News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by AkshatM on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @12:48AM (#20682909)
This is not only not new, but is the standard model for how home loans work in Islamic finance.

Since Islam forbids collecting interest, Sharia-compliant banks and lending institutions instead buy the asset (in this case, a house), and lease it out to the would-be borrower on an installment basis until a predetermined sum has been paid. At that point, ownership can either remain with the bank (but with zero installments) or transition to the would-be borrower.

About the only thing Arrived seems to be doing differently is allowing homeowners to change houses without affecting how much they're paying towards any house - in other words, you're really purchasing a subscription to a collection of homes.

I find this latter concept intriguing, but hard to reason about competitively. Wouldn't the subscription price point have to be higher than interest on a single home loan to offset the average cost of all of these houses?

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by AkshatM on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:02AM (#20682956)
After reading more closely, it looks like it's not a full-fledged subscription model. Your "subscription" is your monthly rent, which goes from 1k to 10k per month. I don't understand if these "rents" are negotiable or come pre-attached to any specific house.

Further, "home equity" is a weird term in this context. Home equity is a mark of ownership and makes clear sense in the cass of a single home - 100% home equity in a single house means you get 100% of all the profits after that house is sold. The total number of "shares" for a single house is fixed and never changes, meaning home equity never dilutes. For a collection of homes in this model, it's murkier because new renters and new houses would impact the number of "shares" available.

Does Arrived plan to distribute profits to renters after any home is sold to all of its renters? Does Arrived plan to sell houses in the first place? Does my "home equity" dilute as more people sign up to use the service?

I wish there was an FAQ page to really address these risks. As it stands, I would be interested since I like the idea of being able to move from any property to another property without negotiating a new lease or contract - it means I'm not locked to any particular economic region.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by fvryan on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:59AM (#20683423)
> As it stands, I would be interested since I like the idea of being able to move from any property to another property without negotiating a new lease or contract - it means I'm not locked to any particular economic region.

^ This is one aspect of housing we think is missing and that we're trying to support. More and more people are ready to build home ownership, but still want the flexibility to move homes or cities. So they get torn between renting or buying. By building the ownership position in a real estate fund, instead of a single home, that ownership position can move with you to new homes.

Re Rent: Monthly rent is set based on the value of the home a member moves into and local rental rates for the area. It should be in-line with what you'd expect to pay in rent for a similar home outside of Arrived and is transparent to members at the outset.

Re Profits: Members participate as LPs in our real estate fund and receive a percentage of rent and appreciation which adds to their investment over their lease term. We take a long-term buy and hold position in the homes so appreciation is based on re-appraisals of the homes over time to incorporate changes in value.

And thank you for the feedback on an FAQ, we're working on it!

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by darawk on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:32AM (#20683045)
> Further, "home equity" is a weird term in this context. Home equity is a mark of ownership and makes clear sense in the cass of a single home - 100% home equity in a single house means you get 100% of all the profits after that house is sold. The total number of "shares" for a single house is fixed and never changes, meaning home equity never dilutes. For a collection of homes in this model, it's murkier because new renters and new houses would impact the number of "shares" available.

If I understand correctly, I think they're thinking of it more like credit. When you make payments to them, you accrue "equity credit". You may exchange that equity credit for a given home, if it reaches whatever value threshold that home has. You can apply your equity credits to any home in their collection, however each home will require a different amount to purchase, and a different monthly payment to live in.

I think it's a really clever and really interesting idea, if i'm understanding it correctly.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by AkshatM on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:40AM (#20683073)
Then I have even more questions, because in order to offset operating recurring costs for Arrived, that "equity credit" can't be a one-to-one mapping to the house's actual value - it has to offset costs for maintaining the house for you.

In other words, if you use your "equity credit" to take a house for yourself, you could end up paying more than the house is actually worth.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by darawk on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @03:58AM (#20683668)
Of course. You'll overpay, just like you would with interest from a mortgage. But you do get something in return for that overpayment. Whereas with a loan you merely get "time value" for your over-payment in the form of interest, here you are also buying the optionality of moving around. That option has value, and it's appropriate for them to charge some premium for that.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by djmobley on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:49AM (#20683373)
Of course you end up paying more than the house is worth, just as you would if you paid down a mortgage with interest.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by kijin on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @03:13AM (#20683489)
Moreover, you'd have to pay for maintenance even if you outright owned the house.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by nradov on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:37AM (#20683324)
What happens to your pseudo-equity when Arrived goes bankrupt?
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by fvryan on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @03:30AM (#20683561)
Arrived the company and Arrived the fund (which owns the homes) are separate entities. Arrived the company is the manager of the fund, but the fund assets are protected in it's own entity. Members of the service invest as LPs in the fund and would have the option to exchange their shares based on the income and value of the homes. If all fund LPs wanted to exchange their shares, the fund may need to sell its ownership position in the portfolio of homes and each member would receive their share accordingly.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by rdtwo on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @09:25AM (#20685560)
Still doesn’t anwser the question. Seems like once you dissolve the entity the new owners could kick you out of the house
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by DoreenMichele on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:49AM (#20683130)
This is not only not new, but is the standard model for how home loans work in Islamic finance.

I've never heard of what you described. I'm guessing it's a new model for most of the US.

(Thanks for describing it.)

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by dmix on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @03:35AM (#20683581)
Not new conceptually but still a new option in the marketplace in most places.

Or similar to the distinction between calling a taxi vs using an smartphone app with live GPS, you’re still ‘calling’ a cab to a predefined location but the experience is new and different, via maps, picture of the driver/car, reviews, receipts, user selected destination without telling the driver, more car/ride options, etc.

Details are everything in business and product development.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by numakerg on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @12:58AM (#20682940)
>lending institutions instead buy the asset (in this case, a house), and lease it out to the would-be borrower on an installment basis until a predetermined sum has been paid

If the would-be borrower misses a payment, do they get to keep a part of their total lease payments? When I take out a mortgage, the house is effectively owned by the bank and I also pay "installments until a predetermined sum has been paid". If I'm not able to pay the "installments" then I get kicked out.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by AkshatM on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:07AM (#20682969)
I would imagine you don't get to keep lease payments, since my understanding is it's effectively treated as rent. So, yeah, you could still get kicked out and then never see a dime of the money you paid back.

However, I'm not an expert on Islamic finance - the expectations around leases could be different.

[dead]
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by AkshatM on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:19AM (#20683011)
I think this comment assumes corporate greed and consumer hoodwinking from the outset, when instead the economics for this arise organically.

You wish to buy an asset, but don't have the funds to do it. At that point, your only options are to pay in installments towards eventual ownership. So you go to a for-profit lending institution, which agrees to let you pay it back in installments, and has you sign a contract for it.

There's nothing inherently greedy about this - it's just the way agents in an economy work. It would be greed/hoodwinking if customers were tricked into giving money away or didn't have terms explained to then upfront or that "interest" or "rates" beyond what is needed to recoup the asset despite depreciation - but I've not seen anything to suggest that is common practice in any home loan situation.

All that Islamic finance does is change who is nominally the owner of the asset under consideration until the asset is paid back. The standard American model - you're the owner, until the bank reposses it. The Islamic model - the bank is the owner until you buy it back.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by drewm1980 on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:44AM (#20683099)
This judaic model where all loans are forgiven after a certain period is relevant too. I guess the capitalist workaround would be for the lender to keep ownership of the house and just evict the debtor on that deadline.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by kbutler on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:13AM (#20682992)
Differences matter. Your derisive, dismissive view is shallow.

I haven't analysed the effects of this home ownership structure, but the business investment approach means that the banks aren't lenders, but are part owners of the company. This gives a different incentive structure and changes the relationship - I think for the better.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by keanebean86 on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @01:52AM (#20683147)
I thought it would be cool to have something like this with apartments. A company has apartments all over a city/state/country. A renter can move to any of the properties without breaking the lease or paying crazy fees. (Dependant on openings of course)

This way the apartment company can keep good tenants and the tenants can move around as needed with less burden.

I don't belive this will work in the realy world because of greed and whatnot but it's a nice idea.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by skohan on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @05:39AM (#20684044)
A friend of mine lives in a housing co-op which works something like this. Rent does not go toward profit: each renter becomes a shareholder in the organization, and rent may only be used to manage existing properties or to buy new properties and expand the network.

When a unit becomes available, existing members have the option to move into it before it will be offered to potential new members. Who gets it is decided by a formula based on need and seniority within the network. This might happen when, for instance, a family starts to need more space, or an elderly tenant would like to move to the ground floor.

It seems to work well, and makes me wish for more non-profit housing.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by cornstalks on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:17AM (#20683242)
Equity Apartments does this here in the Bay Area. I’m sure others do too, though they’re the only ones I’m personally aware of.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by 80mph on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:37AM (#20683329)
Confirmed, Equity does this nationwide. I've transferred leases in SoCal and the DC metro area. There are a number of requirements, but it was extraordinarily helpful to not have to scramble finding a replacement tenant, so that I could just focus on moving.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by rezz on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @05:07AM (#20683932)
Related Rentals allows you to do this all over the USA fairly seemlessly as long as you’re moving into a more expensive unit.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by jnordwick on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:44AM (#20683352)
From what I understand, Islamic financing of home loans is almost there same as a traditional fixed interest home loan, only the house is legally register to the bank and instead of calling it an be interest payment you can it an installment payment. At the end of the term of the loan the house is registered to the party.

This is a little different. You lease and get equity in real estate fund that you are required to contribute to. At the end of the lease you can move or cash out of the fund of you wish. You don't get the home.

This is so you can participate in the upside of owning a home without actually owning. This isn't a way to buy a house. It is a way to lease and still get the appreciation of ownership.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by cottsak on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @03:09AM (#20683469)
I guess Arrived make a conservative bet on the pool and offer the "renter" a fraction of their calculated profits over iterative re-valuations.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by postit on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:49AM (#20683372)
That's common in Germany as well. See Mietkauf or rent to own- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-to-own
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by didibus on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:10AM (#20683215)
> About the only thing Arrived seems to be doing differently is allowing homeowners to change houses without affecting how much they're paying towards any house - in other words, you're really purchasing a subscription to a collection of homes.

I mean, that sounds like a huge difference.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by Havoc on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @05:13AM (#20683949)
>lease it out to the would-be borrower on an installment basis until a predetermined sum has been paid.

A predetermined sum that happens to match what the amortization tables say?

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by apexalpha on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @05:17AM (#20683962)
Yes, exactly this. There are some 'halal-banks' in Europe as well. All they do is calculate what the total paid sum for a regular mortgage would be, then they buy the house for you and sell it back to you for the total sum...

It's 100% the same as with interest, but it's a religious thing so I don't think debating this will result in anything.

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by Havoc on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:05PM (#20688574)
Which I don't mind. Just disappointed it's not cool/different in some way
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by zaphirplane on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @03:20AM (#20683522)
I don’t get the distinction between paying fixed interest and paying a fixed amount called rent. In both cases you pay an amount and own the house at the end. In both cases the lender makes money.

This sounds more letter vs spirit of the law

I am not a money lender I am a tap water buyer at 1k a cup, after a year you have to buy your water back at 1.2k a cup ;)

Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by nigerian1981 on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @04:44AM (#20683849)
In the interest model you are paying to borrow money. In the rent model the risk is shared between the lender and renter. The lender is responsible for their share of the property and should contribute to the maintenance, building insurance etc.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by AkshatM on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @03:24AM (#20683535)
Yes, the distinction is effectively only a connotational one and not a denotational one.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by cprecioso on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @02:47AM (#20683363)
While not very common, it is also a thing in Spain. "Alquiler con opción a compra" (renting with the option to buy), lets tenants live for a predetermined time at a place. When the lease ends, they can choose to buy the place with a discount equal to their rent payments up to that moment.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by srinathrajaram on Wednesday August 14, 2019 @11:38AM (#20696671)
Agree that this is definitely not new. There have been few variants of this play across the US. Trio (thinktrio.com), for example have been around for quite some time. I wonder though, if the typical HN reader is a great target market for this offering.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by fvryan on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @04:05AM (#20683703)
We've researched many co-operative ownership models and some of the more common "rent to own" models that others sub-posted. The main difference with Arrived is that members, and their investment, are not tied to a single home.
Re:Arrived – a new model of home ownership by vkdelta on Tuesday August 13, 2019 @03:17AM (#20683509)