News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:33PM (#19733125)
Facebook is the defense contractor that is building America's Great Firewall and social credit system, so it makes sense that there is a revolving door with the authoritarian regime.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by iheartpotatoes on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:55PM (#19733340)
Only if you are forced to use facebook. Its more of a problem in developing nations. I'm glad Myanmar finally gave Facebook the boot as the default portal to the internet.

When the day comes that we are forced to use a social media platform... heh, we'll all just roll over and start using it. Revolution takes too much effort.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by StanislavPetrov on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:14PM (#19733506)
Unfortunately Facebook does its best to track those of us who don't use it as well (even if their information on us ends up being less comprehensive than the information they have on their actual users).
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by godelski on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:29PM (#19733630)
And you can be pretty effective at that tracking if your contacts use facebook. Since they have access to your call logs they know how frequently you communicate with someone. And people that communicate frequently share general interests.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by i_am_nomad on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:41PM (#19733200)
I’m not familiar with either of those two projects. Perhaps the latter is the aggregation of numerous “good customer” scores, plus actual credit rating, plus the no-fly list. But I haven’t heard about an actual program that implements a social credit score that FB is implementing.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:52PM (#19733318)
Facebook's social graph and engagement data combined with data already obtained by governments makes an elaborate social credit score easy to generate.

As for the great firewall, Facebook has been in talks with lawmakers who want Facebook to do more to prevent "fake news" which is another way of saying that lawmakers want to use Facebook to control the news narrative.

So far, Facebook has been extremely complaint with both of these areas. This new hire is further evidence that Facebook plans to support user privacy only after offering the government plenty of reassurance that its interests and patriot act powers will not be adversely impacted.

I've been concerned/cynical about Facebook's stance on this stuff for a while, but this hire is really chilling. If anyone reading this hasn't read the Patriot Act, give it a read. It is shocking both in how stupid and technologically naive the wording is, as well as in its blatant disregard for the bill of rights. It's definitely the most shameful piece of legislation passed in my lifetime.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by traek on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:54PM (#19733329)
I’d say it’s the media and general public that want Facebook to curb “fake news”, more so than Washington.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:57PM (#19733354)
See the tit for tat between Facebook and lawmakers:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/mark-zuckerberg-facebook-made-m...

Zuck is losing on purpose here by admitting they screwed up, so that he can pivot into a negotiating stance to determine what level of control government will get. This is not all decided yet, it is still in play but this hire suggests that some progress was made in the negotiation.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by inflatableDodo on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:12PM (#19733482)
'The Media' includes The Daily Mail and Fox News. The general public on average don't want facebook to curb 'their' news, perhaps those other people's.

Washington has been shouting fake news from both sides for a while. Is worth noting that Trump just copied something already being said by others and mashed the definition.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by belorn on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:26PM (#19733591)
"I was having a conversation with a senior government official I have know all these many years who work in the White House and I said you're changing American society. He said well we realize that we need a robust social graph of the United States. I said, you mean the United States Government is from now on going to keep a list of everybody every American knows, do you think by any chance that should require a law? And he just laughed." - talk in 2012 by Eben Moglen

Why do we think the government, almost 10 years ago, wanted a robust social graph of every citizen in the United States?

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by gdsdfe on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:42PM (#19733213)
It's called sarcasm
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by pstuart on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:43PM (#19733225)
Or "speculation"
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:25PM (#19733579)
It's actually just synthesis.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by pascoej on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:44PM (#19733238)
What are you referring to?
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by djakjxnanjak on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:51PM (#19733308)
Why do we need a social credit score when we already have money?
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by mindslight on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:12PM (#19733487)
Money has inconvenient qualities for those in power:

1. Actually using it results in parting with it (rather than being able to merely present it over and over)

2. Money held by outsiders is just as valuable as money held by insiders (giving outsiders independent power)

#1 is mitigated by the inflationary treadmill policy, and #2 is mitigated by oxymoronic "money laundering" regulations. But the authoritarians in power are always seeking new ways of eroding distributed paradigms.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by Dangeranger on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:54PM (#19733328)
We already have a social credit score. It's called FICO and it's been doing a great job of making life difficult for people who don't fit the mold for over sixty years.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by godelski on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:22PM (#19733566)
Can we stop making this comparison? At best it is naive at worst you're purposefully misrepresenting the argument.

When people say "social credit score" they distinctly mean something different than "credit score" (you may get this hint by the extra word, "social").

A social credit system not only includes your finances, but as well as much about your behavior. Such as "do you buy cigarettes? How often?" FICO doesn't care about this, they just care about if you're likely to pay back debt (based on your track record of doing exactly that). FICO doesn't care if you're Muslim, black, white, Christian, etc. But a social credit system DOES.

Rather than putting a score on your likelihood of paying back debt, a social credit score scores you on how "good of a citizen" you are. Not just legally, but morally. And that's the danger. Morals shift and vary a lot (more so in the US than most countries). There's a general belief in most first world countries that your skin color, religion, gender, etc should not play a role in how the government of businesses treat you. Social credit systems (even if they don't explicitly add those factors: ie implicit) will use these factors to rate you.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by novok on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:47PM (#19733763)
I think in the past, credit reporting agencies did want to make things equivalent to social credit, or make social credit type things apply to your financial credit score, but were stopped by legislation.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by godelski on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:38PM (#19734122)
Do you have evidence? Or is this just speculation?
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by novok on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @07:27PM (#19743529)
It's a vague memory that I remember reading somewhere in a news article I couldn't find. Maybe it's a good enough hint for someone to else to find the source?
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by edmundsauto on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:39PM (#19733707)
Do you not see any parallels between the two? FICO scores are borderline discriminatory because it turns out that social behaviors and group membership is correlated with those scores.

FICO doesn't "care" if you're Muslim or black, but FICO scores can be absolutely used to discriminate against those groups.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by godelski on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:04PM (#19733895)
This is a fair argument. But there were other factors in my argument. That social credit scores are used to determine more than "can you pay back your credit?"

It isn't hard to argue that FICO can be abused. But what's being argued here is that we don't need, nor want, a system that is more imposing than FICO. One that affects much more of your life, such as "can I use an airplane?"

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by mdorazio on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:39PM (#19734494)
FICO can be and is used to discriminate in job applications. You also seem to be missing the point that debt financing is a huge part of the ability to live a standard American life, much more so than in a country like China. For example, if you can't buy a car, there are many places in America where you simply won't be able to get around. This social-financial reliance system makes credit scores in America a lot closer to a social credit system than you seem to think.

If a score prevents you from using transportation (a needed car), living in decent housing, and getting a decent job, I'd say that score is pretty tightly tied to your social well-being.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by godelski on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:49PM (#19734860)
You realize I'm trying to distinguish a "social credit system" from a "credit system", right?

I will agree that there's problems with a credit system. No argument there. But I'm (we're?) arguing that these problems are exacerbated when adding the social element.

[dead]
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by godelski on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:12PM (#19733944)
COMPAS is only used for those already suspected of/have committed crimes.

A social credit system affects ALL citizens.

Yes, there's controversy with COMPAS and I think you'll find that those that don't want social credit systems likely don't like COMPAS. But bringing up COMPAS is off topic. Especially when you compare it to China.

Let's reiterate and make this easy:

Does <government program> dictate if you and use an airplane? Does it also dictate if you can get a loan?

If you answer yes to (exclusively) BOTH of these questions, then the program might be a social credit system. If you answered no to one or more, then the program is likely not a social credit system.

Note: The China system answers yes to both of those questions. FICO fails on the airplane question. COMPAS fails on both.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:25PM (#19734026)
Maybe the average social credit score in the US is higher than the average in China.

Being added to the no fly list could be the result of an equivalently low score under both regimes.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by godelski on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:37PM (#19734120)
Please do not take this conversation off topic. It is against the rules.

We are distinguishing "social credit scores" from "credit scores". If you would like to argue why they are in fact the same, then that is on topic. But if you are going to assert that they are different and continue off on a tangent then you are going off topic. I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt that you are not trolling, but there's plenty of evidence to suggest that you are.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:49PM (#19734200)
I was certainly not trolling, I was responding to your comment about no fly lists. Sadly you have no response and are resorting to name calling and righteous indignation.

I agree with you that FICO scores are not what Facebook is up to, though a person’s FICO score is likely part of his or her social credit score.

Nonetheless I thought your litmus test sounded overly simplistic.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by godelski on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @09:47PM (#19734848)
On point 2: I think EVERYONE agrees.

On point 3: That frequently tends to be the case for litmus tests. It is also why I hedge all of that with qualifiers. Because yes, it is overly simplified. But I don't know what you expect from me? Write the Principalía of social credit systems?

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:13PM (#19733498)
> We already have a social credit score. It's called FICO

There is a material difference between FICO and what China and, potentially, Facebook are building.

FICO looks at financial factors. It's a model to estimate likelihood of repayment. Being brown or gay or female might correlate with factors that reduce the likelihood of repayment. But if those systemic problems were fixed, and FICO were left unchanged, it should yield an unbiased result.

Social credit scores, on the other hand, directly incorporate biases. Introduce a social credit score into an economically equal society and it will redistribute from the "undesirable" to the "desirable" based on zero economic facts. (Same with ad-driven social networks like Facebook and Instagram.)

It's subtle. But it makes a world of difference in terms of effect and the moral culpability of those who choose to support its development and deployment.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by taurath on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:26PM (#19733592)
There's not really such thing as an unbiased result, especially as it deals with economics. Thats kind of the point of the concept of systemic margininalization.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by longerthoughts on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:15PM (#19733511)
What alternative would you propose?
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @08:01PM (#19734278)
For what goal?
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by dymk on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:57PM (#19733352)
> Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @05:58PM (#19733360)
I think that my comment is pretty much the relevant thing to discuss based on the article. If you disagree please explain why.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by dymk on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:02PM (#19733401)
1) Asserting the presence of an "American Great Firewall"

2) Asserting the development of an American "social credit system"

3) Describing America's political atmosphere as an "authoritarian regime"

4) Describing Facebook as a "defense contractor"

Come on, you know what you're doing

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:05PM (#19733425)
Anyone is free to draw a line in the sand to claim that my statements are hyperbole. I don't consider them so. When we read about China, the narrative of American Exceptionalism tells us that it is reasonable to think that China would seriously implement a social credit score but America would not. I think it is foolish to believe that kind of stuff. Let's just look at the facts.

We must ask how a social credit system would be useful to any government and wonder how any government would turn down the chance to obtain one. There is already hard evidence that the US Government wants to influence FB's news feed algorithm. Strictly speaking that is not a firewall, but the effect (censorship) is the same.

So feel free to belabor the difference between government meddling in the news feed algorithm to promote/demote various ideas and the technology known as China's great firewall. In my view that is a tangential and distracting discussion.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by mfatica on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:13PM (#19733493)
Controlling the news feed on one site is not nearly comparable to a universal firewall... Many people already have stopped using Facebook
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:16PM (#19733525)
> Many people already have stopped using Facebook

Yet it is important enough to public opinion that congress undertakes days of hearings with Zuck to try to control the news feed algo?

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by edmundsauto on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:41PM (#19733717)
This is easily explained by the desire of politicians to grab some time on the news. I didn't see much Congressional behavior or followup that suggests they actually cared about (or understood) the privacy issue.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:34PM (#19734097)
It’s not a privacy issue, it’s a censorship issue.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by lkrubner on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:09PM (#19733463)
Your comment is disingenuous to a degree that’s comical. You complain about the use of the phrase Great American Firewall. Unless you’ve been living under a rock since 2016 you should be aware of the fears in Congress regarding “Fake News” and the extent to which Congress is trying to outsource the work of censorship to Facebook and other social media outlets. There are multiple articles, each week, that make the front page of Hacker News, on this very topic.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by davidw on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:13PM (#19733491)
Some of the other stuff (the firewall) is clearly incorrect, but after thinking about this a long time, I think it's fair to label the current administration as having some fascists or fascist-curious/adjacent/whatever people. Authoritarian works too.

Often, the term gets thrown around too freely by those on the left when they want to disparage someone on the right whose ideas they dislike, so it gets overused.

But I think with the disdain for the rule of law, friendliness and admiration of rulers who are certainly authoritarian, and the push to "believe in me, rather than your lying eyes", the term has a place in the conversation.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @07:37PM (#19734116)
Firewalls don’t only block traffic, they throttle it, log it, and shape it. The US/Facebook firewall is further up the stack than China’s and is more stealthy so rarely blocks any content.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by aerodog on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:03PM (#19733416)
What you're doing is far worse
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by EnFinlay on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:18PM (#19733539)
I am very surprised by the reaction you're getting.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by dymk on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:26PM (#19733594)
Some large subset of the HN crowd isn't interested in being civil, or preferring realistic comparisons to hyperbole, when talking about Facebook anymore.

The two above comments I made are sitting at moderately positive vote counts, so it makes me happy that at least > 50% of HN is bored of the way we've been discussing this topic for the last few years.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by lkrubner on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:52PM (#19733797)
It takes awhile before people gain the ability to downvote, so an aggregate vote of 1 does not imply a 50% split. There is a bias toward positive vote totals, since people can upvote but not downvote when they join Hacker News. On any thread there are more people who can upvote than downvote.

It would be useful if Hacker News would either make a magnitude number available or the actual up and down votes. A comment that gets 3 upvotes versus 2 downvotes will have the same total as a comment that has 412 upvotes versus 411 downvotes, but clearly one comment was ignored while the other struck a nerve.

Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:47PM (#19733767)
It’s not fair to call my comment uncivil.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by EnFinlay on Wednesday April 24, 2019 @01:32PM (#19740798)
I don't think the civil comment was directed at you specifically
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by skybrian on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:04PM (#19733423)
It's a bunch of vague analogies, asserted without evidence. This isn't useful. We already know lots of people hate Facebook.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by lkrubner on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:02PM (#19733410)
The original comment is relevant and very much on the topic, so what are you complaining about? The above article is about Facebook hiring a lawyer who worked on a law that took the USA in an authoritarian direction. The original comment simply emphasizes what is already implied.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ... by resters on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:23PM (#19733573)
This is the key point.