region?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region." I said, "Me, too!"

Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1879, or Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912." I said, "Die, heretic!" And I pushed him over.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by simula67 on Thursday August 22, 2019 @12:09AM (#20764548)
To be fair, sometimes small looking differences can have a huge impact over long periods of time.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by jawns on Thursday August 22, 2019 @08:38AM (#20767339)
I know of no Christian denomination that prohibits adult baptism. But there are some that don't regard infant baptism as authentic. https://www.catholic.com/tract/infant-baptism
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by TheCoelacanth on Thursday August 22, 2019 @09:27AM (#20767767)
Denominations that practice infant baptism typically don't allow adults who were baptized as infants to be baptized. In fact, they imprisoned and executed many people for doing so.

Denominations that don't practice infant baptism would allow those adults to be baptized because they don't regard the first one as authentic.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by jawns on Thursday August 22, 2019 @11:45AM (#20769364)
Do you have a source for the claim related to imprisonment/execution in your first paragraph?

It's true that denominations that practice infant baptism usually don't allow adults who were baptized as infants to be re-baptized, because they consider the person to be already baptized, so there's no need.

But even in cases where denominations try diligently to avoid the case where they're conferring baptism on someone who may have already been baptized (as in the case of the Catholic church and conditional baptism), there are no penalties for baptizing someone who was already baptized. It's just sort of a pointless thing, unless you reject the idea that infant baptism is legitimate, in which case why belong to a denomination that practices infant baptism?

Maybe there were penalties in the past that I'm not aware of, so I'd love to learn more about the executions.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by TheCoelacanth on Thursday August 22, 2019 @09:16PM (#20773823)
This Washington Post article gives a good overview[1]. It's true that they don't execute people for it anymore, but that's just because they have eased up on their treatment of heretics in general, not because they have started condoning the practice.

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/2004/06/19/aton...

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by Avshalom on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:50PM (#20764209)
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by Camillo on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:51PM (#20764214)
A piece of period metafiction set in 2003.