News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by _iyig on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:43PM (#20764169)
The idea is that the reader - briefly acquainted with Bentham and Mill as part of their undergraduate education - has a smug, knowing chuckle when they recognize these references. (Similar to “clapter,” I’d call this a “snuckle” piece.) The quality of the satire itself is irrelevant. Substantive satire is actually impossible: the author briefly recaps Mill and Bentham’s differences for that “oh yeah, I remember now” feel-good reader moment, but can’t get too far into the details as this would alienate the reader, reminding them just how much of their education they’ve forgotten (if they ever did the assigned readings in the first place).

Cynical attitude aside, I’m not sure why this is on HN. It doesn’t seem particularly insightful, interesting, or funny.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by Throw_Away_9812 on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:40AM (#20765301)
Not sure why you were down-voted. That's obviously the main value of the thing. Maybe you've hit a wound spot.

>Cynical attitude aside, I’m not sure why this is on HN. It doesn’t seem particularly insightful, interesting, or funny.

The average HN reader does probably know enough about philosophy to know the differences between Bentham and Mill but not enough to make that seem trivial.

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by tomlock on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:57AM (#20765367)
As a smug postgraduate I find it kinda odd I'd be called out as an undergraduate, since I found the article funny. Cheers.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by _iyig on Thursday August 22, 2019 @03:54AM (#20765674)
I’m generalizing based on my own experience here (and taking some polemic license), but that’s all one can do.

If I’ve misjudged the HN audience and enough do appreciate this link, I can’t/won’t argue with their upvotes!

Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite by dr_dshiv on Thursday August 22, 2019 @12:27PM (#20769757)
The article is an enjoyable and novel intro to philosophies regarding the underlying value systems that we optimize for as a society. That is intellectually interesting to me.