Re:Costa Rica has run on 100% renewable energy for 300 days
by godelski on Saturday July 13, 2019 @01:28AM
(#20426658)
This is exactly right. If we look at history most of the major moonshots have at minimum had a substantial help from the government. Even silicon valley had a lot of help. Places like Bell Labs did as well, and partially forced. We see things now like X, but they're moonshots aren't decades out from being useful. That would be dumb for a company to do, which generally don't last on the other of centuries. But countries do! Even when they don't, the use lives on in the birth of whatever new country. Countries are in the business of succeeding on the time line of centuries, so funding things that takes decades of research and billions of dollars (mind you this is an international effort so that money is spread out over decades AND by many countries) makes a lot of sense. It's a simple fact that countries and companies operate on completely different time frames.
That being said, I have friends in fusion. I know plenty of others that work in various areas of it. No one thinks iter isn't going to work. All the major problems have been solved. The infighting you see is about money, because there isn't much going around for this because the gp is right that this is a difficult problem and we thought it was easier. The argument now is that some think we need iter to prove that it works and that will cause more funding to come in and then we can build the nice fancy power reactors. The other camp is that we don't need iter and that we should put that money into <insert popular method> (most will probably work). This is a very different conversation then what it was 20 years ago. 20 years ago we had neutron problems.
That being said, I have friends in fusion. I know plenty of others that work in various areas of it. No one thinks iter isn't going to work. All the major problems have been solved. The infighting you see is about money, because there isn't much going around for this because the gp is right that this is a difficult problem and we thought it was easier. The argument now is that some think we need iter to prove that it works and that will cause more funding to come in and then we can build the nice fancy power reactors. The other camp is that we don't need iter and that we should put that money into <insert popular method> (most will probably work). This is a very different conversation then what it was 20 years ago. 20 years ago we had neutron problems.