News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @12:24PM (#19739990)
I’m usually the last person to say this. But someone should definitely get fired over the 3 year keyboard fiasco. After the problems they had when they were first introduced in the 12” MacBook, someone should have said its time to switch directions.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by cseelus on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:27PM (#19740733)
That would be Dan Riccio, wouldn‘t it? He is senior vice president of Hardware Engineering, directly answering to Tim Cook and leading the Mac, iPhone, iPad and iPod engineering teams.

Some of the current/recent failures that come to mind:

- The MacBook keyboard issues discussed here

- The MacPro disaster (thermal design issues -> no real update since almost six years)

- The The MBP 2018 thermal design issues

- The MBP „Flexgate“ (display connector design flaw)

- The AirPower debacle

- The iPad Pro 3rd gen. „Bendgate“

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by chipotle_coyote on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:42PM (#19740906)
Dan might be the guy who falls on his sword if anyone does, but I suspect that he is struggling with design constraints imposed from someone higher up. Someone obsessed with making everything as thin as possible -- which is arguably the root of many of Apple's hardware woes, large and small. Someone with a British accent who is fond of white rooms.

(Having said that, I think some of those issues are somewhat overstated. The keyboard is a real issue; the Mac Pro's thermal corner is a real issue, but it's one we have solid evidence is being addressed by both the forthcoming Mac Pro and the already-existing iMac Pro; AirPower is a debacle, but I don't know if that's really his purview; the rest...eh. I'm not saying they're not real, but I don't know how widespread they are as real issues. But with the exception of AirPower and the Mac Pro, all the issues you listed would probably have literally been solved by making everything 1mm thicker.)

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by atomical on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:16PM (#19741280)
I think Ive is preparing us for laptops without keyboards. Two screens, one that you type on. It's a dumb idea but I think they will go through with it.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by chipotle_coyote on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @08:05PM (#19743754)
It's quite possible that's what Ive personally would be happy with, but I don't think Apple's going to do that any time soon. As "courageous" as they like to be with jettisoning old technology, they're aware of what a PR fiasco their current generation of laptops has become. If anything, swapping back to low-profile scissor switches and quietly jettisoning the Touch Bar is the most likely next-gen MBP shift.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by TMWNN on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @11:18PM (#19744682)
If Touch Bar were in addition to the function keys + Escape key, everyone would praise it as yet another brilliant Apple innovation, and rivals would be copying it the way every notebook nowadays looks like the late-2008 unibody Macbook Pro (and really, all the way back to the 2001 titanium PowerBook). But it's not, so they don't and they aren't.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by chipotle_coyote on Thursday April 25, 2019 @02:26AM (#19745554)
It's possible. It's not impossible that if they'd just kept the hardware escape key and replaced the function keys with the Touch Bar it would have gotten a warmer reception; I think Apple really underestimated (a) how much of the MBP's loudest and most influential audience is comprised of developers or developer-adjacent techies, and (b) how many of those folks are really attached to their escape key. Personally I would be a lot happier with that -- in practice, I don't really miss the function keys and media keys, and I've actually used some of the Touch Bar functionality once in a while, but not having the escape key makes me angry and I'm not even a dedicated Vim user.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Thursday April 25, 2019 @03:09AM (#19745724)
I think techies overestimate their influence. The Mac’s revenue was the highest it’s ever been last quarter. The lack of an escape key didn’t hurt sells.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by chipotle_coyote on Friday April 26, 2019 @07:43PM (#19762711)
Techies are a pretty big subset of MacBook Pro buyers, specifically, and that's the only line that has models in it with no escape key. The last quarter was the first one that the new MacBook Air was on sale -- the Air being one of Apple's most popular laptops and the one that had gone years without an update. That drove a lot of the sales that quarter. Were a lot of techies buying the Air? I don't know. But you know what the new Air has? An escape key. :)
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by asdff on Thursday April 25, 2019 @04:07PM (#19752012)
At that point I'd duct tape a magic keyboard on the laptop and watch the Ive fanboys rage.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by mcphage on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:49PM (#19741583)
> The AirPower debacle

I'm not sure "debacle" is the right word for a product they announced, and then later decided they couldn't make, and so cancelled. There were no physical copies out there, no consumers wasted money on it, it was just... a cancelled product.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by pier25 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:32PM (#19740789)
Do you think the engineering team decides the thickness of laptops or the design team (Ive) impose specs onto the engineers?
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by kevin_b_er on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:53PM (#19741021)
Apple operates on Form Over Function and has for years. The engineering team is subservient to the design team. You are seeing the consequences of it live. The engineering team knows the butterfly keyboard design is fundamentally flawed, but the design team has priority. There's only so much the engineers can do to make it Function while being constrained by Form.

This is the same type of corporate structural flaw as Boeing has, just without the loss of life for Apple. They needed to sell the plane without re-certifying, so the management demands some poor engineers work around it while having their hands tied behind their back.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by snowwrestler on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @05:32PM (#19742790)
Without constraints and product goals, engineering is just wanking around with math. Every great product you've ever used started with a vision and then engineering was brought to bear to make the vision a reality.

There is a role for engineering to adjust the vision when necessary to comport with reality. It's not clear that was an issue with these keyboards as it's not clear that anyone knew up front that the butterfly mechanism would have these problems.

It's worth remembering that when Apple launched this keyboard, they didn't just say it's thin, they touted the engineering that went into it. I really, really doubt that this was a situation where the engineering team was banging the problem gong and was overruled. I know that's a popular way of thinking here on HN but I need at least some evidence to believe it.

This looks more like well-intentioned innovation that has just not worked out as well as they hoped, which happens sometimes, even with competent engineers. It's why Apple keeps such cash reserves on hand, so they can try new things and survive the ones that don't work out. Thankfully in this case, laptop keyboards are not life and death products.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:00PM (#19741120)
You have no proof of that. They are both VPs. Once you have a certain level of authority, you don’t get to shift the blame.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by atomical on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:17PM (#19741287)
I'm curious why Apple engineering employees don't post here. It would be a great time for that.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ummonk on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @08:52PM (#19743973)
Apple is notoriously secretive, and has unusually restrictive policies about discussing work outside the company. At best we can have ex-Apple engineers chiming in.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by pier25 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:44PM (#19741537)
Maybe they do :P
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:55PM (#19741643)
Jobs himself once said “Somewhere between the janitor and the ceo reasons stop mattering”

And the discussion about the quote on HN

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2524855

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:45PM (#19740941)
Do you really think if the head of engineering went to Tim Cook and said that Ive’s design wasn’t technically feasible he would have been told to ship it anyway?
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by pier25 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:05PM (#19741167)
I don't know, but I doubt it is that simple.

Maybe if the head of engineering had had another 6 months to test the keyboard design properly he could have concluded that it wasn't technically feasible. But at the time there was a lot of pressure to release a redesign of the MBP and probably the design of the case was already decided. In the end Apple wasn't able to make a proper keyboard to accommodate the specs but maybe it was too late to go back to the drawing board.

I'm speculating of course, but I very much doubt Apple are complete idiots. It's more probable that some circumstances forced them to release the redesign. It was a mistake of course, they should have only updated the specs of the 2015 model, maybe adding a TB3 port. But you know, hindsight is 20/20.

I imagine Apple has been working on a redesign with a new keyboard, but these things take a couple of years. Specially when the Mac is only 10% of Apple's revenue.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by dethac on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:52PM (#19741614)
The thing with keyboards is that... well, for one, scissor switches are perfectly acceptable (the ones in the 2015 MBP and older, and pretty much all laptops today). Further, the thickness of the scissor mechanism can be made to be REALLY small. See: Acer Swift 7 (9.95mm thick, total), the XPS 13 (11.6mm thick, total) the X1 Carbon 6 (15.95mm thick, total), and pretty much any other Ultrabook. This is compared to the MacBook Pro, which is 14.9mm thick. Note that the X1 Carbon has TDP-up configured to 25W vs 28W on the MacBook Pro and the XPS 13 has TDP-up configured to 26W. Point being, thermal constraints did not force a keyboard redesign to fit the new form factor.

This feels like something Google would do: Take something that's perfectly functional, change it entirely, remove features, make it less functional, have it be buggy as hell, then release it while deprecating the old one. Now, sell it as an innovative new feature.

In short: the keyboard redesign does not appear to have any real reason behind it, and it's essentially change for the sake of change.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by pier25 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @03:19PM (#19741810)
Maybe you are right. That would be consistent with the trashcan Mac Pro redesign.

Everyone was happy with the Mac Pro towers, a lot of people still use them today. The trashcan design IMO was more of an engineering/design statement at solving a self imposed problem rather than an existing one.

So, if rumors are to be believed, Apple is making a 180 on the new Mac Pro. Let's hope in a year or two we will have a new MBP with a good keyboard.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by atomical on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:20PM (#19741318)
Sure.

Tim: Hey X, I appreciate the hard work you're doing. But I've been busy with other meetings and slagging off Zuckerberg again. LOL. Why don't you touch base with Jony Ive and see if you two can't come up with something?

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:43PM (#19740926)
The MBP 2018 design issue was fixed by a firmware update a week later.

The AirPower debacle was anything but. They noticed they had an unfixable design problem and cancelled the project. The alternative would have been something similar to the Samsung/Galaxy Fold issue. Shipping a bad product.

Even the Mac Pro not being updated was halfway because they thought the IMac Pro bad external GPUs was the answer. Honestly, for most people it could be and has gotten great review. They had a change of heart.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by mikestew on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @03:11PM (#19741757)
The alternative would have been something similar to the Samsung/Galaxy Fold issue.

Nope, there's another alternative: announce it when it's sitting in the backroom of every Apple store, like back in the old days. I'm sure Apple has their reasons for not doing that much anymore, but it would have avoided this very issue.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @03:46PM (#19741993)
Even in the Jobs era they pre announced the “3Ghz G5” that never happened and the AppleTV that did. Of course they preannounced the iPhone by 6 months.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by raverbashing on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:37PM (#19740850)
That, or he is overridden by the design team and their failure to comprehend bending stress requirements or flexing fatigue in cables
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by caycep on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:30PM (#19740772)
There is a need of a new Bob Mansfield, apparently...
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by uptown on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:31PM (#19740786)
I'm convinced Apple has continued to "flatten" their keyboards in order to transition towards iPad-like devices replacing them entirely. For years, they've stated some variation of the following when speaking about the iPad:

"This is the clearest expression of our vision of the future of personal computing, a simple multitouch piece of glass that instantly transforms into anything you want it to be."

So in their quest to shepherd users towards this vision, they've made design concessions which have hurt their existing users.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by president on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:42PM (#19740914)
I think that the yearly slimming down of devices was just an easy way out to having to do real innovation. Apple wanted to prove that they were getting better and better at something every year. They chose slimming down devices because it is an easier problem to solve than inventing something new and game-changing.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by usermac on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:13PM (#19741252)
Wow, you've got me thinking the next keyboard before it's complete removal might be the one on the Atari 400. See it here: https://www.bing.com/images/search?view=detailV2&id=74D98E13...
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by uptown on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @03:29PM (#19741871)
I could see that. Throw in some advanced haptic feedback and you've got yourself the Mac keyboard of 2020.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by sleepybrett on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @05:51PM (#19742943)
Haptic feedback to find the 'keycaps' is fine and all, but if you've ever tried to type like a human on an ipad for more than a few minutes you discovery that having a thing under your finger that has some elasticity to it is SUPER IMPORTANT.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by smacktoward on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:35PM (#19740830)
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by dilap on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @12:25PM (#19739998)
Truly epic fuckup. Boggles the mind.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by benologist on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:01PM (#19740416)
Apple are currently facing a class action for selling known-faulty iPhone 4S/5 hardware in which they're accused of deceptive or fraudulent business practices. Now they do that across multiple product lines, multiple generations...

https://www.macrumors.com/2019/04/24/iphone-4-4s-5-power-but...

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:17PM (#19740608)
I don’t pay much credence to every random class action suit.

They can even be forgiven for having a systemic hardware issue that only becomes apparent once you have millions of devices out there. The keyboard issue is different. They knew they had an issue when they released the 12” MacBook but they kept introducing new models with the same issue. They could have easily just done a speed bump and kept the 2015 design. No one was clamoring for USB C or the Touch Bar.

Even though I think AntennaGate was overblown and they did keep selling the GSM iPhone 4 with no changes, they did make changes to the design nine months later for the CDMA iPhone 4.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by benologist on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:18PM (#19740622)
It's not a random class action, it's about three generations of iPhones with power button issues that Apple sold whilst knowing they were faulty, eventually relying on a free repair program to fix them instead of solving the problem prior to sale.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by chipotle_coyote on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:56PM (#19741071)
I've been following Apple for years and don't recall widespread reports of what I'm sure would have gleefully reported in the press as "Buttongate"; that some home buttons failed prematurely isn't in and of itself a convincing argument for Apple's active malevolence, given that we're talking about, what, ~200M units? In those numbers, 99.99% of the switches could have no problems at all and there would still literally be tens of thousands of failures.

Maybe Apple shipped faulty switches knowingly. But they're also an awfully big juicy target for less scrupulous lawyers.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:30PM (#19740773)
If the repair program was free? Where is the harm?
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by RandomBacon on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:40PM (#19740888)
The hassle for most people is real.

A magic fairy doesn't instantly swap out the defective phone with a good one (and transfer all the files) the instant the problem occurs.

Some people are in countries with no Apple stores, some people are using it as a camera on a week-long backpacking trip in the middle of nowhere. Some people have families and jobs they have to tend to and don't want to waste what little precious freetime they have on this BS, etc.

Edit: and not everyone in the U.S. who has free time, lives near an Apple Store or can get an appointment next day.

I used to not have responsibilities, and I wondered why everyone has a hard time with things. Now I have responsibilities and can see why.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:47PM (#19740968)
Seeing that the class action suit is only in the US, where does the rest of the world come in?

As far as swapping out files. It literally is a matter of clicking “backup” on one phone and choosing to restore on another one.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by RandomBacon on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:53PM (#19741024)
> It literally is a matter of clicking “backup” on one phone and choosing to restore on another one.

No. It is not.

Please tap "backup" on my dead phone. Please tap "backup" on my working phone when I have no computer or Internet to back it up to.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:56PM (#19741074)
The phone would have been backed up by default the last time it was plugged in. I’m just saying as one last sanity check, I would be backing up the phone. But in the case of the home button. The phone wasn’t “dead”.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by RandomBacon on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:02PM (#19741144)
> the last time it was plugged in.

The last time it was plugged into a wall outlet, in an area with no Internet coverage? Or what about that irreplaceable photo I just took since the last time I plugged it into my computer, that I need right now and can't access until my phone is fixed?

Now we're just nitpicking each other. Hopefully you can at least see that they aren't magical devices that will solve everyone's problems. They do break, and like with any device that breaks, it can be a real inconvience for its user.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:48PM (#19741573)
The phone didn’t die in an area with no coverage in this case - the homr button did. Are you saying that at no point between the time that the home button failed and you took it in to get it serviced/replaced that the hypothetical person couldn’t get internet access?
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by muro on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:47PM (#19740971)
- you need to go and get it repaired, costing you time and effort - it's usually time limited
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by dawnerd on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:12PM (#19740541)
Makes you wonder how it wasn’t caught early in development and if it was why didn’t they fix it then?
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:30PM (#19740767)
As I said in another reply, I don’t fault them for not catching it in development. Some problems can’t be accurately simulated. I fault them for continuing the roll out to the rest of the line after the problem became apparent.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by president on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:46PM (#19740958)
Because people get promotions and collect bonuses for delivering.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ProAm on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:12PM (#19740547)
> someone should definitely get fired over the 3 year keyboard fiasco

Tim Cook. His time is up, Apple needs new leadership so they can move past their Ballmer era

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:27PM (#19740730)
Most of Apple’s rebound can be attributed to two people - Jobs for the vision and Tim Cook for turning around their operations.

There is no next iPhone type product on the horizon. The smart phone already has 66% penetration in the world. Anything that Apple introduces is going to pale in comparison.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ProAm on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:12PM (#19741233)
Apple cant innovate because they wait for others to invest something and then they try to improve it. Thats why they are moving into subscriptions to get MRR or ARR. Build a moat that people forget they throw money into every month and call it profit and revenue. It will certainly work, but its just not the Apple that made people proud to use Apple.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:49PM (#19741588)
Exactly what area should they invest in that could make even a 10% difference in their revenue? What technology do you see in the foreseeable future that will be even a fifth of the size of the phone market?

Also, I wouldn’t be surprised if even the Apple Watch isn’t more successful than any other consumer electronics besides the smart phone and the PC. If you define success in terms of profitability.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ProAm on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @03:08PM (#19741735)
I'd love a good new Macbook Pro I want to buy. Or even a good Mac Pro to start with.

I get it, Apple is in their Ballmer era, making tons of money so no one is allowed to argue. But it doesn't 'just work' anymore. They've fallen from grace, which admittedly is hard because they were so good its hard to always move upward. But they are in stagnation and a little embarrassment now. Tell me these keyboards are awesome? The touchbar useful. The battery life in exchange for thinness amazing.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:11PM (#19742146)
Even if they did come up with a new Macbook Pro or MacPro that wouldn't qualify as "innovation" and definitely wouldn't answer the question:

Exactly what area should they invest in that could make even a 10% difference in their revenue? What technology do you see in the foreseeable future that will be even a fifth of the size of the phone market?

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ProAm on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:20PM (#19742222)
This is why Cook needs to go. I can't answer that question for them, and neither can he. Do you really think the future of Apple is subscription services? Thrilling.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:31PM (#19742299)
The phone market has 66% worldwide penetration. It was clear years before the first iPhone came out that the mobile phone was going to be ubiquitous. As early as 2003-2004, many middle class middle school and high school kids had cell phones.

If it were that easy to find the next electronic device that would have 66% world wide penetration who do you propose is the person to find it?

People were clamoring for an iPod + phone for years before the iPhone came out. What electronic device are people clamoring for now?

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ProAm on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:48PM (#19742455)
> If it were that easy to find the next electronic device that would have 66% world wide penetration who do you propose is the person to find it?

Of course its not easy, but I would hope that the CEO of one of the most valuable companies on earth would have that kind of foresight and skill. That's what he is there for, or to hire people that can do that. They're not and that's my point. Time for some significant changes at the helm.

> People were clamoring for an iPod + phone for years before the iPhone came out. What electronic device are people clamoring for now?

These devices were already out before the iPhone, the iPhone was just more polished, and the ability to buy from iTunes was huge. This is where Jobs deserves his credit, not for inventing a device that was a phone, camera and music player in one, but for making it a good experience. These new MBP's are a horrible experience.

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @05:10PM (#19742625)
I’m not dismissing the faults of the MacBook. But who would replace Tim Cook that could come up with the next big thing? Some low level employee that no one ever heard of or would it be the CEO or VP of another consumer electronics company who also hasn’t come up with the next big thing for their company?
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by pier25 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:33PM (#19740809)
Apple has never been more profitable.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ProAm on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @02:10PM (#19741218)
Same as MS under Ballmer
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:32PM (#19742313)
If another CEO could do better, which company has come out with a consumer electronics product as successful as the Apple Watch since 2011?
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ProAm on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @04:57PM (#19742528)
Tesla
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @05:32PM (#19742785)
Seeing that they aren’t profitable yet, I wouldn’t call it a “success”. Once they can make a product at a price that people are willing to pay and make a profit. Then you can call it successful. Anybody can sell dollar bills for 95 cents.

Seeing that the Tesla is neither profitable nor ubiquitous- how do you define it as a “success”?

Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by ProAm on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @08:08PM (#19743773)
People want to use their new products instead of feeling stuck in an ecosystem they can't leave.
Re:Apple now repairing MacBook keyboards in store, promising... by scarface74 on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @08:16PM (#19743810)
You’ve done surveys?