They won't open a joint savings account for my wife and I because my wife doesn't have a phone bill in her own name "for verification." (We've been on the same Southwestern Bell/Cingular/AT&T, recently T-Mobile, family plan for the past, oh, fifteen years, and it's under solely my name because of employer discounts.)
When I mentioned this to the rep, she told both of us--we were all on speakerphone--that my wife could send in a copy of her driver license. Except Washington doesn't require us to get new licenses when moving and the address on both of our licenses is both the same...and four years out of date.
I get the need for ID verification but funny how we never run into this problem when my wife wants to borrow money in her own name. No one has ever cared about her license or a phone bill when she's taken out credit cards.
When I pointed out that a) he called me and b) this is, quite literally, exactly how scam calls trying to steal money go, he got upset at how I wouldn't "believe him." I told him that's exactly what a scammer would say and hung up.
My "private" information has been leaked to other governments and various malicious actors at least six times, just in 2018, so I'm a little more wary than I used to be and that pissed me off.
I then called Chase and asked if it really was them that called, and they confirmed it was actually them. But then they also apoligized and resumed the previous call from where I hung up.
It was just nice to not be judged for being cautious.
I have multiple Chase accounts in multiple tiers (business, etc...), so my guess is what kind of contact you get depends on the nature of the account.
I see it less as CYA and more as "we can make money off of you so the requirements are relaxed because we're making money"--that is, lending money that she'll presumably pay interest to borrow--versus "oh shit you want to put $1,000 in an account and our bank pay you better do the fifteenth degree."
One day these requirements are going to get out of hand. :D
It says it does here: https://www.dol.wa.gov/driverslicense/moving.html
The "security questions" you choose your answers, in "knowledge-based authentication" the questions and answers are generated based on the information on your credit reports and other databases, such as insurance databases. You don't make up answers, they already know the answers.
Wikipedia refers to "security questions" as "Static KBA".
So, for example, if you always went by "Ron Weasley", having your driver's license , your utility bills, your apartment lease, your animagus registration, and so on all under that name, but your name in their records was "Ronald Weasley", you would be out of luck.
Correct is too easy to guess.
Obviously wrong will be recognised by the customer service representative, who is a kind person, and will help you out by just disabling the question (anecdotes galore for this, to the point we can call it data).
Lie, in a believable way. Put the answer in a password manager. Open your password manager up before calling any CS rep. Be a star in the security theatre. :)
I look forward to password managers including generators for your birth date, family tree, childhood friends, favorite color and maybe also social security number, name and address if those aren't actually required for anything. Then you can have a value for your mother's maiden name that isn't incredibly common, but nonetheless looks like an actual person's name.
Q: Where were you on New Year's Eve in 1999? A: demand-exact-answer-over-phone
Depending on the sources I scanned on the first two pages of results, the cutoff is somewhere between November 2 and November 21.
The thing is, the cost of identity theft of consumers to credit reporting companies is less than the cost to actually adopt secure methods to judge one's credit.
Apparently my bank checks cheques.
I once had to deposit cash in my own account but in different city in India. It was free if I deposited it, but fees for anybody third party. Cashier told me my signature doesn’t match with whats on file and thus either I need to re-sign or need to pay fees.
Here in US I have seen policies in Stores saying we accept check, but we will onetime use the account & routing number on check to pull the amount. I am so confused if by merely giving someone a cheque they are able to “pull” money from just two numbers, and can do it for any amount & any number of times.
That is exactly how checks work. It's optimized for happy-path, with a big mess of a process to handle fraud. The cash equivalent would be to carry a bucket with all your money and when you pay, you present your bucket so that the shop can pull out the amount you and them agreed on.
"Default trust" actually works in our economy. And because of that, friction can be low and things Just Work.
Default trust / happy-path optimization in turn works because of the backstop of a strong legal system, fairly clear precedent, and reasonably well defined property rights. Think: UCC across states; standardized Delaware Chancery precedent; etc.
One reason I'm not a cryptocurrency or smart contracts believer is that the robust exception-handling backstop we have in the US is a mostly-invisible but super-valuable resource.
I find the cryptocurrency "space" fascinating for reasons like this. Because cryptocurrency gets rid of so many of societies long-evolved backstops, it is a perfect demonstration of why our society is structured the way it is and shows exactly what happens when we remove many of its features (eg: removing "trust" is very expensive).
Does it though? I think there's a reason we've stopped accepting cheques - cheques were the best "easy" way to transfer relatively large sums of money at once, now that we're past that and have more secure credit and debit cards cheques are becoming banned. I don't think it was optimized for "happy path" per say, but just for convenience and was the only technology we could manage at the time.
> Does it though? I think there's a reason we've stopped accepting cheques
That's a very specific issue but this is a pretty general fact. With respect to checks, people still write and accept checks, we just have more convenient payment methods. Also checks are still the easy way to transfer large sums of money at many banks. More generally though, just look at how much can be done with a signature under penalty of perjury, and how relatively rarely these are forged. The trust-based system really works decently well in the US.
Humans are great at rallying and pushing and making change when they see identify something as wrong in their direct lives. We work as hard as possible, and develop solutions (vaccines, a strong legal backstop). Then, all is well, and the problems we solved are no longer part of our lives because the system works.
Years later a vocal minority becomes very suspicious (they're inflating away my wealth!, autism!) and tries to overhaul the system. Then they learn why we do things the way we do (scams/manipulation/etc, measles) the hard way.
[1] https://www.occ.gov/topics/consumer-protection/depository-se...
One of mine, too; though only sporadically, it seems.
Now those people at the Board of Elections are hard-core about signatures. I've been hassled twice when trying to vote because my signature on their pad didn't match what is in their records.
I have a "good" signature, and one that looks like a doctor writing a prescription. I have no idea which one they're looking for.
I can tell you that I’ve faked a signature in harmless situations a number of times and nobody was the wiser.
You're technically supposed to sign and endorse the back of every check you electronically deposit; I have never done this since my bank offered mobile deposit and have never had a check rejected. It honestly just makes me sad.
Things like "What's your favorite flavor of ice cream?" Well, I dunno. It depends on my mood.
Or "What if your favorite vacation destination?" Another bad question because my favorite today may not be my favorite when I get back from the next place.
Unfortunately they were all mandatory — there wasn't an option to pick only the sane ones; all ten had to be answered.
Most of them felt more like marketing trying to build a profile on me rather than IT trying to keep my data secure.
Can't do that with United.
The answers are drop-downs.
https://krebsonsecurity.com/2016/08/united-airlines-sets-min...
Whenever I'm confronted with surveillance-based "identification" and I'm unable to just choose a better option like receiving a letter in the mail, I make sure to only answer questions that can be directly deduced from the basic information I've already entered, or otherwise researched online (like the ones about what street is in what city). When confronted with questions about past addresses and whatnot, I make sure to answer "don't know" lest I confirm something they actually aren't so sure of.
I haven't had any problems as a result of doing this. I wouldn't be surprised if there is some "confidence" score based on how much the surveillance databases have actually recorded about you, and even if they aren't super confident will still supply a pass result to keep the client from losing customers.
I would rather be asked my Zodiac sign, although that is definitely weird.
You shouldn't have to spend time doing research on different versions of road names to prove my identity. That's absurd. I can imagine some dystopian future where I'm strapped to a chair and my kidnapper is demanding I answer to obscure names of highways as my only reprieve from torture.
* Decreases the number of bots able to get into your account
* Make it harder for a foreign agent with limited knowledge of English to do the same.
No, I did not write that question for you to answer.
Yesterday, when opening a savings account with a major US financial institution, one of the KBA questions asked for my Zodiac sign. The other two were about a mortgage and the year I was born (±1 year). I do not understand why any competent institution would find these secure and it appalls me that is all the information needed to open an account in my name.
Edit: Here is the screenshot https://i.imgur.com/Mr8gOOA.jpg