I didn't go searching, big was literally the first word on the list I read after going down a few pages, and I wondered about large, so I searched for it. I just looked a bit more, and there's "child", "childhood", and "grandchild", which while not the same problem, does illustrate that they are fairly liberal with their inclusions because they appear to want to use the minimum vocabulary to define something idiomatically, which is a slightly different question than what's the minimum required.
This problem actually seems to share a lot in common with database normalization.[1]
“Our language is an imperfect instrument created by ancient and ignorant men. It is an animistic language that invites us to talk about stability and constants, about similarities and normal and kinds, about magical transformations, quick cures, simple problems, and final solutions. Yet the world we try to symbolize with this language is a world of process, change, differences, dimensions, functions, relationships, growths, interactions, developing, learning, coping, complexity. And the mismatch of our ever-changing world and our relatively static language forms is a problem.” - Wendell Johnson
A great book and fantastic movie.
In fact, it almost seems like there is no other way to describe such problems. They are conceptual, ephemeral, not wholly in the realm of things you can see or witness, but only really describe.
Edit: Some Consequences of Four Incapacities[3] is another that deals with how we understand things.
[1]http://www.peirce.org/writings/p32.html
That's where 1984's "Newspeak" came from. See "Orwell, the Lost Writings".
[1] https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/wordlists/oxford3...
Interesting. But the subject is the nature of the definition. What is the OED definition of definition (circularity intended):
a precise statement of the nature, properties, scope, or essential qualities of a thing; an explanation of a concept, etc.; a statement or formal explanation of the meaning of a word or phrase
Well that's nice. The first component would be amenable to a sclerotic positivism (which denied subjective phenomena as inaccessible to measurement ergo epiphenomena to be ignored; this jettisoned by contemporary cognitivism and phenomenology ); the second addresses the conceptual without a hint of pragmatic methodology; and the salient element of third component is the word meaning which OED defines as:
that which is or is intended to be expressed or indicated by a sentence, word, dream, symbol, action, etc.
So the definition of definition by the ipse dixit English authority on definitions alternates between a call for precision and some rather vague references to intentionality. That was the intent of the above tidbit on the topic of definition. Namely some labels for subjects are amenable to degrees of precision in definition while others with only conceptual referents will have their proffered definitions disputed, diluted, or otherwise hedged and seemingly imprecise.
Steven Stitch in Fragmentation of Reason which is a personal overview of contemporary epistemology alludes to the inherent vagueness of consensual definitions and eventually settles into what he calls pragmatic epistemology
It doesn't matter how contested a word is. You can nevertheless describe its main conventional uses. That would simply be an empirical observation.
Also, just a friendly suggestion: you are writing too much, and using too many long and unnecessary words. Simplicity is often better, both analytically, and to read.
“Put out” also has a zillion variants in those two pages, but itself also is in the list of defining words.
(Though again I'm unsure if the endless English phrasal verbs are counted as distinct in these estimates, not doing which would probably be cheating.)
It's impossible. An English dictionary defined using English words has to have cycles.
It doesn’t list inflections, proper names, adjectives for colors such as yellowish and words used in an entry that derive from that entry (the dictionary mentions blearily and bleary-eyed being used in the definition of bleary)
They also say they occassionally had to use a word not in the list, but don’t say how often they had to. Those words _are_ defined in the dictionary, so it is possible that the reference graph does not have any cycles.
So, I guess 3,000 is a good first guess.