News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:13AM (#20014315)
The advice may not be as great. Amount of land and water needed to grow crops that sufficiently replace nutrition provided by meat may be worse for climate change than just eating meat. Obviously that only applies to grass-fed cattle. I don’t have a source right now, but the choice is not as obvious as many think.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jaxr on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:27AM (#20014556)
The efficiency of converting plant based protein into animal protein to feed that to humans is very low [1]. A huge portion of the crops are actually used to feed cattle. If humans stopped eating meat tomorrow, we would have plenty of food (we'd better start eating a lot more soy, though)

https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/10/1...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by bitexploder on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:34AM (#20014833)
I’ll pass on the phytoestrogens, though. This doesn’t really address the fact that there are ways to still eat meat but minimize the greenhouse effects. For example, chicken and pork is dramatically less directly impactful than beef. There is still the feed efficiency problem, but America’s love of red meat is a better place to start than no meat at all.

https://timeforchange.org/are-cows-cause-of-global-warming-m...

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by rewq4321 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:52AM (#20014921)
The soy/phytoestrogen scare is not scientific/fact-based.

https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/soy/

> Results of recent population studies suggest that soy has either a beneficial or neutral effect on various health conditions. Soy is a nutrient-dense source of protein that can safely be consumed several times a week, and is likely to provide health benefits—especially when eaten as an alternative to red and processed meat.

By the way, the reason @jaxr is talking about eating lots of soy is not because we'd need to be heavily reliant on soy for protein if we gave up meat - there are lots of other protein sources, of course. They mentioned eating lots of soy because we currently feed something like 70+% of soy to livestock, so there'd be a lot of it "laying around" if livestock suddenly didn't exist. Of course, it wouldn't actually play out like that.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by bitexploder on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:24AM (#20015360)
There are too many studies that indicate either way with Soy. Maybe it is just over studied and other common sources of nutrition are under studied. Nutritional discussions devolve into a drain circling effect of studies with no one really convincing anyone else. I monitor my blood and know what keeps me healthy. Why risk it with potentially questionable nutrition?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by NumberWangMan on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:35PM (#20019012)
I would recommend Nutritionfacts.org as a source of high-quality information about nutrition. Dr. Greger (the creator) and a team of researchers read everything they can about nutrition research, examine the studies with a very critical eye, and summarize everything into videos on different topics.

The thing about research is that if you look for studies to support a particular conclusion, you can always find them, usually more than one. You could probably find a study or two to support eating nothing but beef and pork, if you tried hard enough. But if you want the truth, you have to read ALL the related studies, and you have to critique and interpret them and understand their scope/limitations and relate them all together to build up as complete a picture as you can. Dr. Greger isn't perfect, but he and his team seem to be doing a hell of a job trying to find the truth.

He advocates a whole-food plant-based diet because overall, that's what the evidence seems to say is healthiest. But he's not a hard-line vegan or anything, just trying to ensure that people have can make informed choices by giving us all the information. Not just in terms of broad strokes like "eat more vegetables, don't eat so much meat", but all sorts of weird and interesting details like which sorts of lentils are healthiest, or why broccoli sprouts are amazing at fighting cancer.

And it's not an alarmist site -- here's a nuanced take on glyphsate, used on GMO soy https://nutritionfacts.org/video/gmo-soy-and-breast-cancer/

Back to the topic at hand, here's an example about Soy and prostate cancer. https://nutritionfacts.org/video/the-role-of-soy-foods-in-pr...

And to find a way out of the forest of conflicting info -- if you find a study and want to get a second opinion on it, search for it on nutrition facts (you probably have to use google, with a query like "site:nutritionfacts.org <study keywords>").

I'm not encouraging you to blindly believe what Dr. Greger says! You should evaluate it for yourself. But I strongly believe that after watching a few videos on random topics, you'll start to see how most people have no idea what they're talking about when it comes to nutrition science, and intentionally or unintentionally spread falsehoods.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by bitexploder on Monday May 27, 2019 @08:45AM (#20021682)
I will take a look. Thank you for sharing. I do agree most health sites are terrible sources. Many studies are bad too. The burden is high and mostly on individuals to make good choices.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by SECProto on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:32AM (#20015407)
Soy is consumed in great quantities by Japan, the country with the longest life expectancy in the world. The evidence against soy would have to be pretty dramatic and clear-cut to base decisions on it.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by cageface on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:22AM (#20015061)
I find it odd people are so concerned about phytoestrogens, which have shown to actually have a lot of real benefits in the amounts people actually eat, while chugging down mammalian estrogens by the gallon in milk, which have been repeatedly shown to increase risk of cancer, premature puberty etc.

Cows milk is optimized for cows.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by NumberWangMan on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:18PM (#20018746)
Even more -- cows' milk is optimized for baby cows. We think it's weird to even drink human breast milk as adults, but think nothing of drinking bovine milk.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:45AM (#20014631)
Cattle doesn’t convert plant based protein into animal protein. Also cattle eats crop that humans can’t eat and which grows in significantly more tough conditions than those required for crops used as feed.

Eating lots of soy is not healthy.

It’s a very weird and unconvincing argument on your part, to suggest humans should just start eating crops fed to cattle and that would somehow work in terms of sufficiently healthy and available nutrition as well as being net positive on climate change.

Cattle eats grass which grows everywhere in the world and cattle produces vastly healthier and nutritious profile of fat, protein, vitamins and other essential nutrients than what you could achieve by growing human edible crops for similar price. Sure you can achieve good nutrition with other expensive vegetables but that’s not what will happen if humans stop eating cattle. Let’s be realistic.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by nmca on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:30AM (#20014819)
Baffled to read this, as I thought it was widely established as grossly inaccurate.

Suggest you read

Steinfeld, Henning; Gerber, Pierre; Wassenaar, Tom; Castel, Vincent; Rosales, Mauricio; de Haan, Cees (2006), Livestock's Long Shadow: Environmental Issues and Options

Or alternatively anything about food culture and supply in India.

I don't believe your current position is substantiated by any evidence; but I'm happy to look through any relevant numbers if you can find them.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:55AM (#20015540)
I skimmed through it, thanks for the link, my “rebuttal” is mostly that this report takes into account all cattle while I’m specifically talking about grass-fed. There are plenty of statements that clarify that corn-fed cattle production is much worse than grass-fed, like

> The water used by the livestock sector is over 8 percent of global human water use. The major part of this water is in fact used for irrigation of feed crops, rep- resenting 7 percent of the global water use.

And, yeah, that’s kind of my point - let’s limit cattle to grass and push it’s production somewhere out to steppes of mongolia or something, which will help recover Amazon rainforests and free-up land for more nutritious vegetables for humans.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by ar-jan on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:03AM (#20014981)
I suggest you also read Steinfeld's own correction regarding the 2006 claim that livestock accounts for 18% of GHG emissions:

"The comparison measures direct emissions from transport against both direct and indirect emissions from livestock."

http://news.trust.org/item/20180918083629-d2wf0

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by steve_adams_86 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:58AM (#20014959)
Eating lots of soy is not a requirement of a diet without red meat.

Cattle can eat grass, but most of them in North America eat very little grass. They eat a lot of grain that is intensively farmed. That feed farming has a significant impact on the environment through regular agriculture practices. By growing food for humans instead, the impact would be reduced simply because not as much crop is needed.

Red meat does have a good nutrition profile, but a balanced vegetable focused diet does too. People underestimate how much protein and fat can be had from plants. I'm not sure why you think people won't do this if they stop eating red meat. Why isn't that realistic?

I speak as someone who absolutely loves meat and thought much like you do recently. Life without, or with much less meat is fine. I've come to realize I largely eat it out of convenience and comfort.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @11:33AM (#20015411)
> Cattle can eat grass, but most of them in North America eat very little grass. They eat a lot of grain that is intensively farmed. That feed farming has a significant impact on the environment through regular agriculture practices.

You obviously missed my explicit position against corn-fed cattle and went on to attack some straw man. Please re-think and re-state your argument such that I don’t get an urge to dismiss it based on irrelevancy from the very first statement?

In fact in your following two paragraphs you just repeated the same things I already said just using different words.

We don’t disagree on much.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by steve_adams_86 on Sunday May 26, 2019 @05:14PM (#20017557)
I've read all of your comments now and I did miss your position on this. Sorry about that.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by perfunctory on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:18AM (#20014515)
> Obviously that only applies to grass-fed cattle.

There is simply not enough land to replace all meat supply with grass-fed cattle meat. So if we all want to eat meat from grass-fed cattle only, that would mean exactly radical reduction in meat consumption.

Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:33AM (#20014589)
There is not enough land to produce equal amount of meat at the same price point. There is plenty land to produce enough more expensive meat. Which also reduces meat consumption. It’s a win all around.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by jeremyjh on Sunday May 26, 2019 @07:21AM (#20014339)
Isn’t most cattle fed grain?
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by keymone on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:01AM (#20014455)
Yes it is, which is the main issue because apart from impact on land, corn-fed cows do excrete(?) more methane than grass-fed.
Re:Unexpected Surge in Global Methane Levels by Doubl on Sunday May 26, 2019 @09:04AM (#20014705)
I thought it was the other way around, unfortunately, because I'd rather see cattle on pastures rather than in yards