News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by downrightmike on Sunday February 24, 2019 @12:52PM (#19239621)
There is also a meta to this. He is telling people in the past that their children will not have to work as long/hard. In doing this he gives people a dream to think about while they slog away in their own work. It is an escapism fantasy. I've worked at places where they lay people off, half of the group and the other half has to pick up the pieces. a few months later when it gets really bad and people are burning out, a Senior VP comes in to "listen" to people and put up a front that the company cares and tries to sell the employees on the idea that it will get better and that the company only want to keep people occupied 73% of the time. Their numbers I don't know how they came up with that 73%, but people ate it up and still got burned out, all the while talking about how things will get better and somehow that 73% will happen. It never did.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by MRD85 on Sunday February 24, 2019 @02:22PM (#19240093)
The bigger issue is what will happen if our children don't need to work hard. A world where 95% of people don't need to work at all sounds great until we factor in wealth inequality.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by downrightmike on Sunday February 24, 2019 @11:18PM (#19242885)
The same thing is happening today, People without the means have children that may grow up unwanted at a disadvantage, and those who do have the means, have children that they pass those advantages to. There is a reason why Smith and Miller are common surnames, because they had the means to survive and have a source of income and they passed those on. Feudal times are not an unreasonable outcome. We haven't progressed so far that we can't fall back to simpler times.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by hrktb on Sunday February 24, 2019 @05:53PM (#19241184)
I’m intrigued how you see it going.

Currently most employable people are working, and there’s huge wealth inequalities. Do you see people percieving it worse if they didn’t need to work ?

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by thatoneuser on Sunday February 24, 2019 @07:53PM (#19241805)
I think so. I mean yeah lot of people are poor now while working, but at least they have that. If tomorrow everything was automated, we have no structures in place to handle double digit % unemployment. That's now how welfare is designed. So a lot of people would have less than min wage workers.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by MRD85 on Monday February 25, 2019 @03:05AM (#19243902)
I view it largely like I view how we currently treat our disadvantaged. Put them into ghettos, neglect them as much as humanly possible, etc.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by hrktb on Monday February 25, 2019 @06:15AM (#19244752)
I think it all depends on how this happens:

> don't need to work at all

For instance some people currently don't need to work. They are primary care-givers or already retired to give a few.

But we don't put them into ghettos because there is a consensus that we are better with them around than them out of the way, and also they get enough revenue to survive decently (they can get gov. help for that as well)

I think it would be the same if that situation spread to 95% of people, there would be a moment where people will start wondering "is my neighbour a net positive to society ?". People will have a strong incentive to do something that is useful to the group, to keep a modicum of social status. In that sense I don't see society getting worse just because work is not a thing anymore, we'll still somewhat push people to do something, but it might genuinely be useful, for once.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by smallgovt on Sunday February 24, 2019 @03:15PM (#19240360)
Is wealth inequality inherently bad? I've heard of numerous studies that point out that people's happiness and wealth don't correlate much past a certain point. Is that 'certain point' a moving goal post?
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by kartan on Sunday February 24, 2019 @06:06PM (#19241240)
> Is wealth inequality inherently bad?

Lack of agency is. When people are not allowed to take decisions on their own they are unhappy.

Once money covers your basic needs. Money becomes power. High wealth inequality is directly linked to high power inequality.

http://america.aljazeera.com/opinions/2016/2/how-the-rich-co...

- Of the policies listed on the chart, the only one that was passed within four years was the North American Free Trade Agreement, which was opposed by the lowest-income voters and the median voter. On the other hand, the three policies supported by the bottom and middle deciles but opposed by the richest decile — ranging from tax increases to workplace protections — never passed. Across the board, the richest are most skeptical of redistributive policies.

From: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/06/the-bir...

- Rising immobility and rising inequality aren’t like two pieces of driftwood that happen to have shown up on the beach at the same time, he noted. They wash up together on every shore.

So, yes. Lack of wealth inequality is bad.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by BerislavLopac on Monday February 25, 2019 @08:20AM (#19245384)
Wealth and power inequalities are correlated in modern Western societies because they are set up that way. Every society in history has had some level of power inequality, but the source of that inequality varied with different societies, and was not always correlated with wealth.

In Nazi Germany, Jews were traditionally quite wealthy, but they had practically no power; in other authoritarian and/or militaristic regimes, the source of power is usually based on politics or military structure. The power in European feudalism was originally based on land ownership (so wealth-based), but in later stages it became based purely on nobility, so a dead broke nobleman could have had more power than a wealthy merchant (which led to various revolutions).

The danger of equating wealth inequality with power inequality lies in the common belief that removing the former will remove the latter, but this is not the case: it will just be replaced with a different source for the power; a different type of "wealth" if you want.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by gotocake on Sunday February 24, 2019 @04:39PM (#19240780)
That sounds like a case against wealth inequality, since there’s no increase in happiness for the very rich.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by kartan on Sunday February 24, 2019 @05:57PM (#19241200)
> That sounds like a case against wealth inequality, since there’s no increase in happiness for the very rich.

Not necessarily. Inequality seems to bring unhappiness independently of wealth.

You may have more than others. But if you get way less for your work than others, most people will be unhappy. That is why millionaires want more when they see the billionaires.

This video helps to illustrate my point: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meiU6TxysCg

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by downrightmike on Sunday February 24, 2019 @11:22PM (#19242897)
Past a certain point of success, it is only a numbers game. As in once you have achieved your goals and are successful, you are still driven to become successful and money is a tangible way to measure that success. Whether anyone really needs the points to survive is not the question. The question is do they equate money with success?
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by anoncake on Sunday February 24, 2019 @04:40PM (#19240786)
That's one reason why wealth inequality is bad. If someone is already wealthy, additional wealth increases their happiness by less than if someone poorer would have received that wealth.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by StanislavPetrov on Monday February 25, 2019 @03:15AM (#19243953)
> Is that 'certain point' a moving goal post?

No. That point is the place where someone has enough to pay for all the basic necessities of life(food, housing, education, healthcare) without constant economic anxiety over debt, poverty or impending poverty. Studies have pointed out that over and above this point is where wealth and happiness diverge. A 2010 study had that point pegged at about $75,000 for an individual.

https://www.pnas.org/content/107/38/16489

Other studies have shown very similar results, with a sudden drop off in the correlation between happiness and wealth after basic needs have been met. Several are cited here:

https://www.cnbc.com/2015/12/14/money-can-buy-happiness-but-...

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by namirez on Sunday February 24, 2019 @05:15PM (#19240976)
> people's happiness and wealth don't correlate much past a certain point!

Exactly! Most people in the world are well below that "certain point". In an ideal world that everyone has enough to feel safe and secure, probably wealth inequality won't matter as much.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by blueboo on Sunday February 24, 2019 @05:20PM (#19241001)
Except that the only 'wealth' that matters. is that which translates into power. So wealth inequality is power inequality.

That is, wealth inequality is the enemy of democracy.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by dantheman on Sunday February 24, 2019 @06:25PM (#19241328)
If your concerned about power inequality - then we have to worry about politicians, famous people, authors, academics, managers, landlords etc...

Wealth is only one form of power; it is at least achieved in ideal circumstances through voluntary interaction. Whereas many wish to exercise their power through threats of violence.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by emit_time on Sunday February 24, 2019 @04:40PM (#19240785)
> I've heard of numerous studies that point out that people's happiness and wealth don't correlate much past a certain point

That point is significantly above median person income, or a similar comparison to median household income.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by tejtm on Sunday February 24, 2019 @05:10PM (#19240943)
> Is * inequality inherently bad?

Suppose it depends on where you stand (or fall) in the resulting correction event.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by Mikeb85 on Sunday February 24, 2019 @06:28PM (#19241345)
Inequality is bad because those with lots of capital leech off the rest of the economy (rentier class). Economic rents are a drag on the economy. In an automated world where there is no working class, there will be a capitalist/rentier class making income from capital, and a class of people who are essentially on welfare with nothing to do and no way to accrue the capital necessary for social and economic mobility. The end result is class warfare and probably real warfare with less than stellar results.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by x3sphere on Sunday February 24, 2019 @05:11PM (#19240948)
Of course it is a moving goal post due to inflation, rising living expenses, etc.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by pygy_ on Sunday February 24, 2019 @02:48PM (#19240216)
A world where 95% don't need to work is a world where 95% of the people don't have any economic power and will be left to starve.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by Jill_the_Pill on Sunday February 24, 2019 @02:59PM (#19240267)
That sounds like a collective choice, not a logical consequence. Would you ever want to be one of 5% working surrounded by starving people? Or would you work toward some sort of redistribution -- either of resources or hours?

edit: on reflection, probably 95% starving people would accomplish that redistribution pretty efficiently with or without you!

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by maxxxxx on Sunday February 24, 2019 @03:18PM (#19240373)
"Would you ever want to be one of 5% working surrounded by starving people?"

Just go to a third world country or even places like New York or San Francisco. You'll see super wealthy, shiny places right next to homeless people or slums and the wealthy people seem OK with this or don't feel enough discomfort to do anything. Or they just do enough to get these people out of sight.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by watwut on Sunday February 24, 2019 @03:19PM (#19240379)
Looking at history, redistribution does not hapen out of good heart. So yes, 5% will be surrounded by starving people and blame those people.

Also, the 5% is likely to be selection biased for power hungry and ruthless (cause there will be struggle for those 5% positions).

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by burrows on Sunday February 24, 2019 @03:22PM (#19240400)
My Musk-Samsung RoboServant (TM) discourages the ruffians quite effectively.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by coding123 on Sunday February 24, 2019 @04:30PM (#19240729)
Clearly, the 5% would be slaughtered pretty quickly. This is one of the reasons (IMHO) that jobs suddenly open up after things like Occupy, even if there's no tangible or realistic reason why jobs are suddenly needed.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by PavlovsCat on Monday February 25, 2019 @12:51AM (#19243326)
It should console you that you're only getting downvoted because you don't have more prominence. If you did, you'd at least get ignored.

> The frightening coincidence of the modern population explosion with the discovery of technical devices that, through automation, will make large sections of the population 'superfluous' even in terms of labor, and that, through nuclear energy, make it possible to deal with this twofold threat by the use of instruments beside which Hitler's gassing installations look like an evil child's fumbling toys, should be enough to make us tremble.

-- Hannah Arendt

> If machines produce everything we need, the outcome will depend on how things are distributed. Everyone can enjoy a life of luxurious leisure if the machine-produced wealth is shared, or most people can end up miserably poor if the machine-owners successfully lobby against wealth redistribution. So far, the trend seems to be toward the second option, with technology driving ever-increasing inequality.

-- Stephen Hawking, https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/3nyn5i/science_ama...

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by pygy_ on Monday February 25, 2019 @03:56AM (#19244111)
Thanks, I know. I'm not too worried about HN karma.

Also, I don't such a thing to happen. The minute a subset of the economy can work in an automated closed loop (because automation is cheaper than the cheapest human labor), it won't have any economic incentive to do commerce with us, and will instead compete for resources.

Why would it compete? Survival bias. It will have grown in a capitalist framework where weaker, non-competitive players die or are absorbed, and will embody those principles.

    La pluie, ça nous mouille
    et la rouille, ça nous nuit
    Règlons, nom d'un ours,
    le problème à la source

    L'ennui c'est l'oxygène
    qui fait rouiller nos roues
    dentées, c'est l'oxygène
    qui fait rouiller nos clous

    Les tas de viande ils fontt peine à voir
    ils glandouillent du matin au soir
    et ils n'ont plus aucun pouvoir
    y'a plus à s'en soucier

    Les tas de viande ils sont moins malins
    que le robinet de la salle de bain
    du coup ils nous servent plus à rien
    on peut les oublier...

    L'ennui c'est l'oxygène
    qui fait rouiller nos roues
    dentées, c'est l'oxygène
    qui fait rouiller nos clous
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by Ma8ee on Sunday February 24, 2019 @03:30PM (#19240446)
Only if the 95% is left without any political influence. (That political influence is the same thing as money in the US does not mean that that is necessarily so.)
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by JulianMorrison on Sunday February 24, 2019 @03:25PM (#19240415)
No, that's only if it's capitalist.

It doesn't have to be capitalist.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by hitekker on Sunday February 24, 2019 @01:39PM (#19239860)
I believe Yuval Harari in Sapiens once said all social movements start by saying "the world, as it is, is unnatural. At some point, we were moving in the right direction but then we took a detour. We need to get back on track for the world to be natural again."

You are correct that the sentiment of "things will get better, as long as we follow the way" is an empty appeal to the future. But "things use to be better, we've lost our way", that the systems around is are unnatural and therefore wrong, is a powerful drive for a complacent society. A catalyst for social change.

As the oft-repeated 1984 quote goes, "Control the present, control the past. Control the past, control the future."

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by roymurdock on Sunday February 24, 2019 @01:49PM (#19239934)
natural has a completely different definition for different groups of people. was it “natural” for european settlers in America to have slaves up until the 18th century? was it “natural” for native Americans to live communally and without the ideas of property rights and ownership brought over by the Europeans? natural is such a vague and loaded term that its nearly meaningless when applied to “us” as human beings

the real key is labor productivity. unless we invent new machines that make us more productive, and re jump start the demand for skilled human labor as we saw during the various industrialization periods of the last 120 years, then we will continue down a path where humans are less and less valued as their skills atrophy and they can be replaced by automated systems or more often cheaper labor doing a decent job at a much lower rate

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by erikpukinskis on Sunday February 24, 2019 @03:57PM (#19240576)
> then we will continue down a path where humans are less and less valued as their skills atrophy and they can be replaced by automated systems

Have we started down this path?

Are human less valued than they were 100 years ago? 50 years ago? Based on what?

What I see is that there is plenty more work we’re not even trying to do, because we’re busy with the work we’re doing. Just in climate change-mitigating forestry and mental health services, to pick two, there are a billion jobs each waiting to be done. Programming probably also has a billion jobs available. Even cooking, we could move to a personal chef based food system and that would create a billion jobs.

I see no evidence that there is “less for humans to do” today than there was at times past.

I don’t count wage stagnation as evidence because I believe it’s the result of widespread racketeering.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by TeMPOraL on Sunday February 24, 2019 @05:08PM (#19240925)
> What I see is that there is plenty more work we’re not even trying to do, because we’re busy with the work we’re doing. Just in climate change-mitigating forestry and mental health services, to pick two, there are a billion jobs each waiting to be done. Programming probably also has a billion jobs available. Even cooking, we could move to a personal chef based food system and that would create a billion jobs.

There's infinity of jobs waiting to be done. There isn't, and never was, a problem with lack of things for people to do. The problem was and is the lack of things to do for which someone else is willing to pay - which almost always requires that someone else to be able to turn the result they bought into more money for themselves. Mitigating climate change doesn't yield much money to anyone right now, so there aren't many people willing to pay to do it.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by erikpukinskis on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @03:49PM (#19258189)
> The problem was and is the lack of things to do for which someone else is willing to pay

That’s not even the problem. Basically all businesses get started without enough customers to pay the bills.

I think in all the cases I listed there are implicit clients who could pay for the work.

What’s missing is a way to finance the customer development process. People with that skill tend to work on medium sized opportunities and up, and the labor problem is a group of small opportunities that aren’t worth developing on their own.

You have to develop them in aggregate, which is Hard™️.

Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by imtringued on Monday February 25, 2019 @04:14AM (#19244187)
I've never understood this argument. Demand goes up when the price goes down and at $0 or even negative wages demand by employers is infinite. There is no guarantee that a job pays enough to get by.
Re:Workism Is Making Americans Miserable by spynxic on Sunday February 24, 2019 @02:42PM (#19240174)
natural (comparative more natural, superlative most natural) 1. That exists and evolved within the confines of an ecosystem. 2. Of or relating to nature. 3. Without artificial additives. 4. As expected; reasonable. ------ mechanical (comparative more mechanical, superlative most mechanical) 1. (now rare) Characteristic of someone who does manual labour for a living; coarse, vulgar. 2. Related to mechanics (the branch of physics that deals with forces acting on mass). 3. Related to mechanics (the design and construction of machines) 4. Done by machine.

(These definitions were sourced from Wiktionary)

I hope these senses of the terms natural and mechanical help with drawing a clear distinction between what is authentically natural and what is not. If you seek further context about the distinction then search out for senses of the terms nature and artificial. Also, in response to the high regard for labor productivity, remember that efficiency can be a force for both creation and destruction.