Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite
by tomlock on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:37PM
(#20764133)
That's a very postmodern take! I personally think that most people will read this as a criticism of religious schisms, particularly considering the obvious implication that it's a parent talking to a child, rather than peers within an ideology. Also interesting it'd supposedly be taken as a criticism of a particular political ideology when all ideologies have schisms.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite
by viraptor on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @10:54PM
(#20764230)
> considering the obvious implication that it's a parent talking to a child
This made me wonder how many kids are switching to a different branch of religion. I've seen a bit of moving to a completely different faith / no religion, but almost changes of denomination.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite
by yew on Thursday August 22, 2019 @04:26AM
(#20765856)
I would expect it depends on personal experience. All ideologies have schisms, as you say.
The first thing that came to my mind was the local liberal and "materialist" (that is, Marxist) contingents fighting over definitions. (And that does involve a few parents!) But it's equally reminiscent of childhood Catholic versus Protestant conflicts. I only have more recent experience of one to privilege it over the other.
Re:No Son of Mine Is Going to Be a Benthamite
by tomlock on Thursday August 22, 2019 @07:45AM
(#20766975)
Sure, but the idea that texts have different readings depending on perspective is a pretty postmodern one. I was criticizing the claim that the text was likely specifically directed at American liberals.