News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by colinramsay on Thursday March 21, 2019 @06:17AM (#19450598)
While I think this petition will fall on deaf ears, you can't definitively say "half the country wants to leave and half wants to stay", because not all of the country voted in the referendum. Likewise, you could say:

voting population of UK - 17.6m leave votes = people who didn't vote for Brexit

Which is a huge majority and by that measure we shouldn't leave. I don't agree with that standpoint either, but both your viewpoint and that are misrepresentations.

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by coldtea on Thursday March 21, 2019 @06:22AM (#19450628)
>While I think this petition will fall on deaf ears, you can't definitively say "half the country wants to leave and half wants to stay", because not all of the country voted in the referendum.

Those that didn't vote either way, don't count, and shouldn't count.

Percentages in elections are of active voters.

Unless they were prevented from voting some way, their post-facto protests are meaningless.

You can't have your cake (not give a toss about votes and not participate) and eat it (still have your opinion matter on voted topics) too

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by megous on Thursday March 21, 2019 @06:52AM (#19450829)
> Those that didn't vote either way, don't count, and shouldn't count.

That's 3 years ago. There are ~3-4 mil. more young people that are now elligible for vote. Should they have no say?

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by coldtea on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:39AM (#19452137)
>That's 3 years ago. There are ~3-4 mil. more young people that are now elligible for vote. Should they have no say?

They don't have a say in any other long-term-implementation matter which was voted before they became eligible for vote, so why would this be an exception?

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by megous on Thursday March 21, 2019 @11:17AM (#19453312)
You just can't say what the country wants. You may only say what it wanted 3 years ago.
Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by lordlimecat on Thursday March 21, 2019 @08:14AM (#19451401)
There are new voters who had no say in Trumps election. Thems just the breaks.
Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by colinramsay on Thursday March 21, 2019 @06:24AM (#19450642)
I agree. But the statement "half the country wants to leave and half wants to stay" is still false.
Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by coldtea on Thursday March 21, 2019 @06:29AM (#19450671)
Taken literally it is indeed false.

But in democracies the percentages who want this or that are counted through voting. So technically, it is correct.

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by isostatic on Thursday March 21, 2019 @07:02AM (#19450889)
You ask 66 people today,

About 16 will have voted to leave, 16 to remain, 11 who didn't vote but could have, and 23 didn't get to vote because they were too young or aren't British citizens (even if they've lived here for 20 years and have British kids)

(based on 1 million births and deaths a year, with about 2:1 ratio of people dying voting leave (in line with surveys that the older you were the more likely you were to vote and the more likely you were to vote leave)

So about 24% would have voted to leave, 24% to remain, 17% didn't vote, 5% who can now vote but couldn't, and and 30% who still can't vote.

The problem is that only the views of the 24% that voted to leave, and arguably the 41% that voted leave or didn't vote, seem to matter.

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by coldtea on Thursday March 21, 2019 @07:51AM (#19451211)
>and 23 didn't get to vote because they were too young or aren't British citizens

Those are also not meant to vote, and rightly so. If you aren't a citizen (or aren't yet), you shouldn't decide of the country's matters. And if you're not an adult, you are considered not mature enough to have an opinion. That's part for the course in every democracy.

In a democracy, "X of the the country wants Y" = "X of people qualified to vote && who voted, want Y".

Even in the suffrage and civil rights era, nobody seriously complained that this doesn't include 10 year olds or non-citizens of a country.

>The problem is that only the views of the 24% that voted to leave, and arguably the 41% that voted leave or didn't vote, seem to matter.

That's not a problem, that's how democracy works. Want your opinion to matter? 1) Become an adult (e.g. just wait), 2) Become a citizen (if you're a foreigner) 3) DO vote (don't stay at home). Else the others who are will determine the result.

The real problem is the hypocrisy. In the sense that all of the above wouldn't be considered a problem if the majority had voted to remain.

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by isostatic on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:59AM (#19452390)
The problem in this case is that europe has spent 40 years welcoming people from elsewhere in europe. Doesn't matter where you're born, you have the right to live there and build a life.

Imagine if Texas had a vote for independence, but only people born in Texas, and not those that moved from say Chicago, were allowed to vote.

> In the sense that all of the above wouldn't be considered a problem if the majority had voted to remain.

Except it would have been Farage was already calling for a second referendum before the results from the first came in. Rees Mogg and Owen Patterson were also big fans of two referendums, one to start the process, and one to confirm it 3 years later.

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by coldtea on Thursday March 21, 2019 @10:27AM (#19452699)
>Except it would have been Farage was already calling for a second referendum before the results from the first came in.

Sure, hypocrisy on both sides ensure it would be called a problem by the other side.

But it wouldn't be called a problem from _the same_ people today calling it a problem.

So, it's the kind that's only a problem when your side loses -- in which case, it can be discarded as the usual complaint of any losing side ever.

Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by jonplackett on Thursday March 21, 2019 @09:26AM (#19452013)
The point I was making is that the petition proves nothing that isn't already know - a lot of people don't want to leave. It's not even a march where people have to go somewhere to show how much they care. it's just a button click - which is an easier thing to do than go out and vote. so it's not worth reporting, it's meaningless.
Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by atzd4b on Thursday March 21, 2019 @06:23AM (#19450632)
More than half the people who cared enough to go and vote want to leave.
Re:UK Parliament petitions site crashes under traffic for pe... by Jarmsy on Thursday March 21, 2019 @06:27AM (#19450656)
*wanted