News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by edtechdev on Sunday July 28, 2019 @05:51PM (#20550018)
At the bottom of the comments, a member of the Hypercard team said it was killed in 92, before Jobs returned.

There still is no free development tool out there that matches what Hypercard did in terms of power and ease of use. We're still coding with languages designed for constraints that disappeared decades ago.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by jayd16 on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:03PM (#20550309)
I've never used Hypercard and I just can't fathom the love for it.

If nothing matches Hypercard, why don't people use it (or some opensource copy) of it? So many seem enthralled by it but the reality is no one seems to want to bring it back.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by kls on Monday July 29, 2019 @07:49AM (#20553496)
It was a different time, the world moved on to web enabled / multi-user applications. Hypercard and MS Access where decidedly built around single users with the latter having multi-user capabilities but not great support for it. They where both designed in a time where a constant network connection was a luxury and not a commodity. They where awesome for their time, but it was also a simpler time, as of yet no one has come up with a stupid simple app builder for present day computing realities as complexity has exploded, its a interesting problem and if a person could make creating simple apps for web/mobile/multi-user as easy as Hypercard was, they would certainly be rolling in fortunes.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by asciilifeform on Monday July 29, 2019 @04:29PM (#20559058)
One of the attractions of Hypercard was that a "stack" (document) was entirely self-contained; and would always behave exactly the same on any machine where HC could run.

Notably, would run without any need for servers (or, worse, the subscription-and-lock-in "services" ubiquitous today -- arguably the 1980s "computer revolution" was strangled in the cradle, and we've gone most of the way back to 1970s-style time-sharing now: how many phone apps etc. will run usefully without a net connection? The "smartphone" is essentially a small "glass TTY", rather than personal computer in the '80s sense.)

I've run HC stacks written 30+ years ago. How many current-day "web app" documents will be readable as-found 30 years from now? For that matter, I've paid for iOS apps that would no longer execute after half a year (on account of Apple's "API changes", or in some cases -- author's "call home" server fell down and did not get up, etc.) Permanence (in the most basic "I paid for this and it ought to be usable for so long as any compatible iron remains functional" sense) is no longer part of the software commercial culture, and one is likely to be laughed at for merely raising the question.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by scroot on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:01PM (#20559408)
> The "smartphone" is essentially a small "glass TTY", rather than personal computer in the '80s sense.

We now have a generation or two that completely missed this era, and, worse, might be uninterested in the history. The idea that you would have a ubiquitous, portable, always-on personal computing device and that -- at least from the perspective of people who are knowledgeable of about this history -- you would put a Unix on it is completely crazy.

It is, as you say, an expensive and sleek teletype emulator

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by hjk05 on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:10PM (#20550330)
Because newer copies don’t include the nostalgia that’s one of the primary drivers for people’s admiration.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by Angostura on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:37AM (#20552883)
Its power was partly in its ubiquity - people who weren't programmers stumbled across it, had a play and suddenly realised 'this is a bit handy'. There was never really a killer app for Hypercard, it had so many bizarre use-case cases. But its flexibility and ability welcome unlikely users in is where it did so well.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by lochlan on Monday July 29, 2019 @01:00PM (#20556758)
I might consider Myst a “killer app,” especially for its time.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by danaris on Sunday July 28, 2019 @09:11PM (#20550765)
Well, the main reason no one uses Hypercard itself is because emulating classic MacOS is a pain and a half.

I haven't explored all the copies, but the ones I have seen tend to be less featureful and/or less user-friendly than the original.

Furthermore, probably the best modern software that's similar to Hypercard in its overall flexibility and power is...the web. Back in the day, Hypercard was it; there wasn't really anything else in that space. Nowadays, there's still nothing that's quite as awesome or matches all its features, but there are things that are much closer and do a lot of the same things that are much more accessible than emulating or reimplementing Hypercard.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by jhbadger on Monday July 29, 2019 @07:14AM (#20553300)
The existence of the Web is indeed a big reason. While everybody seems to compare Hypercard to things like Visual Basic, and yes, you could use it that way to make applications, most people used it to create stacks on a topic (a particular band, or Shakespeare's plays, or Japanese swords) that were basically Web sites before the Web.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by cortesoft on Monday July 29, 2019 @12:33AM (#20551528)
Emulating Mac OS classic isn't particularly difficult these days. I use sheepshaver with great success. I actually DO use it to run my old hypercard games I wrote in elementary school.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by danaris on Monday July 29, 2019 @03:21PM (#20558364)
Last time I tried using Basilisk II, I managed to get it to be stable (running System 7 in an emulated...IIsi, I think?), but if I ever tried to change anything beyond adding and removing disks, it just wouldn't run.

I haven't tried SheepShaver much, I admit, because most of the stuff I want to run was written for 68k and runs poorly or not at all on PPC.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by tyingq on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:05PM (#20550315)
They do, it's just fragmented. Things like Excel/VB, Quickbase, Airtable, Tableux, etc.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by misterdata on Monday July 29, 2019 @03:20AM (#20552190)
Project I am working on that may be close: https://diasli.de
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by reeeeee on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:01AM (#20552704)
Looks nice! But why is it in dutch? Does it load language settings based on location? Why can't I change it?
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by misterdata on Monday July 29, 2019 @06:13AM (#20553040)
It selects the language based on browser locale - what is yours set to? Should definitively improve this...

From Dutch you can switch to English using the menu in the top right corner (click "Engels")

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by reeeeee on Tuesday July 30, 2019 @07:42AM (#20563911)
Great, thanks! I checked the menu but probably missed the language settings.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by D-Coder on Sunday July 28, 2019 @10:03PM (#20550958)
LiveCode (renamed from "Runtime Revolution"). Free for personal use: https://livecode.com/products/community-edition/.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by irrational on Sunday July 28, 2019 @10:53PM (#20551184)
I guess DreamWeaver might be the modern equivalent (though definitely not as easy to use as Hypercard). Can DreamWeaver set up client-side storage easily? With Hypercard it was dead simple to save stuff to local storage.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by CharlesW on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:48PM (#20561707)
> At the bottom of the comments, a member of the Hypercard team said it was killed in 92, before Jobs returned.

Well, HyperCard had several lives.

An early version of HyperCard 3.0 was demonstrated at WWDC in 1996 which used QuickTime ("QuickTime Interactive", or QTi) as its runtime. That would've allowed stacks to run in browsers, and in every app that leveraged QuickTime to render multimedia content.

The 1992 killing was before my time, but in any case HyperCard was effectively killed forever in 2000 when Jobs reassigned the HyperCard engineering team to not-HyperCard.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by EGreg on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:18PM (#20550367)
I would argue that Visual Basic on Windows was similar to HyperCard for Mac!

It also led to a great number of “regular folks” making “forms” and adding code. And VBX allowed people in Excel to do stuff.

Also don’t forget AppleScript. And now on iOS we have Shortcuts and Workflow too.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by Torwald on Sunday July 28, 2019 @09:09PM (#20550759)
The real HyperCard on Windows was Asymetrix ToolBook, which was very good.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by mattl on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:35PM (#20550423)
VBX or VBA?
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by sansnomme on Sunday July 28, 2019 @06:00PM (#20550053)
Visual Basic. (The non-.NET versions)
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by ksec on Monday July 29, 2019 @09:12PM (#20561189)
And Delphi. Somehow all the RAD Programming Languages all died around the same time frame.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by mysterydip on Sunday July 28, 2019 @06:44PM (#20550233)
I still use it sometimes (and still supported in win10 believe it or not)!
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by minxomat on Monday July 29, 2019 @10:37AM (#20555039)
And works really well on wine. The community is still quite active: http://planet-source-code.com/vb/default.asp?lngWId=1
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by soapdog on Monday July 29, 2019 @07:01AM (#20553243)
you might want to check https://www.livecode.com is is a modern day xtalk, it uses a language and model just like HyperCard but it creates standalones for windows, mac, linux, android and iOS.

PS: Disclaimer, I work for them.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by zem on Monday July 29, 2019 @01:50PM (#20557302)
i poked around the website and forum a bit and one thing I missed was a way to see community libraries and projects. check out the euphoria site for instance: http://rapideuphoria.com/archive.htm
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by soapdog on Monday July 29, 2019 @02:15PM (#20557600)
I totally agree with you that the site needs more work to make these things more discoverable. We don't have a package manager (I built one more than ten years ago, it never got traction and it was very naive) but there are many libraries floating around. Our forums and mailing lists are the most common places to find resources. The IDE also has an online portal inside it that can be used to share code, most people use it to share demos, samples and libraries.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by zem on Monday July 29, 2019 @02:53PM (#20558017)
yeah, that's why i feel like euphoria is a good example - they have a small (but, from what i can see, enthusiastic) community, and their website doesn't have a ton of polish, but it's pretty pleasant to navigate and makes things very discoverable.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by traverseda on Sunday July 28, 2019 @06:56PM (#20550284)
Then it sounds like there's money to be made then. I've never used hypercard, but perhaps it could fill a similar niche as wix?
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by rrggrr on Monday July 29, 2019 @08:06AM (#20553635)
Watch Notion. It's not there yet, but as the API develops it could easily be the next Hypercard.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by ksec on Monday July 29, 2019 @09:15PM (#20561202)
Notion as in [1] ? I thought Coda [2] would be closer ?

[1] https://www.notion.so

[2] https://coda.io/welcome

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by SilasX on Sunday July 28, 2019 @06:24PM (#20550150)
But what's to say it wouldn't have taken the course of HTML/CSS/JS if it ever got similarly popular?
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by ken on Monday July 29, 2019 @05:04PM (#20559440)
CSS has one of the strangest designs in all of computing. It's simultaneously Turing-complete yet too weak to easily encode many common types of styling. It has practically no abstraction capabilities, no namespacing, and its syntax at every level (selector syntax, Unicode escaping, etc) is different from the other languages it has to interoperate with, for no apparent reason.

I doubt Hypercard would have ever gotten anything like CSS. It was unlikely enough that CSS ended up anything like CSS!

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by scroot on Sunday July 28, 2019 @06:39PM (#20550215)
I doubt it. When you made Hypercard stacks you did it in Hypercard. When you make websites, you make them in ... not a web browser.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by mavhc on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:25PM (#20550394)
Except you did make websites in a web browser originally.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WorldWideWeb

Netscape was going to have a built in editor, but they ran out of time, was added in Netscape 3 Gold, and there by default in 4.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by WorldMaker on Monday July 29, 2019 @04:13PM (#20558873)
Also, modern Dev Tools in all the major browsers are getting close to being full blown IDEs in their own right (again). It's got a full REPL one F12 (or Ctrl+Shift+I) press away. (Plus modern syntax highlighting, element inspection, direct CSS and sometimes JS file modification.)

(Pre-Edgmium, Edge's Dev Tools even shared a bunch of code with VS Code and briefly explored hosting a full VS Code experience.)

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by asark on Sunday July 28, 2019 @09:49PM (#20550906)
Hey, Netscape Composer's how I got my start on this boring but too-lucrative-to-give-up road. I definitely made websites in my browser :-)
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by dbtx on Sunday July 28, 2019 @08:37PM (#20550638)
$ seamonkey-bin --edit

::ye olde Mozilla Composer appears directly::

No you wouldn't, but you can ;) How high is your tolerance today?

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by Crinus on Monday July 29, 2019 @04:58AM (#20552698)
I would, why wouldn't i? If all you need is to write some formatted text with a bunch of images and perhaps a table or two, composer does the job perfectly fine and the page you get works on any server and client with practically zero overhead and resources.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by dbtx on Monday July 29, 2019 @08:15AM (#20553710)
They wouldn't. You would, that's fine, and I made a site with it in the distant past, or I tried. I checked, but if I did actually publish it, archive.org doesn't have that version.

I say tolerance because much more recently I had problems trying to make a chart and tripping over colspan and rowspan stuff. I really just need to sketch the contents out on paper, first...

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by Crinus on Monday July 29, 2019 @08:42AM (#20553948)
I'm not sure i understand, your issue with Composer was making a chart? Why would you try to make a chart in Composer, it is a page editor not an image editor, why not make the chart in a tool made specifically for charts and use it as an image? Also what tables and colspan/rowspan have to do with charts?
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by dbtx on Monday July 29, 2019 @01:08PM (#20556834)
Sorry, I meant table and started saying so but I cut that part out at some point. I also tried lowriter; editing tables and rows and cells is better, but not by much.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by jayd16 on Sunday July 28, 2019 @06:57PM (#20550288)
Maybe I'm taking this too literally, but you can code Java in eclipse and web pages in several electron apps. What are you implying?
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by shagie on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:30PM (#20550408)
It is closer to the ideals of smalltalk and LISP (of the '70s) - where there is little or no distinction between the environment in which one writes the software and the environment that the software is run.

This is a fundamentally different way of how the environment works. You could stop a program and access the development environment because that was part of the runtime.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by TheDong on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:10PM (#20550332)
The parent is talking about an integrated environment for development, where that integrated environment is indistinguishable from the language itself.

Examples of this include elisp and emacs, smalltalk and squeak, and to a lesser extent visual studio and C#.

There have been relatively few ecosystems so integrated. Java and Javascript/html/electron apps are notably not like that at all. There is no one "the" environment for coding those, simply several very popular ones.

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by scroot on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:18PM (#20550369)
Yes exactly.

My own take is that Apple should have made a "Hypercard"-like thing the "top layer" of a new operating system. In other words, the entire desktop/windows/buttons interface to the main OS would be itself scripted in Hypercard.

Smalltalk takes this a step further of course by making the whole operating system a live environment. The very UI vocabulary one uses can also double as "programming"

Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by scarface74 on Sunday July 28, 2019 @10:06PM (#20550973)
That was the idea behind AppleScript to an extent.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by jayd16 on Sunday July 28, 2019 @08:38PM (#20550643)
Hmm. Unity scripting sort of works like this if you if ignore the closed source parts. It's kind of nice to edit the editor. At the same time, having the power to corrupt your runtime is arguably more trouble than it's worth.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by pvg on Sunday July 28, 2019 @06:44PM (#20550235)
It was really a thing that could, theoretically, have taken the course of Director or Flash. You can imagine a parallel universe where that happened and my guess is the final result would have been the same.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by justinator on Sunday July 28, 2019 @07:49PM (#20550483)
HTML/Javascript get pretty close. Apples to Studebakers comparison, not withstanding.
Re:Why Hypercard Had to Die (2011) by stonogo on Sunday July 28, 2019 @06:00PM (#20550054)
There are options. Scratch comes to mind. Stacksmith is well on its way.