Case in point, look at everyone's favorite "socialist" country: Sweden. Schooling has improved significantly after privatization with a voucher system.
There is evidence that the outcome was an improvement:
https://web.archive.org/web/20130512223637/http://www.ifau.s...
Of course, there's a political debate attached to it and you will find a lot of people to frame it all differently, but the facts are clear: The private schools are superior.
https://tino.us/2011/03/on-the-swedish-voucher-system/
Sinking PISA scores in the last years is probably best explained by a lowering of standards to accommodate, among other things, for a surging population of newly-arrived immigrants.
Thanks no child left behind! Tying school funding and teacher pay to child test schools is one of the largest blunders this country has made.
You need good quality tests that aren't supplied by book publishers. Ideally you'd test anything, but if tests are unavailable for a particular subject then you have to mandate hours for that subject to keep it from disappearing. You need test security so that the teachers don't cheat.
Instead of just cutting pay, which isn't helpful, you should pay per-student and adjust the number of students per teacher. It is easy to teach a very small group, but very hard to teach a large group. Shift students from bad teachers to good teachers until the quality is equalized. Unfortunately this hits a problem with standardized classroom size. Aside from that though, it would be fine to have one teacher with 9 students and another teacher with 72 students. The teacher with 75 is getting paid 8x as much as the teacher with 9, and the students all get equal quality.
Then explain the success of schools outside of the US that have similar government based funding?
It is why tenure is a thing - what is true and right may not be popular.
They do get a reward for doing well but it is very long term - if they are successful and society could get better funding and well liked for being a success story.
The incentives aren’t aligned properly and there is no negative incentive when a school fails a generation of children. The teacher and admins will just carry on business as usual(rather monopoly) charge a higher fee and deliver a worse product.