News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Qualcomm shook down the cell phone industry for almos... by aey on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:09AM (#20058366)
If it cost apple less to build improvement into 5G that would have been licensed to everyone they would have done so.

Standards require all participants to license at a FRAND rate. If apple developed 5G IP they would have effectively received a rebate based on the relative impact of their contribution.

Qualcomm actually has great execution. You realize 5G is going to put a 1 gigabit network in the palm of your hand? I can’t even get that out of cable.

Re:How Qualcomm shook down the cell phone industry for almos... by forrestthewoods on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:47AM (#20058507)
> Standards require all participants to license at a FRAND rate.

Clearly you didn’t read the article. There’s an entire section about Qualcomm not issuing FRAND licenses.

Re:How Qualcomm shook down the cell phone industry for almos... by mbreese on Friday May 31, 2019 @09:33AM (#20060683)
@aey used to work at Qualcomm according to their resume. So, take that for whatever you think it’s worth.
Re:How Qualcomm shook down the cell phone industry for almos... by aey on Friday May 31, 2019 @10:53AM (#20061420)
Yep, worked at qcom. I think they should charge what the market could bear, like apple charges consumers :)
Re:How Qualcomm shook down the cell phone industry for almos... by aey on Friday May 31, 2019 @10:57AM (#20061458)
They haven’t lost a FRAND case yet.

In the ideal world the phone would be like a PC, and you could buy an iPod touch from apple and swap in the qualcomm 5g modem or the intel one.

Apple pays qcom $14 bucks for the modem. In the PC world I think qualcomm would be able to price theirs closer to 50 compared to intels.

Re:How Qualcomm shook down the cell phone industry for almos... by vasachi on Friday May 31, 2019 @02:01AM (#20058565)
Meh, 1Gbps over cable is nothing, really. Switches with 10g uplink ports cost almost nothing now. Problem is that most software and hardware on user’s side can’t deal with that speed :) 5G smartphones probably won’t be able to give you 1Ggps either.
Re:How Qualcomm shook down the cell phone industry for almos... by aey on Friday May 31, 2019 @04:59PM (#20064908)
I just moved, and I have access to 1gbps fiber at my home for $50 a month vs a severely crippled 100mbps from comcast for $120 a month two blocks away. So land internet is not free, and 1gbps is rare.

Qcom charges Apple $14 bucks for the modem. That doesn't sound crippling or unfair or unreasonable. I think if consumers had the option to buy an ipod touch for 500, then add the modem like you do with a PC no one would be buying a fully integrated device from Apple for 1000.

I worked at Qualcomm, so take this with a grain of salt. But I find it laughable that Apple is complaining when they can sell the exact same thing at 2x the price by just adding a $14 dollar qualcomm modem.