Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer...
by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:42AM
(#19499879)
Maybe so, but that has no bearing on the economic incentives that make google search and facebook different, which was the parent's point.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer...
by ModernMech on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:38AM
(#19500682)
I disagree. Google and Facebook have the same exact business model -- learn as much about you and use that data to sell ads. All of the Google products I listed above are funded by ad revenue. Facebook executes their model by keeping you on one site, while Google executes theirs by being pervasive in your life. They are two sides of the same coin. Since they face the same economic incentives, they have similar pathologies.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer...
by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @07:54AM
(#19499953)
How do the incentives for Facebook and Youtube differ?
From my perspective, they are exactly the same, but I'd be interested to know the thoughts of others.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer...
by creato on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:06AM
(#19500029)
I don't think they are that different, and I think youtube is also problematic in similar ways to facebook. But, this thread from the start was specifically talking about google search and its impact compared to facebook.
I also think there are differences (youtube has some value that isn't predicated entirely on being a social network), but the distinctions are debatable and opinions will vary.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer...
by Retric on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @08:19AM
(#19500111)
Facebook does not pay for content the way that YouTube does. This creates very different economic incentives.
Facebook needs to realy on content from people pushing an agenda. YouTube gets content from people directly trying to make money.
Net result, it’s easy to find many videos for home repair or learning Calculus on YouTube, not so easy on Facebook.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer...
by ModernMech on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:55AM
(#19500807)
I think this fact makes Youtube even worse than Facebook. Let's say you are an idiot with an audience for your idiocy (e.g. anti-vaxers). YouTube is happy to pay you to create idiotic content for your audience. They will even promote your idiotic content across their site if you get enough clicks. What's more is they will cross promote your content with similarly idiotically minded people and lock them in a content bubble that increases clicks and views. The worst part is, for every view of your idiotic content, Google makes a profit, and you do too, so they get to keep hosting your nonsense, and you can make a living creating it. This was all fine and dandy when the context was home repair, but shift the context to idiotic conspiracies and we have an issue that is moving from the confines of the Internet to a public health nightmare.
Re:New York’s Rockland County declares measles outbreak emer...
by Retric on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:19AM
(#19501720)
Yet, YouTube does not have an incentive to promote ignorance over cat videos. Facebooks’s model is so broken they are paying for “please come back” advertising. They could have focused on connecting people, but spreading ignorance and rage was simply more profitable.
Cars may do more evil by killing people than most things, but they are not nessisarily more evil becase they also provide a lot of utility. FB unlike YT has no such excuse.