I have a similar issue with a side project of mine. JS-only websites solve this with server-side rendering or static generation.
1. A web crawler 2. A search index
Or as a good boss used to say garbage in garbage out... the quality of the engine is as much a function of the index’s ability to rank as the quality of the input from the crawler... the fact that none of the other engines crawl with JS enabled is a huge competitive advantage for google
[1] https://blogs.bing.com/webmaster/october-2018/bingbot-Series... [2] https://searchengineland.com/bing-crawling-indexing-and-rend...
Anything that loads no resources unless I have javascript enabled (and is a general purpose website, not some 3d toy or whatever) is trash.
What value a service provides is what matters in the end. Implementation details are secondary.
I’m honestly having a hard time seeing how this isn’t a bug in Google search.
A search engine is trying to predict which pages will be helpful to you in response to your query. This means it should take "how does the page look to users" as input, which today means executing JavaScript.
(Disclosure: I work for Google, not on search)
Non-JS web indexing as a default would vastly dimnish the utility of JS-only pages.
I separately think sites that only work with JS enabled are not great, but that's a problem with the system and not with individual actors.
So Google is enabling the excess of JS we see today? Sites wouldn't do that if it couldn't be indexed by Google.
Nothing prevents a site from doing that and just loading JS afterwards. Or from still being basically read-only without JS. Which might be an improvement...except within epsilon of zero people care in the first place and Google is building software for a rather larger proportion of the market than that, so it's an improvement for what's barely an audience.
Nobody is really "enabling" it except for a browser. And that's not changing. The shirt-rending is becoming tiresome.
It's a shame you find it "tiresome" when people insist on retaining their own opinions, but your exhaustion is not particularly relevant.
And you can have whatever opinion you want; nobody’s saying otherwise. But the constant whining about nothing — and it is nothing — is exhausting.
I think these are both true. Google quality has certainly fallen in my opinion (perhaps as a result of having to constantly counter SEO tricks). Other search engines still have quite a bit of catching up to do as well.
This is one example of many, but it was the last straw for me. I guess techies aren't Google's core audience anymore, I get that, but it feels like we've lost a valuable tool.
People that can actually notice a major difference in result quality should probably go work on search optimization.
Are you able to explain this? Bing and DuckDuckGo are the same thing. DDG uses Bing's API (for non bang searches).
This is not, and has never been, true. Why do people like you keep saying it?
Googles been able to use ephemeral experiences (like autocomplete and answer boxes) to influence users, especially undecided voters. The research, which was reproduced by a German team, is believed to have influenced 2+ million people in the US election alone --
take a listen on the congressional testimony http://naplay.it/1157/37:25 (recommended listen speed is 1.5X)
He claims they moved 2.5 million votes, not voters. This relies on an assumption of straight ticket voters and about 20 votes per voter. He doesn't correct people when they make the votes/voters mistake.
And even that new number, 100k voters swayed is not really well founded. He makes a couple of overlapping claims, one of them I looked into deeply and found that using his own papers, a reasonable way of expressing it was that 8-10k additional votes for Clinton was a reasonable upper bound, as he claimed, might be affected.
And the number was likely lower (and was only that high because more people identify as democrat than republican in the US).
(I work at Google, but take interest in this mostly because it's just terrible abuse of mathematics)
Maybe but it's pretty clear to me that Google now no longer indexes entire websites. This as far as I can tell has not been a concern in the past.
The reduction in Google Search quality is their need to be "helpful" with their desire to use my past search results, and other "big data" they gobble up about me to "improve" my specific results when in fact it makes it worse. That is just the base line, then you have the 100's of other things they have done to the search over the years for political, regulatory and other reasons.
Google search gets objectively worse every year than the previous year.
Example: someone compiled a list of things they learned from indiehackers.com interviews.
http://www.toomas.net/2017/07/18/reverse-engineering-a-succe...
There are a lot of quotes on that page, and unfortunately none of them are linked back to the original interview. Some quotes are very interesting, so I wanted to find the original interview.
I took some of those quotes, put them in double quotation marks, and searched on Google, DuckDuckGo and Bing. By the way, you can only replicate these results by adding the double quotation marks.
Results:
Google always shows toomas.net in the top results, and almost always finds the relevant interview article on the indiehackers website.
DDG (usually) finds the article written on toomas.net, but not the indiehackers interview.
Bing often fails to list toomas as the top result, and doesn't find the indiehackers interview at all.