I get it's a democracy yada yada, but how are people expected to make such a decision ? It has so many consequences on short and long term, even experts in the field struggle(d) to predict. We're not talking about the color of a national football team jersey or a 1% increase on alcohol tax here.
The vote wasn't about staying or leaving EU, it was about how modern propaganda can tear apart a leading world nation.
You always get the worst of people when you target their irrational fears "they" steal our money (EU budget) , "they" invade our country (immigration), &c.
You get the worst anti-democratic statements from people who believe their own voting to be based on rational thought and everyone else's on irrational fears.
Direct democracy isn't the only form of democracy.
We're all irrational and biased, that's inherent to being human. Some people are more informed than other and there are processes to mitigate biases (direct democracy isn't one of them).
The problem comes from people who have no business in the vote, no knowledge of the issues, are not even aware of what biases are, and drink the propaganda kool aid.
Brexit was mostly about:
- "we spend to much money on EU"
- "too many migrants"
Well first off London only strives because of international financial businesses, closing the borders and making it harder for people to migrate is a death sentence [0]. Since the vote Brexit cost the UK much more than what they contribute to the EU [1], they export/import ~50% of their good to/from Europe [2]
Time will tell, what I'm convinced of is that Brexit was sold on lies. It might turns out good for them, but if it does it won't be because of good planning and well thought decisions, it'll be a combination of luck and really good damage control.
[0] https://www.ft.com/content/371c63ba-4b08-11e9-8b7f-d49067e0f...
Of course, that's always the other people...
> Well first off London only strives because of international financial businesses
London isn't the UK and "international" doesn't mean "about the EU-27".
> Since the vote Brexit cost the UK much more than what they contribute to the EU
Laughable nonsense.
> they export/import ~50% of their good to/from Europe
So does Iceland. Is it broke yet?
> Time will tell, what I'm convinced of is that Brexit was sold on lies
I rest my case about irrational voters... It's also quite pointless to turn every discussion into a superficial pro/con Brexit argument.
I never said that. It's all about intellectual honesty.
I know that I'm not qualified for my opinion to matter on the topic (I'm just debunking low quality propaganda here) despite the fact that I did hours of research on it.
We don't ask random people about their opinion on string theory, do we ?
> Laughable nonsense.
https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-britain-eu-economy/brexit...
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/sep/29/britain-bil...
https://qz.com/1477680/brexit-is-a-bad-idea-whichever-way-yo...
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-06-22/u-k-brexi...
https://fullfact.org/europe/our-eu-membership-fee-55-million...
If you "spent hours researching" the topic, you should at least try to question such claims instead of quoting shoddy journalism and publications by dubious lobbyist groups. That's what intellectual honesty is all about.
PS. I remember these predictions - do you? https://www.bbc.com/news/business-37921036
As a fellow EU-citizen I am absolutely horrified by the chaos currently unfolding in the UK, but dismissing the entire voting process while referring to "democracy yada yada" is far scarier than the outcome of a democratic election will ever be.
After all, a stupid decision taken by uninformed politicians isn't necessarily better than a stupid decision made by the people.
They're not random, you're supposed to vote for them.
And they're supposed to represent your general opinion. They're supposed to have an education in politic/economics/&c. which makes them better equipped to make informed decisions. And it's supposed to be their full time job.
Just like anyone can bake bread at home with no tools / minimum knowledge but the bakery at the corner of the street will make better bread.
That doesn't magically make a person competent in other matters. On the contrary, many politicians with a background in economics or law show a frightening lack of insight in many other topics like environmental issues, information technology or science, whereas you will find plenty of experts within those fields (as well as economics and law) within the general populace.
The claim that elected politicians are somehow more competent than we are is a scary one. They are people just as we are. They have limitations just as we do. They specialize in various fields like they do, and just like the rest of us, that often means they don't really know that much about the stuff that is outside their own field.
voting population of UK - 17.6m leave votes = people who didn't vote for Brexit
Which is a huge majority and by that measure we shouldn't leave. I don't agree with that standpoint either, but both your viewpoint and that are misrepresentations.
Those that didn't vote either way, don't count, and shouldn't count.
Percentages in elections are of active voters.
Unless they were prevented from voting some way, their post-facto protests are meaningless.
You can't have your cake (not give a toss about votes and not participate) and eat it (still have your opinion matter on voted topics) too
That's 3 years ago. There are ~3-4 mil. more young people that are now elligible for vote. Should they have no say?
They don't have a say in any other long-term-implementation matter which was voted before they became eligible for vote, so why would this be an exception?
But in democracies the percentages who want this or that are counted through voting. So technically, it is correct.
About 16 will have voted to leave, 16 to remain, 11 who didn't vote but could have, and 23 didn't get to vote because they were too young or aren't British citizens (even if they've lived here for 20 years and have British kids)
(based on 1 million births and deaths a year, with about 2:1 ratio of people dying voting leave (in line with surveys that the older you were the more likely you were to vote and the more likely you were to vote leave)
So about 24% would have voted to leave, 24% to remain, 17% didn't vote, 5% who can now vote but couldn't, and and 30% who still can't vote.
The problem is that only the views of the 24% that voted to leave, and arguably the 41% that voted leave or didn't vote, seem to matter.
Those are also not meant to vote, and rightly so. If you aren't a citizen (or aren't yet), you shouldn't decide of the country's matters. And if you're not an adult, you are considered not mature enough to have an opinion. That's part for the course in every democracy.
In a democracy, "X of the the country wants Y" = "X of people qualified to vote && who voted, want Y".
Even in the suffrage and civil rights era, nobody seriously complained that this doesn't include 10 year olds or non-citizens of a country.
>The problem is that only the views of the 24% that voted to leave, and arguably the 41% that voted leave or didn't vote, seem to matter.
That's not a problem, that's how democracy works. Want your opinion to matter? 1) Become an adult (e.g. just wait), 2) Become a citizen (if you're a foreigner) 3) DO vote (don't stay at home). Else the others who are will determine the result.
The real problem is the hypocrisy. In the sense that all of the above wouldn't be considered a problem if the majority had voted to remain.
Imagine if Texas had a vote for independence, but only people born in Texas, and not those that moved from say Chicago, were allowed to vote.
> In the sense that all of the above wouldn't be considered a problem if the majority had voted to remain.
Except it would have been Farage was already calling for a second referendum before the results from the first came in. Rees Mogg and Owen Patterson were also big fans of two referendums, one to start the process, and one to confirm it 3 years later.
Sure, hypocrisy on both sides ensure it would be called a problem by the other side.
But it wouldn't be called a problem from _the same_ people today calling it a problem.
So, it's the kind that's only a problem when your side loses -- in which case, it can be discarded as the usual complaint of any losing side ever.
A slim majority of those who voted, several years ago, stirred up by masses of illegal propaganda, especially in the last days before the vote. Now after getting some idea of the reality, the tides look to have significantly changed. Current opinion polls are showing significant majority for remain.(61% in the last YouGov poll)
(Also, it was 17 not 33)
That "61%" is probably about right for what would you'd get for a two-way referendum between Remain and No Deal, or between Remain and May's Deal, but if you were to repeat the Remain-Leave referendum (which would be an insane thing to do - it was madness the first time), I wouldn't be surprised if Leave would win again, by a narrow margin.
"Well, if you knows of a better 'ole go to it"?
A) Should we leave?
B) if we leave, should be we leave even without a deal with the EU?
I.e. two (or more) distinct questions. If you vote no at the fort question, you still get to express your opinion on the second.
This is why you do ranked choice voting, which covers any combination of such opinions.
I have found betting odd's to be far superior insight than public opinioin polls and with that, ring up a betting shop and ask them what odds they will give that the UK stays as an EU member, that should give you a fair perspective as unlike polls, any mistake they make costs them money.
But for me and many others, polls are futile and so often very very wrong as Brexit and Trump have demonstrated.
Polls before Brexit where wrong, no reasons to trust them now.
It's not going to prove much even then. As a test I just signed this with a fake name, all you need is an E-Mail address and to enter some valid UK post code.
Anyone who's paying any attention to some Internet petition that's implemented like this is crazy. In some other European countries there's online petitions like this, but they'll make you go through the government's official login gateway.
The people behind the petition website are not idiots.
This can be worrying.
[0] https://www.gov.uk/electoral-register/view-electoral-registe... [1] https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_fil...
They're not going to have a known fool-proof mapping of names/postal codes to something that's guaranteed to be that person's current E-Mail address.
Which, in the age of allegations of say Russian interference in elections[1] means this sort of Internet poll is always going to be suspect.
It doesn't mean it's completely useless, it's some general way of gauging interest for sure, but the GPs suggestion was that something would change once it passed the 33 million mark. I don't think you can make that claim with a poll that's so easily gamed.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_20...
Sure, they would have to give up a lot of privileges, but these would be scrapped anyway and are mostly counter to the idea of a union.
I am not from the UK and I would have voted for staying in the union. Even if the EU is a undemocratic, bureaucratic moloch that really needs a lot of constructive criticism to improve.
But having people actually want to be part of a union is much more important than any technicalities involving trade, foreign relations and policies.
The lack of respect for the position of Brexiteers had its own effect, no matter how stupid you think their decision is.
Basically the Referendum should never have happened in the first place, it doesn't have a legal blinding ( Correct me if I am wrong on this one ), and I totally blame David Cameron for the current mess.
Well not completely. It allows UK politicians to imitate useful activity around the Brexit.
The two halves are not static. Leave voters are predominately older and enough of them have died to shift the proportion (https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/brexit-leave-...). It's clear that that Leave was a racist (https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2016/06/25/483362200...) campaign designed to frighten old people.
>Even if no one had changed their mind since the 2016 referendum, population changes mean that, from 19 January 2019, a majority of voters will back staying in the EU, according to the analysis. By 29 March, when Britain is due to leave the bloc, the Remain side is forecast to have a majority of around 100,000.
Might as well just start banning "racists" and other undesirables from the polls outright if that's the path you want to go down.
One could say the same about May's repeated requests for votes in parliament on her "deal". It was rejected, we need a better solution.
I voted remain but I'd rather crash out with no deal on the 29th than go through this endless uncertainty ad nauseum.
I'm of the opinion you guys should get the Empire back together. The Canadians would love it.
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/dec/07/corrupt-vot...
If it's not codified, then it sounds like a failure of the government structure and charter
Apparently the Brexit referendum was "advisory" so this doesn't count.
> sounds like a failure of the government structure and charter
Everything is a failure of the government structure and charter at the moment, pal. We've had half a dozen constitutional crises this year and the Speaker is digging up precendent from 1604.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_K...
Sounds like it's time for a revolution and rewrite.
https://www.realclearpolicy.com/articles/2018/07/24/conserva...
We already know half the country wants to leave and half wants to stay, so unless that petition has more than 33 million signatures then it doesn't prove much does it.
(FYI: I voted remain and think Brexit is completely dumb, but it doesn't change how pointless petitions are for subjects where it's well established what people's opinions are)