News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by jaxbot on Thursday June 27, 2019 @02:59PM (#20297426)
Seems like misguided faux environmentalism, like banning plastic straws but keeping the longtail of plastic waste. Electric buses are good, of course, but a well-designed and highly utilized bus network, even with the dirtiest diesel engines, is going to get you serious wins over GHG/CO2/VOC emissions from automobiles if you can replace those trips.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 27, 2019 @03:08PM (#20297511)
Certainly we don't want to make perfect the enemy of the good: given a fixed budget we're probably better off buying 2 diesel buses rather than a single electric bus.

But don't forget particulate emissions: I believe that's the primary motivation for electric bus conversion. Buses are a significant portion of particulates in many cities, and particulates kill people.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by NickM on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:07PM (#20299334)
given a fixed budget we're probably better off buying 2 diesel buses rather than a single electric bus.

I think the situation is a little more complicated than that. Electricity is a much cheaper fuel than diesel, and maintenance costs are lower for electric vehicles too, so in the long term electric buses may end up saving more money than they cost.

Add to that the fact that interest rates are very low right now, and it may even turn out that financing the electric buses and charging systems could allow cities to save money from day one, though I haven't crunched any numbers so this is admittedly just speculation on my part.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by semi-extrinsic on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:36PM (#20299565)
> maintenance costs are lower for electric vehicles

I think there is a <citation needed> here. Do ICE drivetrains really constitute a large fraction of the maintenance costs on cars and buses? In my experience, suspension and steering, and auxiliaries, are the things that break.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by vvanders on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:42PM (#20299610)
My anecdotal evidence of ~90k miles on our EV says yes. A coolant flush, tires and windshield wiper fluid are the only things I've done in that time.

Compare that with Brakes, Oil changes, Transmission service, DPF + DEF and the host of other things you get with a diesel engine + transmission.

We've got a diesel truck, diesel tractor and EV, it's pretty easy to see the maintenance differences between the three of them over the years(the tractor being the highest with the added complexity of a hydraulic system).

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by crummy on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:15PM (#20299871)
I don't know anything about cars. Why did you need work done on your brakes on a diesel but not on an electric?
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by tialaramex on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:34PM (#20300016)
The EV gets to just run everything backwards when you step on the brakes. This won't stop you, but it'll make a huge difference to the remaining force needed to stop you, so it massively reduces wear on brakes and (which is why they did it) increases the effective range of the vehicle. And since they aren't worn out, the brakes need maintenance far less often. Driven gently the brakes on a EV might last its useful lifetime.

You can't do this with ICE, if you put diesel fumes in a compression chamber and pump the cylinders up and down, it doesn't turn back into diesel fuel, combustion isn't symmetric, so you need to actually have brakes.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by opencl on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:30PM (#20299983)
Electric vehicles and hybrids use regenerative braking from the motor for a lot of their stopping power. They do still need brake work but significantly less often (100-200K mile interval vs ~50K though there is considerable variance depending on driving habits) because the friction brakes are engaged less often and so wear down more slowly.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by petre on Friday June 28, 2019 @01:32AM (#20301746)
Electric braking, useful 90% of the time to slow down. Hydraulic brakes only get used for a full stop. It's like engine braking on steroids and fully integrated into your brake pedal so that you don't need to know which brake system operates at a given time.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by coryrc on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:28PM (#20299970)
Regenerative braking
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by rlucas on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:35PM (#20300019)
I doubt it's due to the EV's regenerative braking; if anything, that's a more complex system with more things that can go wrong.

The answer is probably easier: a Prius is 3300 lbs and a Dodge Ram is 6600 lbs and carries much, much more if working. Those truck brakes are going to be thrashed much harder.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by dahfizz on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:34PM (#20301272)
The regenerative braking system is not complicated at all. In fact, it comes basically for free!

All that happens is you cut power to the motor but leave the wheels attached to the motor. This is the same as "engine braking" on a manual. The wheels turn the motor, which steals kinetic energy from the car and charges the battery.

There's no extra bits or anything. It's all in the drivetrain that's there already.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by vvanders on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:51PM (#20300110)
Not really, the 85D weighs nearly the same as our Ram 1500 EcoDiesel(taken both to the dump scales at one point or another).

It really does come down to the fact that you brake in the 5-10mph range on the EV(or not at all in stop/go traffic).

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by imtringued on Friday June 28, 2019 @05:59AM (#20302855)
Did you not pay attention in high school? When you step on the gas your car, you are converting electrical energy into kinetic energy. When you release your foot, the kinetic energy that is stored into the car moves tires, which moves the shaft of the electric motor. What happens if you manually rotate a conductor inside a magnetic field? Obviously induction happens, which converts the kinetic energy back into electricity and heat.

>more things that can go wrong. Eddy Current Brakes are a passive system with an extremely high safety track record. If you ignore the bearing that holds the wheel/motor in place there are no moving mechanical parts. I couldn't think of a safer way to stop moving objects.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by petre on Friday June 28, 2019 @01:47AM (#20301803)
It's not complex at all and it's a consequence of electric motor operation. The engine goes into generator mode if you turn the supply into a load, which is very easily done and can also be easily done gradually. Regenerative braking uses this generated power to recharge the batteries, but you can essentialy do anything with it, the easiest thing being converting it into heat using a resistor.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by sitharus on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:49PM (#20299681)
Certainly suspension, steering and auxiliaries are the things that break, but every year (or 15,000km, or whatever your manufacturer recommends) you need to replace the engine oil and filter. Less frequently you need transmission fluids, coolant, air intake filter, brake pads and other consumables. On diesels you also need to refill the emissions compensation tank (the one VW cheated with), replace particulate filters. Heavily used vehicles need these replaced more often.

Electric motors will need their bearings replacing eventually, but they have no transmission fluids, no circulating oil picking up combustion products, and regenerative braking removes a huge amount of wear on brake pads.

I have a plug-in hybrid (EV infrastructure isn't great where I live) and after 2500km the brakes still stick like new. They've barely been used.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by petre on Friday June 28, 2019 @01:29AM (#20301736)
Yes. Fluid changes, filter changes, brake pads, clutch maintenance, sparkplugs, injectors etc.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by barney54 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @03:13PM (#20297565)
Particulates are one reason most city buses in the United States now run on natural gas. That's a real improvement over diesel in terms of particulates.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by supergauntlet on Thursday June 27, 2019 @03:59PM (#20298036)
One big question I have is why LPG isn't a bigger thing for cars. Regular gas and diesel engines can be (relatively) cheaply modified to run on LPG and indeed can often run on both. It's a cleaner burning fuel than both gasoline and diesel AND is cheaper to boot.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by rjsw on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:17PM (#20298255)
A friend had a LPG conversion for a car, the tank took up a lot of luggage space. A larger tank for the same range doesn't matter as much for a large vehicle like a bus.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by bobthepanda on Thursday June 27, 2019 @09:25PM (#20300698)
It’s also not abnormal for equipment on a bus go onto the roof.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by tastygreenapple on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:26PM (#20299481)
I think it's because most people don't understand the benefits of LPG fuel, and LPG vehicles incur costs similar to other alt-fuel vehicles without enjoying benefits.

Honda used to sell a natural gas civic and you could buy a home fill station, in the late 2000s it probably made a lot sense. But now, you'd be better off getting an electric vehicle and a home charger.

I think LPG is interesting, but if you're going to deal with speciality fuel/fueling, you can just get a hydrogen or battery electric vehicle and enjoy the benefits of an electrified powertrain. LPG powertrains retain the complexity and service costs of gas powertrains with pretty marginal benefits. Electrification has its own costs but unique advantages.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by gattilorenz on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:49PM (#20299680)
> LPG vehicles incur costs similar to other alt-fuel vehicles without enjoying

Not universally true. In Italy, where regular gas prices are stellar, LPG is a relatively common thing. Not common enough, but the infrastructure is "there" (although not as capillary as regular gas) and it's advertised as a consumer option.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by tastygreenapple on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:57PM (#20300156)
You're right, I was American-centric. It's a land littered with gas stations and finding other fuels can be extremely challenging.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by i_feel_great on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:48PM (#20299672)
In the case of New Zealand from the mid-70's to the early 80's, CNG (compressed natural gas) was subsidised by the government and there was a very large uptake. My dad had it installed in his Toyota Hiace van and Ford Falcons. This was during the oil shortages era.

When oil became cheap again, the government stopped the subsidies and it was back to petrol. The tanks and the pumps at the services stations were ripped out and sold to the Indians, Eastern Europeans and the Chinese.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by inferiorhuman on Friday June 28, 2019 @04:55AM (#20302594)
Worse fuel economy and increased engine wear are probably the big issues.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by opencl on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:12PM (#20298203)
At least newer diesels are a lot better about particulates than the older ones, the EPA has mandated particulate filters since 2007 and they reduce them by ~85-95%.

http://www.meca.org/regulation/us-epa-20072010-heavyduty-eng...

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by bradknowles on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:28PM (#20299493)
That's assuming you actually believe the numbers haven't been rigged, VW-style.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by ComputerGuru on Thursday June 27, 2019 @10:32PM (#20301015)
The crazy thing about the VW scandal: their cars still met the legal requirements for maximum allowed emissions even without the cheat module (at least here in the USA)!
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by opencl on Saturday June 29, 2019 @09:46AM (#20312533)
How would they possibly rig the numbers on a particulate filter? The cheating was achieved through engine control software selectively disabling parts of the emissions control system when it detected testing was not occurring. You cannot use software to selectively disable a particulate filter bolted onto the exhaust pipe.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by seanmcdirmid on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:48PM (#20300089)
My city has upgraded to hybrid and NG buses in the last decade (in addition to some non battery very old and new trolley electrics), there are plenty of solutions in between dirty diesel and clean electric that have to be considered as well.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by dsfsafasfasf on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:01PM (#20301127)
For particulates you can switch to CNG, and you can probably convert the diesel engines to run off that too.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by elihu on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:05PM (#20298113)
Also noise.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by WhompingWindows on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:36PM (#20298456)
It's neither misguided nor faux environmentalism. As a cyclist, going behind buses is straight toxic. Maybe you're a car user and you don't mind the dirtiest diesel engines, but those particles poison the lungs of our citizens and that nasty emission discourages people from using buses and cleaner transportation modes.

We must move to electrification if we want to save our lungs and our planet. No amount of dirtiest diesel is going to save us.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by ajross on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:56PM (#20298650)
> As a cyclist, going behind buses is straight toxic.

Maybe[1], but still less so than the equivalent emissions from the dozen or so passenger vehicles that bus replaced.

The upthread point (which is correct) is that the environmental gains from bus transportation are concentrated in the efficiency gains of shared vehicles and that the relative impact of the fuel used is fairly minor. Get people on buses, then optimize. The linked article is worrying about things in the wrong order.

[1] I mean, no, not really. Diesel exhaust stinks, it's not particularly "toxic".

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by hollerith on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:05PM (#20298749)
>Diesel exhaust stinks, it's not particularly "toxic".

You might know your body well enough to be able to tell that it is not particularly toxic to you personally, but please consider the possibility others are more vulnerable it (because for example their bodies have more chronic inflammation than yours does).

The URL below goes to an article not about diesel exhaust or pollution, but about chronic inflammation, entitled "Understanding inflammation". Here is all the advice near the end of the article on how a reader might reduce inflammation. Emphasis mine.

>“Losing weight can have profound effects on lowering inflammation,” says Brown, who adds that eating a diet rich in fruits and vegetables and low in fats, processed foods, and sugars is generally a good idea, though more study needs to be done to determine how it might affect inflammation. Exercising, which causes an acute inflammatory response in the short term, but an anti-inflammatory one when we regularly get moving, is another strong step to take, he adds. Other researchers advise getting plenty of sleep, lowering stress levels, and seeking out treatment for inflammation-inducing culprits, such as gum disease and high cholesterol levels. Avoid contact with heavy metals such as mercury, which is found in dangerous amounts in some large fish, and limit exposure to substances, such as diesel exhaust and cigarette smoke, that can set off the immune system.

https://www.johnshopkinshealthreview.com/issues/spring-summe...

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by ajross on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:30PM (#20298997)
I don't know what the argument here is. Obviously you don't want to be sucking down diesel exhaust, and I don't believe I set a stake down on "diesel is good for you".

My point was that, on balance, riding in a bike behind a diesel bus is less toxic than riding behind the train of 10+ cars it replaced (or really that riding in a city filled with single passenger vehicles is less healthy than one inhabited by diesel bus riders.

Get folks out of their cars. Then worry about what kind of buses they ride.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by martythemaniak on Thursday June 27, 2019 @10:26PM (#20300981)
You seem fixated on cars emitting stuff. Riding behind any vehicle that burns and releases any fossil fuel sucks, and all those vehicles should be replaced. In fact cars are quite a bit ahead of busses.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by hollerith on Thursday June 27, 2019 @05:47PM (#20299165)
My argument is that maybe not for you, but for many people the exhaust from one diesel bus is worse than the exhaust from 10 or 20 gasoline / petrol cars. The article I linked to makes no mention of any kind of pollution except for diesel exhaust.

(In California, where I live, the vast majority of cars are gasoline / petrol cars.)

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by ajross on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:09PM (#20299823)
So... you're genuinely advocating against the use of public transit? Seriously?
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by hollerith on Friday June 28, 2019 @01:04AM (#20301634)
No, I don't.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by cr1895 on Friday June 28, 2019 @07:06AM (#20303122)
Public transit isn't limited to diesel-powered buses.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by dsfsafasfasf on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:07PM (#20301157)
It's not toxic in an acute sense, but it's equivalent to cigarette smoke and chronically terrible for you (I love smoking and diesel, btw). Both are low T impartially combusted complex hydrocarbons that generate a stew of different nanoparticles and reactive species.

It's terrible stuff!

You can argue that it's benign in the middle of nowhere, where the concentration drops to nothing quickly. But not in the city!

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by deagle50 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @03:32PM (#20297767)
Except that diesel emissions kill city residents.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by StreamBright on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:10PM (#20298179)
So does coal power plant emission.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by r00fus on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:11PM (#20299844)
So add solar+wind into your jurisdiction's power mix. It's not hard to do, and progressively the diversity of power will be more stable than just relying on the coal plant which will get shut down.

EV buses allow you to wean off carbon power sources in many stages.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by StreamBright on Friday June 28, 2019 @04:01AM (#20302341)
Sorry I would like to run buses when it is dark or when the wind is not blowing.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by Brometheus on Friday June 28, 2019 @05:14AM (#20302669)
Well, they run on batteries.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by StreamBright on Friday June 28, 2019 @07:35AM (#20303279)
I see, how long they run with one charge? Are you implying that worst case the buses are charged with nuclear or coal energy?
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by imtringued on Friday June 28, 2019 @06:07AM (#20302892)
I am speechless.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by StreamBright on Friday June 28, 2019 @07:35AM (#20303281)
Sorry if you have nothing to add here.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by dang on Friday June 28, 2019 @05:46PM (#20309028)
Could you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News?
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by StreamBright on Saturday June 29, 2019 @02:29AM (#20311092)
Like what exactly?
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by dang on Saturday June 29, 2019 @02:37PM (#20314056)
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by munk-a on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:49PM (#20298582)
I don't mean to suggest that power generation modernization isn't important but... it's pretty beside the point, investing in diesel buses is locking that usage in for a great many years while an electric bus may be eventually powered by coal initially then transitioned over to an alternative energy source.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by merpnderp on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:09PM (#20301164)
I’d argue for diesel buses because wind and solar already strain keeping the electric grid stable, except it won’t be a coal plant, it will be a natgas plant, which by itself is a huge win over diesel motors in a big city.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by deagle50 on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:49PM (#20298584)
Are you really comparing pedestrians inhaling NOx directly from tailpipes to a remote power plant?
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by sokoloff on Thursday June 27, 2019 @10:06PM (#20300889)
Isn't it the particulates in diesel emissions that are particularly more harmful than other internal combustion engines?

NOx promotes low level ozone, which is an irritant, but I thought by far not the differentially harmful portion of diesel exhaust.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by StreamBright on Friday June 28, 2019 @03:54AM (#20302315)
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by gataca on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:51PM (#20298596)
Centralized coal power plant outside of the densely populated areas that buses concentrate in >>>>> mobile pollution machines in those same dense areas.

Seems rather obvious

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by StreamBright on Friday June 28, 2019 @04:01AM (#20302338)
Volume of coal power plant >>>> mobile pollution machines.

The 7 out of the top 10 CO2 emission sources in Europe are coal power plants. Their production is blown by the wind to populated areas. Some of coal power plant production ends up different countries as well.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2013/oct/15/european...

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by woodandsteel on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:17PM (#20299409)
>Electric buses are good, of course, but a well-designed and highly utilized bus network, even with the dirtiest diesel engines, is going to get you serious wins over GHG/CO2/VOC emissions from automobiles if you can replace those trips.

The long-term plan is to electrify both the buses and the cars, and also the trucks, and to do that in a reasonable amount of time, you need to work from now on at all of them at once.

What's your long-term plan?

And by the way, most of these cities already have a big diesel network. But let me ask again, what is your long-term plan?

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by dsfsafasfasf on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:03PM (#20301133)
"even with the dirtiest diesel engines, is going to get you serious wins over GHG/CO2/VOC emissions from automobiles"

Not for particulates. Even a clean diesel bus is going to be dirtier in particulates vs. gasoline. Its the nature of the fuel (i.e. not the thermo cycle used).

ON the other hand, converting to CNG eliminates particulates completely (you use the same engine, just feed it CH4)

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by eeZah7Ux on Friday June 28, 2019 @07:42AM (#20303314)
> even with the dirtiest diesel engines, is going to get you serious wins

This is true: more public transport should be the n.1 priority, even if it's diesel.

However you are creating a false dichotomy: electric VS diesel.

We can have more public transport and electric transport at the same time. Less cars, thanks.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by StreamBright on Thursday June 27, 2019 @04:09PM (#20298157)
Depending on what is the source of energy used to charge the buses.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by tropo on Thursday June 27, 2019 @06:54PM (#20299710)
That "well-designed and highly utilized bus network" is the hard part. I've never seen it.

Around here the buses run pretty empty. Sometimes they are literally empty. They take longer routes than cars, with each passenger going a longer distance because the bus route is not what they really want. It would be far better if the passengers had cars.

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by esoterica on Thursday June 27, 2019 @11:47PM (#20301315)
You’ve never seen it because you live in a city with garbage transit.

(It would not be better if all the passengers had cars, because then it would lead to greater congestion and it would take everyone 2 hours to go 10 miles.)

Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by crummy on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:22PM (#20299932)
Wouldn't the proper solution be to improve the bus routes?
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by closeparen on Friday June 28, 2019 @01:45AM (#20301793)
Bus routes are already subject to pretty sophisticated optimization. You can push utility around to do different segments of the community depending on your political priorities, but there aren't global optimizations just sitting on the table. Unless your transit agency is really incompetent, in which case you have to ask why your call to "improve the bus system" today will fare differently from all those that came before.
Re:Why U.S. Cities Aren’t Using More Electric Buses by tropo on Thursday June 27, 2019 @07:39PM (#20300035)
If that were possible, it should have already happened.

The bus just isn't going to take people point-to-point. It will go to a hub, and then people will change buses, and then another bus will go out. Point-to-point service is personal transportation. Shared transportation fundamentally can't be optimized to individual needs.

So the buses drive longer distances, and they have to drive even when empty.

BTW, bus usage can seem better than it really is. You are likely to go on the popular parts of the routes, so you see the buses being fuller than they usually are.