News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by matthewfelgate on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:11AM (#19499131)
Facebook has a lot to answer for. The internet was supposed to be a new human enlightenment by enabling professionals to remotely connect. We didn't bank on the ability of idiots to connect too...
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by ckastner on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:57AM (#19499383)
> We didn't bank on the ability of idiots to connect too...

The downside of this connecting is not "just" idiots, it's the creation of echo chambers in general.

Pre-Facebook social circles only had the capability to form echo chambers when they reached a certain size, something that was greatly inhibited by the reality of the physical world.

Today, even the most irrational minds can meet and reinforce each other's beliefs without any effort at all, beyond a few mouseclicks.

Idiots are just a subset of the problem. The actual problem is people in general just having their misconceived notions reinforced, rather than having them challenged. It's the opposite of intellectual growth.

IMO, Twitter is even worse in this regard.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by dmos62 on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:03AM (#19500006)
Chomsky argued that the medium of television (this was in the pre-internet era) frames any discussion held within it on the outset, because, on it, noone can present an argument longer than 5 minutes, due to logistic reasons, which is insufficient for someone to form an adequate opinion about, and certainly insufficient to change someone's mind. In effect, he was saying that television was an echo chamber, because you'll just end up hearing what you like, all the debates being castrated of the ability to change your mind.

5 minutes. What is the twitter message character limit again?

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by asdff on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:19AM (#19501722)
This is on the nose. Even a 5 minute article is too much work, people would rather read a viral twitter screenshot or watch a talking head on youtube read that screenshot back to them.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by tomjen3 on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:17PM (#19503188)
Irrelevant.

Most posts on blogs are much longer, and some of the most listened to podcasts are hours long.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by dmos62 on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:31PM (#19506279)
This is a critique of "short-form" mediums, like TV, Twitter, Facebook, etc. This is, of course, not a critique of blogs or podcasts (or books, or essays, etc.)
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by chopin on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:21AM (#19499489)
I had a chuckle and generally I agree with you.

However I see as part of the problem that trust in experts has eroded caused by... those experts themselves. There are many accounts of matter experts turning out to be shills for a certain industry which did harm to public up to upright killing people. Look at the opioid crisis or the latest development with Boeing. How would a layperson distinguish between honest and dishonest statements?

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by geggam on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:07AM (#19500030)
Like to upvote this infinity+

Trust is gone and fear is dispensed as a culture.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by maze-le on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:21AM (#19499188)
Its a structural problem, not necessary facebooks -- if it werent for facebook, the idiots would congregate somewhere else to spread their lies. What is missing is an education in epistemology for a broad audience regardless of education level -- the ability to categorize and weight the value of knowledge and sources.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Nextgrid on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:56AM (#19499376)
Facebook is definitely an enabler for this trash. While they can indeed congregate elsewhere (like their own website or forum), people would have to explicitly seek out that “elsewhere”, where as Facebook would promote them for free thanks to their ranking algorithm.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by notacoward on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:54AM (#19499957)
> if it werent for facebook, the idiots would congregate somewhere else

I don't think that's really true. To congregate, people must first find each other. That takes a certain amount of pre-existing interest plus a certain amount of ability to find something matching that interest. Not much, but some. Now, even the most passive and stupid people - a significant demographic, unfortunately - can basically sit back and let the other crazies come to them. The same filtering/targeting tools that have been such a boon for small businesses advertising their products have also been great for every fringe group that used to rely on old fashioned street-pounding evangelism.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Confusion on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:27AM (#19499785)
No, this sentiment is very wrong. 10% of the population is functionally illiterate. Another 10% can't do basic arithmetic. Another 10% has more important things to worry about than vetting all their sources. Another 10% just can't be bothered. There are many more reasons why expecting everyone to just be able to develop the ability to critically gather and evaluate information is clearly a fantasy that can only be entertained when you don't realize how incredibly challenged people are, probably because they don't interact with any.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by maze-le on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:16AM (#19500092)
To the contrary, I think the average joe is generally more reasonable and able to develop critical thinking skills than most people think. They just don't ever get the opportunity to learn it properly. There might be a subset of the population that is actually incapable of proper reason due to cognitive deficits, but that is definitly not the majority.

This sentiment is one of the reasons anti-intellectualism is thriving at this very moment.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:32AM (#19500189)
> This sentiment is one of the reasons anti-intellectualism is thriving at this very moment.

One hell of a feedback loop that is...

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Confusion on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:49AM (#19502113)

  I think the average joe is generally more reasonable and 
  able to develop critical thinking skills than most people 
  think
You think wrong. You would like this to be the case and you let the desire cloud your judgment. It's simply not the case. The research is squarely against you.

  They just don't ever get the opportunity to learn it properly.
That's irrelevant. The point is that they never learned and cannot be expected to learn anym ore. We have to care for these people, instead of expecting them to take care of it themselves, telling them they are capable of it. Because they aren't and they don't.

  This sentiment is one of the reasons anti-intellectualism is thriving at this very moment.
This is not a sentiment: these are facts.

At least 10% of people are functionally illiterate. How are you going to teach them critical thinking skills? How are you going to get them to see the truth about e.g. vaccination? Answer: you don't. This is where we need a government, to take care of those that do not, for whatever reason, take care of themselves.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by neuronic on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:00AM (#19499399)
One problem is that financing the use of the Internet has been equated with "lets put ads everywhere".

I meet so few people who are willing to pay for most Internet sites and services. They have to deliver some great value to be able to live on paid subscriptions.

Would you pay for Facebook if all ads were gone? Or Twitter? I can barely find a use case for these services anymore. Strip it to Messenger and the event pages and that's 95% of all use cases that go beyond narcissism.

Also, I am not sure if Facebook is responsible for the observed stupidity and idiocy or if it simply reveals them...

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by unionpivo on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:34AM (#19499249)
More/better education is always good. But there will always be idiots. Look at flat earth believers (although i have hard time believing they are not just trolls).

They used to be small groups of them all over the world, and they didn't do too much damage. What social media has done is amplified their voice, giving them look of legitimacy.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by maze-le on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:00AM (#19499665)
Not only social media I might add. Traditional media also has a role to play here. They are generally more critical of these types of groups, but they also seek ever more ridiculous stories to tell, in order to get an audience -- so even a story that questions the theories of these groups but reports them as "one view among others" is problematic.

It is the structure of our media/advertising landscape that keeps nuanced but true views below the average interest and and amplifies outrageous crap, since it generates clicks and eyeballs.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by ben_w on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:18AM (#19499478)
Flat Earthers used to be a joke/insult, now it’s a serious example of how the internet has developed not necessarily to our advantage.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by AlexTWithBeard on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:19AM (#19499743)
Flat earthers are trolls, but they are very useful trolls.

They give kids great examples of things like falsifiability and scientific method.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by simonh on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:33AM (#19499822)
It may be difficult to believe but while there may be a lot of FE trolls, there are also a significant number of true believers.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Freak_NL on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:54AM (#19499956)
It's trolling taken to its logical extreme: you literally cannot tell whether someone posting flat-earth 'facts' is a troll or not online. The behaviour of the acolyte and the troll is identical.

Only when you meet these people in real life is there a fair chance of sounding them out to discover if they are just playing along or are actually convinced of whatever conspiracy is being peddled. I would expect most trolls keep their flat-earth proselytizing strictly as an online activity.

But they do seem to exist (the true believers that is).

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by AlexTWithBeard on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:21AM (#19500536)
Ah, ye goode olde Poe's law:

without a clear indicator of the author's intent, it is impossible to create a parody of extreme views... that cannot be mistaken by some readers for a sincere expression of the parodied views.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by i_feel_great on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:39AM (#19499288)
Too many forces will oppose this at every turn. The various religions and political ideologies come to mind.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by maze-le on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:33AM (#19499545)
The fact that you'll face resistance along the path should not stop you from setting the foot in front of the door. And its not an unreasonable thing to strife for. Certainly more realistic than some political demands, for which there will never be a majority consent...
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by asdff on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:26AM (#19501828)
Combating critical thinking is as old as critical thinking. Let them fight.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by asdff on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:24AM (#19501807)
Facebook brought these posts a stamp of legitimacy and concentrated all the idiocy under one URL. Pre facebook, no one trusted flatearth.com or vaccinesarebadmkay.net, because we still believed the old addage "never trust anything you read on the internet." It was a lot easier to ignore faceless people with random usernames spamming on random websites than a post from uncle Kevin, on a platform all your friends and family are using religiously.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:40AM (#19499295)
I think you mean epidemiology.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by maze-le on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:31AM (#19499533)
Nope, but this would also be a good idea in this context.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemology

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by saagarjha on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:23AM (#19499199)
Facebook has certain been a vehicle for the spread of misinformation, but I'm not completely sure that they should answer for it. Having Facebook control what information is "true" sounds awfully dystopian.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by krapp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:35AM (#19499252)
>Having Facebook control what information is "true" sounds awfully dystopian.

But that's exactly what Facebook already does. How would attempting to minimize the spread of disinformation be any more dystopian than optimizing it for maximum utility?

For that matter, why, in these threads, is it only ever a slippery slope to attempt to counter misinformation, but never such to let it spread unchecked and be weaponized by any interest capable of doing so?

Facebook never was, nor ever claimed to be, a neutral arbiter. Their entire business model depends on distorting the truth, which arguably implies some degree of social responsibility on their part.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by dpq on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:36AM (#19499259)
Choose your poison then. Either we let idiots run loose and we are definitely screwed, or we empower some individuals and companies to control and govern communications etc, and then MAYBE we're screwed if we pick the wrong ones.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by samdoidge on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:10AM (#19499441)
>or we empower some individuals and companies to control and govern communications etc

We've been down this route in several countries during the 20th century and it doesn't pan out well.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by ben_w on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:20AM (#19499482)
Every nation did this until the internet. Those companies were collectively called “the press” in the western world.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by prawn on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:05AM (#19500013)
Which kinda worked until the press worked out that favouring contentious topics and maintaining two viewpoints was more profitable.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by simonh on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:14AM (#19500078)
You’re really going to throw the press in Britain, along with independent anti-establishment papers like Socialist Worker and Marxism Today alongside the Times and the Guardian, into the same bucket as that of Soviet Russia, Maoist China and North Korea?
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by ben_w on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:32AM (#19501908)
Given my point is that you don’t need to be a dictatorship to do it, yes.

Not that being free from government influence frees you from the political preferences of your owner, as this recent non-sequitur headline from the Express should demonstrate: “EU BLACKMAIL: Brussels threatens FOOD AID to UK in 'last throw of dice of Project Fear'”.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by dpq on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:34AM (#19499553)
Like I said, we're probably screwed anyway.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:50PM (#19502894)
If we empower some individuals and companies to control and govern communications, we might be okay if we picked the right ones. The problem is, they have to continue to be the right ones, basically forever. That... won't happen. People retire and get replaced; people get corrupted by power; people see what they could do with power and put themselves in place to be the one to replace someone who's going to retire.

There is nobody - no person and no organization - who it's safe to trust with that kind of power.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by saagarjha on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:09AM (#19499438)
Can we perhaps come up with solutions in which we have fewer idiots, or have barriers against the rapid spread of unverifiable information in general?
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by dpq on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:33AM (#19499542)
> solutions in which we have fewer idiots

Not unless you are willing to avadakedavra them all, and this avenue is also wide open for abuse, as you may imagine

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by saagarjha on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:00PM (#19505977)
I was hoping for solutions more along the lines of education than “killing the idiots”…
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by jemurray on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:25AM (#19499773)
In a democratic society you don’t control, you elect strong leaders who guide and mentor the people to the positions that are best for society as a whole. We build a culture that believes in reason, science, humanitarianism, and progress. Then we work on spreading this culture and belief to others around us every opportunity we have.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by manigandham on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @03:39PM (#19505082)
The problem is democracy is about popularity, not reason. Most people do not elect the "best" leaders. We are very far away from that ever happening, regardless of culture.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by raxxorrax on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:49AM (#19499922)
The thing is that this outbreak isn't serious. At all. Nor do anti-vaxxers pose a significant threat. At all.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by notacoward on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:58AM (#19499975)
> The thing is that this outbreak isn't serious.

Every fucking outbreak is serious. Please learn something about epidemiology, and about measles in particular. I've been involved in tracking an outbreak, and have (separately) known people who were seriously harmed by measles. Dismissing any outbreak as "not serious" is truly sociopathic.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by saiya-jin on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:36AM (#19499262)
Well dystopian or not, we either have some form of control, or not and end up where we are now. With great power comes great responsibility and all that.

FB failed on so many basic moral expectations that I have 0 sympathy for that company, and IMHO yes, their purely for-profit product is definitely responsible for the content it provides.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by saagarjha on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:05AM (#19499417)
> FB failed on so many basic moral expectations that I have 0 sympathy for that company

Oh, for sure. But I’m cautious of instituting a blanket policy here that could end up being applied in other contexts where it may end up doing harm.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by yakshaving_jgt on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:05AM (#19499419)
There are certain topics that are verboten in almost all of society. The obvious example here would be an invocation of Godwin's Law. We can all keep an open mind and have hypothetical, Devil's Advocate discussions, but nobody can seriously say "Hmm… Maybe systematically slaughtering Jewish people was the right thing to do".

Given that diseases have killed more people than the Nazis ever did, I don't think it's unreasonable to make that analogy.

I'm absolutely an advocate for free speech, but I am also in support of Amazon's recent move to pull any material pushing the fraudulent vaccine/autism link claim.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Lambdanaut on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:13AM (#19499719)
> I'm absolutely an advocate for free speech

You're also an advocate for the removal of free speech. Let's just be clear.

You can be both, depending on the situation. You are both. Many people here are both.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by orbifold on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:43AM (#19499885)
Facebook should be treated like a publisher and be held responsible for any and all content it disseminates. If someone wants to publish something there publicly (visible to more than let’s say 50 people) it should have to be reviewed. This is what for example tagesschau.de does with every comment.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by threatofrain on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:37AM (#19499846)
If people think I can destroy citizens' voting power and their ability to think and make them endanger kids because of things people voluntarily share over Facebook, what do we say about how much we respect that vote and voter? And what are we saying about what we think Facebook's role should be in this, potentially as a guardian against our destructive and irresistible instincts?

People, both as individuals and communities, also need to have some responsibility over their own willpower, their own souls, their own minds, their own clarity, their own grasp, their own sense of reality. Or else how do we believe in the true heart of democracy -- the citizen and their worthy mind, a mind of ideas worthy of community negotiation and leadership?

Somewhere else people are condemning Google for not showing people the objective truth, and instead giving you what you want to search. Like it's Google's responsibility to regulate you against your own risk for delusion. If people think citizens are that weak then how do you trust the value of their intellect?

Are voters one Facebook network away from losing their trustworthiness as citizens in a democracy?

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by tibbydudeza on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:17AM (#19499170)
Well you can't blame them for the sheer stupidity and idiocy that is now celebrated in our culture today.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by headmelted on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:45AM (#19499325)
It astonishes me still how much of a free ride Google gets.

The public consciousness of Facebook now is such that they're viewed as a pretty malevolent entity in general, but no-one questions the harm that Google's ranking algorithms have done to society.

Most people still believe that when they type a search into Google they're asking for objective results on a topic.

(What it actually shows is the results it thinks the person asking the question wants to see, which is wildly different person-to-person, but presented as objective truth to the user).

This audience knows that because we're deep in the industry, but Joe Public has no idea that Google works this way.

Of course he thinks his own crazy ideas are true and shared by the majority. Google told him so (as he sees it).

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by tuxxy on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:16AM (#19499468)
I would put money on the outcome of some research (with "harm" being well defined) that Facebook has caused more harm than Google's ranking algorithms.

Facebook has constructed a business model on captivating people to spend _as much time as possible_ on their site. Google's search engine does no such thing.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by ModernMech on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:31AM (#19499809)
But Google sure does spend enough time trying to be in every aspect of your life. They want to be your search engine, and your phone, and your TV (you tube), and your music service, and your voice assistant, and your watch, and your calendar, and your email, and your office, and your car, etc. etc.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:42AM (#19499879)
Maybe so, but that has no bearing on the economic incentives that make google search and facebook different, which was the parent's point.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by ModernMech on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:38AM (#19500682)
I disagree. Google and Facebook have the same exact business model -- learn as much about you and use that data to sell ads. All of the Google products I listed above are funded by ad revenue. Facebook executes their model by keeping you on one site, while Google executes theirs by being pervasive in your life. They are two sides of the same coin. Since they face the same economic incentives, they have similar pathologies.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:54AM (#19499953)
How do the incentives for Facebook and Youtube differ?

From my perspective, they are exactly the same, but I'd be interested to know the thoughts of others.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:06AM (#19500029)
I don't think they are that different, and I think youtube is also problematic in similar ways to facebook. But, this thread from the start was specifically talking about google search and its impact compared to facebook.

I also think there are differences (youtube has some value that isn't predicated entirely on being a social network), but the distinctions are debatable and opinions will vary.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Retric on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:19AM (#19500111)
Facebook does not pay for content the way that YouTube does. This creates very different economic incentives.

Facebook needs to realy on content from people pushing an agenda. YouTube gets content from people directly trying to make money.

Net result, it’s easy to find many videos for home repair or learning Calculus on YouTube, not so easy on Facebook.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by ModernMech on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:55AM (#19500807)
I think this fact makes Youtube even worse than Facebook. Let's say you are an idiot with an audience for your idiocy (e.g. anti-vaxers). YouTube is happy to pay you to create idiotic content for your audience. They will even promote your idiotic content across their site if you get enough clicks. What's more is they will cross promote your content with similarly idiotically minded people and lock them in a content bubble that increases clicks and views. The worst part is, for every view of your idiotic content, Google makes a profit, and you do too, so they get to keep hosting your nonsense, and you can make a living creating it. This was all fine and dandy when the context was home repair, but shift the context to idiotic conspiracies and we have an issue that is moving from the confines of the Internet to a public health nightmare.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Retric on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:19AM (#19501720)
Yet, YouTube does not have an incentive to promote ignorance over cat videos. Facebooks’s model is so broken they are paying for “please come back” advertising. They could have focused on connecting people, but spreading ignorance and rage was simply more profitable.

Cars may do more evil by killing people than most things, but they are not nessisarily more evil becase they also provide a lot of utility. FB unlike YT has no such excuse.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by krapp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:52AM (#19499352)
>The public consciousness of Facebook now is such that they're viewed as a pretty malevolent entity in general

The general public doesn't consider Facebook as being even remotely malevolent. I think you're confusing the views within the HN/tech bubble for the mainstream.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by headmelted on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:03AM (#19499406)
I disagree, but the best evidence I can find falls somewhere in the middle:

https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/6/16976328/facebook-mark-zuc...

Facebook hired a pollster to survey opinion about them.

32% of respondents in one survey said they're harming society, while only 7% said the same of Google.

I would suggest this difference is largely because the public doesn't understand how Google works, and believe it is as described above.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by threatofrain on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:47AM (#19499907)
When is the American voter responsible for the quality of their clarity or their grasp on reality? Or should Facebook and Google be more in that business?

How do we have faith in the notion of citizen communal leadership if we think people can't handle Google giving you what you want? How much faith do we have when we think the members of our community aren't trustworthy as vanguards of clarity, so we want Facebook to step in and judge what counts as dangerous delusion?

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:54AM (#19499955)
Facebook is already making these decisions today with the algorithmic feed. They're already stepping in and deciding what people should see and what people should not see. It's stupid to pretend that the status quo is some hands-off natural state of the world, and get upset at the suggestion that the way this is already being done should change.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by threatofrain on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:28AM (#19500161)
If you can't trust people to understand that Facebook promoting the post of a peer in your network, which you curated, isn't as popular as you think it is (Facebook doesn't generate content; the people you accept do)...

What does that say about what we think of their judgment capabilities, and whether they can take on a more serious democratic challenge like a policy debate on Brexit, or the Californian initiative process? I view the judgment necessary for Brexit or other public policy as more than a magnitude harder than judging whether peers or posts in your network are as popular as Facebook wants you to think.

Your response again makes me ask whether we have esteem for the clarity of our peers. Is there even faith that people can manage their own click?

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:51AM (#19500302)
It's hard to argue against this point without looking like an asshole.

But no, I have little faith that many people (including at least one family member) can handle the firehose of bullshit from facebook. I have one family member that was always anti-vaccine, but it was not really an issue until she got on facebook. The degree of radicalization she has now reached is intense, and I pretty directly blame facebook for this. Her sub-network of friends that post about this regularly did not exist before facebook.

There are many firehoses of bullshit, but facebook is a singular example that has connected enough people to it via people they already trust that it seems to be having a real impact on the world's decision making abilities.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by headmelted on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:59AM (#19499986)
This would be a valid point if we were talking about Google/Facebook/whoever giving people what they want or not.

The question I raised is whether not people understand that this is what's happening. It's not explained at all to a user who visits the homepage, hence people believe Google is providing objective truths, when in reality they're not even attempting to.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by threatofrain on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:06AM (#19500025)
You're still feeding into my point about whether or not you trust your fellow peers to be agents of esteem and clarity in an activity of citizen communal leadership (democracy). Do you have esteem for your peers?

If they can't get past this information judgment activity (Britney Spears isn't popular just because YouTube shows me), what happens when a more serious intellectual challenge comes along? Like Brexit?

Does the slightest wind blow away the faith you have in the judgment of your peers?

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by headmelted on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:21AM (#19500117)
You and I agree that we're responsible for our own critical thinking, but the average person accepts as reality that Google is black and white with regards to facts (even though that is clearly not possible).

That's not in itself on Google, but as democratic whims over the last few years have shown, the lack of awareness is having out-sized effects on all of us that still isn't being talked about.

Social media may not be actively seeding viral nonsense, but it sure is making bank selling the petri dishes.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:24AM (#19500139)
The American voter is under attack by entities seeking to confuse, mislead, and misinform him or her for their own profit and power. Isolated from reasonable or normative thought, uneducated in the mechanisms attacking their thought, and indoctrinated in these lies as cultural, social, and even patriotic standards to be upheld and identified with, we can hardly be expected to break this crushing mold and make choices with clarity and rational thinking.

The first step, when one is able to temporarily rise above this suffocating morass, is to cry out that it must be torn down. Reform the first-past-the-post voting systems that generate and enforce an extremist 2-party system, stop powerful and wealthy entities from buying their own rules through lobbying and regulatory capture, adapt rules that were written without a concept for what they would mean in a world with broadcasting and instant copying of information, recognize that harmful externalities are not corrected by an irrational purely capitalistic economy...the list of injustices is long and reasonably obvious, from the outside. Tragically, though, these goals are next to impossible to achieve without a critical mass that the systems are actively repressing.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by TorKlingberg on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:22AM (#19499492)
Google Search has done an ok job ranking search results. Not perfect, but it's not an easy problem. YouTube's recommendation algorithm on the other hand seems to push all kinds of garbage.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by headmelted on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:04AM (#19500008)
The quality of the algorithm isn't the point.

Say the algorithm worked 100% perfectly, 100% of the time.

Joe believes the algorithm is engineered to answer his queries with facts. It's not.

It's engineered to show Joe what other people that think like Joe (based on profiling he is unaware of) have clicked on in the past, in the hopes Joe will click more and generate ad revenue.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by asdff on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:31AM (#19501902)
You gotta fight with it with operators if you want a useful search. Google loves to remove useful operators or hit you with captcha challenges if you are using operators too much.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by bluedino on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:48AM (#19499917)
It's terrible. The first two pages of results for many searches are just blogspam and aggreggated information
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:35AM (#19499555)
> (What it actually shows is the results it thinks the person asking the question wants to see, which is wildly different person-to-person, but presented as objective truth to the user).

I don't think this is anywhere near as significant a problem as you suggest. I just tried a few incognito vs. not incognito searches of various conspiracy theories that have become much more visibly popular in the last few years. I saw little significant difference between incognito mode and not, and most of the results are about why the particular conspiracy theory is bullshit.

In contrast, it's a small sample size, but I've seen first hand a small number of friends (and one family member) become much more extremist anti-vaccine crusaders, and the primary vehicle for me seeing this is facebook.

I think youtube is much closer to having these kinds of problems than google search, but youtube is also a lot closer to being "social media", which is the general problem, not facebook in particular. Facebook is just far and away the biggest and most influential.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by cheschire on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:19AM (#19499744)
I'm interested in hearing if you get different results by using TOR browser instead.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by headmelted on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:12AM (#19500065)
Couple of things.

You'd need to check with Tor for a fair comparison to rule out geographic/workplace affinity.

also..

Your starting perspective governs the search term. I'm confident vaccines are safe overall - so I'll search for "are vaccines safe?" (positive connotation). Someone who believes that vaccines are causing brain damage has already formed a contrary opinion, so in all likelihood would be expected to search for "vaccines cause autism" (negative connotation). The question is the same, but it's been presented differently, and Google will respond to the question asked.

Believe it or not, I'm not actually blaming Google for this. In essence, it's still trying to answer the question asked, but I think we need to seriously reassess what the heck we're doing and maybe launch public awareness campaigns about how this all works at a fundamental level.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:21AM (#19500120)
> Someone who believes that vaccines are causing brain damage has already formed a contrary opinion, so in all likelihood would be expected to search for "vaccines cause autism" (negative connotation).

I understand this, in fact, "vaccines cause autism" was exactly one of my test searches.

As for Tor: I don't have it and I'm not going to bother. And if nothing else, my region is a well known hotspot for anti-vaccine idiocy, so I would expect that to bias the test in favor of the filter bubble hypothesis, not against it.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by headmelted on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:26AM (#19500148)
^^ This makes me feel better, believe it or not.

I still think an Internet search / social media PSA campaign is urgently needed.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:56AM (#19500345)
> ^^ This makes me feel better, believe it or not.

Frankly, why trust me? Why not try this yourself? I wish no one would trust random commenters on any social media, whether it be facebook or hackernews.

I'd rather you not trust me, I only spent 5 minutes on it. For someone such as yourself with such a strong opinion on the topic, I think it is worth spending a bit more time on it. This is one of those rare issues where if you think there's a problem, it's not hard to check for yourself.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by headmelted on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:59AM (#19502238)
I have, insofar as searching from my own connection in multiple incognito windows - but as we've said that tells me nothing.

I'm not going to download Tor because honestly I don't want my ISP thinking I'm up to no good (paranoid and ridiculous as I realize that is).

Totally agree otherwise on trust not being a substitute for critical thinking and applied reason, and yes, it's the biggest problem of all of this.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:18AM (#19499177)
Facebook has nothing to answer for, unless you think facilitating communication with others endows them with the responsibility to monitor and police all communications.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by AnthonBerg on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:28AM (#19499226)
I see a moral obligation that they use part of the shit ton of money they made to help solve the problems. Endowing them with policing responsibility is a false dilemma. There are other things to do: It’s a question of education, not policing.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:55AM (#19499372)
Educating the public isn’t Facebook’s job, that’s the government’s job (and by proxy, our job as voters and members of society) to ensure we educate our children and neighbors and promote research.

Unfortunately, it seems that people aren’t capable properly of wielding the power democracy gives them.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by AnthonBerg on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:16AM (#19500093)
It’s kind of hard to claim that something is some entity’s job, or not.

It is “not their job” as in it is unreasonable to expect Facebook to start educating its users out of the blue. However, it’s easy to argue that it’s better for Facebook’s bottom line in many respects if their user base is more effective at navigating life and surviving.

And also, it can be made their job if we so desire.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by raxxorrax on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:39AM (#19499857)
In a way, that is still shooting the messenger. Or the messengers car to be more exact.

Facebook just mirrors society at large. At least those parts, that would use it in such a way in the first place.

Unfortunately, I don't think moral obligations apply to our current economic system.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Gatsky on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:13AM (#19499454)
Yes. Society lets corps get away with blue murder. We let them make huge amounts of money, at our expense:

Tobacco companies Weapon makers Oil companies

And they all sponsor powerful lobbies to screw up things even more, which we also allow. The EU fines google for the order that links appear on a page, but they let tobacco companies kill people at our expense free of charge.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by hackerbabz on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:20AM (#19499186)
They created a product that is making the world worse. I want them to answer for that just like I want cigarette and oil companies to answer for their products that make the world worse.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:23AM (#19499198)
They created a product which allows people to stay in touch and communicate and organize with others. I can fix things with a screwdriver, or I can hurt someone. I can run over someone with a car, or I can use it to go to work.

Things have pros and cons, and when the cons outweigh the pros perhaps action must be taken. But in this case, the people spreading the disinformation are to blame.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Broken_Hippo on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:31AM (#19499234)
But this isn't like that. This is like seeing a road hazard that will hurt other people, but instead of doing anything about it - not even calling someone else to take care of it - you just ignore it and drive the other way.

Seriously, they will punish an account for a nipple and do it even faster for frontal nudity, and it doesn't matter how tasteful the art is. They refuse adverts if they show "too much skin" (uncovered shoulders hinting at possible nudity). I'm pretty sure they can take these sorts of posts and pages down - or at least work towards taking them down.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by hackerbabz on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:21AM (#19499486)
Except it's more like building the road hazard yourself and blaming people for crashing into it.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:53AM (#19499360)
That’s their perogative for doing what’s good for their ad business. The real responsibility is with holding our leaders responsible for promoting the funding, transparency, and credibility of organizations such as the FDA and CDC, and educating people in the scientific method in general.

Instead we elect people who demean the very scientists working hard to protect our society.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Broken_Hippo on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:58AM (#19499657)
Now, I do agree that part of the responsibility is holding our leaders responsible, and it saddens me that we elect in such a way.

This doesn't excuse facebook, however. This isn't just their ad business I'm speaking of - I was merely pointing out that suggestive paintings are too much. Pointing out they punish artists that paint tasteful nudes. Historical photos are a grey area, and it has taken heads of states speaking out for those to be reinstated.

These are merely normal people's posts.

Yet allowing posts that harm others and entire groups that do the same? Yup, allowed. Because they choose to allow such posts, they share responsibility. They choose to turn a blind eye to anti-vax groups and the like.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by _Schizotypy on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:18AM (#19500106)
This is interesting to me, historical semi nude portraits are okay but recent ones are not? So old things are accepting? What does age matter, I don't see it making that much of a difference in reality
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Broken_Hippo on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:36AM (#19500663)
Soemtimes historical semi-nudes are OK, and sometimes new ones are. Sometimes, however, they are not. Folks have a lot of trouble trying to tell what will get them kicked from facebook.

As far as photos are concerned, age and "famous" do, indeed, matter. The "napalm girl" picture was banned for nudity - even when a head of state sent it out. Facebook said it would allow "historically important" works, but it still lies in a grey area. I highly doubt a new work of equal cultural importance could be posted today.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by nobatron on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:39AM (#19499284)
They allow ads targetted towards people with antivax and other conspiracy beliefs. I think they're looking to change this but they definitely aren't innocent in this.

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/feb/15/facebook-...

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by jquery on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:35AM (#19499829)
This is occurring mainly because of an offline distribution in the Orthodox Jewish community[1], if this source is correct. Facebook has nothing to answer for when people are hand-distributing a pamphlet, and overworked doctors refuse to talk to mothers concerned about vaccines. Coming down hard on communities (via laws about what can be discussed online) can backfire, the cure is sometimes worse than the disease, and yes, people will die if you don’t crack down, but that’s the price of freedom of speech and association. Why are you blaming Facebook instead of Orthodox Judaism? Because they are an easier or bigger target? And what happens when the “do-gooders” get a taste of power and start cracking down on other talk they don’t like? Be careful wishing for the secular equivalent of blasphemy laws! The slippery slope may be a logical fallacy but it’s often a good rule of thumb for reasoning about hard topics. Proceed with caution.

http://gothamist.com/2019/03/26/orthodox_jewish_nurses_vacci...

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by intended on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:44AM (#19499595)
No one knew what they are doing - remember “wisdom of the crowds”? Cynics and other cultures thought this was a pipe dream.

But man, did it work at the start. We all had hopes for the future.

And for that bright moment, we do have the Silicon Valley of yore to thank.

However, what’s not forgiveable is staying in the dark and not adapting.

Especially if you land up on HN, Where pivot is a verb, mantra and well respected course of action.

————

Here’s what i postulate -

Any sufficiently large network is a proxy for the underlying state of the population.

At humanity scale this means that commerce is optimized, but then this (through attention farming) exacerbates human fault lines.

It means that anonymity will always be misused by criminals and revolutionaries.

As a result, there will always be a centralizing tendency that begins to apply on large networks. Only small inconsequential networks can avoid this.

(Central tendency as in - government oversight and force to order chaotic activity online,)

Any tool built must always play on this divide - increasing transparency and central control vs increasing anonymity and increasing the are of illegal behavior.

—————-

Most of this would be solved if print media were still a viable business.

We generate tons of data, and content, sifting through it is impossible.

But teams of editors and reliable news papers could once upon a time, do that. However it seems the information industry is suited for centralized, agenda dominated firms.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by imglorp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:58AM (#19499976)
There's very much an individual aspect here--identifying with and following the various tribes.

We are literally witnessing a self-selecting Darwin event here. The vaccinated tribes will live longer than the unvaccinated ones.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by gowld on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:28AM (#19500160)
That faux science helps no one. As bad as communicable diseases are, anti vax segments won't wipe out the whole population. And these "tribes" are flexible since they are based in psychology not firm genetics. They aren't fish who die when the lake dries up.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by imglorp on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:25AM (#19500566)
I was merely pointing out the causal relation of vaccination vs life expectancy. Do we agree so far? Doesn't that mean there will be a higher proportion of vaccinated to unvaccinated people over time, because math?
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by Spooky23 on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:08AM (#19500039)
It does, but not in this case.

Rockland county is home to a large ultra-conservative religious community that is extremely insular and uses local scale to control the civil institutions of their local government. (Village, school district, etc) Members of the community have limited access to outside media and certainly not Facebook.

In this case, the leaders of the communita took a stance for reasons I do not know. Sheep do what the shepards want.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by baybal2 on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:20AM (#19500114)
> Facebook has a lot to answer for. The internet was supposed to be a new human enlightenment by enabling professionals to remotely connect. We didn't bank on the ability of idiots to connect too...

Cheap printing presses were a wonderful idea, but just one of first major application happened was printing books about the "jew/catholic/arab burning."

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by azernik on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:22AM (#19499490)
This is the ultra-Orthodox Jewish community, where people aren't on the internet so much. Lots of this same misinformation is instead being distributed by print: http://gothamist.com/2019/03/26/orthodox_jewish_nurses_vacci...

The publications are funded by these bozos: https://www.nvic.org

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by cpr on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @04:21PM (#19505606)
...where "idiots" here means "people who aren't as enlightened as we are."

C'mon, if you go with an open mind into the serious problems with vaccination safety, you come away with serious questions. As least I do, and I'm part of the usual Ivy-educated CS crowd around here...

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by sarcasmOrTears on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:00AM (#19499397)
Why people should trust pharma companies considering all the scandals and dick moves? I think we just lost patience and antivaxxers are kinda over-reacting. This is not a problem with misinformation, it's a problem with trust. Patients are always disinformed and act when disinformed wheter they choose to vaccinate or not. Creating and mantaining trust therefore is the main issue.

Edit: gonna specify that I'm in favor of vaccines otherwise some won't read the message and think this is an anti-vaxx post

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:08AM (#19499429)
> Why people should trust pharma companies considering all the scandals and dick moves?

We shouldn’t! We should trust a medicine once they’ve published peer-reviewed papers, cleared multiple national efficiency and safety clinical trial standards, been universally recognised by medical professionals as a prudent personal and publish health measure and can look back on decades of evidence that pretty much points one way. When parents can’t weigh that evidence against some hocus pocus sense of unease, they should be liable for the costs of their decisions.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by sarcasmOrTears on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @06:49AM (#19499612)
People don't have the tools or the time to understand all this stuff. It's all about trust, good reputation. The only way governments and pharmas have been able to deal with loss of reputation is by trying to ridicule worried people, or persecuting them for a choice. Of course this is only making things worse.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:29AM (#19499797)
> People don't have the tools or the time to understand all this stuff

Which is why we delegate that trust to experts. There are many such experts. Take your pick among your government, other governments, pharmaceutical companies, your doctor, anyone else’s doctor, immunologists, or any scientist with domain expertise. They all come to the same consensus.

What doesn’t make sense is distrusting all of them while trusting Internet numpties peddling supplements.

Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer... by sarcasmOrTears on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:54AM (#19500795)
Exactly, that's the point. For many reasons these experts are losing their good reputation, that should be the main concern. If they get a good rep again, less and less people are gonna listen to misinformations