And why more government involvement in sectors would be a good thing?
I understand the benefits of central planning, but when I see it fail locally, I wonder if the flaws outweigh benefits.
The proposition system. People in California voted for laws that were in their interest without taking into account (or not caring about) the 2nd or 3rd order effects of the policy.
The result is that existing property owners are reaping massive sums of money while the rest are struggling to make ends meet.
This is truly another dimension of the More/Less government dichotomy they teach you in school.
Btw, it seems the local governments are quite Anti growth? Am I understanding that correctly?
You might think that renters living in the city would eventually outweigh the landowners and elect council members in favor of new housing, but instead SF passed a rent control measure which prevents the current renters from feeling the sting of the housing shortage so they aren't strongly incentivized to vote for more housing either.
Ie. gov gives rent subsidies of $100 to poor. Landlords react by rising rent prices by $100 because od this new 'disposable income'. The poor don't feel any difference, only the working population which gets squeezed.
The money flows from workers and businesses through the poor straight to rentiers.
Rent SUBSIDIES are a hidden redistribution as you discuss.
Rent CONTROL forces recent transplants to subsidize longtime residents
Ie. gov prevents raising rents to market levels for longtime tenants. They are less likely to move, driving up demand for the remaining housing, which is the only stock available for newer residents.
This then costs newcomers more, while longtime residents avoid paying the market rate on their housing - effectively subsidizing the in-place tenants.
My local taxes depend on my land value + my house value.
Larger land, (or more desirable) more taxes.
In federal taxes, for a rental unit, you get a depreciation expense only on the value of the structure. Not on the land. So more valuable land vs. structure, less federal discount.
Are they separate line items? Or combined? The difference matters.
My condo is taxed based on the whole value of the unit- which is something like 1/2 of the cost of a house in the same neighbourhood, which means I'm taxed about 1/2 of what they are. But I use 1/100th the amount of land they use. Meanwhile, the cost to the city in terms of infrastructure (pipes, roads, drainage, etc) is much lower than the houses in the subdivision down the road.
In effect, today's laws makes high-density-home owners subsidize the high cost of maintaining subdivisions by taxing on total value only. Switch it to 50% value and 50% land use, with explicit line items for each and you'll see more demand for high density housing.
The costs in terms of lots of services that aren't physical infrastructure scales with population, though, and for some services (or for adverse impacts that services don't fully mitigate) is also higher, rather than lower, for the same population when density is higher; e.g., crime rates per capita tend to go up with population density.
The difference between this and property tax is that if you have a 12 story building on one piece of land and a 2 story building on the adjacent one, otherwise identical piece of land, they both pay the same tax, giving the second property owner more incentive to build.
Either way, they do give me a breakdown, which I agree is right (land about 33% of overall value).
Again, for rental properties, there is a disincentive to having low density housing (my condo value in a 20 story building is assessed as 20% land)
[1] close to what I believe I can sell the house for
Some people argue Property taxes vs Land Value taxes thinking it is roughly the same, and that althought it might change tax structure it wouldnt change rent prices.
But thats true if you look at it statically: dynamically, you make poeple in single family homes want to abandon them and sell them to developers, so you naturally turn an enemy (nimby) into an ally (sell for developers).
For example, my current home is assessed as $150k land value and $350k house value for a total of $500k.
Heck, the breakdown is required information in your federal taxes if you want the depreciation expense.
And for all of us who don’t live in crazy-land CA, we have to get assessed since my purchase price (I.e. market value) ten years ago is meaningless today.
What we can do is increase housing supply so that prices of all homes are lower.
Almost every housing law has carveouts for small buildings/landlords with few apartments since they are politically powerful and relatively sympathetic.
Advocating for land taxes rather than zoning changes is wishful thinking
Three adults sharing a flat would pay next to nothing, but not even Bill Gates could afford to make an inner city skyscraper his home.
With a land tax two adjacent properties of equal size would be taxed the same, even if one is an eight story apartment building and the other is a parking lot. This strongly incentivizes improving the land to its highest and best use. Under a traditional property tax system erecting that building results in a large increase in property tax (as the value of the structure is now taxed) which dampens the motivation to build. Under California's prop 13, the parking lot probably has a tax valuation from decades ago and thus is taxed even less, further reducing the benefits to redeveloping the property.
It's been proposed first in california in 1890, as a solution to homelessness and poverty. So Im not feeling confident that will happen.
LVT long time proposal is that most of the value in land rent is due to government spending and another activities positive externality.
One instance in particular, they’ll run a harvester right next to a 6 story development, and it probably only takes 10 minutes of run-time. Pretty crazy, but it’s a tax savings.
No, looks like he was there before me. I did an MSEE in ‘96, under Moore and Gogineni.
So property tax is already controlled at the state level, and any change will require voters to enact it by proposition at the ballot box, statewide.
Services used are inversely proportional to bodies inhabiting.
In far-flung suburbia, you still need all those miles of roads and sewer pipes serving a relatively small number of people.
One of the papers did an excellent heat map of the Bay Area and pinpointed where all the traffic congestion originates. The eastern periphery of San Jose was the worst.
A ten story condo with 100 units takes up as much land as 8 houses with yards. By reducing everyone's taxes then making up the difference via a land tax, you effectively lower the taxes on people using high density land use homes. You make it a more desirable lifestyle.
Demand from voters leads to changes in law.