News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by drcode on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:20PM (#20320592)
> Facebook built this, yes, but they do not have full control

Well, the Libra documents are vague about timelines and how/if they plan to move to a "permissionless" system- Instead of saying "they do not have full control" you should qualify it to say that "their marketing materials claim that even if it launches with full FB control initially, they state that they hope to eventually transition to lower amounts of control."

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:26PM (#20320627)
No, they do not have full control from the start. Even in the current permissioned model.

The 28 (will be 100) member companies do (or rather a majority vote of them do). But Facebook itself will not have full control, from the start.

This is really important and something the media keeps getting wrong. Facebook isn't dumb, they know no one will trust something they control right now, so they made it so they aren't the ones in control.

They likely will be the biggest wallet app though, which is significant. But they still can't single-handedly change the rules of Libra, they need a majority of the Libra Association members to do that.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by tehjoker on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:20PM (#20320942)
"But if you invest a lot of money, you can designate universities or nonprofits to vote for you on this council. So, in effect, the more money you invest, even though you may not have direct power over how the association functions, you can still have enormous influence on the voting blocs of what would in essence be a new international currency. I’m wondering what—"

https://www.democracynow.org/2019/6/19/big_techs_war_for_you...

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:50PM (#20321066)
Sure, look, I'm not saying the Libra plan is perfect and unable to be corrupted, I'm just saying most of the "critical analysis" I've seen thus far doesn't go this deep into how Libra could actually go wrong.

They just say "Facebook controls this and they just want your data" and either conclude that it's stupid and will fail or it's evil and must be stopped, with no other reasoning.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by tehjoker on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:38PM (#20321540)
I don't think that you need an in depth analysis to understand that Facebook and a consortium of powerful private interests are looking to wrest further control of the world financial system from local control. Corporations are the opposite of democracies, so allowing a group of unaccountable players looking after only their own interests to control the world money system would be a disaster. To the extent the economy is already set up this way, it is already a disaster.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:38PM (#20321808)
By that logic, it's already a disaster, so this doesn't really change things? All it does is allow more people to engage in payments online. Even in that view, it seems like a potential net benefit to the world economy, maybe.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by CaptainZapp on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @07:43AM (#20343376)
I argue that it must be stopped in its tracks right now for two reasons:

It has potential to undermine the monetary systems of poorer nations, in essence (re-)colonialising them on the currency front

It has the potential to destroy decades of efforts in achieving monetary transparency and fighting money laundry on a global scale.

Even though some of the more libertarian minded contributors here seem to think that fighting money laundry is a bad thing I can assure you that it's not.

In addition I'm a bit flummoxed about the trust you seem to have in Facbook and they doing the right thing. A trust which is absolutely not warranted when I look at the short and dirty history and the constant lies and evasions of this company.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by drcode on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:33PM (#20320664)
I'm not saying you're wrong, but can you provide a citation? Where does it concretely say that FB will not be in charge of the network when it first launches? The closest I can find is the lawyerly language written here [1] that sounds, on the face of it, purposely misleading: The sentence "In these early years of the network, there are additional roles that need to be performed on behalf of the association" only makes sense if rephrased as "In these early years of the network, there are additional roles that need to be performed BY FACEBOOK on behalf of the association"

[1] https://libra.org/en-US/white-paper/#the-libra-association

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:35PM (#20320677)
From that very page, second paragraph:

"The association is governed by the Libra Association Council, which is comprised of one representative per validator node. Together, they make decisions on the governance of the network and reserve. Initially, this group consists of the Founding Members: businesses, nonprofit and multilateral organizations, and academic institutions from around the world. All decisions are brought to the council, and major policy or technical decisions require the consent of two-thirds of the votes, the same supermajority of the network required in the BFT consensus protocol."

Edit: the things they are describing that "need to be done by Facebook" likely means software dev work, done in open-source (it's already open-source), cause they have a ton of well paid people already that know how to do this whereas Visa, for example, might not. They are recognizing that early on, they will be doing a lot of heavy lifting, that's all.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by drcode on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:39PM (#20320698)
Yes, but in the paragraph I quoted, it clearly implies that the network is already live and that some unnamed entity acting "on behalf of the association" is recruiting the founding members, so there is some time period being referenced in which the network is already live and the founding members have not yet been established.

I should point out I'm not necessarily anti-libra, but I just think anyone claiming that we needn't worry because "Swiss Association" seems unreasonably sure of the situation.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:47PM (#20320745)
It's live in a "test net" at the moment, so developers can build on it. The test net is hosted by Facebook, through this year.

When the "main net" launches, it'll need all 28 members to run validator nodes to start it up.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by tfha on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:06PM (#20321420)
Until it's fully live, Facebook can change the terms, contract, code, strategy, etc. however they want. Until they have an actually decentralized system humming away, it's all us trusting Facebook to do what they promise.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @09:37PM (#20321803)
Until it's fully live, it's all funny money and not any sort of threat to real users. It's not like they can change things now and no one would notice before they launched and it took off?
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by lammalamma25 on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:39PM (#20321021)
If 2/3 of the members vote for something but the infrastructure is built/developed by facebook, I wonder if Facebook can simply say no. Not in the sense of publicly refusing to do it, but if something is not in their interest, they could slow it down or do it poorly so that it doesn't work. It seems the other members would have to take something like that over to get it done which is costly and may not be worth their time/money.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @07:02PM (#20321120)
Any of the members can build their own implementation of the Libra protocol and give it to other members, or they can take Facebook's and modify it (it's already open-source on Github).

Several of the members are already software shops that would gladly manage an implementation if the interests of Libra (and therefore, their own interests, cause they would only care if Libra were successful) were threatened by the Facebook implementation.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by davidgerard on Monday July 01, 2019 @12:59PM (#20327334)
> it's already open-source on Github

the released code appears to be rudimentary at best https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-20/facebo...

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:26PM (#20331613)
It's early, but I wouldn't call it rudimentary... Cryptocurrency implementations are complicated distributed systems problems. If the code were more complete, I'd wager the author would be complaining that too much of it was developed in private.

Idk, we don't need to depend on Bloomberg's opinion, we can check out the code ourselves: https://github.com/libra/libra .

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by tracker1 on Monday July 01, 2019 @03:17AM (#20323137)
Given recent financial censorship by some of the starting member companies, why should I trust any of them more than FB itself? Why not just use existing bitcoin or etherium?
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by gerikson on Monday July 01, 2019 @05:35AM (#20323757)
Are you asking why you personally should not use Libra in preference to BTC/ETH, or whether the parties in the Libra organisation should use BTC/ETH?
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by tracker1 on Monday July 01, 2019 @06:07PM (#20330219)
I'm questioning why FB and the member parties didn't just support an existing solution/infrastructure. The fact is, I don't trust them, and they have proven that I shouldn't. If they aren't actually decentralizing the system, and allowing direct person to person transfers without an account on their system, then that doesn't add anything over fiat currency, except allow them to not pay taxes.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:30PM (#20331631)
It's designed the way it is expressly because of the issues BTC/ETH/etc. have with price stability and regulators. Libra is basically an in-between, it's not fully distributed, but it's not fully centralized.

I'm personally in the "rising tide lifts all boats" camp atm; I think Libra will act as a bridge and help explode the rest of the crypto economy by making the fiat -> crytpo acquisition process way quicker and easier.

So I guess my answer is, I don't think you should use Libra if you don't trust it, and I'm not asking you to. I'm just pointing out that there's a lot of FUD right now about it from people not reading the whitepapers or not caring to be accurate.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by tracker1 on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @08:16AM (#20334264)
If two individuals cannot send each other currency directly, without one of the member companies blocking it, or requiring an account on a given member site... then I don't see any real advantage against fiat currency.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @07:16PM (#20340235)
Because it's digital. In the west, we have a digital abstraction around our fiat money (credit cards / ACH bank transfers) to send our money easily (sorta).

In the emerging markets Libra is primarily targeting (Facebook's fastest growing market), many people have phones and internet (and FB/Whatsapp), but no banking. This doesn't need to beat our fiat, it just needs to beat fiat in Africa.

That said, Libra still has many of the benefits of other crypto for general consumers (ie. the grand majority of people who aren't very worried about the government seizing their accounts or freezing transactions):

- It's safer than a credit card, since payments happen by sending currency (like cash) rather than forking over bank or credit card credentials to a website (the equivalent of forking over private keys)

- Transaction fees are far lower

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by CaptainZapp on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @07:48AM (#20343402)
It's safer than a credit card, since payments happen by sending currency (like cash) rather than forking over bank or credit card credentials to a website (the equivalent of forking over private keys)

Why should it be safer than paying by credit card? If a payment is fraudulent it's not my problem and I get refunded. If the service I paid for isn't received or is not as advertised I have the means of a charge back. With crypto no matter how turn it it's gone. And looking at customer service at tech companies I put exactly zero stock that I get help from them. So I think you have that backwards.

Transaction fees are far lower

Says who? We don't know that yet, do we?

Edited to add: I think the comparison between handing over my credit card number to a website with handing over my private keys is beyond ludicrous.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by gerikson on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @08:37AM (#20334397)
Exactly. This will just be a "meta-currency", stable against a basket of government-issued fiat, and with a permissioned transaction system built on top of it.

Libra's use of buzzwords like "blockchain" and "decentralized" are just PR.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @07:18PM (#20340250)
I mean, it is decentralized... The only difference is the member companies are publicized and we know who their CEOs are, whereas the mining pools that account for the grand majority of Bitcoin's hashrate, for example, are virtually nameless to the general public.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by gerikson on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @07:45AM (#20343385)
The banking system is decentralized too, but the word has a specific meaning in cryptocurrency circles - which I think Libra is invoking. I do agree that currently the Bitcoin mining/transaction system is centralized to a few very large mining pools.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by gerikson on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:41AM (#20333817)
Good answer. I doubt however that Libra's terms of service will allow purchase of "real" crypto - just like I doubt they will allow purchase of drugs, porn, or malware.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @07:19PM (#20340260)
They explicitly encourage crypto exchanges in the materials, actually!

They even designed/are developing a smart contract language called Move to facilitate DAO exchanges and the like.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by gerikson on Wednesday July 03, 2019 @07:43AM (#20343378)
I missed that! That's very interesting.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by gerikson on Tuesday July 02, 2019 @06:43AM (#20333821)
> I'm questioning why FB and the member parties didn't just support an existing solution/infrastructure.

You cannot build a stablecoin on crypto-assets that have limited issuance.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by mbesto on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:48PM (#20320749)
> they need a majority of the Libra Association members to do that.

Don't you find it odd that all of the member companies either (1) are based in SV and/or (2) have strong ties to SV? You don't think these people would collude with each other "offline" if they needed to?

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:55PM (#20320797)
Not odd at all, it's easiest to get them involved cause these people all know each other, obviously.

I don't think most of the new 70+ members they add by next year should be in SV, or even in the US necessarily, and it would be dumb if they did that.

I don't think collusion is a huge risk:

1. Many of these companies are direct competitors (Visa, Mastercard, Paypal, Stripe, etc.), you would need the silence of ALL of them in order to get away with some manipulation (cause they can all independently validate) AND

2. They would have to somehow spoof the public Validator API they are planning (which allows us peons to validate the ledger), without anyone noticing.

That's quite a caper, I think there are easier ways to make money at that point that are way less risky.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by pvg on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:17PM (#20320915)
Visa and Mastercard settled a price-fixing suit just last year. "They're not going to collude because they're competitors" seems like a very odd argument. Colluding while pretending to compete is the central thing that makes that sort of behaviour illegal.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:39PM (#20321018)
Sure, Visa and Mastercard are similar enough their interests could align to collude.

Why would a non-profit or NGO or university (several are already in the Libra Association) stay silent? Where do their interests align with Visa and Mastercard?

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by pvg on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:43PM (#20321036)
Why would a Wookie live on Endor? I'm just saying, you are presenting the definition of collusion as a reassuring check against collusion. This is not a strong argument.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @07:04PM (#20321132)
Neither is an argument that despite all of the ways to detect collusion against the ledger, they will somehow still collude, just cause.

I'm offering several mechanisms built into the proposal, in law and in math, that work against collusion, in addition to market dynamics.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by pvg on Sunday June 30, 2019 @11:06PM (#20322165)
Right but I didn't say that. You said they wouldn't collude because they compete. If that were true, we wouldn't need the law part.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by tptacek on Monday July 01, 2019 @10:18AM (#20325444)
Wookiee.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by mbesto on Sunday June 30, 2019 @07:10PM (#20321173)
> Why would a non-profit or NGO or university (several are already in the Libra Association) stay silent?

Because they don't have equal say perhaps? Or more realistically, because staying silent would politically benefit their institutions.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by mbesto on Sunday June 30, 2019 @07:07PM (#20321155)
> it's easiest to get them involved cause these people all know each other, obviously.

Right and that's precisely the reason drug cartels are so attractive to the people who run them....what's your point?

> Visa, Mastercard, Paypal, Stripe, etc.

Are you serious? If you don't understand how in bed these companies are with each other then I have a bridge to sell you.

You've brought up some seriously good points about how Libra is a reaction to WeChat, but IMHO this is a naive perspective into historically how companies work with each other in markets.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by dannyr on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:54PM (#20320792)
Oh my. What else should Facebook do for you not to trust their word?

Do you think Zuckerberg just magically became a trustworthy person?

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:56PM (#20320806)
I don't need to trust his word, that's the beauty of doing it this way. I just need to trust Swiss law, market dynamics of competitors, and math.

FB isn't dumb, they know they're reputation is in the toilet right now.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by tfha on Sunday June 30, 2019 @08:13PM (#20321451)
It's not set in stone until the network is live. Everything at this point is still in the hands of Facebook. And I doubt that will change.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by drcode on Sunday June 30, 2019 @07:06PM (#20321142)
Please show us the Swiss law.
Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by dannyr on Sunday June 30, 2019 @05:59PM (#20320824)
Oh, you keep saying in your comments that Facebook isn't dumb.

I agree.

Facebook's leadership is smart. They know what they are doing. They just hope that most of us would be dumb enough to believe them.

Re:Nipping Libra in the Bud by carlosdp on Sunday June 30, 2019 @06:04PM (#20320846)
Don't have to believe them, the governance and cryptoconsensus in the whitepapers is enshrined in law and math, and in addition there are competitors in the Libra Association that would easily decry other members if they tried something to subvert the operation of the currency.