News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by dingaling on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:10AM (#19491970)
> The day the Internet died.

No. The day the ”Upload Other People's Work" Internet died.

> what we're likely to see is a massive spike in people streaming video over encrypted tunnels

Or just creating their own content. Wouldn't that be awesome?

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by makomk on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:19AM (#19492064)
All the people I know who create their own content are utterly pissed off about this, because it totally screws them over when it comes to sharing their content. It means that every platform they use will be forced to either shut down or instate odious, false-positive-prone, likely career-ruining content filtering. The only folks it's good for are the large corporate content factories who are effectively almost totally exempt from dealing with this mess.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by mcv on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:14AM (#19492577)
You miss the point. It doesn't just filter other people's work, everything has to pass through filters that do not exist and are impossible to create for anyone smaller than Google.

It will either be the end of any kind of user participation on the European internet, or everything that happens has to pass through Google's filter. Neither are good options for internet freedom.

Note that Google's Youtube filter already has a tendency to block people's own content when it resembles content of the big copyright holders. For example: someone playing a piece from Bach on the piano when Sony has also released a recording of that piece from Bach. Youtube will flag that, Sony is fine with that, and small content creators don't have the resources to fight it.

That situation will get a lot worse.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by philpem on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:28AM (#19492135)
You need only look at the rampant abuse of Content ID to see what the likely result will be...

"Sorry, the video you uploaded 'Me playing Beethoven on the piano' contains BEETHOVEN'S 5TH SYMPHONY by BMG-EMI-XYZ Music Corp. You cannot upload this video."

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by gniv on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:14AM (#19492586)
Is that illegal though (wrongly blocking a video)? If it isn’t, YT can just shrug it off.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by trickstra on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:05PM (#19493080)
Wrongly blocking is not illegal. They may invoke the clause that says the platform owner can reject anything even without explanation, which is always buried somewhere in their T&C. But more importantly - even if wrongful blocking was illegal - if the ways to shut something down "just in case it might be illegal" are super fast and automatic, but the ways to challenge that outcome are super slow, then people will just give up in that process. Not all, but enough to matter.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by belorn on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:47AM (#19492888)
It is not illegal for a filter to wrongly block something. I think the pirate party tried to insert such clause in the past.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by mcv on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:21AM (#19492649)
Small time content creators have no way to challenge this. YT's terms and conditions probably allow YT to block it for any reason at all, and as long as you lack the resources to sue them, they can just shrug it off.

Measures like this only serve Big Content. And badly, in my opinion.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by dredmorbius on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:39AM (#19492796)
There is no consequence for filing unsubstantiated claims.

There is consequence for failing to honour substantiated ones.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:42AM (#19492836)
It's probably fraud, but yeah, still no consequences for large media corp execs who are personally responsible for that fraud.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by philpem on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:54PM (#19493606)
The DMCA has a similar provision (from memory it's something like "filing a false claim is considered perjury").

I've never, ever heard of a single charge being filed under that clause -- but I've heard of tons of instances of DMCA being abused. On this statement, I'd love to be proven wrong!

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @01:40PM (#19494174)
> A statement that the information in the notification is accurate, and under penalty of perjury, that the complaining party is authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.

So basically useless. They claim to be acting "on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed" and they are, even though the allegation is completely without merit.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by isostatic on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:18PM (#19493191)
Don't use platforms them. Host it yourself.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by phinnaeus on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @02:41PM (#19494791)
I think it is completely absurd to expect every content creator, with their diverse talents, to all _also_ posses the expertise needed to host their own content.

Reminds me of the Dropbox launch thread here on HN a decade ago where some sysadmin chimes in with "but this is so easy for the layman to do themselves with FTP and [other technologies laypeople have never heard of]" (not an actual quote).

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by drchaos on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @03:51PM (#19495388)
But does it really have to be that difficult? It's absolutely possible to build a system where you can deploy a docker container with a single click and host your own content on that. Add federation into the mix, and you'll get some kind of meta-Youtube or -Bandcamp, comprised of thousands of individual instances, which do not even need to be on the same hosting service.

The blogosphere was similar to that, before everyone gave up and went to Facebook.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by CamperBob2 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @03:35PM (#19495281)
If the law were structured to make Dropbox illegal, then that particular neckbeard's observation would have been much more insightful. It seems likely that individual users are going to have to "get technical" in response to creeping authoritarianism from the EU and other powerful, unaccountable actors.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by wvenable on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @02:36PM (#19494749)
You have to host somewhere!!! Ever gotten an abuse email from the data center holding your physical hardware? I have. My tiny forum that has 50 participants max actually has a filter to prevent anyone from using the word "Elton".
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by phinnaeus on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @02:42PM (#19494809)
It's simple, just get a static IP and host it on your home internet. Unless your ISP decides to shut you down. Then just setup your own ISP and datacenter and get your own peering agreements!

/s

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by isostatic on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @08:17PM (#19497132)
> You have to host somewhere!!! Ever gotten an abuse email from the data center holding your physical hardware?

No

This law does nothing to change that in any case. Get a (US law) DMCA takedown, and ignore it, job done.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by wvenable on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:08PM (#19497635)
No, this law changes nothing. But also hosting your own changes nothing. You can ignore a DMCA takedown but maybe your host won't. And from my experience, hosts don't care that much -- they'd rather toss you than deal with legal issues.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by isostatic on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @04:57AM (#19499059)
Use a host that ignores the DMCA -- why would a bad american law apply to the majority of the internet?

Now that americans are realising that other countries exist, and make laws like the DMCA, maybe they'll stop doing it.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by rurban on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:47AM (#19492332)
This would be an invalid flag. BMG-EMI-XYZ Music Corp does not own this work, they could only own a certain recording of a certain orchestra playing this piece. And we know that detecting that certain recording via music matching does not work, only checking the strong hash of it would work. Which would be trivial to circumvent by a single bit-flip.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by thirdsun on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:00AM (#19492439)
> BMG-EMI-XYZ Music Corp does not own this work.

Hasn't stopped big companies from making false claims before. After all they are the ones responding (and likely rejecting) the appeal of the uploader. See: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/09/sorry-sony-music...

> And we know that detecting that certain recording via music matching does not work, only checking the strong hash of it would work. Which would be trivial to circumvent by a single bit-flip.

So you're saying that even Google hasn't made upload filters work reliably? Who can if not the company behind Youtube?

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by rurban on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:10AM (#19492542)
Google filters might have a success rate of 10%. We know that Facebook was not able to detect all the instances of the New Zealand shooting live recording, which is a trivial instance of exact matching.

They would need to match all EU copyrighted work. There's not even a database of EU copyrighted work. Because our copyright law works differently than in the US. There's no exact OCR or proper fuzzy matching of video or audio possible. Maybe with success rates of 60%. This is too risky for a big content provider. Esp. dealing with an entity who has no idea what they are talking about (the EU parliament).

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by philpem on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:54AM (#19492389)
Content ID uses some kind of fuzzy matching... a "single bit flip" (as you put it) isn't enough to confuse it.

Yes it's true XYZ Music Corp would only own that performance (as it's Beethoven and the piece is long out of copyright). The problem is, the automatic filter is a fuzzy matcher: it compares the upload against every other performance of Beethoven's 5th it's been programmed to recognise.

Let's say our uploader has been learning from one of those performances. Their performance will sound very similar to another pianist's -- at least to the fuzzy-matcher.

And therein lies the problem: the uploader's piece is clearly copyright to them, but the magic upload filter can't tell the difference.

It's like uploading a silent theatre production (let's say some kind of homage to silent films) and the upload being flagged for violating the copyright in 4'33".

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by EpicEng on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:57AM (#19492421)
Does it matter when the average person has little to no recourse in the matter? Does it matter when e.g. YT will _punish_ you if you decide to contest it and lose per their arbitrary process?
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by fock on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:40AM (#19492817)
Just have a look at what was passed today:

> Article 17/9: Where rightholders request to have access to their specific works or other subject matter disabled or those works or other subject matter removed, they shall duly justify the reasons for their requests. Complaints submitted under the mechanism provided for in the first subparagraph shall be processed without undue delay, and decisions to disable access to or remove uploaded content shall be subject to human review. Member States shall also ensure that out-of-court redress mechanisms are available for the settlement of disputes. Such mechanisms shall enable disputes to be settled impartially and shall not deprive the user of the legal protection afforded by national law, without prejudice to the rights of users to have recourse to efficient judicial remedies. In particular, Member States shall ensure that users have access to a court or another relevant judicial authority to assert the use of an exception or limitation to copyright and related rights.

So this also encourages to appeal in court against the current very opaque content upload policies. Certainly this is not strictly better than the current situation (where you can be arbitrarily banned), but definitely progress compared to the situation today, where platforms just act like they see fit.

> Article 17/7: The cooperation between online content-sharing service providers and rightholders shall not result in the prevention of the availability of works or other subject matter uploaded by users, which do not infringe copyright and related rights, including where such works or other subject matter are covered by an exception or limitation.

So overblocking will be costly as well, if enough suitable laws are signed into effect and people start complaining. And this really puts large scale commercial (remember non-profits are exempt) sites in a though spot: they either share revenue with content-creators/their organisations (which are mostly s*, but could be changed...) or they employ even more moderators (remember the small paragraph, where banning is to be done by humans ;)) – which all severly limits the current exploitation of the internet as a big chunk of empty space, where the strongest strongman is going to grab the biggest slice and employs an army of user-slaves.

> Article 17/10: For the purpose of the stakeholder dialogues, users' organisations shall have access to adequate information from online content-sharing service providers on the functioning of their practices with regard to paragraph 4.

I guess already today a lot of people would like to know, how Content-ID blocks their content, but Google can't and won't say (because it will show their dirty secrets...).

=> IMO: all in all, for the average person, the internet might develop back to where it was 20 years ago with select content-providers and quite a large proportion of actual people hosting fun stuff (and moderating their own boards...). If people are as IT-literate as they claim to be (although I doubt that for the large percentage of fortnite-playing #saveyourinternet-people) we might as well enter a real golden age of the internet.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by philpem on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:56PM (#19493635)
The problem is the balance of power in this equation.

You call your lawyer and ask them to sue (as an example) Google.

I expect the response would be something to the effect of "are you mad, rich or both? Because this is going to take a long time and be very expensive."

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by fock on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @04:06PM (#19495529)
So you are basically saying that Google stands above the law? Well, I think the copyright reform should be your smallest problem.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by thecatspaw on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:05AM (#19492502)
At which point you mark this as a false flag on youtube and youtube tells you to go to court over it.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by philpem on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:57PM (#19493650)
How many small-time Patreon-funded content creators have the time and money to take on a major media company in court?

Just because you could doesn't mean it's feasible from a financial point of view.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by posterboy on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @02:22PM (#19494607)
Court fees are proportional to the cause, like 10%. At least in Germany, only that has to be payed up front; Paying the lawyers comes later. So the cost should be within income,and in cases where it isn't, procedures are in place to excuse the plaintiff. Filing should be relatively straight forward, safe any catch-21s that require a lawyer, that I not being a lawyer don't know, but even a lawyer could not foresee with certainty right now.

A real problem would be the usually long wait.

However, taking into account several more circumstances, either side might not be keen on a court case, and thus provide to avoid it. That hinges on morals and technical details.

The problem with copyright's blurry edges around the originality threshold hasn't changed at least. The Olympics organisation is famous for suing, and loosing often enough, over its trademarks, for example.

> take on a major media company in court

In court or outside? And why the media companies? Laws can be repealed by supreme courts on constitutional grounds. That's an even bigger judicial hurdle to consider. If lobbying or legislative orders are involved, it would be a superset of the problem, as the court is to an extend bound by the lawgivers interpretation of the law, disregarding any side effects that are implementation specific. That's the undefined behaviour of the law. The service nulled all your bits after you passed ownership? The content wasn't registered initially and you assumed it was licensed to null? Ohohoho, none of those side-effects were mandated.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by thecatspaw on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:28AM (#19499227)
You dont have to take youtube to court, you have to take the other side to court, which maliciously striked your video.

So yes, its still an invalid flag, but if you want your video up again, you have to sue somebody who is probably in another country

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by mrep on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:18AM (#19492060)
And do what with it? Most aggregaters won't host your content for you for fear of lawsuits and if you host it yourself, nobody will find your dinky website because nobody is going to pay you to link to it.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by rurban on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:44AM (#19492300)
The problem is not uploading illegal content. The problem is that this legislation is technically impossible to fulfill, there does not exist foolproof content violation check mechanisms and there will none. This needs strong AI, and a not existing framework to recognize and handle "works". This is impossible without a court order.

Therefore every platform provider visible in the EU (like Wikipedia, Facebook, Youtube, every blog, newspaper comment sections, ...) needs to stop accepting user content, because they cannot guarantee that copyright violations will not occur. They cannot be filtered and not detected. Think e.g. of song texts in images. Will you OCR every image for a work? There does exist a foolproof method to bypass AI, it's called captcha. Even if you install comment or upload submission queues with manual labor ("manual filtering"), you cannot guarantee copyright violations, only courts can do that.

The politicians might have thought of an GEMA-like index to store hashes of protected content in some form or another, which could be distributed to content certain providers, but this doesn't affect the law, which is much broader and not fulfillable. Thus Web 2.0 is dead.

If I would be Facebook I would rather ignore said new laws and go to court over it. The existing framework is good enough, the best way to handle copyright violations.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Hamuko on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:13AM (#19491996)
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by philpem on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:35AM (#19492202)
Ooh, nice one. That's an even better example than Beethoven.

Even better still: there's a song which consists of 4 minutes and 33 seconds of silence. That's it - silence.

"Your latest video upload contains 5 seconds of stunned silence, which has been identified as an extract of 4'33". This extract is copyrighted. Your video has been deleted."

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:51AM (#19492924)
The creative elements of Cage's work are that it's performed as a piece by an orchestra, and presented as a work (eg a specific length, sold as other works are). Your any-[other]-length-of-silence doesn't infringe. If it did then Cage's piece would lack the artistic distinctiveness needed to make it a work for copyright purposes.

Just having a urinal doesn't infringe on Duchamp's "Fountain", not even if it's the same model, only if it is presented as artwork does it become a copy of Duchamp's "work".

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by simiones on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:39PM (#19493427)
You know that, the lawyers know that, but how do you expect the content filtering mechanism to know that???

True, for 4'33'' there is a simple rule that they probably follow - ignore silence :). But for Fountain (if it ever came up) it's hard to imagine that the difference between a protected copy and a non-protected similar image could really be automatically discovered.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by philpem on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @12:59PM (#19493675)
This is it. A human being can identify the context. Taking Fountain as an example -- a photo of a urinal on a building merchant's website is an illustration of the product they're selling, not an infringement.

But the filter doesn't know about context, it just correlates two images... and you get "Comparison with copyrighted work 'Fountain', 75% match".

75% > 0%, so the filter says "non".

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @02:22PM (#19494603)
Isn't this:

> decisions to disable access to or remove uploaded content shall be subject to human review

intended to handle those cases? I'm not saying that it will be adequate.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by koonsolo on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:40AM (#19492263)
> Or just creating their own content. Wouldn't that be awesome?

People on YouTube are creating content, lots of it. Will they still create it when some filter keeps blocking them?

If you want pirated stuff, just download torrents. They won't disappear with this new law.

The only thing that will appear are filters.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by jakelazaroff on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:49AM (#19492346)
A couple that might be affected by the lack of a fair use exemption in Article 13:

- use of unlicensed samples in music. Goodbye, Soundcloud rap and EDM music scenes!

- use of images and video clips in memes. Goodbye, Tumblr and Reddit!

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by friedman23 on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:40AM (#19492814)
those sites aren't going to leave, they will just leave Europe.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by _emacsomancer_ on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:10AM (#19492538)
> Or just creating their own content. Wouldn't that be awesome?

Until Disney/Comcast/Weyland-Yutani decides that their own your original content. Or the content-id'ing algorithm generates a false positive. Just think a little bit about how all of this will be implemented.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Xelbair on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:34AM (#19492190)
Yeah, i am really curious what approach will content hosting companies take.

Will they analyze each video if it is a illegal or legal one, checking everything... or just implement a simple, fast and cheap filter that will block most of the content, with no way to appeal the ruling, just like youtube is doing now...

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by koonsolo on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:43AM (#19492293)
I hope they block the entire EU. And yes, I live in the EU.

That way they need to shamefully roll back this law, and we're sure they don't try to pull off such a farce in the (near) future.

Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by ivolimmen on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @11:43AM (#19492851)
Or we post a huge load of original content of the EU pm's making sure we the people own the copyrights. Making their digital life a hell...
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by Zekio on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @01:46PM (#19494249)
you could potentially email MEPs copyrighted work and they would be obligated to filter their emails
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by csunbird on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:37AM (#19492223)
While I do agree with your point on this, I do not think the Youtube's Content ID is cheap at all.
Re:European Parliament approves copyright reform by philpem on Tuesday March 26, 2019 @10:56AM (#19492409)
I seriously doubt Google would licence it to potential competitors either.