News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by mikece on Friday July 12, 2019 @01:54PM (#20422782)
It's interesting how incredibly low France's CO2 output is, mainly thanks to their investment in nuclear power. And while uranium isn't renewable, I think we've got 300,000 years worth of it available. Think we can crack fusion or ultra-high-efficiency solar by then?
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by dv_dt on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:02PM (#20422883)
https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/07/giant-batteries-and-...

> This month, officials in Los Angeles, California, are expected to approve a deal that would make solar power cheaper than ever while also addressing its chief flaw: It works only when the sun shines. The deal calls for a huge solar farm backed up by one of the world's largest batteries. It would provide 7% of the city's electricity beginning in 2023 at a cost of 1.997 cents per kilowatt hour (kWh) for the solar power and 1.3 cents per kWh for the battery. That's cheaper than any power generated with fossil fuel.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rb808 on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:42PM (#20424774)
Solar & Batteries work great in California when peak demand is when its hot. In the frozen North though its different, esp if you want to replace gas/oil heating with heat pumps, peak demand would be cold nights in January.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by joncrane on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:56PM (#20425835)
Peak demand for energy. But peak demand for electricity is during peak AC season just like California.

I don't think anyone is saying we're replacing natural gas to cook and heat with.

(At least I hope not, cooking with gas is an indulgence I partake of regularly.)

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by mattlondon on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:08AM (#20426909)
Certainly in the UK there is talk of trying to wean people off of using gas to heat homes.(1). Options to replace it are electric heat pumps and/or hydrogen-based systems.

Most people I know have abandoned gas hobs and replaced them with induction hobs - they feel a lot like cooking with gas (unlike halogen or ceramic ones), but are a lot more practical (e.g. cleaning, extra space etc) and better for air quality.

1 - https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/mar/13/hammond-...

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by viraptor on Saturday July 13, 2019 @08:12AM (#20427665)
> induction hobs - they feel a lot like cooking with gas

This really depends on the hobs. Bad ones are nowhere near gas quality and trend to regulate the heat by going a few seconds full power then few seconds off. Good ones regulate in a much smoother / more consistent way. We can't compare generic "induction hob" - it doesn't exist.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by black_puppydog on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:21AM (#20426779)
In the North, AC will simply not show up on your energy footprint. Heating will most definitely. So yeah, electric heating is is. I hate electric heating as a user, but nearly every apartment here in France has it. And since France is most nuclear, that's actually not bad in terms of CO2. For cooking there's induction, which easily competes with gas in terms of convenience IMHO, but yeah, for heating I'd like better solutions.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by kupiakos on Sunday July 14, 2019 @11:13AM (#20433842)
Interesting, AC uses a massive amount of electricity during the summer in Illinois, a place which doesn't spare on cold winters.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by daveFNbuck on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:32AM (#20426969)
What's wrong with electric heating?
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by tetraca on Monday July 15, 2019 @05:43PM (#20445569)
Why transfer 36% of a fire's energy hundreds of miles away to heat your home, when you can simply burn fire locally, and get 100% heat efficiency?

In cold climates, it's far cheaper to use gas heating.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by black_puppydog on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @02:12AM (#20447853)
Although in fairness, it would be interesting to make that comparison after accounting for external costs of both. CO2 emissions for gas, and nuclear plant decommission /storage in case ofnjuclear power like here in France
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by joncrane on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:45PM (#20429514)
Interesting how there, the trade-off of electricity for nuclear is so advantageous, that you can even do inefficient things with the electricity downstream and still come out ahead.

Is electricity really cheap in France?

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by gumby on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:20PM (#20428784)
Gas cooking is probably my #1 primary source of CO2 emissions. I ought to switch to electric. Burning that gas at a weaker plant and sending it to me over the wires is still cleaner at a mg-CO2/joule than burning it at the point of use.

("primary" means I directly cause it; if I drove a car that would probably be my #1).

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by st1ck on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:57PM (#20473376)
I wonder, how do gas cooking carbon emissions compare to your breathing and, well, other biological byproducts.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by godelski on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:47PM (#20425802)
This is the key that people forget. Not all power source work equally as well in all areas. There is a need for a diversified energy portfolio.

I do want to follow this up saying that I fully support building as much solar and wind as we can. Not doing so is kinda dumb. Just saying it isn't a cure all.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by WalterBright on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:34PM (#20423161)
The need for batteries would be greatly reduced if the electricity rates were higher for when the grid was running on batteries.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by dragontamer on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:37PM (#20423184)
On the contrary. California's current energy usage goes from ~16GW to 32GWs each and every day.

http://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/default.aspx

Currently, electricity is generated by "peaker plants", which spin up when the price of electricity goes up, and then spin down when the price of electricity is low. Consumers are often passed the buck: peaker-plant electricity (usually natural gas) costs more than baseload electricity (usually nuclear or coal)

Utility-scale batteries are competing against the Natural Gas peaker plants. The question is if utility scale batteries can make as much money (ie: provide the power at low enough costs) to be worthwhile.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by WalterBright on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:37PM (#20425150)
Wholesale prices for electricity certainly vary, but consumer prices are a flat rate, 24/7. Nowhere I've lived has this not been the case, and there is no incentive whatsoever for consumers to time-shift their electricity consumption.

A huge part of what caused the Enron California electricity crisis is the utilities were unable, by law, to adjust consumer prices as wholesale prices changed. The utilities were required, by law, to provide whatever consumers demanded whenever they demanded it, at a fixed price, regardless of what it cost the utilities to provide it.

If this has changed in California, that's for the better. In Seattle, the price of electricity is the same, 24/7.

Consider gas prices at the pump. They vary every day, based on demand and supply of gas. Gas prices go up over Memorial Day. They go up when a refinery burns down. They go down in winter when people drive less. It works very well at matching up supply with demand.

It broke down completely in the late 1970's when the government imposed price controls and allocation controls at the pump. When Reagan repealed all that, things worked fine again.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by philipkglass on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:04PM (#20425624)
I don't know when it changed, but California mandates time-of-use pricing for all commercial, industrial, and agricultural electricity customers. Residential customers can opt into ToU plans too. My uncle is on one because he is retired, so can set his own hours, but also likes to run electricity-intensive tools in his shop.

https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/General.aspx?id=12194

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by WalterBright on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:43PM (#20426005)
Even better than ToU is having it priced minute-by-minute based on supply/demand, just like gas prices are. After all, a cloudy day may reduce solar output, and prices should rise accordingly.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by ComputerGuru on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:52AM (#20426696)
Here in in Illinois we have ComEd which has a RRTP program with “real-time” pricing for residential customers based on supply and demand. I’m not sure if it’s true real-time but current price in 5-minute resolutions.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by WalterBright on Saturday July 13, 2019 @04:02AM (#20427049)
That sounds like the right kind of system. The next step is to build this awareness into things like the HVAC system, the refrigerator, the car charger, etc.

Finally, a point to having internet connected appliances!

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by NickNameNick on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:45PM (#20425210)
Not in the US, but I have two meters on my house. One meter is attached to most of the circuits, and charges the 24/7 rate.

The other meter is attached to the heater system, only works off-peak, and charges a discounted rate.

The heater is basically a slab of steel, wrapped in heating elements, surrounded by insulation. It heats up when the power is on, and temperature controlled vents let air circulate when it's cold in the house. Works ok, but I'll probably change it out for a heat-pump soon.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rahimnathwani on Saturday July 13, 2019 @04:54AM (#20427168)
What you describe sounds like 'Economy 7' in the UK.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by erichocean on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:05PM (#20426075)
> consumer prices are a flat rate, 24/7

This is false.

Source: I'm a California resident; it's not true here.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by WalterBright on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:04AM (#20426598)
I looked, California utility rates come in a number of plans, which are recent. Some are "tiered", meaning the more you use the more you pay. This doesn't help with the battery problem.

There seems to be an increasing use of Time of Use plans, which will help with the battery problem. But they're a poor match, still being fixed rates for fixed times.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by dv_dt on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:52PM (#20423869)
The bidding costs for peaker plants have been beaten by renewable+storage combos for IIRC 2-3 years now for new builds of capacity. IF you think about it, the gas turbines are a fairly expensive capital cost with high maintenance vs renewables. Add to that intermittent operation and that capital costs performs even worse while adding maintenance wear and tear for startup/shutdown.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rswskg on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @08:51AM (#20449520)
There is so much scope here for a hydrogen economy to take off. Run at 32gw all the time, when demand is 16gw, send that energy into generating hydrogen/and or batteries. It's the ideal use case for 'always on' nuclear.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by ApolloFortyNine on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:39PM (#20423208)
Then start investing in reducing the energy consumption of air conditioners, as that's by far the biggest consumer of energy in a home, and it's rather useless if it doesn't run during the day.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by icebraining on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:35PM (#20423694)
But during the day is exactly when you less need batteries, since the sun is shining on the solar panels...
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by merpnderp on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:25PM (#20424658)
I don't know about LA, but in the midwest temps usually peak around 4pm, so AC really starts to crank right when solar is letting up.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by ido on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:53AM (#20427023)
Depends on latitude I guess? In Berlin at the peak of summer sunset is around 10pm.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by nicoburns on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:57PM (#20423910)
Yeah, solar seems like a pretty perfect match for aircon. It's also hottest when the sun is shining...
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rakoo on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:16PM (#20428764)
It is cheaper than fossil fuel but reliable intermittent electricity is still polluting way too much to efficiently curb green house gases.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rabidrat on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:45PM (#20423265)
We've got 300k years of fissile material, at current usage rates, which is only a small fraction of our current energy usage. If we magically went to 100% nuclear fission for energy (which is not reasonable for personal transportation, at least), and continued to increase energy consumption per business as usual (developed economies not reducing, and developing economies rapidly catching up to developed usage per capita), then it would not last nearly as long, by 2 orders of magnitude. Also I think that estimate imagines efficient breeder reactors and "complete burning" of the material, and does not take into account our current incredibly wasteful techniques of using 5% of the available energy and burying the rest in an unrecoverable mountain sludge.

I know that a few thousand years still feels like a long time, but with nuclear fission, it is truly the most non-renewable resource, being formed only in stellar explosions. Let's put aside the science fiction of asteroid mining nuclear fuel for now; I think a reasonable argument could be made to not spend nuclear fuel for our primary energy needs. If we have dreams of ever being able to do mass interstellar travel, nuclear material is the only fuel we have so far with reasonable energy density for the speeds and distances involved. (Of course some will say "nuclear fusion" or "light sails", to which I say, we should defer mass consumption of fissile material until we have a reasonable expectation that those methods are viable).

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by yostrovs on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:56PM (#20423347)
"We" now and "we" ten thousand years from now are very different people. Those in the future will laugh at your concerns for them. It's as if ancient Egyptians would worry about whether we, now, have enough flood plain space to harvest crops.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by fsloth on Friday July 12, 2019 @04:28PM (#20424194)
Nuclear fuel is a non-trivial resource. There is no basis for thinking we will ever find anything better.

Scientific progress is not a law of nature. It needs very specific environment to thrive. Before scientific revolution kicked in the pharaohs would have easily adjusted to europe and elsewhere.

No one can predict whether there is an infinite amount of scientific progress ahead of us or will we hit a wall.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by godelski on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:34PM (#20425771)
There are plenty of areas to look at for new energy generation just within particle physics alone. Not to mention that we're at the finish line with a net positive fusion reactor (I don't know a single fusion scientist that doesn't think iter will work).

Scientific progress may not be law, but there isn't a thousand year period where humans haven't advanced.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by hermitdev on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:53PM (#20426034)
I don't mean to be negative, but we've been hearing fusion is 5 years out for how long?

Point is: you can't really put a deadline on R&D. We won't really know when it works, until, well it does. And who knows how long it will to take commercialize once we do get it working.

I mean, Musk said fully autonomous vehicles in 2015 were easy and would be solved in 2 years. 4 years later, Tesla'd are killing people by driving into highway barriers or broadsiding a semi trailer. Ambitious? Yes. Are we there yet? No. I think autonomous driving is a worthy goal and we should keep working at it. Same with fusion. But do I believe the projected timelines? No. Doubt that I'll see fusion as a power source in my timeline. Maybe never fully autonomous vehicles (I mean trully fully). And I'm still under 40. Maybe I'm overly pessimistic, but I think a lot of people underestimate the true difficulty of some of these projects.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by godelski on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:21AM (#20426777)
> Musk said fully autonomous vehicles in 2015

Quoting Musk is probably the worst example you can give. His track record for prediction isn't great.

You're right that it is hard to predict how long R&D takes, but governments are different than companies. Companies have a lifespan in decades, possibly a few centuries (if you're REALLY really lucky and pivot a lot). Profits are focused at the yearly level and long shots are decades out. Governments on the other hand generally have much longer lifespans. Decades are short periods of time for them. Investing in things that will pay off in a century is great business here (lots of science and math falls into this category). This is the problem. People are comparing how companies operate to how governments operate. They have completely different agendas, priorities, and operate at completely different time scales.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by DuskStar on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:24PM (#20426126)
> I don't mean to be negative, but we've been hearing fusion is 5 years out for how long?

Fusion is an amount of money away more than an amount of time.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by hyperbovine on Friday July 12, 2019 @11:03PM (#20426251)
Unless you believe markets are completely inefficient I just don’t buy this argument. Think about the reward awaiting the person or company that finally cracks fusion power: trillions of dollars in wealth; the gratitude of an entire planet; instant, everlasting fame, and so on. So, ample incentives already exist. No, the reason we haven’t solved fusion is that it’s a hard problem, and the right genius(es) have yet to come along.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by chmod775 on Saturday July 13, 2019 @12:03AM (#20426427)
Companies are just too risk averse for expensive moonshots like this.

Construction costs alone for ITER are estimated to be $22 to $65 billion dollars. This doesn't even factor in the cost of actually running it after that or the cost of feeding all the scientists involved in it (which receive government funding through their respective countries).

You can probably count the amount of companies with enough cash lying around to finance this on one hand. And then they'd still need the people for it.

Even once ITER is completed you still don't have a realistic product to sell. ITER is of no use besides getting us one step closer to fusion energy.

And at the end of it we may just realize that fusion is never going to be cost efficient compared to other energy sources.

That's no risk any sane company will take.

As always the free market will wait until all the groundwork has been laid by taxpayer funded scientists, and even then only make a move if there are massive government subsidies - as has happened and is still happening with fission energy.

The free market is much better at low-risk and incremental innovation. Stuff like this? Not so much.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by godelski on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:28AM (#20426658)
This is exactly right. If we look at history most of the major moonshots have at minimum had a substantial help from the government. Even silicon valley had a lot of help. Places like Bell Labs did as well, and partially forced. We see things now like X, but they're moonshots aren't decades out from being useful. That would be dumb for a company to do, which generally don't last on the other of centuries. But countries do! Even when they don't, the use lives on in the birth of whatever new country. Countries are in the business of succeeding on the time line of centuries, so funding things that takes decades of research and billions of dollars (mind you this is an international effort so that money is spread out over decades AND by many countries) makes a lot of sense. It's a simple fact that countries and companies operate on completely different time frames.

That being said, I have friends in fusion. I know plenty of others that work in various areas of it. No one thinks iter isn't going to work. All the major problems have been solved. The infighting you see is about money, because there isn't much going around for this because the gp is right that this is a difficult problem and we thought it was easier. The argument now is that some think we need iter to prove that it works and that will cause more funding to come in and then we can build the nice fancy power reactors. The other camp is that we don't need iter and that we should put that money into <insert popular method> (most will probably work). This is a very different conversation then what it was 20 years ago. 20 years ago we had neutron problems.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by hyperbovine on Saturday July 13, 2019 @10:50AM (#20428304)
> Companies are just too risk averse

The risk calculation is: expected cost minus expected reward. The expected reward is astronomical (no pun intended!), so you're simply restating my point: fusion is not likely to work regardless of how much money we throw at it. Amazon's R&D annual budget exceeds $20b. That's one company spending half an ITER a year. The private sector has no problem coming up with those sums for ideas it deems promising. The problem is that industry has decided, quite rationally in my opinion, that fusion power is not one of those ideas.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by chmod775 on Sunday July 14, 2019 @01:06PM (#20434468)
> That's one company spending half an ITER a year.

No it's not even close to the total cost of ITER. It may just pay for the cost of actually physically constructing it.

The R&D that got taxpayer funded scientists to the point where we are able to construct it at all is going to be a multiple of that.

> The problem is that industry has decided, quite rationally in my opinion, that fusion power is not one of those ideas.

So you're saying that things like fission reactors, spaceflight and GPS, treatments for some rare and not-so-rare diseases, the Human Genome Project, ARPANET, everything that came out of CERN, etc. were bad ideas just because no private company could be assed to develop and build those first?

No. It's a fact that all of these were vitally important to get our species where it is today, even though they would have looked like a terrible investment of time and money from the perspective of a private company. Today private companies have happily entered some of those spaces that have been pioneered by government funded scientists.

It's true that many moonshots fail. That's why they're called (sometimes literal) moonshots. But it's important to try anyways so we can advance as a species.

And most of the time we learn a lot even if we fail.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by arcticbull on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:24PM (#20426123)
It's always 5 years out until it isn't! :)
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by vlovich123 on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:12PM (#20425664)
Fusion is powered off of hydrogen, the single most abundant element in the universe. Seems to me like the smart bet is that sometime within 3000-300k years humanity will have developed fusion.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by cyphar on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:06PM (#20425861)
Cold, net-positive fusion. Current fusion reactors either require more power than they output or would run far too hot to be sustainable.

While I too am hopeful that humanity will be able to crack cold fusion in the next few hundred millennia, it should be noted that cold fusion is something which has simply not occurred in our universe before. Yes, fusion is the most commonly-occuring process in the universe, but all of it runs hot. It is possible that net-positive cold fusion might never come to pass and we'll have to go back to solar panels so we can exploit the output of already-existing hot fusion from the Sun.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by tsimionescu on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:20AM (#20426775)
Why would you need cold fusion? Simply net-positive energy output from a (hot) fusion reactor would do the trick.

Of course, there is a risk there that we will hit some fundamental efficiency limitation that simply makes it not worth it. But st least it's not known to be a physical impossibility, like cold fusion is believed to be.

In fact, more than cold fusion, I think there is a reason to hope for warm superconductors at some point in the future.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by cyphar on Saturday July 13, 2019 @03:16AM (#20426934)
That depends on how hot we're talking. I'm not up-to-date on the latest hot fusion work (so I might very well be completely wrong here) but I'd have naively assumed that containment would be a significant limitation of having stable hot fusion reactors. Most research fusion reactors I've seen online only run for minutes at most -- and that's with net-negative fusion.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by vlovich123 on Sunday July 21, 2019 @12:45PM (#20492184)
https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/29074/skunk-works-exot...

Basically there's lot of research into how to do containment that's far more efficient than Tokamak reactors that suffer from the problem you mention. A 100 years is a really long time to bet against given how the pace of our innovation is constantly increasing, let alone 3000 years. Keep in mind that thorium has 3x the capacity & we don't even have reactors to process that so even "regular" has a very long shelf-life. Uranium scarcity isn't a thing when compared with global warming & meets our energy needs drastically better than solar/wind & even hydro while having a much more compact ecological foot-print.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by ben_w on Saturday July 13, 2019 @06:35AM (#20427411)
From what I’ve been told, the runtime limit is mainly because they have a stringent and tiny limit on the lifetime radiation production of their reactors. These limits are not technological, they are because the reactors are research projects.

I believe the main losses are plasma instabilities, rather than the energy cost of the containment. This is somewhat secondhand knowledge though, I merely used to hang out in a pub with someone who worked in this field.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rabidrat on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:44PM (#20423783)
Those in the near- and medium- future are already lamenting our lack of concern for them :(
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by oliwarner on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:04PM (#20423427)
This assumes we don't screw ourselves into another dark age via societal breakdown climate disasters. Both events seem increasingly likely within 100 years, let alone 10,000 years.

Humanity in Y12019 might be exactly where we are now.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by manigandham on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:55PM (#20425260)
In that case there's no problem with fuel.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by ben_w on Saturday July 13, 2019 @06:36AM (#20427417)
Exactly where we are, but without all of the easily available petrochemical and coal deposits.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by godelski on Friday July 12, 2019 @07:33PM (#20425467)
This is utterly laughable!

If we can't make any improvements or find an alternative energy source (like fusion, who's fuel is essentially limitless) then we probably don't deserve to live anymore.

The assumption that we'll make absolutely no technological progress in a (at a ridiculous lower bound!!) 3000yr time frame (and that we shouldn't use an energy source because of that) is laughable! Let alone calling something the least renewable because of it. Specifically with nuclear we've made tremendous progress in the last decade alone. There is no evidence to support this kind of thinking. Let alone that humanity won't make any progress.

If we took this kind of thinking to any other kind of problem we'd never make any progress. There's reasons to not use nuclear (I'm pro), but this isn't one of them.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by ravitation on Friday July 12, 2019 @04:29PM (#20424200)
> Put aside the science fiction of asteroid mining nuclear fuel for now

> If we have dreams of ever being able to do mass interstellar travel

We probably should put aside the science fiction of mass interstellar travel for now too then?

Especially given that asteroid mining (or lunar mining) is relatively achievable in the near term compared to interstellar travel...

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by fragmede on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:39PM (#20425988)
> If we magically went to 100% nuclear fission for energy (which is not reasonable for personal transportation, at least)

Not quite so fast. A nuclear power plant under the hood of a car may be unfeasible for a long time to come, but what is becoming feasible is electric cars. Right now, a Tesla is still powered by coal in most places for now, but as more renewable energy sources come online, they magically get switched over to being solar powered, and then they become "nuclear powered", if/when that time comes.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by merpnderp on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:33PM (#20424718)
There is effectively an unlimited amount of uranium dissolved in ocean water which can be mined at a much higher cost, but which is an insignificant cost in the operation of a nuclear plant. There's no reasonable reason to delay consuming uranium, and absolutely ridiculous to consider saving thorium (not that we can actually consume thorium yet).
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by mikece on Friday July 12, 2019 @04:04PM (#20423983)
We have 300k years of uranium at current usage rates. If we switched over to Thorium the supply is orders of magnitude greater.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by UnpossibleJim on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:44PM (#20424791)
What is the foot dragging on the momentum of Thorium generators?
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by mikece on Friday July 12, 2019 @07:32PM (#20425462)
They don't produce plutonium. Department of War (later the Dept of Energy) had a LFTR (liquid fluoride thorium reactor) running at Oak Ridge but the primary goal there was to produce plutonium for the military's nuclear weapons arsenal, not electricity.

In addition to having a far more plentiful fuel source, a LFTR runs at ambient atmospheric pressure so it's not necessary to have a massive containment dome surrounding the reactor in case of a core loop breach. Also, the chemistry of a LFTR tolerates the addition of partially spent uranium fuel (popularly mislabeled as "nuclear waste") which is then consumed in the normal fuel lifecycle of a LFTR. Why this wonder of chemistry isn't more commonly known is beyond me: we could simply solve the Yucca Mountain problem by recycling the partially spent fuel stored there into liquid metal reactors like the LFTRs. The downside is that if you have to scram a LFTR the core chemistry solidifies (it's liquid metal, after all) and restarting is time and energy intensive.

Ultimately, though, because the LFTR didn't produce plutonium for bombs the Department of Defense didn't have interest in running it.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by godelski on Friday July 12, 2019 @08:44PM (#20425793)
I disagree with this. 233U is part of the Th cycle. You definitely get transuranic elements out, though admittedly less. There is an advantage though, you can produce power and pull out enriched uranium while doing that; an enticement plant that generates power. (Note: we already use reactors that have low plutonium yields)

The real reason that we don't have thorium reactors is that it's difficult. All the kinks aren't worked out. Compound that with that it's hard to implement new reactor designs and the process becomes really slow to work out those kinks.

The answer, unsurprisingly is extremely complicated but certainly isn't just because it doesn't produce Pu, or rather creates low yields. This myth needs to die.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by arcticbull on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:27PM (#20426130)
I think it's fair to say our expertise in Uranium cycle fuel came out of the fact it generates substantially more plutonium for nuclear weapons. This was a huge reason it was selected over Thorium initially. Now, it may just be momentum. I argue it's because back in the day, it didn't product Pu.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by godelski on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:14AM (#20426752)
Also keep in mind that the Uranium cycle is SIGNIFICANTLY easier. I'd argue that that played a major role. But I'm also not denying that weapons didn't play a role.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by jandrese on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:07PM (#20426082)
The fact that as a total percentage of the cost of generating the power Uranium is cheap as heck. All of these complex alternative fuel plans are solving a problem that doesn't currently exist.

If we went all in with fission we still have thousands of years before it's an issue, by which point we'll probably have figured out some even better alternatives.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by TremendousJudge on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:08PM (#20424955)
the fact that they don't really exist yet?
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by arcticbull on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:29PM (#20426139)
They do! CANDU reactors, in operation all over the world, can use Thorium fuel today.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CANDU_reactor

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by kjar on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:39PM (#20425162)
Oh dear this ancient repeated never ending debate. Nuclear lost - in cost, in failure modes, in lack of private funding, in plant build time, in risk of enrichment systems... dead horse is dead. Edit. Add the fact the reactors take decades to develop, cool story we have about ten of those decades before really shit has hit irreversible climate destabilization fan.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by manigandham on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:56PM (#20425267)
Tell that to the US Navy which operates dozens of reactors in wartime vessels travelling millions of miles and enduring rough conditions and even combat with one of the best safety records of any industry.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by Retric on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:42PM (#20426000)
The US has 2 sunk Nuclear submarines (129 and 99 lives lost). With at least USS Thresher being related to a loss of propulsion and thus at least indirectly the reactor. Considering how few where in service and none being sunk in wartime that’s not a great safety record. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sunken_nuclear_subma...

The cause of USS Scorpion’s sinking is unknown so it may be related to the reactor or it may not.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by manigandham on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:59PM (#20426056)
We're discussing safety record for nuclear power specifically, not lost ships for any reason. The USN has about half of all the reactors running by the USA. How is that a "few"?

If you read the page about USS Thresher then it clearly explains it had nothing to do with the reactor and was a "high-pressure water spraying from a broken pipe joint may have shorted out one of the many electrical panels, causing a shutdown ("scram") of the reactor, which in turn caused loss of propulsion" followed by other personnel and procedure issues that led to a sinking.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by Retric on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:05PM (#20426078)
That quote directly says the loss of reactor power was part of the chain of events leading to a sinking.

Sure it did not blow up, but that does not mean the reactor was safe to use as a critical piece of equipment. Loss of power is a huge deal and the reactor being unable to recover in that situation is a major design flaw.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by manigandham on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:30PM (#20426149)
That's like saying a torpedo hit the sub and the reactor stopped working so it's a reactor problem. You're being disingenuous. The reactor was not the part that malfunctioned.

Again, if you read that page then you'll find several other causes like faulty ballast tanks that didn't eject, isolating the steam system too quickly and eliminating potential energy from the turbines, and inexperienced personnel not restarting the reactor after shutdown. If just the ballast tanks had worked then the sub would be safe for rescue, if the steam was used then it could continue to drive to surface.

According to an official report [1]: "U.S. Nuclear Powered Warships have safely operated for more than 50 years without experiencing any reactor accident or any release of radioactivity that hurt human health or had an adverse effect on marine life. Naval reactors have an outstanding record of over 134 million miles safely steamed on nuclear power, and they have amassed over 5700 reactor-years of safe operation." and this is from several years ago.

1. https://www.mofa.go.jp/region/n-america/us/security/fact0604...

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by Retric on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:37PM (#20426175)
Steam turbines are part of a nuclear reactor. If it had used batteries and Diesel engines there would have been no steam system to fuck up.

I absolutely agree it was not the single cause of failure, it was even recoverable in theory. But, if the reactor had continued to supply power, like large result battery systems tend to, then it would have likely made it. That directly means using a reactor was less safe to put on the sub.

If an aircraft lost all engine power over the ocean because of a defective engine design and thus crashed. Well you can bet the navy would blame the engines, but with nuclear power they care about perception. The loss of a crew is acceptable risk, the loss of nuclear reactors from a public backlash is a loss of capability.

PS: They can and do mitigate this risk by having large battery systems for redundancy, it’s only a few hours of power. But, it can run a redundant electric engine to move the sub, and that’s an important lesson learned.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by manigandham on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:43AM (#20426677)
If it was a diesel-electric then the broken water-pipe would've shorted out the batteries and electrics, and the flooded engine room would've stopped the engines, resulting in the exact same loss of power.

The fact is that the reactor didn't fail, it worked normally. The steam system didn't "fuck up" but was used incorrectly. The part that did fail was the ballast tank safety system. Diesel-electrics aren't a magical answer and have major disadvantages (like the need for air intake in a submarine).

It seems you're arguing that nuclear-powered designs aren't good, which is an entirely different topic than the safety record of the reactors themselves. Bad design of a system is not an argument that that core principles are inherently wrong, which is exactly the same thing any nuclear expert will tell you about Chernobyl.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by Retric on Saturday July 13, 2019 @02:35AM (#20426826)
It’s very possible that a broken pipe would have shorted out all batteries on an equivalent non nuclear sub. But, that would also have been a significant design flaw.

Anyway, I think this is more a case of disagreements about what constitutes a system than about what happened. I would say if the design of a critical system lets people mess up then that’s a failure of the design and the system. Chernobyl was very much a case of operators doing a long series of dumb things as people do. Similarly, the operators caused an issue with the steam system, but that just means the system and it’s design was also faulty. (IMO, the steam system should be considered part of the nuclear power plant as civilian nuclear power plants also use a steam loop for similar reasons.)

I would rate the US Navy highly on nuclear safety operations especially over the last 50 years.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by arcticbull on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:33PM (#20426159)
It's the safest form of energy in terms of deaths per terawatt-hour generated by an order of magnitude [1].

[1] https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2011/03/deaths-per-twh-by-ener...

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by kortilla on Friday July 12, 2019 @07:18PM (#20425383)
Perhaps the dead horse is the claim that it’s dead? The only thing it’s held back by is ignorance.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by conanbatt on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:02PM (#20424918)
3000 years of not worrying about energy by todays standards looks like a fantastic deal to me.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by yellowapple on Friday July 12, 2019 @07:25PM (#20425417)
That's also 3,000 more years to figure out how to make a useful fusion reactor, or to figure out how to smoosh neutrons and protons and electrons together to turn uranium into a renewable resource, or to figure out how to blow up stars and harvest fissile material that way.

3,000 years is a long time at our current rate of scientific discovery.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by pier25 on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:35PM (#20424734)
Even if nuclear only lasted 3000 years it would be more than what fossil fuels will last.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by willio58 on Friday July 12, 2019 @09:50PM (#20426027)
And by then we will have many better alternatives
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by melling on Friday July 12, 2019 @04:26PM (#20424170)
Why would we put aside the science fiction of astroid mining? In 3000 years, it probably won’t be a problem.

And I’m not sure how you think it’s the most non-renewable. How much oil do you think we have left?

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rabidrat on Friday July 12, 2019 @04:46PM (#20424353)
The earth can make more oil given enough time. There will never be more fissile material in this solar system.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by melling on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:34PM (#20424726)
Enough time is millions of years for the earth to make oil.

If it makes you happy, i’m willing to ration the uranium so the earth’s supply lasts 10,000 years. If our exponential knowledge curve can’t solve the problem by then we might be in trouble.

The singularity should be within the next 10,000 years.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by read_if_gay_ on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:17PM (#20424606)
Once you get to the point where you mined all of the fissile material in the solar system you probably have fusion figured out or how to use solar power at large scales.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by tim333 on Friday July 12, 2019 @05:34PM (#20424728)
I'd say we have a reasonable expectation that fusion will be viable this century in the sense of working. Whether it will be cost effective remains to be seen.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by Rylinks on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:50PM (#20423299)
it's the most non-renewable resource, but it also goes away whether we use it or not.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by Retric on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:33PM (#20423682)
It’s going away on the scale of billions of years. Personally, I think it’s much better to use it for space exploration than unusually expensive electrical power.

Now if was even vaguely cost competitive with battery backed up wind and solar then that’s a reasonable argument, but until then I just don’t see the point.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by acidburnNSA on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:55PM (#20426226)
With seawater extraction and breeders there's enough uranium to power the entire world many times over for hundreds of millions of years. Thus, just like the fusion fuel in the sun, uranium fission fuel is effectively as renewable as it gets.

http://ansnuclearcafe.org/2016/10/03/nuclear-power-becomes-c...

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by nanomonkey on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:06PM (#20426081)
For all intents and purposes it is a renewable resource. Breeder reactors allow us to utilize our fissible materials for an absurd amount of time.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by acidburnNSA on Friday July 12, 2019 @10:56PM (#20426229)
Yup. Just like the finite but immense fusion fuel in our nearest star.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rakoo on Saturday July 13, 2019 @11:55AM (#20428651)
Does your figure account for the uranium contained in seawater ?
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by geophertz on Friday July 12, 2019 @04:42PM (#20424315)
By 300,000 years I hope you mean 200? https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-will-glo...

Not the only source but I couldn't bother to search more.

EDIT: this article says 90 years normally and 5 years if everything was run on nuclear power https://phys.org/news/2011-05-nuclear-power-world-energy.htm...

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by roenxi on Friday July 12, 2019 @07:30PM (#20425452)
Good news! That figure probably grossly underestimates how much uranium can be extracted. Indeed, I'd interpret that 200 figure as 1,000-2,000 years worth of supply.

If nothing else, people havn't seriously looked. For example, in Australia, the state of NSW "proclaimed on 14 September 2012 ... [the removal of] the ban on uranium exploration" [0]. Australia has worlds most extensive uranium resources in the world, although not in the state of NSW for obvious reasons. Possibly we can extend our lead.

But practically, the 'resources' definition that that article is relying on (going purely off the Australian legal framework) likely involves investment on the part of companies to be able to advertise. We've a lead-silver mine in Australia that have '20 years of resources' on the books over 80 year periods, because every time they need a mine extension they go out and 'discover' a bit more of the resource that everyone knows is there but havn't officially measured yet. The current 20 years of resource is a polite lie as well, they've got lots more.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranium_mining_in_Australia#Re...

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by r00fus on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:47PM (#20423279)
Just imagine if we were fully nuclear here, and reprocessing the fuel like France.

Perhaps the climate would be in a non-crisis mode.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by dudul on Friday July 12, 2019 @02:20PM (#20423043)
And surprisingly, there is a constant "let's end nuclear!" campaign going on in France. A lot of people complain about the risks of accident and the nuclear waste.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by pgeorgi on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:42PM (#20425181)
Nuclear reactors are delicate machines, and owners all over the world treat them badly to maximize profits, those in France being no exception.

In theory there's lots of controls and oversight and everything, in practice the nuclear industry has waste products that are suitable for military purposes, and so they can get away with rather a lot as their watchdog ultimately also owns a military.

These campaigns to "end nuclear" might have less traction if the owners managed their systems properly.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by charlesju on Friday July 12, 2019 @07:27PM (#20425430)
If we believe climate change is a catastrophic disaster for humans now and near future, we should do everything to protect ourselves.

There is a false dichotomy of renewables vs nuclear. Pursuing these options are not mutually exclusive. Only in so far that we want to devote limited resources to the problem.

The real solution is that we should pursue both. Nuclear so we have a back stop to the problem. Renewables so that we have hope for the best case clean and safe energy future.

It is foolish to believe the projections on renewables will absolutely happen. There are a lot of problems that can happen with technology at scale. Nuclear is a surefire bet, with risks being nuclear meltdowns and improper waste management.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by rswskg on Tuesday July 16, 2019 @08:48AM (#20449513)
We would have done the same in the UK, except it was foiled by an anti nuclear movement which is still informing the environmental movement today. It's a heart breaking own goal.
Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by TomK32 on Friday July 12, 2019 @03:31PM (#20423665)
Nuclear energy always has and will be a purely political thing. Without state funding no private or public company would have taken on the potential future risks of harnessing the same power that laid waste to two cities and forced the Japanese Empire into decades of submission.

Sadly we live in a world were future risks are ignored and lessons from the past, be it nuclear bombs or warfare in general, are forgotten and ignored.

Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days by notinversed on Friday July 12, 2019 @06:28PM (#20425090)
We have already cracked solar and battery tech. Coal is dying. Nuclear appears to be near dying as well. This has happened in the past three years or so.