So everyone there is hoping that Apple buys them out.
Selling toast isn't easy when you let the customer borrow your bread and butter.
To put it another way, Apple took their ball and went home. No soup for them!
FYI - IBM handed Microsoft and Intel a big chunk of market share because who would ever want a personal computer...
I believe it was because they needed a PC in a hurry. I have heard that Ken Olsen ridiculed the IBM PC for its crude design, but it was the beginning of the end for DEC.
That's a much better explanation. They made the entire thing in a year, and 90% of it was made by outside vendors. I think both of these things, long-term, contributed to its success.
And that was just the start. Fantastic article. Qualcomm, man, just evil business practices that worked for a decade and may continue depending on appeals.
Here is the thing. If Apple sold a 2G network based iPhone with a non Qualcomm IP modem, and a 4G iPhone at 2x the price with a Qualcomm modem, which one would make more money for Apple?
And if it wasn't a percentage, it will be a fixed price for everyone, while it may sound fair, all of a sudden everyone selling a phone would be paying in total ~$50 to Patents license. That might not matter to higher end phones, for the lower spectrum that is a huge increase in Total Cost.
Sure, without QCOM's IP, other non-wireless parts of the phone won't add/contribute as much value or drive market demand for the phone.
Their business model existed largely via the mismatch between cellphone companies and wireless carriers.
Free market pricing is based on demand of the feature not the cost to make it. Qualcomm should be pricing the part at the point where the phone without the qualcomm part is equal value per dollar.
Apple is sitting on 200b in cash. What would be great for consumers if they spent some of their cash on 6g networks before they turn into a sovereign wealth fund.
Anyway, such verticals integration is unlikely to be good for consumers.
Consider the 64 GB iPhone XS selling for $1000 vs the 512 GB one for $1349. Is Qualcomm adding any extra value to the second phone as compared to the first one? Obviously not, so why should they capture any of the extra purchase price?
For the industry at large it was $500 (now $400) [1]
https://fudzilla.com/news/mobile/47691-apple-qualcomm-licens... [0]
https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-qualcomm-licensing/qualco... [1]
Sure, first, QCOM licensing fee only applies to the first $400, which is in turn also based on the wholesale, not retail, price from Apple's contract manufacturers.
second, without QCOM, Apple wouldn't be able to price the iPhone XS at $1000 (or the iPhone 7 at $550), much less sell nearly as many units. Would you even consider paying $550 for the 128GB iPod Touch, which is essentially at feature parity with the iPhone 7, but without QCOM's IP?
Sure, QCOM is not a marketing/consumer electronic company they way Apple is. Your 99% of consumers buy the iPhones over the iPod because of QCOM's wireless functionality, not because of their branding.
And how many of those 99% of consumers do you think would pay $1000 for a OLED iPhone XS without QCOM's patented wireless features that allow to make phones call or data? Or how many would pay half the price? or even a third? The iPhone 7 without OLED, the most popular selling iPhone in many countries, still costs at least twice as much as comparable iPod Touch and sells multiples of the unit sales of the iPod touch.
Free market pricing is based on demand of the feature not the cost to make it. Qualcomm should be pricing the part at the point where the phone without the qualcomm part is equal value per dollar.
This is the problem with mandatory standards and patents that cover those standards.
Standards require all participants to license at a FRAND rate. If apple developed 5G IP they would have effectively received a rebate based on the relative impact of their contribution.
Qualcomm actually has great execution. You realize 5G is going to put a 1 gigabit network in the palm of your hand? I can’t even get that out of cable.
Clearly you didn’t read the article. There’s an entire section about Qualcomm not issuing FRAND licenses.
In the ideal world the phone would be like a PC, and you could buy an iPod touch from apple and swap in the qualcomm 5g modem or the intel one.
Apple pays qcom $14 bucks for the modem. In the PC world I think qualcomm would be able to price theirs closer to 50 compared to intels.
Qcom charges Apple $14 bucks for the modem. That doesn't sound crippling or unfair or unreasonable. I think if consumers had the option to buy an ipod touch for 500, then add the modem like you do with a PC no one would be buying a fully integrated device from Apple for 1000.
I worked at Qualcomm, so take this with a grain of salt. But I find it laughable that Apple is complaining when they can sell the exact same thing at 2x the price by just adding a $14 dollar qualcomm modem.
But if you need to give Qualcomm money for the 9000 Bold (in house stack, no qualcomm at all, GSM, and sold around the world), because you need to license it to buy the modem for the 9670 Bold (CDMA, sold in select market, and CDMA use was minimal elsewhere), then out of the 99 problems you've got, Qualcomm is one of them.
RIM sold more 9000 than 9670. In its heyday, the GSM stuff is everywhere, but needed to keep the CDMA for NA and a half-hearted attempt to enter China.
That entirely depends on what Qualcomm was charging RIM's competitors.
Blackberry had a meteroic rise and they collapsed because of iPhone and (later) Android.
I wouldn't call RIM / Blackberry a meteroic rise. They start in the mid 90's and built up the products in a pretty smart way with each following the next until the total shift of the Storm.
And it was a super outdated Android runtime that ran like dogshit compared to the native BB10 apps.
Also, if you wanted any sort of Google Play services stuff, you had to have an app on a laptop/desktop to sign all your apk's the same and remove a specific check... and you'd have to do it all over again every time you wanted to update an apk with play services.
Not ideal.
It would make for a great email + basic usage phone, but not for media consumption. And the camera's not great.
I used a BlackBerry Classic that also ran BB10 until December 2017, and I still pick it up from time to time and wish I could still use it. The Classic is unique in that it has three independent input methods, all of which work super well:
1. Touch screen: the BB10 OS is actually designed for touch, with fluid and intuitive gestures. Swipe up to go home, swipe up and to the right to go to the notifications hub (reverse the gesture to just peek), swipe left to pull off a screen layer to go back, swipe down from the top to view the settings pane (standard place for settings in every app).
2. Optical trackpad and hard nav buttons, just like on old BlackBerries. You can fully control the phone without touching the screen (great for when you're wearing thick gloves during winter). Works super well for a mouse pointer in the browser. The trackpad even works reasonably well in Android apps, which weren't designed for it (presumably, it piggy-backed on the accessibility focus stuff).
3. Hardware keyboard: typing experience is great—not necessarily faster, but super precise, and no pop-up keyboard getting in the way. Every app is designed with keyboard shortcuts in mind, and the OS makes discovery super easy, so stuff like [C]omposing an email, scrolling to the [T]op of the page, or scrolling to the [N]ext page in a PDF are single click operations. Modern BlackBerries also have great keyboards, but since they run Android, they have none of the shortcuts (except app shortcuts).
As an active participant in Playbook's entire development from (near) start to end, there were multiple reasons. They weren't good reasons (most of my colleagues had, eh, concerns which got override,) but they somewhat made sense.
What happened was that multiple teams (internal and external) screwed up, so much so that the thing's internal was completely redesigned half way through development ie. Switched to a completely different SoC .
As another poster noted, their power supplies were great. I still have a couple left around my house. They had to be great partly because of a design oversight....
If they could have taken more time, it might have been better.
But the Playbook product did effectively expose the lack of depth, talent and relevant experience at RIM. I'm ashamed to say.
I still use the well made power adapter (Micro USB) that came with it to charge devices to this day. Kinda sad seeing that blackberry logo and knowing the tablet was horrible.
BlackBerry was a small company up against the #1 product of the era (iPhone) and a 'free' competitor. Both companies are basically #1 and #2 brands in the world. They have very deep experience in all things, channels, money etc..
We had no 'mapping team' really, Google had 100 people.
iOS is from MacOS. BB had this ancient thing.
We were just a tiny company that got clobbered, but frankly, BB was culturally more like 'motorola' than an advanced, well run entity. BB could not compete.
RIM started in 1982, not in the 1990's. The 'rise' was quite meteoric when they decided to put email on your hip, and added a phone.
Build quality was very poor. Overall experience was very poor.
She ran back to iPhone as soon as she could.
RIM died because their products were poor compared to the competition, it's as simple as that.
There was a fundamental change in phone capability and interaction that really shifted the market, and made new winners and losers.
Then the Passport launched, LOVED the format, best format ever squared and large screen, beautifully fitting everywhere though being larger, loved the TOUCH keyboard, loved the unified messaging but had NO F* network connection ever. Just could't be called or call others. A second Passport the same. Then one got dropped and it totally broke internally, the "steel frame" didn't help in any way, I assume it contributed due to its weight and momentum.
Reality is often a bit more nuanced than that.
Patent licensing fees were a big part of the equation, which led to inability to lower costs to compete.
Yes. OP asserted that too. Like OP, you haven't actually given a reason why. Here's some counter-arguments:
1) BB grew exponentially all the while paying Qualcomm licensing fees - why didn't it affect them then?
2) EVERYONE was paying the same licensing fees to Qualcomm. You couldn't build a smartphone connected to the cellular network and not pay those fees. So are you saying that it affected BB more than it affected Apple, Palm, MS, Samsung, etc. ?
As to #1, around BBOS v5 and v6, when they were pretty much top dog, all the cellphone accounts that wants to use a BB pays a service-access fee, or a BlackBerry Tax that goes to the company. Enterprise companies that want their emails and everything else also pays for the BlackBerry Enterprise Server. They were practically the only game in town.
They didn't have problem then, because they were rolling in cash; just like how they didn't have a problem basically buying up Philips st expanding, or keep coming up with phone models even though there's no way that there's enough demand to actually absorb the production.
#2 on top of needing to deal with Qualcomm licensing fees, which often applied (as the article stated) on non-qualcomm phones, they basically freaked out after losing that lawsuit to the patent troll, so they end up overpaying for licenses (not sure who's the licenser in this case) to avoid getting hit with more patent trolls. The contracts for those licenses were quite hard to get out of. By the time they were making the BlackBerry Priv, they don't have the SAF to juice their income. Patent licensing, Qualcomm and others, were disproportionally high, compared to other Android providers. They can't renegotiate some of them due to the contract wording. Being 1% of the market means Qualcomm hardly cared to give support, because Qualcomm is far more likely to help Samsung and other android phone, that pushed out far more numbers than BlackBerry did at the end.
It ends up being that they end up licensing their brand, because had they manufactured their own phone, they'd have to deal with the patent licensing contracts that they can't get out from.
There's probably a reason why OP won't be too forthright in describing why. I'll leave that as an exercise to the reader.
They sipped battery and data, and once that gear is setup, the SAF was very profitable.
Even to this day, email is not the same level of instant.
This is one big piece of that puzzle. I'd still kill to have a vertical slider for a phone...
Samsung should start selling 5G modems in NA as well. I know this stuff isn't going to work in the short term, but this is the sort of choices we need.
https://www.semiaccurate.com/2019/04/16/qualcomm-just-beat-a...
https://www.semiaccurate.com/2019/04/18/why-did-intel-kill-o...
So please, please, stop bringing up SemiAccurate on HN.
And 4th, 10nm is not dead, Intel is not skipping it for 7nm. Nokia is not dead either. And it doesn't matter how anyone spin it, SemiAccruate is like tabloid of Tech Report, and to ensure the quality of news I personally believe it should serve no role on HN.
I thought chip-makers weren't required to license QCOM's patents -- QCOM like all other wireless SEP holders only collect licenses at system-level.
They could have formed a joint venture with other manufacturers to split the development costs.
RIM pushed hard to develop its own chip 3G/4G chips because Qualcomm absolutely strangled the company with its licensing cost/terms. They pretty much demanded a separate cellular R&D team (QCT) that duplicates half the effort. All CDMA based phones must contain chips from QCT because Qualcomm holds CDMA patents and they won't license them to anyone. Finally, Qualcomm was, while very technically competent, will give you no assistance whatsoever if you deviate from what they want you to do. Basically 'my way or the highway.'
Edit: As an aside, my heart goes out to Intel's defunct Infineon-based 5G modem team.