News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by strikelaserclaw on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:22PM (#19218500)
- He had received an offer at a start-up, and he would have loved to take it, but it paid half as much, and he felt locked into a lifestyle that made this pay cut impossible. “My wife laughed when I told her about it,” he said. Sounds like a good wife to me, and this "pay cut" is making 500k-600k instead of 1.2 million, what world are these people living in that you can't give up a job that you hate because you can't afford to live on 500-600k.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by naravara on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:28PM (#19218570)
>what world are these people living in that you can't give up a job that you hate because you can't afford to live on 500-600k.

The one where you lock into a mortgage and a car that assumes a $1.2M salary to keep ahead of.

It's really easy to let your lifestyle expenses balloon, especially in a high-COL city where minor increases in living space/amenities can end up costing large amounts of money.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by rglover on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:41PM (#19218745)
Yup. The golden rule: don't ratchet up your lifestyle when your income rises and you'll be far happier in the long run.

Also don't give a damn what people think about you. Typically people get trapped in that mouse wheel because "look what they have."

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by 3pt14159 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:27PM (#19219777)
Yep. And if you get windfall and are really itching to spend it do yourself a favour and research what stuff is expensive but lasts. In NPV terms you'll be saving money, but you won't be pulling on hard-to-escape expenses.

Source: I sold a company and quadrupled my spend on housing. Something stupid that I regret. But I also spent money on high quality stuff that is still lasting almost a decade later.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by naravara on Thursday February 21, 2019 @03:54PM (#19220484)
This isn't really germane to the $500k+ set the article is talking about. Everything you're buying at that tier is going to last. What eats up their incomes is housing, transportation, and stuff like private school tuition and childcare.

The challenge there is it's hard to ramp those down once you lock in. Downsizing on housing means having to move and possibly sacrificing social life and opportunities along the way. Pulling your kids out of private school has consequences for their long term prospects and their socialization. And so on.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by 3pt14159 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @04:45PM (#19220848)
> Everything you're buying at that tier is going to last.

I respectfully disagree. Luxury goods are often flimsy or expensive to maintain (e.g., Toyotas vs Porches) so research is still required.

As for private school and housing, these are exactly the expenses I'm talking about not getting wound up in. I went to private school almost my whole life, and I understand what it is to not want to be pulled away from a community, but the reality is that $500k—let alone $1m—is more than enough to afford a good private school and a good home in any city. The struggle to live on $500k / year is an artificial, self-sabotaging one.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by jseliger on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:28PM (#19219788)
I'm surprised no one here has yet name-checked Tom Wolfe's Bonfire of the Vanities. There is a famous comedic passage in which Sherman McCoy discusses his expenditures relative to his (vast) income.

EDIT:

One breath of scandal—

—his spirits plunged even lower. One breath of scandal, and not only would the Giscard scheme collapse but his very career would be finished! And what would he do then? I'm already going broke on a million dollars a year! The appalling figures came popping up into his brain. Last year his income had been $980,000. But he had to pay $21,000 a month for the $1.8 million loan he had taken out to buy the apartment. What was $21,000 a month to someone making a million a year? That was the way he had thought of it at the same—and in fact, it was merely a crushing, grinding burden—that was all! It came to $252,000 a year, none of it deductible, because it was a personal loan, not a mortgage. (The cooperative boards in Good Park Avenue Buildings like his didn't allow you to take out a mortgage on your apartment.) So, considering the taxes, it required $420,000 in income to pay the $252,000. Of the $560,000 remaining of his income last year, $44,400 was required for the apartment's monthly maintenance fees; $116,000 for the house on Old Drover's Mooring Lane in Southampton ($84,000 for mortgage payment and interest, $18,000 for heat, utilities, insurance, and repairs, $6,000 for lawn and hedge cutting, $8,000 for taxes). Entertaining at home and in restaurants had come to $18,000.

-------------

It goes on. The guy needs Mr. Money Mustache.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by kurthr on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:43PM (#19218770)
Yeah... I literally don't buy it. High Cost of Living city has nothing to do with needing $500k/yr in earnings (post tax). What kind of mortgage and car do you have that? Simple answer... that's a $10M house or a $2M car or half of each of those.

Besides the fact that if you're earning $1.2M salary, you're taking home other bonus/stock that are comparable. Getting locked into this sort of lifestyle is a choice not driven by need. A drug dealer in "low cost" Detroit or Sinaloa might make the same claims...

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by throwaway-1283 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:44PM (#19219400)
Usually when someone mentions a salary figure it's pre-tax. $500k in NYC is ~285k post-tax.

If you have a family, a $1.5m house (which barely gets you a shabby 3-bedroom in a high cost city) will, assuming you put $300k down, be around $8-$10k/month in mortgage + property taxes + insurance + any hoa/maintenence, which is by itself 40% of your monthly take home.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by abrahamepton on Thursday February 21, 2019 @04:13PM (#19220623)
> If you have a family, a $1.5m house (which barely gets you a shabby 3-bedroom in a high cost city)

Uh... median house price in Seattle is less than half that. $1.5 million for a house in Seattle will get you an extremely nice house. Extremely nice.

If you disagree, it's because you have incredibly high standards for what constitutes "nice". That's fine, but it makes it more than a bit silly to complain that you "can't afford" a different lifestyle.

You're just making bad choices at that point.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by throwaway-1283 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @04:21PM (#19220681)
I didn't mention Seattle...I'm referring to NYC or SF.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by abrahamepton on Thursday February 21, 2019 @04:33PM (#19220757)
So literally 2 cities. Wildly expensive cities like DC, Seattle, Boston are still highly livable on $1.5 million.

Honestly, if you're regretting your life choices so severely but you're unwilling to live anywhere but NYC/SF, you're either not really regretting your life choices that much, or you're just really bad at making good decisions with your life.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by throwaway-1283 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @04:43PM (#19220828)
I'm making the assumption that there are more jobs that pay $500k+ in Silicon Valley and NYC. If you can get that salary in 2nd cities like SEA or BOS then of course you're doing better than someone making the same in higher CoL places.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by scottnyc on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:52PM (#19219978)
Article says friend is in Manhattan and earned (i.e. total comp) $1.2mm. Very unusual for anyone in finance to have that high a salary short of being a CEO earning $10mm+.

Suppose he lives on the UWS in a 2000 square foot 3-4 bedroom condo which he bought for $4mm and has a $3mm mortgage. With a 30year fixed mortgage, that's maybe $180k a year. Don't forget the $60+k a year in condo fees and taxes. Throw in anywhere from $40-80k for nanny/childcare/preschool for the 1-2 kids he may have and you already have nothing left over if he went to a $600k comp.

I'm not saying he can't choose to live more conservatively, but when you're used to making $1.2mm a year, it's not hard to imagine how he got here. High cost of living does play a part, especially in NYC.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by refurb on Thursday February 21, 2019 @05:36PM (#19221208)
$1.2M total comp is not that unusual in finance if you've been in a number of years[1].

[1]https://www.wallstreetoasis.com/salary/investment-banking-co...

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by uuwp on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:34PM (#19219281)
More like a 2M house and a 120K car. 500K/year isn't enough to live in a 10M house because it's 20 years of work (30, accounting for other expenses) and that assumes no cut in income. To get into a 10M house one needs to start a very successful business, which is quite possible after all the experience at such a job.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by jhall1468 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:53PM (#19218882)
100% agree. We recently purchased a car. In our case the "expensive" aspect is that we bought new... a new Subaru Outback. We could certainly afford a brand new Escalade, but those types of behaviors would lock me into my current employer or something that pays similarly and that idea isn't something I'm fond of.

And this dude bought that shit despite hating his professional life. Hard to feel bad for him.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ticmasta on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:35PM (#19219292)
I've been in a similar position as you for most of my life. One weird aspect: employers/managers/companies have come to rely on you "needing" the pay cheque as a powerful motivator and control. When you can literally walk away from a job because you don't need the money to make your end of month payments it makes the relationship weird in some aspects. I don't even know if the party who traditionally holds this power consciously realizes it, but in my experience they seem to exhibit less confidence or willingness to play the "because I own you" card. It could also just be that I come across as less of a push-over and they respond accordingly. Regardless, interesting phenomenon...
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by tqkxzugoaupvwqr on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:57PM (#19219550)
I’ve heard it given the name “Fuck you money” – the money you have that gives you the ability to just say “Fuck you!” and walk away from your employment.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by dclusin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:52PM (#19218873)
The median annual earnings of palo altans is about $400k/year. That's probably workable for cheaper areas like south palo alto where a house built in the 80s will run you $2.5 mil. Move closer to downtown and you could easily double or triple your necessary annual take.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by zhobbs on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:02PM (#19218968)
"According to Census data, the median household income in Palo Alto is $137,000 a year, while the US average is $57,600"

from: https://www.cnet.com/news/silicon-valley-middle-class-earns-...

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by poof131 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:27PM (#19219193)
Those numbers don’t remotely reflect the cost of living for people moving to the area now. Prop 13 has distorted things dramatically. In Palo Alto, there are numerous retired people living in houses paying property tax rates essentially set in the 1970s. In fact, Palo Alto has the lowest tax rate in the country by percent since the houses are so expensive but the people pay so little compared to the value.[1] You could definitely live off $500k, but $137 would be really tough to near impossible with a family. Prop 13 has really broken the California housing market.

https://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/news/2016/12/01/pro...

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by vasilipupkin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:11PM (#19219058)
I think this type of Census data understates household incomes. I am not exactly sure why, but Atherton comes in at about 400k a year per household. That is a lot, but doesn't seem like a lot for Atherton.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ryanburk on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:47PM (#19219432)
I believe it is skewed since many people in these neighborhoods aren't making their money through salary income (anymore), but instead through interest / dividends.

If you sold your company, aren't working at FB/goog/etc and are sitting on a ton of stock holdings, your income is going to show as near $0

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by vasilipupkin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @03:38PM (#19220360)
that should be accounted for in govt household income calculations, but I could be wrong. For example, ton of stock holdings will pay you dividends or capital gains.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by throwaway-1283 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:55PM (#19219530)
What you put on your tax return every year doesn't really reflect your actual wealth. Even in tech most people top out at ~$200k-$250k base salaries but you may vest and accumulate millions in stock RSUs that you don't sell in a given year.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ariwilson on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:18PM (#19219719)
Stock RSU vests go on your tax returns.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by throwaway-1283 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:24PM (#19219759)
Ah ok - I'm thinking private shares
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by arcticbull on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:03AM (#19223266)
Those do too. The only thing that doesn't is deferred compensation in the form of an ISO or NSO. The latter is recognized as ordinary income when exercised.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by vasilipupkin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @04:05PM (#19220573)
My working explanation is that it's actually survey data. the richest people either don't answer the survey or understate their actual holdings when they do answer.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by gthippo on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:30PM (#19219800)
Don't RSUs show up on the W-2 as income though (even if you don't sell them)?
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by arcticbull on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:04AM (#19223269)
They do; RSU vesting is a taxable event. It's counted as ordinary income based on the fair market value at the time it vests and taxes are due immediately. Companies tend to withhold a percentage of the shares and sell them to cover your tax burden.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by glitchc on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:38PM (#19219324)
No, this seems right. The typical distribution of income across the pop., even in a distorted environment like the valley, looks far more like a Poisson distribution with a long tail than a typical Gaussian
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by vasilipupkin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @03:42PM (#19220404)
137 is a median. Half the people in Palo Alto make less than 137 in household income? Maybe, if you count East Palo Alto. But Atherton at 443 ( https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-hundred-richest-plac... ) ? seems too low
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by telchar on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:29PM (#19219795)
You don't want to rely on it for means because the high incomes are capped at a relatively low level so that they don't out high-earners in sparse areas. But that shouldn't affect medians.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by zhobbs on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:41PM (#19219373)
I can't find the $400k/year number anywhere. The census puts it at "$250,001" which seems like a fishy number.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by vasilipupkin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @03:40PM (#19220371)
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by glitchc on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:35PM (#19219294)
Stock options are not counted as income. They are exactly that: Stock options. Your income is your take-home pay, specifically gross pay on your stub extrapolated to annual salary.

Yes, there is capital income from stocks and other market investments, but appreciation for those comes under capital gains, which are calculated (and taxed) separately, and don’t count as employment income, for good reason: You can’t use stock options vesting in 4 years to buy food tomorrow or pay mortgage next month.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by caleblloyd on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:30PM (#19219805)
The spread between purchase and grant price for Incentive Stock Options actually is counted towards income for Alternative Minimum Tax.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by gshulegaard on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:40PM (#19219362)
Which makes it ironic that capital gains taxes can bite exercisers before they are actually able to be liquidated.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by zaccus on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:29PM (#19219799)
So... sell your expensive shit and buy less expensive shit. That's what us plebs are expected to do. No one's locked into anything.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by Alex3917 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:39PM (#19218718)
> where minor increases in living space/amenities can end up costing large amounts of money.

It is pretty crazy how little extra money buys you. E.g. in NYC, the only differences between a $2,000 month apartment and a $20,000 a month apartment are going to be things like location, granite countertops, a well-designed bathroom, and better windows. But in most cases the actual floor space and layout is going to be almost identical.

Clearly those things are worth something, but it's easy to see how the work and stress of paying for those accents is to result in a net negative happiness for many if not most people.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by umanwizard on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:19PM (#19219130)
This is not true. $20,000/mo rent in NYC will get you a gigantic apartment (thousands of square feet), as you can verify on any housing listings website.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by Alex3917 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:38PM (#19219335)
It can get you that, but not if you want to be in SoHo on the 30th floor of a luxury building or whatever.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ameister14 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @03:47PM (#19220436)
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by maps on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:41PM (#19218742)
To consume $100k a month we need a $10-20 million dollar mortgage (50-100k/mo depending on years and rate). I have to assume a few cars, dining, etc would probably end up being $10-20k/mo so the mortgage is probably around $15 mil. So in NY or SF you are looking at something like a 1-2k sq/ft 2 bed 1 bathroom shithole apartment. Not so luxurious after all really.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by alehul on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:44PM (#19218793)
Less than $15m could buy a 5 bedroom mansion of a single-family home in San Francisco, and in New York, a ridiculously stunning 5 bedroom apartment.

Where did you get 1-2k sq/ft 2 bed 1 bath shithole from?

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by kurthr on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:46PM (#19218813)
I assume you're being sarcastic... a $15M shithole apartment! X^D
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by maps on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:30PM (#19219229)
Yeah looks like I obviously touched a nerve with some people here I guess?
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by vonmoltke on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:47PM (#19219433)
You didn't touch a nerve. You're out in bizzaro-land. $15MM in Manhattan will get you a brownstone on the Upper West Side.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by umanwizard on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:23PM (#19219154)
Your NYC numbers are way off. Here are some listings for apartments for sale between 9 and 12 million: https://streeteasy.com/for-sale/manhattan/price:9000000-1200...

For those who don't feel like clicking the link: most are very large (5-6 br) apartments, in expensive neighborhoods, in nice new buildings.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by eclipxe on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:44PM (#19218796)
And that's not even taking into account taxes...
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by arcticbull on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:35AM (#19223372)
Yeah, Manhattan real estate is something like $1600/sqft and SF is $850-$1200 unless you want something in one of the fancy new high-rises. $15 million will buy you 12,500 square feet haha. Just check Zillow.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by adamredwoods on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:52PM (#19218869)
Putting kids through school, paying for parent's mortgage, vacation properties, country club dues.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by InitialLastName on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:02PM (#19219586)
> country club dues

> vacation properties

I'm glad there's a "stupid tax" for wealthy people too.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ojbyrne on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:53PM (#19219987)
You're likely not going to get that $1.2 million job unless you "travel in the same circles" as the people hiring.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by toasterlovin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:39PM (#19218712)
So this dovetails with what I think is the most fascinating topic in evolution: the demographic transition in humans. If you're not familiar, demographic transition is the term used to describe what has happened to the demography of nations as they become developed. Which is that, rather than producing more children with their material abundance, people in rich nations have less children. This is not, at all, what biology would predict. More resources should lead to more offspring.

My personal hunch as to what causes the demographic transition is that we have an evolved system for determining whether we are doing well or doing poorly and that system calibrates itself by examining the people around us. But, because our current economic and social system sorts people by income and status (talented people migrated into the cities from farms, even more talented people moved into more expensive neighborhoods, etc.), and because advertising constantly shows us higher levels of consumption to aspire to, even people who are, in an absolute sense, raking in obscene amounts of money are surrounded by a peer group that are roughly at their level. So it never really feels like you're rich; even though you live in a $3 million dollar home, you live on a street with $8 million dollar homes; even though your kid goes to a $30k/year private school, you can't afford to spend $200k vacationing in France during the summer like some of their peers, etc.

Interestingly, this parallels my own experience. As a senior developer, I'm now making roughly 3x what I made before becoming a programmer. Back then I would have imagined that all of my wants would be satisfied by 3xing my income. Yet somehow I still yearn to make more.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by freeflight on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:54PM (#19218904)
> This is not, at all, what biology would predict.

Why isn't it? Afaik in biology, healthy populations tend to be stable populations.

Populations that shrink or grow too fast are often a sign for something going very wrong, usually having to do with sustainability.

That's why I think people in rich nations having fewer children is a feature and not a bug. It's the result of increasing living standards because when you have very low child-mortality rates you don't need to "try" several times to get one into adult age, just like the availability of contraception allows for more reliable family planning.

The same applies to having a social security net: Without that, you have to depend on your offspring to take care of you when you get too old to work/sick.

In a situation like that, more off-spring is always better, as long as you get them through childhood into productive adulthood. Each child is a future potential care-taker and each one of them could end up being a big earner. In that context, a whole lot of people treat getting children like playing the lottery.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by toasterlovin on Sunday February 24, 2019 @12:06AM (#19237228)
Biological organisms are machines for turning energy into additional copies of the genes that created the organism. People in the developed world have access to an obscene amount of energy. Yet fertility rates are below replacement level in basically every developed country (if you don't count first generation immigrants). And when you zoom in, you notice that poor people have more children than all but the top several percent of earners (so fertility goes down as access to resources goes up). If you saw something similar in any other species, it would be the biggest unsolved riddle in biology. Something truly strange. And yet here we are basically not paying attention to it at all.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by gregorymichael on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:41PM (#19218748)
As it says on the wall at Jimmy Johns, "The gap between 'more' and 'enough' never closes."
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by spectrum1234 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:24PM (#19219760)
hahahaa
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by antisthenes on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:13PM (#19219077)
> people in rich nations have less children. This is not, at all, what biology would predict. More resources should lead to more offspring.

This is not correct. Rich people in rich nations have more kids than middle-income people in rich nations. What matters is your comparative purchasing power.

Fertility actually increases with income, even for women with education; this is mostly due to rich being able to afford the costs of child care, and feeling secure enough to invest into all of their children as much as they feel they need to. (whereas a middle-class, educated woman would only feel secure investing into 1 child)

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by reallydude on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:22PM (#19219148)
> This is not correct.

What isn't correct based on what?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by toasterlovin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:28PM (#19219197)
All you really need to know is that developed nations are home to the highest levels of human affluence that have ever existed, at all levels of society. And yet they have the lowest fertility rates ever measured. So low that they are not sufficient to maintain population size.

But if you go even further, you'll see that fertility actually declines with income in developed nations. It's not until you get to the top several percent of income that fertility starts rising again.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by antisthenes on Thursday February 21, 2019 @09:38PM (#19222659)
> It's not until you get to the top several percent of income that fertility starts rising again.

Yes, that's what I meant. You could argue about the significance of the top percentage rise in fertility, but if anything, it shows that fertility is constrained by lack of resources in a significant way as well as education specifically.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by toasterlovin on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:46AM (#19223424)
If fertility is constrained by lack of resources, the why do poor people in the developed world have more kids than middle class people?
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by antisthenes on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:23PM (#19227084)
Presumably because within the budget constraint, the survival rate of many kids will result in a similar amount of kids at the end of the woman's fertility window.

I didn't say it is constrained by lack of resources, I said it's also constrained by lack of resources.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by toasterlovin on Sunday February 24, 2019 @12:13AM (#19237249)
It's probably about whether women are on a career track and, thus, what age they start having children. Poor women generally aren't on a career track. They finish school and start working a job that doesn't require school or much training. So they can (and do) have children pretty early. Rich women do usually go to college, but they meet a future husband there who is on a high-earning career track and are able to start a family relatively early because they don't have to help pay the bills.

What I'm saying, though, is that if you look at the fertility curve[1] you'll see that many middle class families could eliminate one earner and still have 2-3x the income as poor families that have more children. But people are choosing not to do that (well, secular people are choosing not to do that; intensely religious people often do exactly that).

That's what's interesting to me.

[1]: https://twitter.com/CSchmert/status/993934031174725632

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by lotsofpulp on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:43PM (#19218777)
> and because advertising constantly shows us higher levels of consumption to aspire to, even people who are, in an absolute sense, raking in obscene amounts of money are surrounded by a peer group that are roughly at their level.

Animals evolved using competition as a mechanism to select the best mates. Advertising is not the cause, it's the nature of all animals to project power. There might be some people here and there who are satisfied or whatnot, but even without advertising, people would be competing.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by shredprez on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:50PM (#19218848)
This is a fair nit, but still: it's self-evident that modern advertising high-jacks natural competition and amplifies it in order to drive an unnatural level of spending (else companies could just skip advertising and see no change in revenue).

tl;dr Not a root cause, but a powerful multiplier.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by lkrubner on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:04PM (#19219600)
It's also worth examining if our typical ways of measuring inflation (in the USA, the Consumer Price Index, or CPI) is an accurate guide to the real costs of raising children. The CPI currently takes into account a very diverse range of goods, including canoes and guns and lamps and kitchen wares and music and coffee grinders. The CPI tries to avoid the assumption that some purchases are more important than others, but if you are raising children, you know some things are much more important than others. You can cut back on coffee grinders, but you can not cut back much housing -- you need a certain minimum for each child.

My great grandmother gave birth to 16 children (this is my mom's mom's mom) who lived to adulthood. She (with my great grandfather) had no trouble housing them, feeding them, clothing them and ensuring they got educations to at least 8th grade, most to 12th grade. Does the CPI accurately reflect the changing costs of each of the things that were then easy to afford? How much would it cost to raise 16 children now? In theory, we are much more wealthy now than my great-grandparents were in the period 1880 to 1910, and yet they were able to afford something that nowadays would take a great deal to afford. Why is that?

Another thing that the CPI does not capture is how some new expenses have arisen that have become essential. In particular, automobiles. In much of the USA, having an automobile is non-optional.

We should think about those changes in lifestyle that make comparisons difficult across time. My great-grandparents raised 16 children in a dense town where transportation was dominated by walking. If you were trying to recreate that lifestyle in a USA suburb, some odd questions come up. Can you fit 16 children in one car? Do you get multiple cars? Who drives them? These questions point out how difficult it is to make direct comparisons.

Nor is it correct to simply say "No one needs to live in the suburbs in the USA, they can, if they wish, continue to live in a dense urban center". But the USA economy is a cohesive whole, and the existence of the suburbs effects the price of things in the urban core, as well as the focus of transportation infrastructure. Over the last 100 years, most USA urban centers have built significant transportation infrastructure to help workers in distant suburbs come into jobs in the urban core, and then go home at night. The money spent on those infrastructure projects could have been spent on some other priority, but instead were spent as they were because of the existence of the suburbs.

So it is very difficult to make direct comparisons, because some lifestyle changes make direct comparisons blurry. But in that blurriness, we can argue that in important ways our standard of living has not increased as much as the CPI seems to suggest. In particular, for those people who have a strong craving to have a large family, one can reasonably argue that their standard of living has actually decreased over time.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by JackFr on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:51PM (#19218866)
Let's say you've got three kids and you're living on the Upper East Side of Manhattan. Your mortgage and maintenance for a 3 bedroom apartment at $3.5MM are going to be ~15000 a month or 180K a year. Three private school tuitions are 150K. Living in NYC you're paying NYC, NYS and Federal income taxes for probably the highest tax rate in the country. So basically it's easy to be paycheck to paycheck on 500K in NYC.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by umanwizard on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:28PM (#19219203)
It's "easy" to squander almost any amount of money -- even Johnny Depp went broke. But just like Depp didn't have to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars a year on wine, nobody has to live on the UES and send their kids to 50k/yr schools.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by tannhauser23 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:48PM (#19219950)
Yeah but imagine that you already do and now you're explaining to your wife why you want to pull your kids out of their schools and move to the suburbs so you can take a job that pays half what you already make. I'm not saying I'm sympathetic to the guy, but I understand the situation he's in.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by vasilipupkin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:14PM (#19219086)
a problem easily solvable by a move to NJ, which of course, would dramatically increase your misery level. In fact, that's probably why that guy is miserable - he doesn't live in Manhattan and has a 2 hr or more commute every day.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:48PM (#19219446)
There are plenty of wealthy people living a comfortable lifestyle in rich communities off the Palisades pkwy. with a 20 minute hop into the city. 15 if you drive at entitled speeds.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by alexhutcheson on Thursday February 21, 2019 @04:32PM (#19220749)
> with a 20 minute hop into the city.

Maybe early on a Sunday morning? Or maybe if you're stopping the clock as soon as you get to the other side of the GWB?

On a weekday morning, you'd be lucky if you can get from Secaucus to the Manhattan side of the Lincoln Tunnel in 30 min.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by eclipxe on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:34PM (#19218638)
>what world are these people living in that you can't give up a job that you hate because you can't afford to live on 500-600k.

New York City

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by mrfredward on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:02PM (#19218972)
The median income for NYC is $57,000. Surely 10X what a typical person makes is enough for a family to get by, it's just not enough for the lifestyle they want.

Source: https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/newyorkcitynewy...

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by leroy_masochist on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:42PM (#19219385)
You are correct, but if this guy's an HBS alum pulling in 7 figures on the buy side, then he and his family are living the Upper East Side lifestyle which means:

Private school tuition - $50k/kid/year Additional activities such as tutoring, sports, etc - $10-20k/kid/year Mortgages+fees or rent for a 1,500 square foot apartment in a doorman building in East 80's - $75,000-150,000/year Mortgage or rent for country home in Hamptons or Litchfield County - $40,000-100,000/year

Literally half of his income is going to be taxed as an NYC resident. So he's got $600k of cash flow and if he has 2 or 3 kids, the very basic fixed costs of housing and schooling are likely taking up about half of that. With the remaining half he has to pay for food, vacations, cars, clothing, etc, and anything left after that will get saved.

To be clear, nobody is making this guy do this. Nobody's forcing him to "summer" anywhere, nobody's forcing him to enroll his daughters at Spence when PS 6 is free. But at the same time, this is a guy who came up through a system in which preppy affluence was the chosen lifestyle of his "me 10 years from now" role models. As easy as it is to mock the concept of anyone being "trapped" when they make 1.2mm a year, the truth is that stopping his current job would be profoundly disruptive and stressful for this guy, his wife and their kids. So I get where his wife is coming from when she laughs at his mention of the startup.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by scottlocklin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:54PM (#19219515)
> Nobody's forcing him to ...

I dunno, his wife did laugh at his startup job offer and divorce is expensive. Not that I feel bad for the guy, but it is often something like that.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by eclipxe on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:49PM (#19219458)
This guy NYCs
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by sambroner on Thursday February 21, 2019 @03:10PM (#19220133)
Yeah they do. On the nose.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by SpicyLemonZest on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:12PM (#19219062)
Avoiding lifestyle inflation in the first place is definitely part of the puzzle, but it’s not clear that it can dig you out of the hole once you’re in it. Is giving up the lifestyle they want and have really going to make them happier?
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by kirkules on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:39PM (#19219347)
Is an answer of "yes" inconceivable?
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by umanwizard on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:25PM (#19219172)
Plenty of people living in NYC are doing totally fine on a tiny fraction of that.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by rc-1140 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:16PM (#19219700)
That depends on your definition of "totally fine" is and where in NYC someone doing "totally fine" lives.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by justaguyhere on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:42PM (#19218757)
During the 2008-2010 crash, there were reports of many women leaving their wall street husbands when they lost their jobs. I still remember reading about one woman - one of her excuses were that she was no longer able to buy organic fruits (avocados or something) - apparently she only eats organic, and organic everything.

That might be a small example, but it shows the way the wealthy lead their lives. Luxury cars, high end electronics, multiple homes ... they all add up.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by swagasaurus-rex on Friday February 22, 2019 @05:48PM (#19229859)
Did those wives have any way to make the kind of money needed for their lifestyles themselves?

After all, it's not like wealthy bachelors were common during the recession.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ChuckMcM on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:25PM (#19219770)
Contained in that question is a really interesting bit of learning.

There are many ways to go through your career and your 'wealth' cycle. What worked for me was that when ever I got a raise or "extra" money (bonus, stock vesting, etc) I always adjusted my savings rate so that my take home pay was unchanged relative to inflation. The company gave me a 10% raise and inflation was 3%? I added 7% of that raise to my savings rate. As a result, my savings grew and my lifestyle didn't change, I could always "live on" a much more modest salary than I was being paid. That gave me tremendous flexibility in being able to take jobs that had a 'pay cut' but had other aspects that made them desirable (learning something new, opportunities to develop a new skill, more fun, Etc.) And after a while the amount of money your "savings" is kicking off gets to be more and more significant. If you're lucky, then one day the number your savings is kicking off is the same amount you're paying yourself out of your own paycheck and then you can walk away at anytime, keep your life style, and never have to work again. That gives you a tremendous amount of flexibility in how you spend your time.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by vitaflo on Thursday February 21, 2019 @02:47PM (#19219933)
>what world are these people living in that you can't give up a job that you hate because you can't afford to live on 500-600k.

The same one where a dev making $160k can't give up a job they hate because they can't afford to take a job paying $80k.

Everything is relative. To many Americans and $80k desk job is the lap of luxury. To many devs, that pay would be insulting.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by rwc on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:24PM (#19218520)
Not sure how you're interpreting the "good wife" but I interpreted her reaction as laughing at the notion they could afford to live on anything less than his current 1.2m salary.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ForHackernews on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:30PM (#19218588)
I believe OP is being sarcastic about "good wife".
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by projectramo on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:00PM (#19218944)
I bet its mostly taxes and real estate.

City + State + Federal taxes are around 50%. So $600k. Private School per kid is $50k. Assume two kids so about $100k.

Okay, now a 4 bedroom apartment in NYC is like $25k/month (on Zillow, eyeballing it), or about $300k/year.

You're down to $100k-$200k for food, vacations, clothes, cars etc.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by scarmig on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:38PM (#19219323)
> You're down to $100k-$200k for food, vacations, clothes, cars etc.

Oh, the humanity.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by projectramo on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:57PM (#19219540)
You're doing fine, but at $600k, you'd be taking home $300k, and then its all going on rent unless you downsize drastically and move out of private school etc.

I'm just explaining why the move would feel tough for a family.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by dangwu on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:27PM (#19218553)
It’s not about living on 500k vs 1 million. It’s about much, much earlier retirement.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by lovecg on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:40PM (#19218734)
To expand on this, many people who make this much as employees have a great deal of anxiety about the future of tech, and a reasonable doubt that this level of income cannot continue indefinitely. From that point of view it seems foolish to walk away from the opportunity.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by swagasaurus-rex on Friday February 22, 2019 @05:50PM (#19229875)
People outside of tech have anxiety about the future of tech.

People inside tech having anxiety about it?

Seems to me the anxiety has far less to do with tech than with the nature of the economy and employment in general.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by joncrane on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:36PM (#19218678)
For many readers here, and adherents to the FIRE philosophy, sure.

But to most people who actually make $1.2 million per year, it means giving up all kinds of status symbols and creature comforts. Many of which they are locked in to via mortgages, leases, etc.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by smacktoward on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:29PM (#19218575)
More likely it's about keeping up with the Joneses. If all your old school friends are making $5 million, it pains your status gland enough to "only" be making $1 million.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by JackFr on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:36PM (#19218674)
The funny thing is when you move from making $1mm to $5mm you pick up a different set of friends to keep up with.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by smacktoward on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:38PM (#19218701)
It's true, the coke dealers don't really hang around until you reach a certain income threshold.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by minikites on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:31PM (#19218603)
I don't understand the mindset of burning yourself out in middle age so you can "enjoy the world" when you're much more likely to be frail and have serious health problems that prevent you from participating in many activities.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by seveneightn9ne on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:08PM (#19219033)
If you make 1.2 million a year you could literally retire after 1-2 years and live comfortably (on ~40k) for the rest of your life. Want to live on 100k? Only takes 4 years.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by eclipxe on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:51PM (#19219474)
Taxes.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ojbyrne on Thursday February 21, 2019 @03:09PM (#19220124)
And inflation.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by cat199 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:33PM (#19218631)
Is it?

Many people could retire after one year at 500k or 1M because their cost of living is such that they would be able to save almost all of it, and this would spread across their retirement..

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by pjc50 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:41PM (#19218744)
The average UK private pension pot is £100k ... this implies that either people with £1m should be retiring earlier, or we'll have a generation who can't afford to retire.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by CamTin on Thursday February 21, 2019 @03:53PM (#19220477)
The situation is similar, if not worse, in the US, and the latter is true: absent government pension programs like Social Security, almost nobody can afford to retire. Social Security is the retirement plan for regular people. Basically only union workers with defined-benefit pensions and high-salary professionals who are able to fund their 401(k) meaningfully have any kind of plan for retirement besides living on Social Security. The luckiest can also draw on help from family, life insurance, and getting part-time work as e.g. a Walmart greeter.

Thinking about retirement savings at all is kind of a luxury.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by madengr on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:42PM (#19218762)
Even a poverty level wage (for family of 4) is $25k/year. So $500k over a 20 year retirement sounds like a lot, but it’s not.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by cat199 on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:03AM (#19225884)
not saying it's easy, and no, doesn't sound like a lot.

but it's possible, is my point - the difference on whether it is possible or not possible is the lifestyle one chooses to lead with it.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by minikites on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:58PM (#19218926)
You're leaving out the compound interest that could be earned through stocks/bonds.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by madengr on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:17PM (#19219111)
Yes, but even bonds don't keep up with inflation, and you need enough principle to ride out the dips. The "safe" return is considered to be 4%, which is $20k on $500k, so you'd be dipping into the principle even on that poverty scale.

It just take a lot more to retire than the average person realizes, and not eat Alpo.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by uptown on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:32PM (#19218623)
What world are they living in where startups are paying $500-$600k?
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by dilyevsky on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:35PM (#19218657)
If “startup” means “pre IPO” then there quite a few places in town that go up to this for very senior roles.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by nemo44x on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:57PM (#19219548)
I think a lot of people here don't realize how lucrative the sales roles in tech companies are - if you're good at it. Top sales reps often make more than than top level managers.

I estimate the top sales people are the highest compensated people in a company. It is true meritocracy, however. You are judged on a single metric more or less and the bottom of the group is dismissed without second thought.

You can make a great living on the engineer side of the operation and it's steady but you'll never see the highs of the top sales people even when you're at a point with stock and salary being many hundreds of thousands.

It's not a life for me but I have nothing but respect for the effort, time and relationship building great sales people put in. It's a hard, competitive ladder but if you make it work you'll hit high 6 figures and at times 7 figures for many years.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by eclipxe on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:39PM (#19218722)
Uber, Lyft, AirBnb....500k+ for Sr & Manager roles.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by ransom1538 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:27PM (#19219192)
Sales. If you bring in 20million in accounts. A 1 million paycheck is just a write off.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by entee on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:36PM (#19218677)
Could be a sales gig, commission can push total comp quite high, particularly in enterprise sales gigs.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by throwaway-1283 on Thursday February 21, 2019 @01:05PM (#19218995)
Take home pay in NYC on a $500k salary is ~285k/year or $23.75k/month. If you are supporting a family, then rent + living expenses + tuition + retirement + college savings etc will eat most of that easily.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by dudul on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:27PM (#19218558)
The way I read this part is that his wife laughed at how ridiculous the idea of taking a 50% pay cut was. I think that she was the one who couldn't imagine living with 600k instead of a million.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:43PM (#19218775)
Let me guess: he lives in San Francisco?

Ok, looks like it was actually New York, but under the same principle: golden handcuffs.

Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by majani on Friday February 22, 2019 @01:47AM (#19223612)
In my experience, for men it's usually some combination of women, children, addictive substances and "stunting" that finds guys in that situation.
Re:America’s Professional Elite: Wealthy, Successful and Mis... by onetimemanytime on Thursday February 21, 2019 @12:36PM (#19218676)
Making $1.2 Mil and probably spending already even the future raises that may not come. Your lifestyle adjusts to your salary.