btw being from the UK, "they" singular in text is normal, especially in this case where the gender of the player is unknown, and seeing he/she here would really trip me up (as it does when I read older articles from the US that use "he" arbitrarily). It's a style thing, but one I've always liked as more accurate.
Things will get out of balance the more it is forced, because with every politically correct motion, there is an equal opposite motion. All that is achieved is further polarization and misunderstanding.
To say the articles’ use of ‘they’ is normal in the UK feel duplicitous. I’ve read my fair share of British literature, newspapers and articles. The text feels completely alien to British writing.
I can't speak for the British writing you've read, but as a Brit living in and having grown up in the UK, singular non-gendered "they" is normal and common in both formal and informal text. Could be a function of my social context or the writing I've been exposed to, it's true. We all have our own perspective.
For example: "Could the person who left their umbrella please pick it up?"
However, here it is used in a rather new setting for a specific and known individual. This is a rather new phenomenon pushed by the transgender and genderqueer community.
I am specifically addressing the latter usage of the form 'they' in the third person singular. Do you agree this form is new? If not, could you give references to earlier usage than, say 1990?
I thought it was a fairly universal idea that there’s an high level of amount of gender imbalance with regards to professional programmers. Most frequently seen at programming meetups and conventions. Maybe it’s not commonly accepted as a problem in your sphere, but I’d bet if you asked around you’d get answers that surprise you.
Don't you think that by emphasizing the differences by forcefully changing our accepted speech, you are making it harder for women to enter the sphere?
To be able to fight, but refraining from fighting, is what makes us human. It allows us to show mutual respect and to form true connections.
Since the article is about the player more generally (the article discusses the player in other games), and the player prefers not to be gendered, I think "they" is appropriate here.
"Every one must judge according to their own feelings." That's a nice example on how it can be used. Most of the older examples include "every" or "any" before using they. I think I need to study that part of the language as (at least in some situations) it seems like a nice way to get around using a generic form.
In my language journalists created a new word for it that was met with resistance first, but it doesn’t corrupt another word and it has been added to all dictionaries and is used heavily.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/10/opinion/pronoun-they-gend...
I do not think a formal 'they' is improper, or a new innovation e.g. see comment here (https://www.lexico.com/en/grammar/he-or-she-versus-they) (I might amend this later to add some examples with some google-fu, but it shouldn't be hard to find some 17th-century prose). See also the comments and answers here https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/108457/is-using-...)
That said, the author misuses and misapplies the construct, as the gender seems known to me from a quick pass of the article, and as mentioned by other commenters. Yes, it feels forced and it usually doesn't -- you probably have already encountered similar examples before, but did not notice them.
We don't know the gender here.
It's probably more likely they just wanted to remain anonymous rather than this being part of some sort of movement to eliminate gender in text
So the only acceptable option by this line of thinking is that the default pronoun should be 'he/him'. This attitude seems something a little different from 'conservative'.
I agree that "they" is awful, and I would definitely prefer that we just have to make the unknown pronoun always be "she" if that is what everyone needs to not throw an inequality tantrum.
From this information the gender of the player is unknown, and since the article is about the player, not the avatar, gender neutral pronouns are appropriate to maintain journalist integrity.
From your comment it sounds like you’re attributing gender politics to this article where there isn’t necessarily any.
The fact that they play a female character does not mean they are female.
Conservative definitely checks out
I'm from the UK, it might be normal to occasionally say they when you don't know the name, gender and have an image but I don't agree with others that the way this article is written isn't very stilted as a result.
I think the wider debate has probably sailed. I remember the confusion at having to add a fourth gender (beyond M/F/other) to an input dropdown list on a system 10 years ago. It's probably a textarea now.
I thought this referred to a group known as the Katia Sae? Is this a person?
But worse, and I think more likely, it shows you are intolerant to change. I think that, equally likely, it shows you are just plain intolerant to some people.
There are two kinds of changes: for the better and for the worse. Being always pro-change would make one an idiot.
Everyone is intolerant to some people. Apparently you are intolerant to intolerant people.
I’m not sure if it’s something to get up in arms about, but it’s not really something to be bothered by either in my opinion.
My opinion is that pronoun doesn’t matter regardless of whether it’s he/she or they. They just seems marginally less effective at conveying information.
A good example of this is pretty much any football (soccer) stadium. For matches most of the crowd are men and a large number of them are drinking more than usual. Heck, I've been in a stadium with a 50/50 crowd: even when the toilets were split 2/1 for women in favor of men there was always a long queue for the girls and nothing for the boys.
Bathrooms are clean if you clean them. It is also more hygienic and gives a better impression of the place. Saving money by gendered bathrooms and only cleaning the bathroom once a week belong in the same gender discrimination category as other cost-saving tactics that involve gender.
Hover-pee is a really common thing for women, and the results are what you imagine bthey would be.
This is what I was replying to. Bit of a confusing way to say “enter a room containing a urinal” if that’s what you actually meant.
(I cringe every time someone uses the euphemism 'bathroom' to mean toilet. Like, we all know you are not going to take a bath in a pub after two pints right?)
Where people go to rest.
Or the wash room.
Where they go to, erm, wash.
1) it reads like shit 2) screenshots even shows the player char is female? 3) it feels so freaking forced.
I know i am probably downvoted now like hell but I am so sick of this movement to get rid of gender in text. It started with all of this ‘the programmer, he or she ...’, then everything was a ‘she’ (any male coders in modern textbooks anymore?) , and now all are ‘they’...
Call me conservative but I don’t like it. And tech is especially affected...
Every stupid js conf only has gender neutral toilets. And people fucking hate it. But no one dares too say it loud. Too easy to get banned...