Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ...
by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:13PM
(#19733498)
> We already have a social credit score. It's called FICO
There is a material difference between FICO and what China and, potentially, Facebook are building.
FICO looks at financial factors. It's a model to estimate likelihood of repayment. Being brown or gay or female might correlate with factors that reduce the likelihood of repayment. But if those systemic problems were fixed, and FICO were left unchanged, it should yield an unbiased result.
Social credit scores, on the other hand, directly incorporate biases. Introduce a social credit score into an economically equal society and it will redistribute from the "undesirable" to the "desirable" based on zero economic facts. (Same with ad-driven social networks like Facebook and Instagram.)
It's subtle. But it makes a world of difference in terms of effect and the moral culpability of those who choose to support its development and deployment.
Re:Facebook taps lawyer who helped write Patriot Act as new ...
by taurath on Tuesday April 23, 2019 @06:26PM
(#19733592)
There's not really such thing as an unbiased result, especially as it deals with economics. Thats kind of the point of the concept of systemic margininalization.
There is a material difference between FICO and what China and, potentially, Facebook are building.
FICO looks at financial factors. It's a model to estimate likelihood of repayment. Being brown or gay or female might correlate with factors that reduce the likelihood of repayment. But if those systemic problems were fixed, and FICO were left unchanged, it should yield an unbiased result.
Social credit scores, on the other hand, directly incorporate biases. Introduce a social credit score into an economically equal society and it will redistribute from the "undesirable" to the "desirable" based on zero economic facts. (Same with ad-driven social networks like Facebook and Instagram.)
It's subtle. But it makes a world of difference in terms of effect and the moral culpability of those who choose to support its development and deployment.