A $200k/year graduate starting salary is enough to get a lot of people to set their values to one side for a while.
Personally, this doesn't really go against my morals or values. They installed the app. No one forced them to. Not everyone has the same set of morals and values you do. If it's not illegal and no one is harmed. I don't care so much.
I can't prove a negative. So you would have to prove the positive, what harm came from this app?
Would you say that the current political climate has been harmful? I would. I would not only say that, but I would also say that it's come about specifically because of data collection practices which have enabled data analysis of entire populations in a way which has never been seen before.
While analysis of populations is not inherently bad by itself, the outcome certainly has been, particularly because the abilities and effects are so new that there's little or no law governing people towards positive effects for society as a whole. Without those laws, the effects become geared toward benefiting people at the top either directly (company CEOs) or indirectly (capabilities sold to those who can afford them).
Seriously, look at the state of peoples finances. That's the cause. Look at the amount of money the rich have compared to those who voted for Trump, Brexit, etc. Look at the quality of life. This has been coming for a long, long time. Blaming on Facebook and Twitter is not very insightful of the state of affairs in the world today.
My understanding is the entire Cambridge Analytica thing is about privacy and not actual harm from the Facebook aspect.
At scale, such behaviour cannot possibly be good for democracy.
But it seems very much like there is an attitude like working for Facebook or Google is amoral. That I don't believe. Especially when there are companies sell software to track phones secretly to countries like Iran. That's on the border of amoral.
Then why do you assert it as being truthful?
The history of FB's data collection practices is replete with "harm".
And prove the "harm" in its data collection practices. Since you've been very specific in data collection, I will expect your response to be about data collection.
It’s an ongoing source of debate and confusion as to what Software ‘Engineer’ means.
Someone likely will do nearly every unethical thing, but that doesn't mean it is right for anyone to do it.
It would be too much to expect engineers to somehow be angels without the threat of punishment when even doctors need these systems.
But on the other hand, imagine if you heard about this agile thing but you can’t legally apply it because waterfall is mandated and if you apply agile you might be stripped of your license to practice software engineering.
This isn't a very meaningful statement as people widely disagree about what the ethical action is.
Facebook in general seems to have good intentions and terrible awareness of what is crossing a line. They really wanted their platform to be the center of everyone’s lives and now appear completely unprepared for the consequences of pushing that agenda so hard.
-- Upton Sinclair (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upton_Sinclair)
These are good people. They just don’t care.
I think these two statements contradict each other.
Like most things, these things are points along a spectrum, not absolutes. Even that is probably too simplistic - points in n dimensional space I guess :)
It's a given assumption that anyone who once worked for a shady company is also shady?
There's a reason that these companies do what they do. Fraud, breaking the law, and dark patterns are way easier ways to make money than doing so do ethically and legally. Companies either die a hero or live long enough to become a villain.
I'm exaggerating a bit, but realistically the list of ethical tech companies is a lot shorter than the list of unethical ones.
There are levels and degrees of bad behavior.
Facebook is rotten from the head down.
The data collection gives power to those who hold the data. Having all data on someone gives absolute power. It can be both looking at intimate data to directly manipulate or dominate a person, or apply data science to an incredible detailed corpus of data, and in the future learn things about individuals and groups that we can't even fathom.
> literally killing someone
You’ve presumably not read about Myanmar or fbs involvement in organising genocide?
It mostly bothers because it seems like a great deal of the recent hate towards FB is because people blame them for Trump. If Clinton wins I don't think people care.
That said, yes I think FB should do a better job of "know your customer" when selling ads. Obviously they shouldn't sell ads to Russian intelligence. But it doesn't bother me all that much. For one, I don't think it had that big of an impact. For two, it's a dangerous path to go down when you start questioning if your political opponents have the right justifications for their votes.
>You’ve presumably not read about Myanmar or fbs involvement in organising genocide?
Which part of that involved a FB employee going out and literally killing someone?
In relation to fb, do you see any problem with what happened in Myanmar? They allowed the organising of a genocide.
I have previously worked with developers in start-ups and was amazed to hear some of their backgrounds. One previously worked for a company that bundles spyware with freeware MSI products. Another worked for an airline agency, where they advertise fake a discount on tickets when the price was in fact higher than market. Needless to say, their actions outside the work environment matched their actions inside.