I don't think most of the new 70+ members they add by next year should be in SV, or even in the US necessarily, and it would be dumb if they did that.
I don't think collusion is a huge risk:
1. Many of these companies are direct competitors (Visa, Mastercard, Paypal, Stripe, etc.), you would need the silence of ALL of them in order to get away with some manipulation (cause they can all independently validate) AND
2. They would have to somehow spoof the public Validator API they are planning (which allows us peons to validate the ledger), without anyone noticing.
That's quite a caper, I think there are easier ways to make money at that point that are way less risky.
Why would a non-profit or NGO or university (several are already in the Libra Association) stay silent? Where do their interests align with Visa and Mastercard?
I'm offering several mechanisms built into the proposal, in law and in math, that work against collusion, in addition to market dynamics.
Because they don't have equal say perhaps? Or more realistically, because staying silent would politically benefit their institutions.
Right and that's precisely the reason drug cartels are so attractive to the people who run them....what's your point?
> Visa, Mastercard, Paypal, Stripe, etc.
Are you serious? If you don't understand how in bed these companies are with each other then I have a bridge to sell you.
You've brought up some seriously good points about how Libra is a reaction to WeChat, but IMHO this is a naive perspective into historically how companies work with each other in markets.
Don't you find it odd that all of the member companies either (1) are based in SV and/or (2) have strong ties to SV? You don't think these people would collude with each other "offline" if they needed to?