News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by spraak on Sunday May 26, 2019 @01:22AM (#20013299)
Often I see comments asking what we can do to combat this, or expressing feeling hopeless. While it is not the complete solution, one direct way is by eliminating your personal consumption of animal products. Animal agriculture is a huge contributor to methane production, especially from cows.

> Overall, we conclude that methane emissions associated with both the animal husbandry and fossil fuel industries have larger greenhouse gas impacts than indicated by existing inventories. [1]

[1] https://www.pnas.org/content/early/2013/11/20/1314392110.abs...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ar-jan on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:47AM (#20014901)
Let's also look at greenhouse gases in general:

"According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the largest sources of U.S. GHG emissions in 2016 were electricity production (28 percent of total emissions), transportation (28 percent) and industry (22 percent). All of agriculture accounted for a total of 9 percent. All of animal agriculture contributes less than half of this amount, representing 3.9 percent of total U.S. greenhouse gas emissions. That’s very different from claiming livestock represents as much or more than transportation." [0]

Global direct greenhouse gas emissions from transportation versus livestock represent 14 versus 5 percent respectively. [1]

Also consider: "According to the FAO, as much as 70 percent of all agricultural land globally is range land that can only be utilized as grazing land for ruminant livestock." [1]

[0] https://theconversation.com/yes-eating-meat-affects-the-envi...

[1] http://news.trust.org/item/20180918083629-d2wf0

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rewq4321 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:39AM (#20015129)
> Global direct greenhouse gas emissions from transportation versus livestock represent 14 versus 5 percent respectively.

The FAO's latest number for livestock emissions is 14.5% when considering the full life-cycle. It doesn't matter that we don't have a full life-cycle analysis for transportation - that doesn't change the number for livestock. The author tries to dismiss the 14.5% because "[transportation might be a bigger culprit]" and talks about "unringing" the bell on the FAO report simply because of a correction from 18% to 14.5%, which seems a bit of an overstatement.

On top of this, new (2017) data seems to suggest that our predictions of livestock emissions were too low:

> Using the new emissions factors, we estimate global livestock emissions of 119.1 ± 18.2 Tg methane in 2011; this quantity is 11% greater than that obtained using the IPCC 2006 emissions factors, encompassing an 8.4% increase in enteric fermentation methane, a 36.7% increase in manure management methane, and notable variability among regions and sources.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5620025/

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ar-jan on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:51AM (#20015516)
It does matter, because it makes sense to focus on the biggest contributors to emissions, where the most gains could be made.

The current thinking goes we should eat "less or no meat", when the effort could be put towards not using grain for livestock feed, and promoting other changes such as reducing methane specifically by adding seaweed to the livestock's diet. That's not to mention that grazing is essential to both prevent and reverse desertification.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rewq4321 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @12:36PM (#20015773)
I think this is a "we shouldn't bother with X because Y also helps (and is more convenient for me), even though they're not mutually exclusive" argument.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jefflombardjr on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:18AM (#20013430)
Live stock farming is ~27% of methane production, where fossil fuels are ~33% [1]. Eating an eco friendly diet is great on the individual level, but we should not underscore the drastic need for decisive action on an institutional level.

[1] https://whatsyourimpact.org/greenhouse-gases/methane-emissio...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by h0l0cube on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:34AM (#20013487)
One way to achieve both action on an institutional level, and reduce the consumption of meat, would be to capture the 'environmental costs' in the price. This could be orchestrated by government intervention, or on a less-effective scale, it could be a market differentiation for certain beef brands to include climate-change mitigation as part of their strategy and charge a premium.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by FailMore on Sunday May 26, 2019 @04:53AM (#20013891)
Yes 100%. The world needs Environmental Economics. This would make it financially worth while for huge investment to flow into environmentally friendly products.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rjf72 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:03AM (#20013548)
And to emphasize here, those figures are likely both inflated if this article's hypothesis is correct. That being that primarily natural factors are driving the surge.

It's because of this, and practical reality, that I don't understand why scrubbing is not considered a bigger part of the discussion on these topics. For instance one new technological solution [1] proposes an atmospheric removal of CO2 that could cost as little as $94 per ton. Our current CO2 emissions due to fossil fuels are about 37 billion tons a year. That's $3.5 trillion, 4% of the global GDP, to remove 100% of annual emission output. And an even better aspect of these solutions is that they also scale indefinitely. For instance you could not only reduce our footprint to 0 but even reduced the concentration of various gases in the sky, such as CO2, if that was deemed desirable. The same technology (or an inverse) also has direct application to future geoengineering efforts on other planets.

Ultimately this is technology that there does not seem to be any physical barrier against - in other words we can develop it. And now seems like a great time to develop it. The current mitigation ideas of cutting back on x seem to be all we consider, yet they have immense barriers to execution. By contrast technological solutions would be something that would require no sacrifice and simultaneously also greatly expand our technology and developmental capabilities. And most importantly they all seem tantalizingly close.

Yet in spite of all of this there seems to be near 0 discussion of these options. This is something I find confusing.

[1] - http://www.digitaljournal.com/tech-and-science/technology/ne...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by Quenty on Sunday May 26, 2019 @04:00AM (#20013696)
I think the assumption is we need to actually go carbon negative in the long term. So scrubbing with be essential in the long term.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jefflombardjr on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:07AM (#20013569)
More important than carbon scrubbing, we need energy innovation and to make environmental damage illegal and stop allowing companies to profit off of it.

See my other comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20013495

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rjf72 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:41AM (#20013630)
I think the argument that you posed in your other post to be challenged in one particular way. You claim that there is no time to deploy carbon scrubbing. I immediately see two major issues with this argument. The first is that greenhouse effects are not irreversible. As you remove greenhouse gases from the atmosphere, you change the heat equilibrium. Even feedback effects can be mitigated both by temperature change which reduces the feedback as well as by simply managing with their (causative) consequences - which tend to be an increase the gas emissions, by removing those emissions. In other words human social change does have a limited timeline of viability, but scrubbing does not.

The second is that everything is relative to other options. The first major paper (to my knowledge) regarding imminent danger from climate change was published some 40 years ago. The first 'alarming' governmental report and subsequent media involvement was 30 years ago. Since then there's been effectively 0 change by reliance on social systems, treaties, agreements, and so on. Nearly all of the progress we have made is because natural gas became cheaper than coal, which would have happened with or without these agreements. I don't see this inability to effect social change in any way changing in the future. So by claiming there's not enough time to enact scrubbing (which by the earlier point is not necessarily a reasonable argument to begin with) you're suggesting that other viable alternatives can be enacted more rapidly - and I also see no reason to believe this to be accurate.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jefflombardjr on Sunday May 26, 2019 @04:18AM (#20013768)
> The first is that greenhouse effects are not irreversible.

The UN clearly says there is a point of no return, could you please clarify what you are trying to say? https://www.un.org/press/en/2018/gaef3500.doc.htm

edit: better report https://www.egu.eu/news/428/deadline-for-climate-action-act-...

And what do you think about this type of scrubbing? https://www.ozy.com/fast-forward/the-search-for-a-perfect-pl...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rjf72 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @05:44AM (#20014052)
I don't think plants are a viable solution for quite a number of reasons.

The most fundamental is that they are inherently temporary storage. Plants absorb various gases as they live, and then emit it as they die. So you're just kicking the can, and not even especially far. For instance a tree can absorb up to around 50 pounds of CO2 per year. To put that into contrast an iPhone 7 results in about 123 pounds of emissions, so you need 2.5 trees per iPhone per year. Alternatively a gallon of gasoline releases about 19 pounds of CO2. So for every 10 gallons of gas a person uses you'd need about 4 full grown trees. And again that is per year, per person. Look around your house and imagine how many trees you'd need just to temporarily mask just your own personal consumption. It'd be a small forest, per person.

That leads to the second problem - scale is limited. With an unbelievably massive planting effort we could probably work to temporarily mask our emissions today. And while our emissions today are a problem, you can't ignore the future. Right now the vast majority of the world doesn't emit much per capita, but that's because most of the world lives in less developed areas. As China, India, Africa, and other areas continue to develop their emissions per capita are going to continue to increase. We should expect worldwide emissions to sharply increase over the coming decades, and so we need solutions that can scale accordingly.

And the final issue is that these solutions can, at times, go up in flames. For instance a recent study on wildfires has indicated that wildfires in places such as California can end up contributing even more to their CO2 output than the vehicles in those areas. [1] Mass planting of greenery would work as temporary storage, but it's not an especially stable form and so the net effect would be very difficult to accurately predict.

[1] - https://www.livescience.com/1981-wildfires-release-cars.html

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rjf72 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @04:47AM (#20013867)
Sure, these reports are talking about the point of no return in terms of human activity having an effect. In the grand scale of climate humans play an extremely small role. For instance with CO2 we account for less than 4% of all emissions in the worldwide CO2 system. The reason that our effect is meaningful is because it's a system that's in equilibrium. CO2 was being absorbed and released in a fairly balanced system, though one that does tend to have its own cycles over time. So even small changes to the system can have a disproportionate effect.

In other words imagine 2000 calories is what you need to sustain your weight at your current activity levels. And you increase the caloric intake just 5%. Even though you've added almost nothing to what you regularly consume, you're going to go from zero weight gain to some very non-zero amount of gain. You eat thousands of calories and then adding a hundred more suddenly makes you go from a-okay to weight gain? It's a logical but counter-intuitive problem. The exact same thing is happening with worldwide CO2 levels and the increase in atmospheric greenhouse gases.

But now enter feedback mechanisms. As the Earth heats up natural processes begin to release more and more CO2. For instance through the melting of permafrost or otherwise frozen gases (the likely culprit here). You reach a point that the Earth is producing enough additional CO2 that even if you instantly cut human emissions to 0 it would be unlikely to have any meaningful effect. So when the UN speaks of things such as irreversible change, they are speaking exclusively of solving the problem by reducing our emissions.

Scrubbing does not have this problem. Instead of trying to change our role in the equilibrium (for instance trying to decrease those 100 calories) it works on the system as a whole. And you can scrub arbitrarily large amounts. You could even make places like Venus habitable again with scrubbing technology - though to emphasize - Venus is many many many orders of magnitude away from anything we would need to solve on Earth. There are also other grand motivations for developing it. For instance, atmospheric scrubbing, once well developed, could even begin to work as contingencies against life destroying natural or unnatural disasters - nuclear fallout, mega-volcano eruption, meteorite impact, etc. And the opposite (atmospheric injection) could help resolve natural disasters like gamma ray blasts which are one plausible explanation for the Ordovician mass extinction event. We're still just as vulnerable to many of these dangers today. So these are all very important technologies, but don't have a private economic incentive, so it's one area I think would be wise to consider increasing funding for. And again, there's no better time than now.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by scythe on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:16AM (#20013584)
Whatever the current numbers are, they must be wrong. The subject article, after all, says that methane is way higher than estimated.

But, if I’m looking for errors, it seems more likely to me that we’d mis-estimate methane leaking out of the ground during fracking or from landfills than methane coming out of cows or manure storage facilities. I mean, you can measure a cow. You can put it in a room and measure the methane. But how do you measure the ground? It seems like the kind of thing you can mess up.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by sametmax on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:12AM (#20013575)
A good part of fossil fuel is used to farm those stock, farm the food for those stock and move around / process / package both.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by fit2rule on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:01PM (#20016370)
We stop feeding cows corn, and feed them seaweed instead. Trouble is, how do we get the seaweed to the cows? Turn corn into biofuel for the purpose?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by sascha_sl on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:01AM (#20014105)
This is terrible advice, because it makes people think they did "enough" themselves to combat climate change when dropping animal product methane to 0 would not even be close to enough.

Remember, 100 companies are responsible for 71% of climate emissions. These need to be dealt with, swiftly.

https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/jul/10...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ourlordcaffeine on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:50AM (#20014420)
>Remember, 100 companies are responsible for 71% of climate emissions

Most of these 100 companies are oil companies, and the emissions from oil they sold on to consumers is unfairly attributed to them. Exxon don't burn oil for fun, they sell it to people to power their cars.

This statistic is incredibly misleading.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rapind on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:57AM (#20014955)
Pollution is an externality of the oil industry. Might be better if today's consumer paid for that at the pump rather than future generations dealing with it in the environment.

The artificially low price of oil due to postponing / offloading these external costs significantly slows free market innovation of alternatives and efficiencies.

So... what's the best way to pay for these negative externals so we don't simply pass the buck to our kids?

We don't have to throw executives in jail for addressing the market, we just need a more comprehensive (and truer) price (via taxes) applied to oil.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by manfredo on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:28PM (#20018266)
> Pollution is an externality of the oil industry

Is it? When I pour motor oil in my motorcycle, drain it 500 miles later, and have it recycled does it put CO2 in the atmosphere? Nope, at least not beyond the refining process.

Burning oil is what puts CO2 in the atmosphere, and it's consumers that do that. Not oil companies. Sure, one could say that oil companies are the ones providing the fuel that consumers are using, but that's sort of like an obese person complaining about food companies making him fat.

We could charge more for fossil fuels, but this effectively functions as a regressive tax. It's a tax based on how long people need to commute through and need more energy to deliver goods over greater distances. This disproportionately impacts less developed areas, which are typically less wealthy.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rapind on Monday May 27, 2019 @02:19PM (#20024171)
How much of the oil "industry" is for producing lubricant though? I'm talking about gas, stations, fertilizer, plastics, etc. It touches everything. For the sake of skipping this minor contention, let's just not tax unrefined motor oil.

In terms of gasoline, the technology builds on itself. Infrastructure like roads and fast food, expectations like the ability to commute, etc. If cars and gasoline were prohibitively expensive, commuting would pretty quickly become obsolete. Companies that require workers to drive 2 hours a day would have a hard time hiring people... or we'd find new ways to sustain it (alternatives and / or efficiencies). The price of all goods would go up considerably too (shipping, manufacturing). We rely on it so heavily!

Obviously we can't eliminate dependence overnight, which is why being proactive (arguably not proactive enough anymore though) and gradually implementing programs to phase it out or change it are required.

The goal should be to manage the pain / cost so we don't get hammered by a massive change in the future, or maybe taking too long and getting stuck with an unmanageable situation like massively accelerating climate change. The pain WILL happen regardless, and probably already is.

Just running with it, like we're mostly doing right now, is likely to disproportionally affect less developed areas far more than the price of gas and goods (floods, fires, and apocalypse type stuff).

If you believe climate change is real and negative (I assume you do) this is one part of a potential solution. If you don't believe climate change is real and negative though, then we're just not on the same page yet, and it's too early to have this discussion.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ianai on Sunday May 26, 2019 @01:01PM (#20015916)
“So... what's the best way to pay for these negative externals so we don't simply pass the buck to our kids?”

Start sequestering carbon or create funds to research effective ways to sequester carbon. For the US, it’d be as simple as giving the DOE R&D funds and a mandate.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ced on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:52AM (#20014923)
Are they seriously counting Joe's car's CO2 as Exxon's responsibility? Can I ask for a reference/quote on that?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by simonh on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:37AM (#20014217)
It’s great advice because it’s a tangible change individuals can make immediately. There is very little we can individually do about the 100 companies, or do at all in the short term. This problem will need to be tackled on multiple fronts simultaneously. Advising people not to do something that could make a real difference doesn’t seem particularly helpful.

I’m fed up reading comments along the lines of ‘we shouldn’t try to solve this problem, because we should be solving this other problem instead’. In every case I’ve seen this argument, there’s absolutely no constraint at all preventing us from doing both.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:13AM (#20014315)
The advice may not be as great. Amount of land and water needed to grow crops that sufficiently replace nutrition provided by meat may be worse for climate change than just eating meat. Obviously that only applies to grass-fed cattle. I don’t have a source right now, but the choice is not as obvious as many think.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jaxr on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:27AM (#20014556)
The efficiency of converting plant based protein into animal protein to feed that to humans is very low [1]. A huge portion of the crops are actually used to feed cattle. If humans stopped eating meat tomorrow, we would have plenty of food (we'd better start eating a lot more soy, though)

https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/10/1...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by bitexploder on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:34AM (#20014833)
I’ll pass on the phytoestrogens, though. This doesn’t really address the fact that there are ways to still eat meat but minimize the greenhouse effects. For example, chicken and pork is dramatically less directly impactful than beef. There is still the feed efficiency problem, but America’s love of red meat is a better place to start than no meat at all.

https://timeforchange.org/are-cows-cause-of-global-warming-m...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rewq4321 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:52AM (#20014921)
The soy/phytoestrogen scare is not scientific/fact-based.

https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/soy/

> Results of recent population studies suggest that soy has either a beneficial or neutral effect on various health conditions. Soy is a nutrient-dense source of protein that can safely be consumed several times a week, and is likely to provide health benefits—especially when eaten as an alternative to red and processed meat.

By the way, the reason @jaxr is talking about eating lots of soy is not because we'd need to be heavily reliant on soy for protein if we gave up meat - there are lots of other protein sources, of course. They mentioned eating lots of soy because we currently feed something like 70+% of soy to livestock, so there'd be a lot of it "laying around" if livestock suddenly didn't exist. Of course, it wouldn't actually play out like that.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by bitexploder on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:24AM (#20015360)
There are too many studies that indicate either way with Soy. Maybe it is just over studied and other common sources of nutrition are under studied. Nutritional discussions devolve into a drain circling effect of studies with no one really convincing anyone else. I monitor my blood and know what keeps me healthy. Why risk it with potentially questionable nutrition?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by NumberWangMan on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:35PM (#20019012)
I would recommend Nutritionfacts.org as a source of high-quality information about nutrition. Dr. Greger (the creator) and a team of researchers read everything they can about nutrition research, examine the studies with a very critical eye, and summarize everything into videos on different topics.

The thing about research is that if you look for studies to support a particular conclusion, you can always find them, usually more than one. You could probably find a study or two to support eating nothing but beef and pork, if you tried hard enough. But if you want the truth, you have to read ALL the related studies, and you have to critique and interpret them and understand their scope/limitations and relate them all together to build up as complete a picture as you can. Dr. Greger isn't perfect, but he and his team seem to be doing a hell of a job trying to find the truth.

He advocates a whole-food plant-based diet because overall, that's what the evidence seems to say is healthiest. But he's not a hard-line vegan or anything, just trying to ensure that people have can make informed choices by giving us all the information. Not just in terms of broad strokes like "eat more vegetables, don't eat so much meat", but all sorts of weird and interesting details like which sorts of lentils are healthiest, or why broccoli sprouts are amazing at fighting cancer.

And it's not an alarmist site -- here's a nuanced take on glyphsate, used on GMO soy https://nutritionfacts.org/video/gmo-soy-and-breast-cancer/

Back to the topic at hand, here's an example about Soy and prostate cancer. https://nutritionfacts.org/video/the-role-of-soy-foods-in-pr...

And to find a way out of the forest of conflicting info -- if you find a study and want to get a second opinion on it, search for it on nutrition facts (you probably have to use google, with a query like "site:nutritionfacts.org <study keywords>").

I'm not encouraging you to blindly believe what Dr. Greger says! You should evaluate it for yourself. But I strongly believe that after watching a few videos on random topics, you'll start to see how most people have no idea what they're talking about when it comes to nutrition science, and intentionally or unintentionally spread falsehoods.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by bitexploder on Monday May 27, 2019 @08:45AM (#20021682)
I will take a look. Thank you for sharing. I do agree most health sites are terrible sources. Many studies are bad too. The burden is high and mostly on individuals to make good choices.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by SECProto on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:32AM (#20015407)
Soy is consumed in great quantities by Japan, the country with the longest life expectancy in the world. The evidence against soy would have to be pretty dramatic and clear-cut to base decisions on it.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by cageface on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:22AM (#20015061)
I find it odd people are so concerned about phytoestrogens, which have shown to actually have a lot of real benefits in the amounts people actually eat, while chugging down mammalian estrogens by the gallon in milk, which have been repeatedly shown to increase risk of cancer, premature puberty etc.

Cows milk is optimized for cows.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by NumberWangMan on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:18PM (#20018746)
Even more -- cows' milk is optimized for baby cows. We think it's weird to even drink human breast milk as adults, but think nothing of drinking bovine milk.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:45AM (#20014631)
Cattle doesn’t convert plant based protein into animal protein. Also cattle eats crop that humans can’t eat and which grows in significantly more tough conditions than those required for crops used as feed.

Eating lots of soy is not healthy.

It’s a very weird and unconvincing argument on your part, to suggest humans should just start eating crops fed to cattle and that would somehow work in terms of sufficiently healthy and available nutrition as well as being net positive on climate change.

Cattle eats grass which grows everywhere in the world and cattle produces vastly healthier and nutritious profile of fat, protein, vitamins and other essential nutrients than what you could achieve by growing human edible crops for similar price. Sure you can achieve good nutrition with other expensive vegetables but that’s not what will happen if humans stop eating cattle. Let’s be realistic.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by nmca on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:30AM (#20014819)
Baffled to read this, as I thought it was widely established as grossly inaccurate.

Suggest you read

Steinfeld, Henning; Gerber, Pierre; Wassenaar, Tom; Castel, Vincent; Rosales, Mauricio; de Haan, Cees (2006), Livestock's Long Shadow: Environmental Issues and Options

Or alternatively anything about food culture and supply in India.

I don't believe your current position is substantiated by any evidence; but I'm happy to look through any relevant numbers if you can find them.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:55AM (#20015540)
I skimmed through it, thanks for the link, my “rebuttal” is mostly that this report takes into account all cattle while I’m specifically talking about grass-fed. There are plenty of statements that clarify that corn-fed cattle production is much worse than grass-fed, like

> The water used by the livestock sector is over 8 percent of global human water use. The major part of this water is in fact used for irrigation of feed crops, rep- resenting 7 percent of the global water use.

And, yeah, that’s kind of my point - let’s limit cattle to grass and push it’s production somewhere out to steppes of mongolia or something, which will help recover Amazon rainforests and free-up land for more nutritious vegetables for humans.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ar-jan on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:03AM (#20014981)
I suggest you also read Steinfeld's own correction regarding the 2006 claim that livestock accounts for 18% of GHG emissions:

"The comparison measures direct emissions from transport against both direct and indirect emissions from livestock."

http://news.trust.org/item/20180918083629-d2wf0

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by steve_adams_86 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:58AM (#20014959)
Eating lots of soy is not a requirement of a diet without red meat.

Cattle can eat grass, but most of them in North America eat very little grass. They eat a lot of grain that is intensively farmed. That feed farming has a significant impact on the environment through regular agriculture practices. By growing food for humans instead, the impact would be reduced simply because not as much crop is needed.

Red meat does have a good nutrition profile, but a balanced vegetable focused diet does too. People underestimate how much protein and fat can be had from plants. I'm not sure why you think people won't do this if they stop eating red meat. Why isn't that realistic?

I speak as someone who absolutely loves meat and thought much like you do recently. Life without, or with much less meat is fine. I've come to realize I largely eat it out of convenience and comfort.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:33AM (#20015411)
> Cattle can eat grass, but most of them in North America eat very little grass. They eat a lot of grain that is intensively farmed. That feed farming has a significant impact on the environment through regular agriculture practices.

You obviously missed my explicit position against corn-fed cattle and went on to attack some straw man. Please re-think and re-state your argument such that I don’t get an urge to dismiss it based on irrelevancy from the very first statement?

In fact in your following two paragraphs you just repeated the same things I already said just using different words.

We don’t disagree on much.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by steve_adams_86 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @05:14PM (#20017557)
I've read all of your comments now and I did miss your position on this. Sorry about that.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by perfunctory on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:18AM (#20014515)
> Obviously that only applies to grass-fed cattle.

There is simply not enough land to replace all meat supply with grass-fed cattle meat. So if we all want to eat meat from grass-fed cattle only, that would mean exactly radical reduction in meat consumption.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:33AM (#20014589)
There is not enough land to produce equal amount of meat at the same price point. There is plenty land to produce enough more expensive meat. Which also reduces meat consumption. It’s a win all around.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jeremyjh on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:21AM (#20014339)
Isn’t most cattle fed grain?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:01AM (#20014455)
Yes it is, which is the main issue because apart from impact on land, corn-fed cows do excrete(?) more methane than grass-fed.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by Doubl on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:04AM (#20014705)
I thought it was the other way around, unfortunately, because I'd rather see cattle on pastures rather than in yards
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by perfunctory on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:39AM (#20014392)
> because it makes people think they did "enough"

It doesn't. I reduced my own meat consumption and I don't think it was enough. In fact, no single measure would be enough. There are no low hanging fruits here. We need lots and lots of different adjustments across the board.

So, this is a good advice, along with all the other good pieces of advice.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ced on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:40AM (#20014227)
All companies exist to serve customer demand, or to serve companies that serve customer demand. Sure, they should be regulated (... thus increasing the price of consumer goods?) On an individual level, traveling less, buying less stuff, or buying less damaging stuff is the best that most people can do.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by bamboozled on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:23AM (#20014341)
I think non-essentials and some types of food via an emissions tax would be a great thing.

For example, flying is so cheap I would say people "over do it" just because they can. I often think it would be great if there was more cost associated with air fair to factor in the environmental damage each flight causes.

Yeah people will be inconvenienced slightly but what is the alternative? Holiday in locations closer to home? Go by rail? Video conferencing ? They all seem like good options compared to the alternative.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by mrpopo on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:32AM (#20014368)
Most of these companies are Chinese power companies, aramco, etc. How do you deal with them without dealing with humans personal consumption of energy?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by Rovanion on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:36AM (#20014376)
You got to start with what's within your control, right? Then you may continue with others. But until you do that you're a hypocrite.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by oliveshell on Sunday May 26, 2019 @01:29AM (#20013312)
It’s a nice thought, but even if we accept that the global population doing this would stem the tide of climate change (which I am doubtful it would), one quickly realizes that there is no way that the entire global population is going to stop eating animals, and we are back to feeling hopeless.

I’m increasingly convinced that carbon sequestration on industrial scales is the only serious way to solve this problem.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jefflombardjr on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:37AM (#20013495)
> I’m increasingly convinced that carbon sequestration on industrial scales is the only serious way to solve this problem.

This is akin to trying to prevent the dust bowl[0] with giant vacuum cleaners. The environment is a system. We are a function of it, not the masters of it. We need to address the feedback loops causing this crisis that we are creating.

Even if that would work - As others have pointed out, we don't have the luxury of time to deploy industrial scale carbon sequestration. And even if we did - this type of thinking still discounts nature's value. [1] Why do we think it is easier to develop and deploy industrial scale carbon sequestration equipment when we have plants that are pretty damned good at doing just that? [2]

We need a total perspective change here. Nature doesn't need saving, the concrete deserts that are cities need green roofs and trees. We need to stop useless commutes and start working from home where applicable. We need to realize that lawns are an ecological disaster. [3]

But above all else, We need to make environmental damage illegal and stop allowing companies to profit off of it.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dust_Bowl

[1]https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/10/this-is-why-putting-a...

[2]https://www.thoughtco.com/which-trees-offset-global-warming-...

[3]https://earther.gizmodo.com/lawns-are-an-ecological-disaster...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by semi-extrinsic on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:49AM (#20013655)
> we don't have the luxury of time to deploy industrial scale carbon sequestration

Yes, we do. It's just that it costs money, and nobody wants to pay up. Same goes for all other realistic climate solutions that we have, unfortunately.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jefflombardjr on Sunday May 26, 2019 @04:40AM (#20013846)
* Above all else we need energy innovation:

https://www.reddit.com/user/thisisbillgates/comments/auosel/...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by vinc on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:57AM (#20013681)
You know what's the simplest solution for carbon sequestration on industrial scales? Trees! And do you know how we could make space for more trees? By switching as much as we can to plant based diets because it takes a lot more plants to feed the animals that we eat instead of eating the plants directly.

I did an estimation once for Western Europe using FAO stats[1] and by switching to a vegan diet we could roughly double the size of the forests, that's a massive scale! It'll help fighting the climate crisis and it'll also help solving the species extinction crisis in Western Europe. And the cool thing is that we don't need to wait for all the human population to switch overnight to a vegan diet, reducing meat and dairy consumption is a perfectly valid first step that everyone can do! The more people switch diets and the more space will become available for rewilding.

We can already see plant based diets becoming more and more popular, and at the same time it seems that flexitarian diets are also getting quite mainstream. I think there's hope on that front at least.

[1] https://vinc.cc/essays/changing-our-diet-for-a-wilder-world/

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ianai on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:12AM (#20013412)
Sequestration won’t do enough soon enough. This could be methane deposits evaporating from long frozen stores (permafrost and other sources). Methane is a much bigger problem for the atmosphere than carbon and sequestration won’t touch it.

If quitting meat sounds tough, consider that I’ve heard the only effective thing to do would be immediately cease all ICE production/use. But oddly feeding cows seaweed would cut their methane production something like 90%.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by cageface on Sunday May 26, 2019 @05:46AM (#20014058)
That’s a best case scenario based on lab results, not feeding cows at scale in the field. The number looks a lot closer to 50% in other trials. In a addition there are tremendous challenges in producing and transporting enough seaweed to implement this even if the kinks get worked out without doing as much damage to the environment.

It’s good to keep all options on the table but seaweed is far from the silver bullet some people want it to be.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by WAHa_06x36 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:02AM (#20014287)
Methane also has a much shorter half-life in the atmosphere, though, so just decreasing production of it will have a big effect in the short to medium term.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by village-idiot on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:34AM (#20015417)
Fun fact, properly managed cattle herds can sequester carbon on an industrial scale! Techniques like rotational intensive grazing can help build up the top soil and rich root system that used to cover the plains, sequestering carbon and making the soil far more fertile.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by 52-6F-62 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:41AM (#20015457)
To add to that— adjusting the diet of cattle to one of red algae has proven to reduce their methane emissions dramatically.

https://www.technologyreview.com/s/612452/how-seaweed-could-...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by village-idiot on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:53AM (#20015530)
Methane release from cattle is largely a by-product of nitrogen fixing fertilizers putting natural methane eating bacteria in the soil into an inactive state. If we stopped using synthetic (and oil based!) fertilizers at least on where the cattle poop, a lot of that methane will get sequestered into the top soil too.

Which also explains why the flatulence of 60-100m buffalo before the industrial era didn’t warm the planet.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by 52-6F-62 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @12:08PM (#20015621)
Interesting. I haven’t looked that deeply into the problem, but I’ll have to read about that.

I imagine some locales might be worse for that problem than others, yeah?

Do you have any info you can share?

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by village-idiot on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:52PM (#20017058)
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by 52-6F-62 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:45PM (#20018053)
Well that’s great, thanks!

So it (at a high level, barely read place) sounds like standard fertilizer proves to have negative effects at scale when used where there might be the need for methane breakdown.

Do I have that about right? I’ll have to read that at length later, but it seems so simple that I feel I have it wrong. Because otherwise it seems like an easy fix—even if it means production has to decrease and price has to go up for cattle meats.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by village-idiot on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:57PM (#20018098)
That's pretty much my read as well.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by 52-6F-62 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:08PM (#20018481)
It really makes me wonder if, funny enough, places like Alberta and Texas are actually low methane producers because they allow their cattle to simply wander in large natural pastures much of the time to graze...
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ab8 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:02AM (#20014696)
> there is no way that the entire global population is going to stop eating animals

Hard problems always feel this way. <insert slavery reference>

1. No way to stop eating animals 2. No way to stop driving/flying 3. Don't ask me to change. YOU change.

=> no change in status quo

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by devit on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:13AM (#20014142)
Just outlaw animal husbandry and meat sales or apply high enough taxes to meat, and meat consumption will become small enough to be irrelevant.

People can be vegan just fine, it's only a matter of habits.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by 52-6F-62 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:47AM (#20015494)
Not everyone can be vegan just fine.

Nutritional balance isn’t as well understood as many people think.

I’m all for reducing the scale of meat, but for someone like me—who’s been urged to eat more red meat as a result of my deficiencies on top of supplementation—ceasing to do so will put my health back at risk.

I don’t need to eat it every day, but it’s a near essential part of my diet.

Problems of nutrient uptake are the reason medical researchers and professionals aren’t just telling us to go ahead, subside on non-nutrient cellulose fibre cakes and just pop a pill containing all essential nutrients and calories every day.

https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/dietary-suppl...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by vbuwivbiu on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:30AM (#20013470)
I'm reading a lot of smoker's-logic in the replies to this: people who love eating meat clutching at straws trying to rationalize it. Nobody's forcing you to do anything! You can happily ignore this and continue living your life as you wish.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by louthy on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:06AM (#20014475)
Or, it’s logic. Instead of blanket dismissal of everyone that doesn’t agree with you, why don’t you engage individually and help them understand your point of view. You may even find that you need to update your thinking rather than just claiming an entire group of people are deluded.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rewq4321 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:09AM (#20015007)
I'm not seeing much logic in the responses to be honest. We've known for a long time that animal agriculture produces more 100-year carbon equivalent emissions than the whole transportation industry (cars, trains, trucks, boats, planes, ...) combines. It's also the leading cause of deforestation, ocean deadzones, and extinction.

> The 2006 report Livestock's Long Shadow, released by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations, states that "the livestock sector is a major stressor on many ecosystems and on the planet as a whole. Globally it is one of the largest sources of greenhouse gases (GHG) and one of the leading causal factors in the loss of biodiversity, while in developed and emerging countries it is perhaps the leading source of water pollution."

> A 2017 study published in the journal Carbon Balance and Management found animal agriculture's global methane emissions are 11% higher than previous estimates based on data from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

> In November 2017, 15,364 world scientists signed a Warning to Humanity calling for, among other things, drastically diminishing our per capita consumption of meat. A similar shift to meat-free diets appears also as the only safe option to feed a growing population without further deforestation, and for different yields scenarios.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_meat_p...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by imtringued on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:33AM (#20014202)
It would help if you read the article which explicitly states that more than 40% of the emissions come from fuel production. Agricultural emissions can be managed by changing the diet of the animals.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ab8 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:58AM (#20014680)
> changing the diet of animals

Changing our own diet is on the table too... considering we don't need to eat cattle to survive. This problem is one of overconsumption, and isn't going away by keeping our lifestyle the same.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by village-idiot on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:31AM (#20015398)
And by better animal husbandry techniques like rotational intensive grazing.

Well managed cattle herds can sequester carbon in the top soil. There is absolutely no need to go vegetarian to save the planet.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by breatheoften on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:52AM (#20013524)
I had an impossible burger slider yesterday for the first time — as a fan of the taste of meat, I’m very ready for the non-animal based meat future!
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by maelito on Sunday May 26, 2019 @04:49AM (#20013877)
What's their carbon footprint ?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by lui8906 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @05:09AM (#20013931)
"The carbon footprint of the latest Impossible Burger recipe is 89% smaller than a burger made from real beef, according to a science-based life cycle assessment released by the company this week."

https://www.fooddive.com/news/impossible-burger-boasts-much-...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by mattigames on Sunday May 26, 2019 @01:38AM (#20013336)
The only way methane from live-stock is gonna disappear is by either: 1) Lab-created meat 2) Seaweed and other techniques of reducing methane released by cows [0] 3) Less humans due birth control or fortuitous events (e.g. a plague)

[0] https://www.technologyreview.com/s/612452/how-seaweed-could-...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by estebank on Sunday May 26, 2019 @01:55AM (#20013360)
4) Reduce demand.

I'm Argentinean, if I stopped eating meat my passport would probably be revoked. I grew up thinking that it was perfectly normal to eat meat 7 days a week. Even with this background, I started reducing the amount of meat some time back. I'm not vegetarian by any means, but I reduced my meat consumption about 80% without even trying. I'm sure there are lots of people that could too.

> Less humans due birth control or fortuitous events (e.g. a plague)

Like everything, consumption follows a Pareto distribution, where some "whales" drive most of the demand. You can focus on them instead of hoping for lots of people dying.

Also, reduce poverty and the amount of newborns in this planet will naturally decrease precipitously, without any need for a mandate from anyone.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by steve_adams_86 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:07AM (#20013394)
I also grew up eating crazy amounts of meat here in Canada. I'm steadily moving towards a vegetarian (though with some fish and other sea life I harvest) diet despite still absolutely loving meat. I just can't justify it anymore. To me (and I know others don't need to feel the same way) it's practically immoral to eat in a way that wouldn't be sustainable if everyone else did. It's incredible to be born in a place and time where I can afford dry aged sirloin, fresh bacon, roast chicken, or smoked duck breast with my meals... But to partake in it is a serious disservice to everyone else in the world, however minute that disservice may seem at the global scale.

Having kids robbed me of the selfishness I required to isolate myself from the externalities of my lifestyle. To be honest, some days I wish I still didn't worry about it.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by tomp on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:06AM (#20014124)
How do you justify having kids (also unsustainable if everyone did it.)?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by steve_adams_86 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:04AM (#20014985)
Honestly, I can't. It makes me feel bad for doing that to others and also for what the world might become for my kids. I wish I was kidding. This sort of thing has kept me up at night.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by your-nanny on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:00AM (#20014452)
justify your own existence!
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by effie on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:28AM (#20014568)
> it's practically immoral to eat in a way that wouldn't be sustainable if everyone else did.

Why would that be immoral if you have negligible negative impact? It would only be a problem if everybody else will begin doing it. Which does not happen. Having children, hunting in the woods, owning a big house. Eating meat. Not being a universal example for every person is not immoral. People have different needs, and one person has more impact on the environment than other (but usually still negligible). If you want to limit yourself in this particular way, fine, but this isn't particularly moral thing to do. It is more of a feel-good thing to do.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by steve_adams_86 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:14AM (#20015033)
I see where you're coming from and I largely agree. In fact if we do go hunting, we will eat meat. Obviously if everyone near me was hunting for meat, the forest would be emptied in no time. But they don't, so the impact is still less than buying beef for example so I think that's acceptable. I also hunt for fish and crustaceans when I dive, which wouldn't be sustainable if everyone else did.

I suppose my desire is partially to exit a commercial food system that I know is unsustainable. That system doesn't look like it will become sustainable any time soon, and I don't want to vote for it with my dollars and contribute to the issue with each meal.

I also don't necessarily do it to feel good. It feels bad at times, otherwise neutral. It feels like doing too little. There's no warm fuzzy feeling from half measures like this. I wish I could do more, but I struggle to figure out how.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by mattigames on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:07AM (#20013389)
Changing people mentality is the less likely way methane is going to be reduced; I'm sure you tried to convince your family but you had little or no success, some parts of the world are even having trouble making people believe that vaccines are good don't think they gonna pay much attention about methane.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by fungi on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:12AM (#20013409)
If you are going to eat red meat go Kangaroo, it's healthy and sustainable.

There are a million articles on the internet arguing either way. I would start with this one for an interesting angle: https://theconversation.com/from-pests-to-profits-making-kan...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by louthy on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:21AM (#20014529)
I live in th UK, I’d suggest transporting it from Australia to the other side of the world would have some ethical implications
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by fungi on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:29PM (#20018789)
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by taneq on Monday May 27, 2019 @03:12AM (#20020079)
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by aaronbrethorst on Sunday May 26, 2019 @01:34AM (#20013325)
Cut down on your consumption of meat. That's good and important.

But it is no substitute for voting.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by baxtr on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:17AM (#20013585)
Absolutely. Even worse: It’s not only the direct production of methane but also deforestation for soy production / farmlands that drives climate change.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by eb3c90 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:14AM (#20014319)
I would also argue that supporting efforts to understand where the methane is coming from would be good.

For example Methane Sat[1] looks like it can cover a wide area and is coming on-line in the time frame to do some good (2020).

[1] https://www.edf.org/climate/how-methanesat-is-different

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by andy_ppp on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:49AM (#20014413)
I’ve personally started just eating meat on the weekend as a gateway drug into full vegetarianism, it’s actually a really nice thing eating so much veg and clean food all week and then maybe roasting a really nicely grown chicken on the weekend. I definitely feel much better.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by fungi on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:13AM (#20013415)
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by pdr94 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:56AM (#20014439)
To get a better sense what you can do to actually make a difference, I highly recommend https://www.amazon.com/dp/0954452933/tag=davidmackayca-20 (also available online for free).

If you take one transatlantic flight, you'd produce more CO2 than by driving for a year.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by YeGoblynQueenne on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:57AM (#20014672)
The article makes it clear that methane emissions from farming can be reduced without reducing the production [1].

At the same time, the majority of methane is produced by fossil fuel production that drives industry, transportation and energy production, that are also the largest sources of C02 emissions.

It seems to me that by addressing the emissions of industry, transporation and energy production, we'd be killing two birds with one stone- whereas by going vegan or vegetarian we would only achieve a small reduction in both kinds of emission.

The best thing to do to reduce emissions seems to stop driving, stop flying, prefer public transport, stop buying a new phone every year and stop burning as much excess electricity as we now do. Going vegan or vegetarian seems like a personal option, and a distant third or fourth priority for the general population.

There are many more, much more effective things to do than stop eating meat.

_______________

[1] Thus, there is wide agreement among experts that, regardless of the drivers behind the surge, reducing emissions from fossil-fuel production and distribution, primarily through ending leaks and venting, is one of the few options available to control global methane levels and that this option is the most practical one. In addition, scientists report that there are narrow opportunities to address agricultural emissions, e.g. changes in the diet of livestock can reduce the production of methane without affecting production.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by WhompingWindows on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:31AM (#20015097)
The most impactful, single action any of us need to take is breaking the stronghold that fossil fuel interest have in politics. We can all go vegan today, but if there's no broad, strong policy to decarbonize transport and industry, it won't matter how many bean burgers we eat. We need political power, not just avoidance of beef.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jobigoud on Sunday May 26, 2019 @12:46PM (#20015831)
The nice thing about not eating meat is that it's a non exclusive effort. It's just something you integrate in your routine and you can still try to curb carbon emissions at the political level if you think it's the best course of action.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by hdfbdtbcdg on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:12AM (#20013413)
How will this help with the catastrophic release of methane from melting tundra and gas hydrates?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by vbuwivbiu on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:16AM (#20013423)
a + b - a = b

b < (a + b)

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by TeMPOraL on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:33AM (#20015409)
While true technically, it doesn't matter if (a + b) ≈ b. The parent's question is essentially about that.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by andrepd on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:28AM (#20014356)
The impact of my choice as a consumer is a blip in the radar compared to the impact of large companies changing their course, or being forced to change their course. Even more, compared to the people making those decisions. We need to take personal responsibility to those concrete people quickly, instead of blaming abstract concepts like "corporations" or "the market".
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by bubblewrap on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:35AM (#20013492)
A more effective way of treating the feeling of hopelessness might be to simply stop consuming the news.

They feed on our fears...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by neiman on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:16AM (#20013424)
Assume that humans stop consuming livestock products tomorrow. The real goal would still be to reduce livestock, right?

How will it be done exactly? How long will it take? Will they be released to nature? Killed? Not allowed to reproduce and we'll wait for them to die of old age? Be supplied condoms?:-)

I don't have the knowledge to know whats needed to be done, or which steps are needed to be taken to do that, even if we stop consuming livestock products.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by pjc50 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @03:06AM (#20013562)
An overnight stop isn't going to happen. Even a decade would be an absurdly optimistic short time for that to happen.

That's longer than the normal farm lifespan of almost all food animals. Most ones reared for meat have less than two years.

Reproduction of farm animals is totally controlled today by segregation usually from birth.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by cheerlessbog on Sunday May 26, 2019 @02:22AM (#20013439)
Also if we reduce meat consumption but not milk and eggs, what happens to the animals too old to produce efficiently? Killing and eating them might have a lower environmental impact than letting them live out their old age and then rot.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by HaukeHi on Sunday May 26, 2019 @06:58AM (#20014279)
Meatless Mondays won't cut it. But even if we were to offset our worst carbon excesses—such as intercontinental air-travel and meat—ethical consumerism won't solve the climate crisis. Most other people simply won't offset their emissions. We need coordinated policy approaches to climate change.

And policy needs to be global in scope. Because even if advanced economies were to reduce their emissions to zero, this would be insufficient to prevent warming with substantial risks. Note that emerging economies are producing an increasingly large share of total global emissions, while the share from advanced economies is dwindling, now accounting for only 35% of global emissions. This trend continued past 2015 and is forecast to continue in the coming years.

By 2040, emerging economies will produce 75% of all emissions, while only 25% will come from advanced economies.

But policy-makers are still stuck in a mid-2000s mindset. Back then, their emissions were still the highest in the world and they had to focus their policies on reducing their own emissions. This no longer makes sense.

Advanced economies have a special obligation to do more to lower emissions in all countries. Why is it our responsibility? Because our per capita emissions are still the highest and we have emitted the most carbon since the industrial revolution.

Only if the policies of advanced economies lead to reduced emissions in all countries, can we prevent dangerous climate change. The most effective policies to prevent climate change are those that stimulate clean energy innovation. In other words, those that stimulate progress or breakthroughs in clean energy technologies (or any low-carbon technology that lowers emissions as well as demonstration projects, i.e. RD&D). Providing the global public good of cheaper clean energy technology helps all countries reduce their emissions.

If you want to do something check out my crowdfunding campaign for effective climate policy here: https://www.lets-fund.org/clean-energy

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by codingdave on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:14AM (#20014318)
Personally, I'd be more responsive to what you have to say if you were to post comments that were more participatory in the discussions, and not always using your comments to post the same link to the fundraising site you founded.