Being added to the no fly list could be the result of an equivalently low score under both regimes.
We are distinguishing "social credit scores" from "credit scores". If you would like to argue why they are in fact the same, then that is on topic. But if you are going to assert that they are different and continue off on a tangent then you are going off topic. I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt that you are not trolling, but there's plenty of evidence to suggest that you are.
I agree with you that FICO scores are not what Facebook is up to, though a person’s FICO score is likely part of his or her social credit score.
Nonetheless I thought your litmus test sounded overly simplistic.
On point 3: That frequently tends to be the case for litmus tests. It is also why I hedge all of that with qualifiers. Because yes, it is overly simplified. But I don't know what you expect from me? Write the Principalía of social credit systems?
A social credit system affects ALL citizens.
Yes, there's controversy with COMPAS and I think you'll find that those that don't want social credit systems likely don't like COMPAS. But bringing up COMPAS is off topic. Especially when you compare it to China.
Let's reiterate and make this easy:
Does <government program> dictate if you and use an airplane? Does it also dictate if you can get a loan?
If you answer yes to (exclusively) BOTH of these questions, then the program might be a social credit system. If you answered no to one or more, then the program is likely not a social credit system.
Note: The China system answers yes to both of those questions. FICO fails on the airplane question. COMPAS fails on both.