Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite
by jacobolus on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:17AM
(#20765167)
More realistically it was written by someone who once as a bored undergraduate (apparently at Princeton) sat through a philosophy course where he read Bentham and Mill (and also Hegel and Kant), thought that the differences between Bentham and Mill were a bit blown out of proportion, and had an amusing idea about how to write a satirical letter where this got taken to an extreme.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite
by paggle on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:35AM
(#20768493)
So you choose the totally literal reading. Not what I’d choose, but also an understandable choice given that this is a technology and programming-oriented website.
I won’t say that the allegorical reading is more “correct,” but if you’d like some clues leading to it, look for the breadcrumbs like this: “And, even though Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill are ideologically similar, I refuse to let my son believe in Bentham’s very-slightly-different version of ethics.”
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite
by jacobolus on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:15PM
(#20772422)
Yes, the whole thing is obviously a joke.
My point is, don’t take it too seriously.