News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by whb07 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:30PM (#19536434)
The fundamental problem with public school teachers are that the “customer” in the relationship isn’t the parent or the child, but the gov bureaucrat. So while the results of a teacher might hurt the child or the parent, who cares as it’s not them to who they cater to.

The incentives aren’t aligned properly and there is no negative incentive when a school fails a generation of children. The teacher and admins will just carry on business as usual(rather monopoly) charge a higher fee and deliver a worse product.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by apocalypstyx on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:21PM (#19536803)
The more fundamental problem may be that the contemporary horizon of meaning has so contracted that we cannot conceptualize of anything not defined in terms of "customers" or "product" (or "war").
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by whb07 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:33PM (#19536872)
I’m not sure I follow. Care to expand how one can serve someone they aren’t beholden to in some way?
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by username223 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:58PM (#19537516)
Fiduciary duty? Hippocratic oath? Pride in a job well done? Friendship? Altruism? Empathy? There are plenty of ways.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by gridlockd on Monday April 01, 2019 @11:57AM (#19544686)
...none of which work "at scale". If they did, we would be living in completely different societies. People unduly ascribe all sorts of virtues to teachers.

Case in point, look at everyone's favorite "socialist" country: Sweden. Schooling has improved significantly after privatization with a voucher system.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by username223 on Monday April 01, 2019 @04:57PM (#19548148)
Any links about Sweden? Most voucher efforts in the US seem to work by taking the best students and/or most engaged parents out of the public schools. And Swedish PISA test scores seem to have floated around 500 for the last 15 years, with a slight downward trend, if any.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by gridlockd on Wednesday April 03, 2019 @02:42PM (#19566023)
Sweden adopted the voucher system in 1992, not fifteen years ago.

There is evidence that the outcome was an improvement:

https://web.archive.org/web/20130512223637/http://www.ifau.s...

Of course, there's a political debate attached to it and you will find a lot of people to frame it all differently, but the facts are clear: The private schools are superior.

https://tino.us/2011/03/on-the-swedish-voucher-system/

Sinking PISA scores in the last years is probably best explained by a lowering of standards to accommodate, among other things, for a surging population of newly-arrived immigrants.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by njepa on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @03:58AM (#19551971)
As far as I know schooling hasn't improved in Sweden because of the voucher system, instead schools have fallen behind the neighboring countries which have more traditional systems.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by wnevets on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:42PM (#19536519)
>The fundamental problem with public school teachers are that the “customer” in the relationship isn’t the parent or the child, but the gov bureaucrat. So while the results of a teacher might hurt the child or the parent, who cares as it’s not them to who they cater to.

Thanks no child left behind! Tying school funding and teacher pay to child test schools is one of the largest blunders this country has made.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by tropo on Sunday March 31, 2019 @07:53PM (#19539279)
The implementation was botched, but the idea was fine.

You need good quality tests that aren't supplied by book publishers. Ideally you'd test anything, but if tests are unavailable for a particular subject then you have to mandate hours for that subject to keep it from disappearing. You need test security so that the teachers don't cheat.

Instead of just cutting pay, which isn't helpful, you should pay per-student and adjust the number of students per teacher. It is easy to teach a very small group, but very hard to teach a large group. Shift students from bad teachers to good teachers until the quality is equalized. Unfortunately this hits a problem with standardized classroom size. Aside from that though, it would be fine to have one teacher with 9 students and another teacher with 72 students. The teacher with 75 is getting paid 8x as much as the teacher with 9, and the students all get equal quality.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by nichos on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:13PM (#19536749)
Thanks to government in general. America's students are much worse since the inception of the DOE.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by wnevets on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:52PM (#19537014)
Citation needed
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by josho on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:10PM (#19537607)
> The incentives aren’t aligned properly

Then explain the success of schools outside of the US that have similar government based funding?

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by whb07 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:19PM (#19538097)
Can you define "success"? Furthermore, can you provide examples where schooling isn't better served by a private entity (in scale and time)?
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by Nasrudith on Sunday March 31, 2019 @06:39PM (#19538895)
Education is a messy topic to optimize as well for "customers" as they may not know best either. That isn't exclusive to education of course.

It is why tenure is a thing - what is true and right may not be popular.

They do get a reward for doing well but it is very long term - if they are successful and society could get better funding and well liked for being a success story.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by duxup on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:51AM (#19536202)
Teachers are still poorly paid, they aren't really changing any of the problems teachers face, and a great deal of opportunity and advancement is determined purely by seniority....

They may win some battles but I would argue they aren't winning the war, and their emphasis on seinority above all isn't very appealing.

I still see young teachers with new ideas held back by a union that caters to luddite established teachers who are effectively untouchable, don't want to change and enjoy most of the benefits.

American unions focus on seinority > all is the reason I would never want to be a part of them.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by verisimilidude on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:19PM (#19536366)
The article addresses this, pointing out that many of these teacher strikes are led by the workers themselves, rather than union leadership (which often tries to avoid strikes).

This is HN, right? I'd expect someone here to seize on that opportunity, and develop some sort of service to help workers organize themselves, perhaps against the wishes of their union-appointed bureaucrats.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by duxup on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:21PM (#19536382)
I'm not convinced that either the unions or one off actions are doing much.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by sundaeofshock on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:11PM (#19536734)
Teachers keep withholding their labor and getting pay increases as well as increases in overall school funding. I’m curious why you feel that is not “doing much”.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by morpheuskafka on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:48AM (#19536174)
I generally support teacher labor movements. However, I think it's important to consider the effects that even the smallest disruption. For example, last year in NC the teacher's groups organized a "Rally for Respect." What they did to bypass strike laws was they encouraged every teacher in the state to request unpaid personal day, which is normally rubberstamped by the principal as you only have a couple. When half the school wants leave, that would be when you stop signing them. But instead, to avoid that conflict, nearly all major districts cancelled school entirely, treating everyone taking leave as a foregone conclusion.

So, one extra teacher workday, barely even worth noting, right? Well, it just so happens that the day selected was the day of the AP Lang exam that year. By the time they saw fit to announce the non-strike, all of the exams had already been ordered and students and teachers had been planning for the normal date. Thanks to the non-strike, the state had to pay $45/exam to get late exams, and it could have caused some students to miss the exam if they had to take a conflicting exam late for a legitimate reason. Oddly enough, College Board wouldn't have charged if it were a real strike.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by door5 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:54AM (#19536223)
The whole point of strikes is that they are disruptive.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by morpheuskafka on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:55AM (#19536229)
But when government workers strike, they don't disrupt the legislatures that set their pay, they disrupt the everyday citizens who might have even been sympathetic to their cause.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by sundaeofshock on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:27PM (#19536418)
I’m not sure what point you are trying to make here. Of course strikes are disruptive to the general public; that’s one of the reason people strike. Ordinary citizens who have their lives disrupted will turn to their elected officials to end the disruption. There will always be people who turn unsympathetic when workers withhold their labor. The long-term benefit is worth it.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by ferongr on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:15PM (#19537167)
As an ordinary citizen affected by, I support privatization where possible and at-will employment regimes for public servants where not. Public servants are privileged and should not have the right to strike.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by RestlessMind on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:23PM (#19537226)
So if public servants are forbidden from striking and their employer (govt) starts abusing them, what would be their recourse? Voting might be insufficient if size of the workforce is too small to matter.

In general, strike is a tool labor has against capital. Just because capital happens to be provided by taxpayers, how does that warrant a special case handling?

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by ferongr on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:48PM (#19537437)
They can always quit. But nobody quits from guaranteed for-life employment with generous pensions, lots of paid leave and limited workload.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by snazz on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:01PM (#19537541)
Public school teachers don’t have any of those benefits, at least in the US. Their pay and pension are anything but generous, they have little paid leave (where I live, maternity or paternity leave uses up paid sick days too), and they work long hours, with the expectation that they are available to answer emails practically every day.

This is pretty much why there are very few public school computer science teachers who do a decent job, since the ones who can legitimately write code can get a much better job at a private company.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by cascom on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:10PM (#19538042)
They have little paid leave because they have summers and other holidays off, and as for answering emails - welcome to having a job in America.

When you factor that they only work 2/3 of the year, the value of their pension and healthcare teachers actually make a considerable amount of money.

That being said I’m not sure what the right amount is - I put a great deal of value on education - then again the best private institutions probably pay less than public ones at the k-12 level

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by RestlessMind on Monday April 01, 2019 @10:19AM (#19543462)
Same can be said about private sector workers. Then why have separate rules for public vs private?
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by pnw_hazor on Sunday March 31, 2019 @10:43PM (#19540003)
They can vote their bosses out and they usually have statutory civil servant protections as well.

When government employee unions negotiate with their employers, they negotiate with a political actors who, if they act right, get support from the union for their next re-election.

The incentives encourage political actors to bend to the unions will to receive donations or endorsements in their next election.

Typically this is called a conflict-of-interest.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by sfkdjf9j3j on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:43PM (#19537401)
What do you mean specifically by "should not have the right to strike"? As in, they should have their right to free association limited? They should be forced to work under penalty of jail time?
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by door5 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:46PM (#19540316)
You're right, to some degree, public sector employees have stronger labor protections than private sector employees. However, we disagree in that I think these protections are a good thing, and I support nationalization where possible and private sector unions where not. Everyone should have the right to strike.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by manfredo on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:54PM (#19537488)
It causes more parents to say "screw it" and put their kids in private schools. And now those parents have a lot less reason to support public school funding.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by door5 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:38PM (#19538212)
People rich enough to put their kids in private school are a tiny minority. It doesn't matter what they think. This is a working class movement for working class people.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by manfredo on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:47PM (#19538274)
No, they aren't. The average private school tuition is about $10k a year [1]. Ones affiliated with religious institutions like Catholic schools often offer subsidized tuition for lower income people. It's within reach for a sizable portion of the middle class. In many states, private school tuition is tax deductible.

Granted, cheaper private schools are more common in the less affluent areas (namely, the South) where it's essentially taken for granted that the moderately well off and above send their kids to private schools. If you're from a wealthy coastal city with public schools good enough that the wealthy are comfortable sending their kids there, then it's understandable why some may associate private schools as being more exclusive to the upper class.

1. https://www.privateschoolreview.com/tuition-stats/private-sc...

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by sundaeofshock on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:14PM (#19538436)
Median household income in the US is $65k. $10k/year/ child is not affordable for most households.

You also mention religious schools. Why should a person have to indoctrinated in a religion to receive a good education?

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by manfredo on Sunday March 31, 2019 @05:36PM (#19538578)
> Median household income in the US is $65k. $10k/year/ child is not affordable for most households.

Er, no? Assuming it's tax deductible most families can probably make some lifestyle changes to free up $10k. Sure it might inhibit other goals, like building up saving or consumer spending. But it's a sacrifice that many people can make if they have a strong incentive to do so (like if the local public school is crap). And this is ignoring any sort of subsidy or assistance.

> You also mention religious schools. Why should a person have to indoctrinated in a religion to receive a good education?

I mentioned them in context cheaper private school education. Not to mention, the fact that you immediately leapt from "religious school" to "indoctrination" indicates that you seem to be approaching this with your conclusions decided a priori and are looking to justify them rather than participate in good faith.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by sundaeofshock on Sunday March 31, 2019 @07:03PM (#19539026)
> lifestyle changes to free up $10k.

Seriously? Do you have a family? Raising kids is really expensive, even without sending them off to public school. After rent, food, clothing, medical care, and transportation, there is not much left.

As for your comments about religious school, I am basing my comments on real the real world experience of having gone to a religious school for 7-years. All of these schools require some type of education about the school’s founding religion. At a minimum, we are talking about a regular class. Many schools require their students to adhere to the standards of the religion during the course of the school day. Please explain to me how this is not indoctrination?

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by manfredo on Sunday March 31, 2019 @08:07PM (#19539331)
If an extra $10k out of an overall family income of $65k is impossible then I'd say that this family isn't managing money well. Were they not putting anything into savings before? Did they have no savings? Again, it'd be a significant sacrifice to afford private school - I've said so since the beginning - but it is possible for a lot more than just "a tiny minority" (your original words).

> All of these schools require some type of education about the school’s founding religion. At a minimum, we are talking about a regular class. Many schools require their students to adhere to the standards of the religion during the course of the school day.

And from this, you jump to "indoctrination". I and other family members have been to religious schools as well. One of my sister's closest friends was Jewish, and went to Catholic without any type of issue. And both my sister and I are about as atheistic as you can get. If merely teaching a class about the founding religion counts as indoctrination then this is a very, very permissive definition of indoctrination you're using.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by door5 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:36PM (#19540260)
Advocacy of a specific religion should not be part of a citizen's formal education. Private religious schools receive public funding and public accreditation, and they should not, nor should any other private school, for that matter.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by manfredo on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:33AM (#19540532)
I'm not sure why you're mentioning public funds, seeing as it was never brought up. Regardless, public funds can only be used for secular education: https://www.pewforum.org/2009/05/14/shifting-boundaries5/. Public funds can be spent on religious schools provided that the funds go to secular education within those schools.

The above commenter immediately claimed that private religious schools are "indoctrination" - despite the previous comment only mentioning religious schools in passing (since they're generally less expensive than secular religious schools). That kind of intense blanket leap to a serious allegation is not indicative of reasonable view on the subject, regardless of one's opinions on public funds going towards religious schools.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by pnw_hazor on Sunday March 31, 2019 @10:38PM (#19539972)
About 22-23% of school age children in Seattle, WA go to private schools.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by door5 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:33PM (#19540244)
Are you validating my point? Less than 1/4th of all children in one of the wealthiest metropolitan areas in the country.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by manfredo on Monday April 01, 2019 @12:48AM (#19540584)
10% of students nation-wide attend private K-12 schools [1]. This is not "a tiny minority".

https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=55

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by door5 on Monday April 01, 2019 @02:00AM (#19540888)
This is pedantic. 10% is proportionally a very small number. I'm far more invested in the interests and priorities of 90% of people than of 10% of people.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by pnw_hazor on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @12:30PM (#19555893)
In Seattle about half of school age white kids go to private schools. Half of the largest demographic.

Also, I don't believe that you are more invested in the 90% over the 10% unless the 10% is a group you disfavor -- such as parents who refuse to condemn their children to bad public schools if they can help it.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by door5 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @06:25PM (#19559168)
I condemn the rich who want to isolate their kids instead of working on a public school system accessible to all, yes.

It's oddly transparent to limit your stats to white people.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by mikeash on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:41PM (#19536936)
When corporate workers strike, they don’t disrupt the board members and major shareholders that set their pay, they disrupt the everyday customer who might have even been sympathetic to their cause.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by pnw_hazor on Sunday March 31, 2019 @10:54PM (#19540041)
Private unions are fine. Government unions are problematic because the interests of taxpayers and the government officials that negotiate with the unions are not in alignment.

Government office holders benefit greatly if they take care of the government unions in terms of campaign donations, endorsements, rallies, and so on. Taxpayers not so much.

Why else do government union employees get outsized retirement benefits that have caused disabling debts to local governments?

That is what happens when the taxpayers' negotiator personally benefits from keeping the government unions happy happy.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by mikeash on Monday April 01, 2019 @09:39AM (#19543091)
I don’t see that the union is a particularly important part of what you describe. The same things could happen without a union. The misaligned incentives are the same either way.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by Zach_the_Lizard on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:42PM (#19537393)
They do tend to disrupt profits, which in turn does disrupt the board. Since board members tend to be large shareholders or representatives of large shareholders, they would personally feel the effects of their net worth decreasing.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by mikeash on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:28PM (#19537757)
Strikes by government workers disrupt taxes and affect elections. What’s the difference, really?
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by door5 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:58AM (#19536245)
Yes they do -- These strikes have been incredibly effective. If ordinary citizens are not sympathetic to the teachers but sympathetic to the legislators, they have a distorted view of the situation, probably from right-wing, anti-union media.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by duxup on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:07PM (#19536298)
Yeah the few things they have gotten here and there have been pretty unimpressive.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by hedora on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:59PM (#19536648)
Labor laws were a carefully negotiated compromise between economic chaos and workers rights.

I think the lesson here is that that they’ve been weakened to the point of irrelevance, people still need to (and will) strike, and it will cause more harm to employers than the system that was intentionally dismantled after the last few decades.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by tomatotomato37 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:27PM (#19536841)
I don't get labor movements for public institutions. I mean for corporate or private businesses its makes sense to counter the profit above all else motive, but for something like a school which uses public funds to push a societal good I find it to be a bit entitled.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:16PM (#19537169)
I think that the issue is that even though school is a societal good (and presumably most teachers are motivated at least somewhat by altruism) it is also how teachers make their living. So the same forces involved in a private sector strike are in play, just with management replaced by the government, school board, or citizens.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by Zach_the_Lizard on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:48PM (#19537429)
On the other hand, private workers don't typically vote for their leaders, but public unions can and do get to vote. So they have additional levers to pull
[dead]
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by erentz on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:35AM (#19536098)
I may be wrong but I doubt Salman Khan would agree with you.

On the other hand there is this line of thinking that sounds plausible, that we have the idea of instruction and homework backward in our school system. Kids should watch videos by great instructors as homework, and should do the exercises (what would normally be the homework) in the classroom. With the role of the teacher in this scenario to assist students where they have difficulty. This way the teachers aren’t spending 80% of their time doing the repetitive stuff that’s the same for every student but can instead focus more time on the problem areas students are having.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by Kephael on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:39AM (#19536119)
The flipped classroom model doesn't work with unmotivated students.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by erentz on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:45AM (#19536150)
You seem to be invalidating your own argument that we don't need teachers.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by Kephael on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:48AM (#19536169)
No, I'm saying there's no need to throw resources at the lower 40% of the student population. The educational system is already babysitting for them. The smart and motivated students can already learn far more on their own from textbooks and online resources such as KhanAcademy, edX, Cousera, etc.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by eesmith on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:48PM (#19536564)
Right, so how do you tell which are the "lower 40%"?

And how do you ensure that it isn't really just a proxy for being poor? Since hunger, lack of a long-term home, parents who need to work multiple jobs to support a family, etc. are things which make it difficult even for smart and motivated students to learn.

Of course there are some smart and motivated students who can learn from books and online resources. But is that all of the remaining 60%? Or is it 5%

Bear in mind that Khan Academy disagrees with your assessment that it can be a general purpose replacement for teaching. Quoting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khan_Academy#Criticism : "Khan Academy positions itself as a supplement to in-class learning, with the ability to improve the effectiveness of teachers by freeing them from traditional lectures and giving them more time to tend to individual students' needs", so KhanAcademy" (emphasis mine).

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by 0815test on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:46AM (#19536155)
It's a lot better than the status quo. What's easier for the teacher, motivating a student during practice or getting them to pay attention to the lecture?
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by hobs on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:11AM (#19535972)
Do you really believe that some internet videos are going to replace human contact with regard to teaching?

I would consider my experience with education sub-par at best, but even I know that this will NEVER be the case.

[dead]
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by dang on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:05PM (#19538014)
Would you please stop posting flamebait comments to HN? We ban accounts that do that. If you'd instead review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and take the spirit of this site more to heart, we'd be grateful. Here's one of them:

"Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive."

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:23PM (#19537227)
Two thoughts:

Are you saying that a teacher should be able to babysit more that 28 students or that a teacher shouldn't be working as a babysitter? It seems to me that as a practical matter "babysitting" is an inherent part of a teachers job (particularly in lower grades) and that's probably something that they cannot do efficiently much above 28 students.

Second, my understanding is that teacher to student ratios is one of the major metrics used to identify the health of a school. Granted, since I don't personally know the data behind that, this is effectively an "appeal to authority", but it still strikes me as reasonable to put some stock in the expert's opinions.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by whatshisface on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:11AM (#19535978)
American public school teachers provide childcare as they shepherd children through their education. The fact that they give lectures is almost incidental - if you had teachers stand at the back of the room and play youtube videos, the price would not go down.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by duxup on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:09PM (#19536309)
I'd say the education provided is more than "incidental".
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by Kephael on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:32AM (#19536086)
Not running schools like welfare systems is one of the reasons why the East Asian countries have been doing vastly better when compared to most Western countries.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by howard941 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:57AM (#19536243)
What do you make of the starkly-contrasting Finnish approach? https://www.deseretnews.com/article/865563989/What-we-can-le...
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by Kephael on Sunday March 31, 2019 @12:12PM (#19536318)
I don't know, but you're not going to be successful at real math without a lot of practice. The PISA exam is a joke and looks like 6th grade math.

http://www.oecd.org/pisa/test/PISA%202012%20items%20for%20re...

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by pnw_hazor on Sunday March 31, 2019 @10:59PM (#19540066)
In plenty of school across American, teachers do teach the equivalent of standing in the back of the room and playing youtube videos.

It is depressing to see how much the quality of US public education has declined while the spending has increased.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by Helloworldboy on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:09PM (#19536720)
You're being downvoted, but I agree. In the information age public school teaching is a glorified jobs program.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by pnw_hazor on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:02PM (#19540083)
...daycare program.

But it doesn't have to be this way. And that's what makes it so sad. One look at an 8th grade primer (math, language arts, geography, history, any will do) from the late 19th Century or early 20th Century and it is clear American public education took a very wrong turn somewhere along the line.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Sunday March 31, 2019 @01:59PM (#19537065)
Vice writers are unionized and are thus profiting from pro-union laws that allow them to undermine the contracting rights of their employer and get themselves above-market wages. Therefore the angle they choose for this article is not surprising to me.

Most of those working in the media have a major conflict of interest when writing about politics.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:17PM (#19537183)
Can you explain what you mean by contracting right?
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:23PM (#19537230)
The right to hire whoever you want at whatever terms you want to offer. Collective bargaining mandates for one violate that right. You can't offer an employment contract that doesn't obligate you as an employer to collectively bargain, meaning negotiate with a representative of a collective bargaining unit to the exclusion of all other parties, in the event that a majority of workers in a work unit unionize and demand it.

Anything the press commonly defines as a "labor right" is really a restriction on the employer's right to freely contract.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by hedora on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:40PM (#19537842)
> The right to hire whoever you want at whatever terms you want to offer.

You are describing the right to own slaves, except that current US law provides slaves with significantly more legal protection than you propose, and the thirteenth amendment limits slavery to criminals.

I feel like this should go without saying, but the article is about illegal strikes, and you seem to be advocating for more aggressive enforcement of anti-work-stop laws.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:16PM (#19540139)
Making an offer that another person is free to accept or reject has no resemblance to slavery. This kind of inflammatory mischaracterization of what a free market is is unfortunately very common now that millions depend on the rent-seeking that anti-contract-freedom laws enable unionized workers to engage in.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:37PM (#19538202)
I see what you are saying; however, I think those restrictions are often necessary due to to the dramatic difference in power between a corporation and an individual employee.

Since most people do not have the opportunity to support themselves anymore (because they cannot afford farmland or the capital to start their own business), for most people working for someone else is no longer voluntary. Therefore, I think those people must have the right to negotiate fair* working conditions with their employer.

* I realize that the exact definition of what constitutes fair is going to differ between different people and political views. However, I think there are general principles that most people can agree on such as making enough to provide for ones family, a safe work environment, being treated with respect by the employer, and work hours that allow the employee to participate in other aspects of life.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by tropo on Sunday March 31, 2019 @08:09PM (#19539342)
No, "fair" is more like a lack of fraud or coercion. It means that you get what you can manage without those, which is generally the market rate. You may be able to trade off pay, safety, respect, and hours. (give up some of one to get more of another) The deal you get comes from the value you bring. Getting more than your share, for example by coercion against the employer or by defrauding the employer, is definitely not fair.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @08:40AM (#19553390)
I definitely agree that it is legitimate for an individual to trade off certain benefits of a job for others. I think the issue arrises when they either do not have the opportunity to actually make that decision (e.g. if all of the jobs they are able to get lack one of those traits) or if the overall split of benefits between the employer and employee is skewed (e.g. the business becomes more profitable but the increase in profit is not split with the employees).
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by tropo on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @04:19PM (#19558168)
Employees get their wages. They must be paid the market rate no matter if the business is profitable or not. If they aren't paid that, they leave. The business can't force employees to stay and work for less, even if the business is losing money. If the business had to share profit, then it would only be fair that it gets to share losses, forcing employees to stay and work like slaves... but we don't find that to be acceptable.

Profit is the dream that drives entrepreneurs to take crazy risks to start businesses. Without that, they would not try, and jobs would not get created.

There is some justification for keeping the profit from getting extreme, to keep customers from being hit with abusive monopoly pricing. The least harmful way to do this is by enforcing the existence of competition, breaking up any business that gains excessive market share. One could draw the line at 15% for example, splitting any business with a greater market share. Another possibility is to persuade businesses to split themselves, perhaps via taxes based on market share. A danger is that innovation slows due to businesses avoiding hitting the market share limit.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:17AM (#19569521)
>>There is some justification for keeping the profit from getting extreme, to keep customers from being hit with abusive monopoly pricing.

Another option is for the state to directly fund open-source software in sectors prone to monopolization. Then there will be competition, and if the open source software wins out and becomes the market standard, no profit gouging.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:22PM (#19540196)
Workers as a whole don't get more from having employers forced to offer above-market wages to their workers.

Employers as a whole have a certain amount that they can afford to spend on labor expenses. Forcing them to spend more on that, or divide that spending between a fewer number of workers to pay each a higher wage, does not raise aggregate wages in the long run.

The former does in the short run, but it comes at the expense of lower capital investment, which results in less company/productivity growth, and smaller future wage gains. The split between labor expenditure, or profit from selling services, and company profits, or profit from delaying compensation and personal consumption to found and invest in companies, has some optimal ratio that maximizes growth in productivity. The aggregate of all interactions of a free market will approach that optimal ratio as a result of the pursuit of profit aligning with the outcome of raising total productivity, while mandates to reduce company profits to raise wages won't. And growth in productivity is the source of almost all wage growth, and is the only sustainable source of wage growth. Sacrificing it is a huge strategic mistake for public welfare.

As for the latter - hiring fewer workers and paying each more - it provides no short term net boost to wages, because the higher per worker compensation is neutralized by fewer workers being hired, and it reduces company performance, and with it, growth in GDP output and future labor expenditures.

As for fairness, the only fair outcome is that both parties are free to accept or reject what the other offers. A fair wage is what the worker's service is actually worth based on supply and demand. Anything else is just some ideological judgment.

It is unfair to use the threat of imprisonment to restrict someone from making an offer in the market. Force should always be used as a last resort, to punish and deter others from violating people's rights, and not as a policy tool to shape consensual human interaction and engineer some ideologically desired social outcome. The use of force means the imprisonment of those who do not comply. This is not a power that should be used against behaviour that is not unambigiously a violation of another party's rights.

>>for most people working for someone else is no longer voluntary

We must work to live. That is the nature of the world. It doesn't mean making an offer in the market, that others are free to accept if it is better than the next best offer they can find, is an act of coercion. Therefore there is no moral justification for prohibiting people from making offers that don't meet some arbitrary minimum standard. It's only ideology, that is designed to rationalize exerting totalitarian control over others, that says otherwise.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @08:35AM (#19553354)
My argument is that the unfairness comes from the fact that some people are able to make money off of natural resources (e.g. land) that they did not create or (in many cases) earn and are able to exclude others from doing so. This then leads to a situation in which many people do not have access to natural resources with which to make their own living and therefore their only choice is to work for people who do have those resources. In that sense their state of being employed by others instead of themselves is not voluntary.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @09:55AM (#19554075)
>>This then leads to a situation in which many people do not have access to natural resources with which to make their own living and therefore their only choice is to work for people who do have those resources. In that sense their state of being employed by others instead of themselves is not voluntary.

People would have to work even if all land was divided equally across all people.

Furthermore, there's no fundamental reason why every person born deserves to share equally in all natural resources. The act of being born does not add value to the world. A family can have 10 children per generation and massively increase the share of natural resources they control under your moral code.

Finally, even if someone's share of natural resources is unfairly small, it doesn't follow that the person offering a job is violating their rights by offering one that doesn't meet some minimum standard.

If you want to make a case that someone is being unfairly denied natural resources, then that should be the issue dealt with, by gathering evidence and proving the case in a court of law. The alleged injustuce shouldn't be used as a flimsy excuse to restrict other people's rights.