News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by belorn on Saturday August 17, 2019 @05:23PM (#20726496)
The advantage that people wanted to get is that in the end you also get a road.

Roads take up space, cost money to build and maintain. If you build it next to the road the road need twice the amount of space and still require the space, construction and material for the actually road. If you build it above the road you get all the issue of overhead roof on a road (trees that fall on it, wind, height limitation).

In addition to saving money by not actually building a normal road, the idea in most of solar roads projects is that it combines the work of putting internet and power cables into the ground.

That it currently do not work economically is the issue that the article showcase. Maybe it will never work and it always will be cheaper to simply build the road with current construction methods, put internet/power cables under it, buy large lands (farming land?) and construct regular solar parks.

Other concept of combining solar panels and building materials that is argued as more cost effective are roofs on houses. Same concept as solar road, ie that you get a roof and a solar panel in one without spending the work and material for both, but I have no idea if the economics is better than solar parks or if it is cheaper to just build normal roofs and go the route of getting land and building solar parks separately.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by mbrumlow on Saturday August 17, 2019 @06:10PM (#20726732)
> That it currently do not work economically is the issue that the article showcase.

It's more than that. We simply don't live in a world where physics is in favor for doing this.

Many people have done more than back of the envelope calculations to show this simply was a non starter.

Those (people who took money to build ) push this idea are either ignorant at best and dishonest at worst.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by Wowfunhappy on Saturday August 17, 2019 @07:07PM (#20727024)
I do wonder if the concept could work on a sidewalk, given that they aren't being perpetually driven over by 3,000+ pound vehicles.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by CydeWeys on Saturday August 17, 2019 @07:55PM (#20727207)
Water drainage is still going to be a big problem, as is damage/scratching caused by shoes, bicycle kickstands, trolleys, anything else with wheels that is pushed/pulled, you name it. Plus the simple fact that most sidewalks (at least here in the city) are often in the shadows of buildings.

It only makes sense to start thinking about sidewalks once you've covered all the roofs, which are way better in every sense.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by zimpenfish on Sunday August 18, 2019 @04:46AM (#20729035)
There's a solar bike path in Holland which did pretty well. Exceeded expected yield the first two years but then dropped back to slightly under.

https://en.solaroad.nl/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/prf1-ENG-S...

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by tinco on Sunday August 18, 2019 @07:15PM (#20733568)
It didn't do well, they just marketed the failure as a success, and they were at scamming a different municipality for a follow up 'experiment'.

Why can't they just work on something that makes sense?

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by ars on Saturday August 17, 2019 @09:14PM (#20727578)
The ground pressure from a truck is around 150 PSI. A woman wearing high heels can match, and even exceed that.

So the sidewalk would need to be just as strong as the road.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by mirimir on Sunday August 18, 2019 @01:00AM (#20728332)
It's not that simple. Looking at the damaged roadway, I see lots of punctate damage. That puzzled me until I read your comment. I'm pretty sure that it's gravel under truck tires. So the same force-concentration dynamic as high heels.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by pjc50 on Sunday August 18, 2019 @03:08AM (#20728716)
Not only that, a common problem round here (UK) is that trucks park partially on the pavement. They routinely crack two-inch/50mm thick concrete paving slabs. I'd like to see a solar panel that can withstand that.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by mensetmanusman on Saturday August 17, 2019 @10:23PM (#20727834)
Surprised this is getting down voted, this is a common example in physics 101 describing the concept of point pressure. Architects have to consider the point pressure of heels when designing certain walkways.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by kbutler on Saturday August 17, 2019 @11:26PM (#20728049)
Common physics example, but it disregards how women actually walk and stand in heels. They walk on their forefoot, rather than balancing their weight on the heel.

https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/The-higher-the-heel-th...

Shows less than 30 N/cm^2 (40 PSI) for women in heels - and higher heels result in lower heel pressure. Forefoot pressure is higher, despite the larger surface area.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by reitzensteinm on Saturday August 17, 2019 @11:51PM (#20728129)
Yeah, and a heel surface area of 32.3 +/- 4.4 cm^2. There are shoes with heel surface area of sub 1cm^2.

I don't think the study invalidates parents claim, if anything it more it less supports it.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by mbrumlow on Sunday August 18, 2019 @09:42AM (#20730074)
Even so. It would be a flaw to not consider that at some point in time a women may put full force on the heel. Thus the example is valid.

Also I have seen high hees being abused by walking mostly on the heel.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by egdod on Saturday August 17, 2019 @10:21PM (#20727820)
The woman in heels doesn’t ever slam on her brakes and skid.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Saturday August 17, 2019 @11:23PM (#20728042)
That applies sheer stress to the road, but it doesn't really impact the compressive force or pressure applied, right?
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by tom_mellior on Sunday August 18, 2019 @03:13AM (#20728728)
Sidewalks are still flat on the ground, which is not great in much of the world (like Normandy) where sunlight comes in at an angle. You would still get some generation, but would it be worth it compared to cells mounted elsewhere at a better angle, with less need for hardening, and less accumulation of dirt? Doing this on the sidewalks would add a lot of costs and complications.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by flukus on Monday August 19, 2019 @09:47PM (#20743209)
Better to build it above the sidewalk where it can be angled more efficiently and provide people with some sun/rain shelter.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by cs02rm0 on Sunday August 18, 2019 @03:46AM (#20728828)
Maybe a motorway hard shoulder would be preferable to a live lane.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by 6nf on Saturday August 17, 2019 @06:31PM (#20726846)
So the problem is that a normal road costs on the order of $3 million per mile, and a solar road costs... 10 times as much. And it doesn't last as long.

It just does not make sense.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by surelyyoujest on Saturday August 17, 2019 @08:25PM (#20727358)
It is plausible, but how much money is actually saved if you need to build panels that can stand wear and tear of vehicles above them? Surely the engineering is different and more costly than regular panels that don't need to be built to withstand cars rolling over, plus their maintenance, no?
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by evilmushroom on Saturday August 17, 2019 @09:28PM (#20727641)
Or just put them above the road then? :P
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by zdragnar on Sunday August 18, 2019 @01:30AM (#20728426)
Put them above the road and tall trucks can't go through anymore. Plus, the support structures needed suddenly become obstacles for cars to hit when making emergency maneuvers or drivers lose control, and now you've got tons of glass shards, electrified wires and steel supports falling down onto the freeway.

Under the road is literally the only option, and it's a terrible option at that. Rooftops - or better yet, former farm fields- are always going to be cheaper and more efficient.

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by atq2119 on Sunday August 18, 2019 @02:31AM (#20728613)
There's a standard maximum height for vehicles that is taken into account for freeway bridges, so your first argument is nonsense.

The rest still stands, of course. If you absolutely do want to put solar panels in the same place as cars, starting with parking lots is clearly a better idea. Fewer problems with high speed collisions, the electricity is generated closer to where it's needed, and people will be thankful for having parking in the shade. (Still more expensive than putting panels on a roof or field of course.)

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by zdragnar on Sunday August 18, 2019 @11:42AM (#20730858)
"Nonsense" would only apply if practice were as good as theory; a very very brief Google search will net plenty of results for freeway overpasses and pedestrian bridges being hit. One example:

https://www.cbs58.com/news/truck-wedged-under-bridge-shuts-d...

Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by Can_Not on Sunday August 18, 2019 @02:42PM (#20732019)
This isn't really a criticism of the core idea to just say "what if somebody built it stupidly low", traffic lights have been fine my entire life and maybe some highways will have to be skipped or doubled for NASA/ military purposes.
Re:The first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing... by scotty79 on Sunday August 18, 2019 @06:01AM (#20729298)
You get two in one but for double the price of both combined and then some. Not to mention the horrible quality and durability of the two things you get.