For those not familiar with the Apple Mouse, the commenter means that the power plug is on the part that you’re supposed to have on the mousepad, meaning you can’t charge it while using it, at all.
Easily the worst way to design a mouse, ever. I don’t understand how it was approved.
I agree that it's a very ridiculous placement, but do you have a better idea where it should be placed? IMO, this is the best option given the constraints.
The usual ridicule is that you can't use it when it's charging. To me, it's a non-issue at all:
- When the battery drops to a low level (4% I think?), you will see a notification on your device reminding you that the charge is low. So have never been caught in a situation where I needed to charge the mouse while using it. - The battery lasts a long time. Apple claims that it lasts 2 months per full charge. Based on anecdotal evidence from myself and a friend, it lasts 3 months per full charge. So this 2 months claim isn't based on some super unrealistic assumption that Apple makes. So why is this important? Because at 4% when you receive the warning notification, the mouse can still run for another 2 days! (Assuming constant usage everyday and one full charge lasts 60 days, then 4% = 60 / 100 * 4 = 2.4.) - Finally, it charges super fast, too. A couple of minutes of charges can run a full day. So if you come to the office to find your mouse out of charge (because you forgot to charge it for the past 2 days despite the notifications), then plug it in before you get your coffee and you're good to go.
My point is that, yes, the charging port placement is ridiculous, but 1) I don't think there are better options and 2) it's really not that big of a deal because it is extremely unlikely that you'd need to charge while you're using it.
How about having a small notch at the front of the mouse, like every other mouse I've used? It can then be simultaneously wired, and usable. Maybe you're right that it's usually not frustrating, but I was trying to use this mouse at my office once and it wasn't charged, and it seemed pointless to wait before using it.
> then plug it in before you get your coffee and you're good to go
What if I don't want to test my mouse before coffee? What if I have urgent emails to answer?
I understand that it isn't a world-breaking choice, but I don't understand why they would choose to change this. I love Apple, but this seems like one of those situations where a company changes something just to change it, claiming it's new and innovative, but actually reduces usability.
Plug it in once a month (when it's at ~50% or so) for an hour or two when you finish your day or go to lunch?
I use this mouse with my desktop PC. It's got a port in the front to connect via USB to charge while allowing the user to use the mouse. Furthermore it supports wireless charging.
I'm shocked Apple thought putting it at the bottom was a good design decision.
Is there any other context in which Apple would tolerate an avoidable two minutes of wait time? Definitely not for their web pages!
Same with the pencil 1st gen - it charged so fast that it having a male port actually made sense as it made on the go charging feasible.
That's a minute longer than you should have to wait to keep using your mouse. I can appreciate that they minimized the impact of the poor design, but that doesn't mean it's not a poor design.
> This resulted in them actually using it as a wireless mouse instead of a wired one.
Does that improve functionality at all? It sounds like the same style-over-substance design that's led Apple to sacrifice important functionality for unnecessary size/weight cuts in the last few years.
Putting it on the bottom did nothing but remove that optionality for the user, and that can be really frustrating.
Unless the reason it charged so quickly was because it connected to the bottom of the mouse, I don't see the justification.
It is my work mouse for 99% of my working time, and as a very heavy user of it I love the mouse, and it just isn't something that enters my mindspace at all.
I feel like this conversation is one half people who have and use the mouse, and who have no problem with it, and one half people who don't use the mouse and imagine that it's some critical issue that they would face daily. And the latter are busy down arrowing anyone who isn't outraged about a non-issue.
My mouse is wireless. When it says battery low you know what I do? I plug it in and it looks just like a wired mouse for an hour.
Tell me what exactly you get in exchange for losing that feature? Sexiness?
Could they put the port somewhere else? Not with the current design (and it's a design that works spectacularly well for flicking and scrolling with fingers on the touch surface -- it seems to be a bit more than a design for looks). Well I suppose they could put it on the left or the right, but that would be stupid. They can't fit it on the ends. So they should have designed it for a non-issue that users of the mouse have no trouble with?
An hour? A 2 minute charge will run a Magic Mouse for a full work day.
I do. It was on purpose. They do not want people using the wireless mouse as a wired mouse with a short, thick cord not designed for it. Which is totally what my parents would do.
That's still stupid as hell, as it basically asserts you're not allowed to use your computer if your mouse is out of batteries.
Logitech's MX master came with a super long cable (it's at least 150cm / 5 ft), pretty flexible, and the charging port's at the top of the mouse. When it's out of battery it just becomes a wired mouse for a short while, it's super convenient. The Anywhere 2S is the same, and for all that I preferred the VX Nano overall, not having to hunt for a pair of emergency battery when I forget/forgot to recharge the 2S is extremely useful.
In fact that's pretty much the only thing I dislike about my Apple Wireless Keyboard: if I forget to charge/change the batteries when it starts whining it becomes dead weight.
NeXT workstations never had function keys.
Like this wouldn't invite even more outrage?
I take it you've never used it before.
"To charge your Apple Pencil (1st generation), PLUG YOUR Apple Pencil INTO THE Lightning connector ON YOUR iPad. You can ALSO charge it with a USB Power Adapter by using the Apple Pencil Charging Adapter that came with your Apple Pencil." Emphasis mine.
Apple not only designed this BS way to charge, but also promoted it as the canonical way on their official docs (even on their videos).
I could just paste the whole excerpt, but I wanted to "rub the relevant part "in the face", so to speak.
I take it you are familiar with the concept of adding emphasis to a statement to highlight some part, right?
If you're asking for the specific use of caps, it's because italics don't look very well in HN, and I can't bold IIRC.
It was just a terrible idea, no excuses. Requiring a dongle only adds insult to injury.
This is another example of sound engineering taking a back seat to user-facing design.
Instead of a fully removable cap, I would have used a tether to keep it secured to the device, and the connector would be on a short cord with a 90-degree connector. A removable clip would then secure the device to the edge of the pad as it charges. Otherwise the whole thing could flop around without damage to the male connector or female socket. Though this is all with the benefit of hindsight, everyone ought to know better than to plug anything into anything else without some strain relief.
Pencil 1's terrible, though. It's led to many a "oh I could use my Pencil for this... oh it's dead, yet again. I'll just charge it... but I want to keep using my ipad, so where's the pinkie-nail-sized adapter again? Eh, screw it, I'll do something else."
[EDIT] also, when's it done? Dunno. Oh and the tiny adapter is directional, though either side kinda fits whichever way you put it, but I guess putting an arrow on it or making the ends different colors wouldn't have been "beautiful" so there's a little getting-it-right ritual every time. Get it wrong and it won't charge. Which, again, any little LED indicator of charging status would've solved that problem, too.
Just think, when your Pencil plug end snaps, because it was protruding from the end of the iPad and you've dropped it, or hit something, or made a sudden move, etc, how convenient would that be?
It's a bad design, end of story.
Personally I don't like moving from Lightning to a more-proprietary non-standard magnetic interface. I think the first generation Pencil has a much better design in this regard, since now we have it working with the standard iPad and iPad Air.
But, I think the design of the first generation Pencil is pretty good, so I'm curious of your thoughts since you find it to be a bad design.
Yeah, very much so. Both the charging and also the better grip.
>Personally I don't like moving from Lightning to a more-proprietary non-standard magnetic interface.
That's a non issue with the Apple Pencil, because it's already a proprietary product itself, inherently tied to the iPad. It's not like it's a cross-product/cross-platform device, and needs a standard charging interface. You'll need an iPad to use it in the first place, so might as well charge it with one.
It _is_ cross product insofar as it's on the iPad, iPad Air, and iPad Pro. This is pretty useful for me and my partner since we can simply share a single Pencil since neither of us rely too much on it. But that's just an exception case, I'm sure.
Lightning is proprietary, but very common. I've got a half dozen Lightning cables lying around. If I want to pair the Pencil to a new device, I simply plug it into the Lightning interface and it's ready to go.
I was trying to think of a better phrase than what I used "more-proprietary", since both are at 100% proprietary that doesn't come across how I intend.
Basically I strongly dislike these weird interfaces that we're putting on the iPad -- the one for the keyboard wasn't great, and the addition of the one for the Pencil also doesn't feel great. But, if that's the direction that best serves the function provided then I suppose it's fine. My hope then is that we get those to move down to the lower-end devices (as we've seen with the Air getting the keyboard cover).
And then it gets dropped...
I wonder if the poor hardware has to do with increasingly outsourced R&D. I mean, everyone at Apple is rich, why should they bother with all the hard details ...
Exactly. And my life improved so much since I reduced the backpack carrying my laptop by 1mm...
Arrow keys being disabled in Safari iOS
3D Touch
Removing the 3.5mm Jack...
- removed the SCSI port
- removed the floppy disk drive
- removed the CD ROM
It hurt EVERY time. The pain does not get less when they do it over and over again.
Guess which one apple (and everyone else) is using despite this being available for two years? (Not aptX) Wireless just isn't ready yet.
You plug the Pencil into the iPad to pair it. It comes with an adapter that you use to charge it with a regular cable.
"To charge your Apple Pencil (1st generation), plug your Apple Pencil INTO THE Lightning connector on your iPad. You can ALSO charge it with a USB Power Adapter by using the Apple Pencil Charging Adapter that came with your Apple Pencil. "
(Emphasis mine).
Besides, you shouldn't need to plug it that way to pair it either.
> Besides, you shouldn't need to plug it that way to pair it either.
Agreed. And glad that's not necessary for the latest generation.
You said "You plug the Pencil into the iPad to pair it. It comes with an adapter that you use to charge it with a regular cable."
As a response to the parent, your comment makes sense only if you meant to imply: "you're not supposed to plug it to charge it, only to pair it".
But if you meant to imply that as the right way to do things as according to Apple, you're wrong.
Apple suggests to plug it to the iPad to charge it (not just to pair it), and mentions the charge cable only as something you can "also" do.
In other words, Apple doesn't say you're just meant to "plug the Pencil into the iPad" only to pair it, and not only it doesn't discourage users to charge by plugging to the iPad, it suggests it.
In one way there's a single step.
In the other way, there's 2 steps and it involves another piece of equipment.
How might you write the documentation on how to do that thing?
Personally, I'd go with two sentences. The first that describes how to do the thing in one step. The latter, how to also do it in two steps and with another piece of equipment. I'm genuinely curious, is there a better way to approach that?
That's my whole argument. That Apple presents it as 2 different equally good ways to achieve the same end result (and even mentions the pencil-protruding-dangerously way first and the second way as an aside).
In case you've lost context, I made the point to answer the parent commenter, who said that "the pencil-protruding-dangerously" is not a problem, because you're meant to charge the Pencil the cable-extension way in the first place (and sticking it directly to the iPad is just needed once at first to "pair it").
Well, my point is, if that's "how you're meant" to do it, (a) nobody told Apple, (b) Apple themselves suggested this fact to no one, and in fact went on to recommend the "just stick it" way as (a) equally good as the other, (b) first.
>Personally, I'd go with two sentences.
This is only OK if you assume both ways are equally safe and good. Which is my whole point: that Apple assumes that, and presents them as such -- when in fact they are not.
As for how I'd do it: "You can charge your Pencil with the provided cable adapter. In an immediate need, you can also just stick it on your iPad, but be careful, it's a brain damaged way, and it's easy to snap the egde that way".
I still don't agree that it's a particularly dangerous method of charging the device [1]. But I get that you'd change the wording since you feel it's dangerous.
Do you have one? It charges very quickly. Basically go make a cup of coffee and it's charged for the day+ when you get back. Leave it plugged in overnight and it's good for almost a month.
The idea is you weren't supposed to leave it plugged in.
2 hours of charging = 2 months of use so it's not like charging was supposed to be a regular occurrence.
The idea is I don't care about the idea. If I forgot to charge it, or come back from holidays and it's off, I want to be able to plug in and still work.
Like with every other mouse.
Not to mention: when the charge lasts so long (2 months) it's even easier to forget to recharge it and take it for granted. Unlike something you need to charge e.g. daily or so, this is something that stays out of your mind for months on end -- until it fails.
As I mentioned elsewhere. You plug it in, go get a cup of coffee and come back with a day+ of usage.
To me, it just reeks of laziness, just like the iPhone X "notch" and the Pencil gen 1 charging. In all these fairly recent examples, Apple basically gave up and didn't even bother trying.
And it's also completely different from removing a headphone jack – you could actually see that as a form of progress. But charging a mouse without being able to use it – try and convince me that is progress.
It's the Lightning connector which was never designed to be moved within the socket tens of thousands of times a day.
Plugs not being able to stand up the stress and strain were never Apple's concern.
Apple cables (for lighting, charing MBPs, etc) have easily strained since time immemorial.
I am consistently annoyed when Apple, who has the magnetic charging plug patent until 2025, refuses to use it in exactly the applications where it would be most beneficial.
The other two being:
- the touch strip, which I find mostly annoying. I'd prefer physical buttons with the ability to show different labels (a la Optimus keyboard).
- whichever idiot thought putting the power plug at the bottom of the Magic Mouse was a good idea.