News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Sunday March 31, 2019 @02:23PM (#19537230)
The right to hire whoever you want at whatever terms you want to offer. Collective bargaining mandates for one violate that right. You can't offer an employment contract that doesn't obligate you as an employer to collectively bargain, meaning negotiate with a representative of a collective bargaining unit to the exclusion of all other parties, in the event that a majority of workers in a work unit unionize and demand it.

Anything the press commonly defines as a "labor right" is really a restriction on the employer's right to freely contract.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by hedora on Sunday March 31, 2019 @03:40PM (#19537842)
> The right to hire whoever you want at whatever terms you want to offer.

You are describing the right to own slaves, except that current US law provides slaves with significantly more legal protection than you propose, and the thirteenth amendment limits slavery to criminals.

I feel like this should go without saying, but the article is about illegal strikes, and you seem to be advocating for more aggressive enforcement of anti-work-stop laws.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:16PM (#19540139)
Making an offer that another person is free to accept or reject has no resemblance to slavery. This kind of inflammatory mischaracterization of what a free market is is unfortunately very common now that millions depend on the rent-seeking that anti-contract-freedom laws enable unionized workers to engage in.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Sunday March 31, 2019 @04:37PM (#19538202)
I see what you are saying; however, I think those restrictions are often necessary due to to the dramatic difference in power between a corporation and an individual employee.

Since most people do not have the opportunity to support themselves anymore (because they cannot afford farmland or the capital to start their own business), for most people working for someone else is no longer voluntary. Therefore, I think those people must have the right to negotiate fair* working conditions with their employer.

* I realize that the exact definition of what constitutes fair is going to differ between different people and political views. However, I think there are general principles that most people can agree on such as making enough to provide for ones family, a safe work environment, being treated with respect by the employer, and work hours that allow the employee to participate in other aspects of life.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by tropo on Sunday March 31, 2019 @08:09PM (#19539342)
No, "fair" is more like a lack of fraud or coercion. It means that you get what you can manage without those, which is generally the market rate. You may be able to trade off pay, safety, respect, and hours. (give up some of one to get more of another) The deal you get comes from the value you bring. Getting more than your share, for example by coercion against the employer or by defrauding the employer, is definitely not fair.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @08:40AM (#19553390)
I definitely agree that it is legitimate for an individual to trade off certain benefits of a job for others. I think the issue arrises when they either do not have the opportunity to actually make that decision (e.g. if all of the jobs they are able to get lack one of those traits) or if the overall split of benefits between the employer and employee is skewed (e.g. the business becomes more profitable but the increase in profit is not split with the employees).
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by tropo on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @04:19PM (#19558168)
Employees get their wages. They must be paid the market rate no matter if the business is profitable or not. If they aren't paid that, they leave. The business can't force employees to stay and work for less, even if the business is losing money. If the business had to share profit, then it would only be fair that it gets to share losses, forcing employees to stay and work like slaves... but we don't find that to be acceptable.

Profit is the dream that drives entrepreneurs to take crazy risks to start businesses. Without that, they would not try, and jobs would not get created.

There is some justification for keeping the profit from getting extreme, to keep customers from being hit with abusive monopoly pricing. The least harmful way to do this is by enforcing the existence of competition, breaking up any business that gains excessive market share. One could draw the line at 15% for example, splitting any business with a greater market share. Another possibility is to persuade businesses to split themselves, perhaps via taxes based on market share. A danger is that innovation slows due to businesses avoiding hitting the market share limit.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Thursday April 04, 2019 @01:17AM (#19569521)
>>There is some justification for keeping the profit from getting extreme, to keep customers from being hit with abusive monopoly pricing.

Another option is for the state to directly fund open-source software in sectors prone to monopolization. Then there will be competition, and if the open source software wins out and becomes the market standard, no profit gouging.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Sunday March 31, 2019 @11:22PM (#19540196)
Workers as a whole don't get more from having employers forced to offer above-market wages to their workers.

Employers as a whole have a certain amount that they can afford to spend on labor expenses. Forcing them to spend more on that, or divide that spending between a fewer number of workers to pay each a higher wage, does not raise aggregate wages in the long run.

The former does in the short run, but it comes at the expense of lower capital investment, which results in less company/productivity growth, and smaller future wage gains. The split between labor expenditure, or profit from selling services, and company profits, or profit from delaying compensation and personal consumption to found and invest in companies, has some optimal ratio that maximizes growth in productivity. The aggregate of all interactions of a free market will approach that optimal ratio as a result of the pursuit of profit aligning with the outcome of raising total productivity, while mandates to reduce company profits to raise wages won't. And growth in productivity is the source of almost all wage growth, and is the only sustainable source of wage growth. Sacrificing it is a huge strategic mistake for public welfare.

As for the latter - hiring fewer workers and paying each more - it provides no short term net boost to wages, because the higher per worker compensation is neutralized by fewer workers being hired, and it reduces company performance, and with it, growth in GDP output and future labor expenditures.

As for fairness, the only fair outcome is that both parties are free to accept or reject what the other offers. A fair wage is what the worker's service is actually worth based on supply and demand. Anything else is just some ideological judgment.

It is unfair to use the threat of imprisonment to restrict someone from making an offer in the market. Force should always be used as a last resort, to punish and deter others from violating people's rights, and not as a policy tool to shape consensual human interaction and engineer some ideologically desired social outcome. The use of force means the imprisonment of those who do not comply. This is not a power that should be used against behaviour that is not unambigiously a violation of another party's rights.

>>for most people working for someone else is no longer voluntary

We must work to live. That is the nature of the world. It doesn't mean making an offer in the market, that others are free to accept if it is better than the next best offer they can find, is an act of coercion. Therefore there is no moral justification for prohibiting people from making offers that don't meet some arbitrary minimum standard. It's only ideology, that is designed to rationalize exerting totalitarian control over others, that says otherwise.

Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by harimau777 on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @08:35AM (#19553354)
My argument is that the unfairness comes from the fact that some people are able to make money off of natural resources (e.g. land) that they did not create or (in many cases) earn and are able to exclude others from doing so. This then leads to a situation in which many people do not have access to natural resources with which to make their own living and therefore their only choice is to work for people who do have those resources. In that sense their state of being employed by others instead of themselves is not voluntary.
Re:How “illegal” teacher strikes rescued the American labor ... by CryptoPunk on Tuesday April 02, 2019 @09:55AM (#19554075)
>>This then leads to a situation in which many people do not have access to natural resources with which to make their own living and therefore their only choice is to work for people who do have those resources. In that sense their state of being employed by others instead of themselves is not voluntary.

People would have to work even if all land was divided equally across all people.

Furthermore, there's no fundamental reason why every person born deserves to share equally in all natural resources. The act of being born does not add value to the world. A family can have 10 children per generation and massively increase the share of natural resources they control under your moral code.

Finally, even if someone's share of natural resources is unfairly small, it doesn't follow that the person offering a job is violating their rights by offering one that doesn't meet some minimum standard.

If you want to make a case that someone is being unfairly denied natural resources, then that should be the issue dealt with, by gathering evidence and proving the case in a court of law. The alleged injustuce shouldn't be used as a flimsy excuse to restrict other people's rights.