News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model Y by myself248 on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:42AM (#19396882)
Snow-land wants to know: Front-wheel drive, ever?

I'm not driving rear-only, ever. Did that once, not again.

I'm not paying another $11,000 to get the dual-motor version when all I care about is the front. That's a whole 'nother car worth of money.

Keep on building California cars, Elon. I'll buy one as soon as it fits both my budget and my climate. Some models fit one or the other, but nothing does both.

Re:Tesla Model Y by sliken on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:11AM (#19397314)
FWD has a reputation for being good in the snow, I grew up with a FWD Saab that was pretty awesome in the snow. Mostly because it had tall narrow tires, FWD, and well over 60% of the car's weight over the front wheels.

However RWD is actually better... assuming the car has a good front/rear balance near 50%... like the Telsa. Any FWD gets LESS traction when climbing than driving on the flats. A RWD gets MORE traction when climbing than driving on the flats. Of course when driving down hills you can always throttle off and just use the brakes.

Additionally your limited traction budget in a RWD allows the front wheels to be dedicated to steering only. On a FWD you have to spend part of your traction budget on acceleration.

So get the RWD, it's cheaper than AWD, and better in the snow than FWD.

Re:Tesla Model Y by lagadu on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:50AM (#19397827)
The problem is the tendency to fishtail on long, light corners, nothing to do with going up or downhill.
Re:Tesla Model Y by sliken on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:28AM (#19398325)
Oversteer (RWD without enough traction) and understeer (FWD without enough traction) are two sides of the same coin.

Personally I'd rather have oversteer, which is easily compensated for (a bit of steering and let off the throttle), but doesn't impact your path around the corner. It's also quite fun.

Understeer on the other hand does impact your path around the corner, the car plows straight ahead as you ask too much of it. Additionally the threshold for understeer is lower since it's the front tires trying to handle acceleration and steering. So a RWD has more traction at a given speed than FWD.

Keep in mind that the that RWD in terrible in the snow comes from things like empty pick up trucks (no weight on the rear wheels) or old American sedans and sports cars that had large engines in the front and not much weight out back. Generally even with a perfect 50/50 weight distribution that the RWD is going to have the advantage.

Re:Tesla Model Y by dragontamer on Friday March 15, 2019 @10:23AM (#19399947)
I've always seen it as a thing of habit.

If you're used to understeer (FWD loss of traction), then for safety reasons, you should stick to understeer. If you're used to oversteer, then stick with oversteer.

Its not like it snows every day. Your opportunities to practice loss of traction are few and far in between.

Re:Tesla Model Y by sliken on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:05PM (#19404753)
Dunno, it's not rocket science. Sure if it snows a few times a year, ignore it.

But if it snows often there's a simple choice. Do you want to lose the ability to accelerate (oversteer), or do you want to lose the ability to accelerate and steer (understeer)?

Even a single hour in an abandoned parking lot should get you familiar with either, and it's quite instructive to spend significant time over the threshold of sliding to help prepare you for the occasional surprise on real roads.

Re:Tesla Model Y by dsfyu404ed on Friday March 15, 2019 @08:52AM (#19399193)
>However RWD is actually better... assuming the car has a good front/rear balance near 50%... like the Telsa. Any FWD gets LESS traction when climbing than driving on the flats. A RWD gets MORE traction when climbing than driving on the flats.

You don't even need "good" weight distribution for RWD to hill climb better. I live on a hill. My RWD pickup goes up it better than the FWD wagon which has near 50-50 weight distribution.

The AWD wagon (same model and generation running the same exact tire) and the pickup in 4wd will run circles around anything with two driven wheels though. All three vehicles are old so no limited slip diffs or traction control so it's a fairly scientific comparison.

>Additionally your limited traction budget in a RWD allows the front wheels to be dedicated to steering only. On a FWD you have to spend part of your traction budget on acceleration.

Basically anything that makes a car handle well in the dry makes it handle well in the snow. Everything behaves the same but your coefficient of friction is less.

Re:Tesla Model Y by sliken on Friday March 15, 2019 @09:05AM (#19399289)
Wider tires and grippier tires both help in the dry, but are worse in snow.
Re:Tesla Model Y by sunstone on Friday March 15, 2019 @05:24AM (#19397998)
Another important point to note is that with old time RWD the slipping tire got all the power while with electrics the rear tires work in a positraction mode where power is directed to the tire with traction, which is much much better in the snow.
Re:Tesla Model Y by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday March 15, 2019 @05:08AM (#19397925)
Are the roads all completely straight where you live?
Re:Tesla Model Y by oblio on Friday March 15, 2019 @05:51AM (#19398141)
It's not about oomph going up or downhill, it's about control :)
Re:Tesla Model Y by eemil on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:42AM (#19398399)
Not an issue in this day and age, IMO. While FWD is more controllable, and safer in the snow, modern stability control systems have done a _lot_ to bridge the gap.

My 2006 era RWD car has the manufacturer's optional stability control, and I'm constantly impressed by how effectively it keeps the car in-line in snow. Even on long, sweeping turns, where it's hard to know when you're beginning to slide. This is without any kind of steering control, with only engine power limiting and individual-wheel braking.

Much more important, is to have proper tires for the season. Even if you don't experience snow, you need tires with the appropriate temperature ratings. Summer tires will turn rock-hard in freezing temperatures, and lose a lot of grip. Even on bare pavement.

Re:Tesla Model Y by kolinko on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:50AM (#19396914)
Hm, on the website it says that there is an all-wheel drive version just 10-15% more expensive ($4-$5k).
Re:Tesla Model Y by tapland on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:36AM (#19397445)
I was going to correct you on what 10-15% of the sales price was, but then I noticed that yes, it is 50% more expensive here from Sweden.

The US price is not that bad!

Re:Tesla Model Y by jakobegger on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:09AM (#19397631)
You can just put sand bags in the trunk in winter :)

My parents used to do that so they could drive our Toyota Hiace in winter. As a bonus, there's fresh sand for the sandbox every spring!

Re:Tesla Model Y by Justen on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:18AM (#19397682)
You also use the sand when your tires are stuck in the snow.
Re:Tesla Model Y by audunw on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:28AM (#19398329)
RWD EV is probably better than FWD ICE. They'll generally have better weight distribution and the fine-grained control over the torque is better.

Anyway, if grip is important, you might as well go for AWD. The difference from RWD to FWD is tiny, if any (I also live in snowy-lands and have driven both). But going to AWD, especially with the dual motor AWD you get with EVs, is a world of difference and probably worth the upgrade.

Re:Tesla Model Y by justtopost on Friday March 15, 2019 @11:33AM (#19400594)
Having driven both, fwd ice is way better in the snow.
Re:Tesla Model Y by fingerlocks on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:26AM (#19397057)
I prefer to have an optional locking differential on the drive wheels for snow.

In my experience, the most common problem with snow is getting enough traction to move out of parking spot or up a steep incline. Like most AWD vehicles, the AWD Tesla has an open differential which does not help much in these scenarios. When traction gets dicey it behaves like a 2WD with torque spread between one front and one rear wheel.

Re:Tesla Model Y by sliken on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:22AM (#19397362)
Indeed, most cars are single wheel drive (FWD or RWD with an open differential).

Some more expensive sporty cars have limited slip differentials, mostly to avoid inside drive wheels spinning in sharp corners. It helps in the snow as well of course.

My Subaru WRX had a limited split in the center and rear, so it had three wheel drive when slippery. The higher end STI had an option for a front limited slip differential. Apparently when rallying on tight courses they would pick three wheel drive because it allows rotating around the inner front wheel for very sharp turns. It's great fun, plant a wheel (literally motionless), the car spins around it, until you let go of the wheel and the car launches in that direction. On more open courses the rally drivers would select the four wheel drive to get the most of the traction when going mostly straight.

The Tesla AWD is actually 4wd, but under software control. I wouldn't say as nice as a locking differential, but pretty close and able to get some power to all four wheels.

Re:Tesla Model Y by fingerlocks on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:50AM (#19397521)
The Subaru differential system is really a beautiful thing all on it’s own. It’s funny, just after posting my comment I thought “should have mentioned the limited slip for the subie fans”.

And to my chagrin, I’m deep in a worm hole learning a whole lot about the Tesla AWD system tonight.

Re:Tesla Model Y by lagadu on Friday March 15, 2019 @05:03AM (#19397894)
LSDs are no longer the domain of expensive sports cars though, nowadays they made it all the way to the cheaper cars, like the hyundai i30n and the mk8 fiesta st. It's pretty cool.
Re:Tesla Model Y by gambiting on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:28AM (#19398326)
But those are still the "sport" versions of pedestrian cars. No one is fitting a limited slip diff to a base model of the i30 or the fiesta. The i30n will be 1% of all i30 sales if even that.
Re:Tesla Model Y by imeron on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:01AM (#19397252)
It has a diff-like behavior by actively braking the wheels from software. See Youtube video https://youtu.be/xbaNQQaFrnE
Re:Tesla Model Y by londons_explore on Friday March 15, 2019 @07:11AM (#19398548)
I'd like to see high speed video of this working.

Friction is non-linear so you're going to need very fast feedback loops on the brakes to simulate a locked differential. One can't just apply a fixed amount of braking to every wheel and have stuff magically work out.

Re:Tesla Model Y by sliken on Friday March 15, 2019 @07:37AM (#19398684)
Yes. On normal cars this is achieves by sensors and brakes that I believe work at 100 times a second and up. Tesla have the advantage that they have similar control over acceleration. This technology has been common for years, and early on it had lots of downsides, but it's most recent versions is quite good. It's becoming more and more popular, even on enthusiast cars.

The main issue is while limited slip differentials do work, they are expensive, add weight, and they add friction. So the software solution gets you better MPG, better HP, and more control. There's many different names for it, traction control, torque vectoring, traction assist, etc.

Even Subaru who bet the heaviest on AWD (selling only AWD until they sold the BRZ), and had one of the best respected AWD systems is moving to open differential with the brake assist, on at least some of their cars. Not sure about the STI and WRX though.

Re:Tesla Model Y by bluedino on Friday March 15, 2019 @08:23AM (#19399004)
It also works just fine for Toyota's full size pickup, the Tundra. No 'real' locking differential but it can climb trhough hills/rocks just fine
Re:Tesla Model Y by fingerlocks on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:31AM (#19397423)
Thanks! My side hobby is restoring & retrofitting 80s vehicles, so I had not considered new tech like this. I just assumed it worked like every other open diff.
Re:Tesla Model Y by pedrocr on Friday March 15, 2019 @05:01AM (#19397889)
That's how every other open-diff car already works. Everyone does that. EVs just have the extra advantage that they're much more precise at applying power so the traction control can be much better.
Re:Tesla Model Y by fingerlocks on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:18PM (#19401872)
I was referring to the brake based traction control system, not the differential
Re:Tesla Model Y by pedrocr on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:56PM (#19402335)
That's also what I mean of course. All modern AWD systems and even just FWD/RWD cars use the ABS to do traction control with open-diffs. The base AWD system in a Subaru is three open-diffs and then ABS braking is used on any wheel that's slipping to make sure the torque still reaches the other wheels.
Re:Tesla Model Y by fingerlocks on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:46PM (#19405025)
Right, as I mentioned, I'm an 80's VW van enthusiast. I've transplanted subaru engines into VW vans, but I always clip the unused sensors (like traction control) from the wiring harness. I haven't touched anything newer than 2005 yet.

So, despite "everyone doing it" by your words, I was just unaware of how it worked because it's not relevant to me. My VW syncro van has both forward and rear locking differentials anyway.

Re:Tesla Model Y by justtopost on Friday March 15, 2019 @11:34AM (#19400613)
This is great unless you drive you car hard. Then the system overheats your brakes before you even try to slow down. No thanks.
Re:Tesla Model Y by ramenmeal on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:46AM (#19396896)
Interesting point. This should actually be an advantage for Tesla as the engineering and manufacturing costs would be much lower to produce front, rear and all wheel drive options than a traditional ICE car. I'm guessing they're hoping people buy the dual motor option for this scenario though.
Re:Tesla Model Y by sliken on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:55AM (#19398475)
Well there's a few problems with that. First of all FWD saves money, complexity, and weight on an ICE car because you avoid a long drive shaft, and you can mount the engine transversely which is more compact. You also get more interior room in the car since there's no hump for the drive shaft.

With an electric car you don't save anything with RWD vs FWD, you end up with poorer steering, poorer acceleration, and worse hill climbing, especially if it's snowy or icy. Nor is it cheaper to produce.

As a result even electric cars intended for city use like the BMW i3 and Renault have RWD.

On the model 3 the rear motor is larger and a permanent magnet motor (which is more efficient) and the front motor is an induction motor. So a FWD would have less power than the RWD, and it would also have less range than the RWD. Not sure Tesla would want to try to sell a car slower (because FWD), slower (because of less HP), and with less range (because of efficiency) without it being cheaper to produce.... just to have a FWD.

Re:Tesla Model Y by fingerlocks on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:48AM (#19397178)
Why would the costs be lower? Honest question.

On an ICE vehicle the only difference between rear and all wheel drive is a differential and a drive shaft. Maybe I don’t know enough about electric vehicles, but “dual motor” sounds a lot more expensive.

Re:Tesla Model Y by pedrocr on Friday March 15, 2019 @04:58AM (#19397865)
> On an ICE vehicle the only difference between rear and all wheel drive is a differential and a drive shaft.

You need three differentials for AWD as you first need to split the power front/back and then right/left in each axle. That's two more differentials than in just RWD or FWD. You also need to package all that together with a gearbox. That's why many manufacturers don't even offer an AWD option, and having both FWD and RWD versions of a car is very rare if it happens at all.

Meanwhile Tesla already builds all their cars to have two independent motors front/back each with their differential. They could very easily build a FWD car right now just by omitting the rear assembly. The cars are apparently even already designed to work with just the front motor for reliability so even the software update would be simple.

And building AWD cars by having two electric motors is almost surely not more expensive than the ICE way. Electric motors are much simpler than combustion ones and you eliminate all the mechanical parts needed to split the power between the axles. Control also becomes much better as the software gets to adjust power independently to both axles.

Re:Tesla Model Y by dsfyu404ed on Friday March 15, 2019 @09:01AM (#19399260)
>And building AWD cars by having two electric motors is almost surely not more expensive than the ICE way.

You need a differential for each driven axle. The expense of the extra motor and motor controller vs the expense of the transfer case (or FWD based equivalent), and drive shaft (not really all that expensive) is probably close to a wash or slightly in favor of the ICE vehicle. I don't think you understand how cheap and commoditized drive-train parts are. Like really, these assemblies are cheap and almost go together like legos (from an OEM perspective). It's not like you burn tons of engineering hours making a FWD or RWD vehicle into AWD so long as whatever floor pan you're working with was designed to be AWD compatible.

Re:Tesla Model Y by pedrocr on Friday March 15, 2019 @09:29AM (#19399490)
Thinking about it some more, maybe in a mass produced ICE AWD can indeed be a cheaper add-on. Something like a Subaru that does AWD for all cars. I was thinking more of the direct Tesla competitors that tend to charge quite a bit for AWD as an extra. But it's hard to compare from the outside as adding AWD to a car is often associated with different trim levels too.

Someone like Sandy Munro that does detailed costing would be able to answer this definitively for a few models. But it will most likely depend on the actual implementation to see what ends up cheaper. According to Munro Tesla has a big advantage in the cost, weight and performance of the motors right now compared to other EVs so that might be enough to tip the scale. I'd love actual data though.

Re:Tesla Model Y by londons_explore on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:59AM (#19398485)
Big electric motors are actually pretty cheap. They've existed in industry for over a century, and their manufacture is entirely automated. The raw materials cost of two motors each with half the power matches that of one motor.

The motor controllers are probably the more expensive part, although most of the cost there is engineering design cost (much of industry doesn't use fancy motor controllers needed for a car, and cars use high power MOSFETs which are rapidly evolving tech). Tesla designing them in house will eliminate much of the cost over enough volume.

Re:Tesla Model Y by colechristensen on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:47AM (#19396901)
Silicon Valley transport tech needs to visit the north some time. There is going to be a very rude awakening when everyone realizes their machine learning models only handle light rain in the southwest.
Re:Tesla Model Y by dmix on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:05AM (#19396985)
Literally every time self driving cars are brought snow and rain are mentioned as a necessary step for wide deployment.

They were aware of this problem even in the 1990s.

Re:Tesla Model Y by riffraff on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:30AM (#19397069)
software engineers are aware of <DST, weird person names, malicious users, 4-byte UTF characters etc> yet they still write software that doesn't handle them well.

The fact that people abstractly know a situation exists does not mean they will handle it correctly.

Also, remember the issues with "racist" face recognition systems that were trained on non-diverse data sets?

It's not like google engineers forgot black people exist, but I think it's not trivial to pay the proper attention to some problems if they are outside of your daily experience.

Re:Tesla Model Y by CamperBob2 on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:03AM (#19396978)
Don't they sell a ton of Teslas in Norway?
Re:Tesla Model Y by riffraff on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:30AM (#19397073)
they do, due to subsidies and high income.
Re:Tesla Model Y by bryanlarsen on Friday March 15, 2019 @08:33AM (#19399071)
I bet RWD drive cars have fewer fatalities in the snow than AWD drive cars do.

While their ability to go forward is much better, their ability to stop is very similar.

I see lots of SUVs driving stupid fast on snow.

Re:Tesla Model Y by JustSomeNobody on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:21PM (#19401913)
I'm from and in Florida and have never driven in ice or snow. Why not just call an uber on snow days? :)
[dead]
Re:Tesla Model Y by kibibu on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:01AM (#19396970)
It means the power is applied to the front wheels, not the back. Youre thinking of front/mid/rear engine.
Re:Tesla Model Y by xedeon on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:35AM (#19397102)
EV's are also significantly much better at traction control because they can make corrections by the millisecond compared to the lag of a traditional ice car. That is a very important distinction.
Re:Tesla Model Y by josefresco on Friday March 15, 2019 @07:33AM (#19398660)
> they can make corrections by the millisecond compared to the lag of a traditional ice car

Do you have a source on this? I'm curious to read more as I thought modern AWD systems were pretty advanced.

Re:Tesla Model Y by xedeon on Sunday March 17, 2019 @02:00AM (#19412471)
I mean... Traditional cars have to burn the gas and convert it to kinetic energy before it even get to the wheels.

The electric motor just takes the electrons to power without the need for a transmission. In addition, the speed can also be controlled instantly by varying the frequency of the AC power.

But since you asked for a source:

"advantages of powertrain solutions with electric motors are faster response time (order of milliseconds) and possibility of dual direct control either by speed or torque, increasing the flexibility of the control of pitch-plane vehicle dynamics [5]."

https://www.academia.edu/14960312/A_Survey_of_Traction_Contr...

[dead]
Re:Tesla Model Y by jammur on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:16AM (#19397017)
The difference is that a traditional RWD car has a heavy engine in the front, but is being pushed from the back where none of the weight is. So lack of traction and fish tailing is the obvious result.

However, I think a RWD electric car would have less problems with traction (and thus, fish tailing), since the weight is distributed over the length of the car more evenly.

I think push vs pull is legit, but I don't think it would be as much of a problem when all the weight isn't in the front. I'd be interested to hear from some Tesla owners who drive RWD in the snow.

Re:Tesla Model Y by ivan1783 on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:34AM (#19397095)
Not really...check weight distributions for any modern vehicle, you will find the majority of the competent manufacturers get it right around 50/50 front/back. Meaning your FWD Honda has no advantage over a RWD BMW except for the tendency for the Honda to understeer and the BMW to oversteer. This is the main problem in less than ideal traction conditions...
Re:Tesla Model Y by petersellers on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:20AM (#19397353)
Define "competent manufacturer".

I'd be willing to wager that most front wheel drive sedans sold in the US are closer to 60/40, not 50/50. Pickup trucks (very popular in the US) also have a weight distribution much more skewed to the front.

50/50 distribution is more common for sports cars sure but that is not the majority of cars sold.

Re:Tesla Model Y by sliken on Friday March 15, 2019 @07:01AM (#19398490)
This is true, at least for premium cars. However even if the FWD honda and RWD BMW are similar in the flats. The hardest thing to deal with when it's slippery is the climbs, and then the RWD has the advantage.

Even on the flats, when cornering the FWD has the front wheels steering and accelerating, while the RWD uses different wheels for that. Granted not a big difference, especially since when it's slippery you aren't using many HP.

Re:Tesla Model Y by pasta on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:01AM (#19397256)
When the force vector is coming from the back it has the tendency to go into any direction. When there is enough grip in the front you can steer. A heavy engine in the front means even more grip.

But that's all useless on ice. Even if the car was 100% balanced.

Re:Tesla Model Y by semi-extrinsic on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:29AM (#19397412)
FWIW, a traditional RWD car is usually pretty close to 50/50 weight distribution, while a FWD car is usually closer to 70/30.

However a RWD racing car is typically also biased with more weight on the driven axle, e.g. the Porsche 911 is around 40/60. So it's pretty pretty clear that more weight on driven axel == good. It's just not possible to get 40/60 in a BMW 5-series type car while keeping the practicality.

Re:Tesla Model Y by dingaling on Friday March 15, 2019 @07:07AM (#19398531)
Anecdote: growing up in the UK in the 70s / 80s, snow was rare and most drivers didn't know how to cope. RWD was common in Cortinas, Sierras etc but it was the little rear-engined, RWD Skoda Estelle that I remember doing the best in the snow. I particularly remember an orange one weaving past abandoned cars.
Re:Tesla Model Y by lutorm on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:19AM (#19397030)
With "normal" cars, there are two differences between front and rear wheel drive: one is the tendency to under vs oversteer, which does not affect your ability to get going. The other is the fact that front-wheel drive cars have the weight of that heavy IC engine over the driven wheels, giving more traction. Grandparent was pointing out that's not the case with a Tesla.

When I grew up in Sweden everyone had RWD cars and got around fine. But it was common to put some sand bags or lead shot in the trunk to get more weight on the rear wheels. The other thing you need are real snow tires.

Re:Tesla Model Y by fyfy18 on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:28AM (#19397064)
In my country where there is usually snow on the roads, or at least ice, for most of winter, BMW saloons (RWD) are pretty common here too. I think people buy them on purpose so they can slide around tight corners.
Re:Tesla Model Y by _ph_ on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:32AM (#19397088)
RWD is no issue in the snow, if there is enough weight on the rear wheels, as in cars like the 911 and the VW beetle. RWD is only an issue, if the engine is in the front of the car. Most electric cars have the battery in the middle of the car, putting enough weight on the rear wheels. Additionally, traction of electric cars can be controlled much better than with combustion engines.