It is infinitely cheaper to develop things in-house or with smaller software shops, But then you won't be able to interface with your factory's material providers' system, or other Banks, etc because they only talk some protocol that is copyrighted/trade secret of those firms.
They are not fighting google. Google just happened to enter in the cross fire and have deep pockets to fire back! What oracle (and others like IBM behind the scenes, via DC Federal Circuit "lobbying") are fighting back, is the freedom of smaller software shops to provide their clients with fully compatible offerings to their money cows.
This is the only time someone conscious of freedom and privacy should be rooting for Google.
Thanks for this summary! I had no idea this was the underlying reason. I feel silly now because I thought it was just some weird obsession of someone in Oracle's C-suite.
In this situation, a significant new revenue stream ( an Android tax) is definitely worth fighting for. And Ellison loves lawyers; he even sued to compete in the America’s Cup...
New Zealand sued to challenge Dennis Conner off cycle, and when Conner pitted a cat against a mono hull, New Zealand sued again.
Except that there is no hope of that ever happening. Even if Oracle won in a big way, then Google would eat the one-time cost of deprecating the Java API on Android, similar to what Apple did between Objective C and Swift. There is no sustainable revenue stream there.
Then it could be announced that the Java API will be removed in a specific future version (so update your applications now), the Google Play cut of applications using it will now be 50% instead of 30% for those without it, some of the OEMs will immediately start selling phones that don't have it and those phones are less expensive so people will buy them and developers will have to use the new replacement to reach those app customers, etc.
Forcing a transition to happen faster is not fun, but that isn't the same as not possible.
Cases tend to run back and forth until one party gives up, or goes bankrupt. Lords, even SCO v Linux is still going.
Sorry, how could that be an upside? It's plain, zero-sum rent-seeking. I.e. only an upside if you happen to collect the rent.
It is zero-sum iff the benefit to Oracle is exactly equal to the deadweight loss imposed by the tax.
I tried to calculate this in the simplest econ 101 way, and got a surprising result. I would appreciate someone else commenting...
Assume that the schedule of supply and the schedule of demand are straight lines. We have three groups: (1) purchasers of phones; (2) vendors of phones; (3) Oracle.
In the absence of a tax imposed by Oracle, an equilibrium quantity Q_e of phones trade at an equilibrium price P_e. [1] This generates gains from trade, producer and consumer surplus, equal to the area circumscribed by the schedule of supply, the schedule of demand, and the line Q = 0.
When Oracle imposes a fee on phone sales of value F, the price and quantity-traded of phones adjust. The new quantity traded Q_f is lower than Q_e, and the new price P_f is higher than P_e. The gains from trade are now the trapezoid circumscribed by the line Q = 0, the line Q = Q_f, the supply schedule, and the demand schedule. The missing gains, the deadweight loss, are equal to the triangle circumscribed by the line Q = Q_f, the supply schedule, and the demand schedule.
Oracle receives F×Q_f in fees, a benefit equal to F×Q_f.
The deadweight loss is a triangle with base F and height (Q_e - Q_f). It is therefore equal to (F×Q_e - F×Q_f)/2.
Balancing the gains to Oracle against the deadweight loss, we see that they are equal when Q_f is one third of Q_e, or in other words when the fee is so massive that it cuts the quantity traded by 66%. If Q_f is larger than that, the benefits to Oracle exceed the loss imposed on purchasers and vendors.
This result would seem to imply that we could improve the efficiency of the marketplace by allowing random third parties to impose large taxes on pretty much any good. This is hard to believe. Where did I go wrong?
[1] In reality, there are a variety of models available at a variety of price points. This doesn't affect the problem I have with my result, though it is probably relevant to the phone market in specific.
You inverted the sign. The zero sum thing is the prospective transfer to Oracle. If you pay $100 and Oracle receives $100, net across everyone is zero.
Then whatever lack of commerce caused by the higher prices occurs is a deadweight loss with negative sum. You start from zero and go down.
To get a positive sum you need to be creating something with value greater than its creation cost.
After the fee, there's less producer surplus, less consumer surplus, and more Oracle surplus. As a consumer, I don't see which part of the price of the phone goes to the producer (generating metaphysical good) and which part goes to Oracle (generating metaphysical evil). I just see that the phone is worth more than its price by an amount equal to my consumer surplus. My surplus is measured in dollars just like Oracle's surplus.
But it seems that after Oracle imposes the fee, it generates so much Oracle surplus that it could cover the deadweight loss out of its own pocket and leave everyone better off. This is surprising.
I think your comment is mostly correct, but I'm going to try to put it in terms that make more sense to me.
The answer is that the loss of producer/consumer surplus is being calculated incorrectly. Deadweight loss is the triangle described, but the loss of consumer surplus is more than just the consumer-surplus part of the deadweight loss. It also includes the rectangle separating the price the consumer would pay in the absence of the fee, P_e, from the price the consumer does pay, P_f. My mistake isn't that I inverted a sign, it's that I compared the wrong quantities -- I included a benefit to Oracle without accounting for the cost to consumers and producers who are still willing to trade under the new regime. (Where the deadweight loss only includes consumers and producers who were willing to trade under the old regime, but not under the new one.)
(bananamulch and 34624523 both said the same thing I'm saying here.)
> When Oracle imposes a fee on phone sales of value F, the price and quantity-traded of phones adjust. The new quantity traded Q_f is lower than Q_e, and the new price P_f is higher than P_e.
The producers/consumers combined would lose both the oracle tax and the deadweight loss (lack of opportunities that otherwise would have occured).
But then again, what if phones have a negative externality from a society where no one talks to eachother? The oracle tax might be good for society.
I don't think this is necessarily true. Google and/or handset vendors could just eat the additional cost and keep prices the same for consumers.
I saw a lawyer's office earlier. Big logo said "We fight for fair". Sure, per minute.
The law is in general a good thing, but you have this whole business going that is from a fundamental point of view just meaningless. This business is about patent claims, and often all it manages to do is stifle innovation.
You could argue the productivity of both these specialities.
It would be obvious if someone's shopping around a loan, to the extent that it was very easy to get a broker to send over a competitor's offer sheet so you could compare.
People hate finance because at the core it's sales and you make your keep by being predatory since everyone does it. If you don't, you sink.
BT Section A is the case.
While I think this lawsuit is terrible and I hope Google wins the legal case, from a moral standpoint they kind of acted like assholes back in 2005 when they decided to fragment the Java ecosystem rather than negotiating a licensing deal with Sun. So now we have real Java in multiple JDK / JRE implementations plus this weird pseudo-Java offshoot in Android. The language used by Android looks a lot like Java but it hasn't kept up with improvements in the core language and standard library, so now developers can't reliably reuse code across those platforms. That harms the software industry as a whole.
There are plenty of commercial 3rd party companies selling alternative JVM implementations, none of them has ever had any issues with either Sun or Oracle.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Java_virtual_machines#...
Probably because Sun went along with it, so why bother?
Now they deserve everything they will get out of this.
It’s also cheap marketing.
They are maintaining/improving the barrier to entry.
The industry's, justified, hate for Oracle is blinding them to the larger underlying concern.
Many people forget that Oracle technically won the legality of the last case, hence why we're here. They just weren't awarded damages. Even the judge didn't buy Google's arguments about open source or compatibility concerns.
That's why all the rulings keep getting overruled. The lower court judge is sane (he's actually awesome, you should check out Alsup) and keeps ruling in accordance with established case law, and the appeals court (who shouldn't even be answering copyright questions) keeps going 'nah, all that case law is stupid'.
Hence why this should go to the supreme court who'll most likely tell the court of appeals for the federal circuit that they can't just go make their own law.
Read the original ruling.
That's not true and doesn't really fit within any legal timeline. That's my point.
Can you point to what part of this ruling sided with Oracle on either technical or legal matters? (With the exception of rangeCheck.) Or can you link to what ruling you mean by "the original ruling"?
That said, it is common wisdom around F/OSS folks that you can't take other people's interfaces and change the license on it, e.g., I can't write and distribute a proprietary Linux kernel module using EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL functions. I haven't seen a good analysis of whether this case is relevant to that—would a Google victory mean that VMware's use of vmklinux is legal (well, at least in the US), that ZFSonLinux is in the clear, that Nvidia can write proprietary drivers using dma-buf, and that CLISP should have been able to use readline without relicensing itself under the GPL?
That is because by using EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL functions you are invoking code that is GPL'ed. If you made a clean room implmentation of a kernel that exposed the same interfaces as Linux, you could licence it anyway you want.
So I think there are only two interpretations. One is that EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL attempts to claim a copyright on the interface, and not the code. The other is that redistributing a GPL-incompatible object that invokes GPL'd code is always infringement, and (possibly) the special exception for userspace in Linux's copyright statement, https://github.com/torvalds/linux/blob/master/LICENSES/excep... , is the only thing that makes normal userspace processes non-infringing, and that regular EXPORT_SYMBOL is basically also an explicit exception (which may or may not even be legally meaningful - during the dma-buf discussion, various copyright holders expressed that they did not interpret EXPORT_SYMBOL as an exception).
What does this have to do with anything? If you think this is a relevant statement you are severely confused about the current subject matter and what is being argued in court.
Please explain how the above statement is relevant to the current case.
My claim is precisely that this is not a relevant statement.
Are you contending that interfaces and API's are not software and do not have software licenses around them?
Because that is a severely mistaken belief on both a technical and legal level.
Yes, on a legal level.
From a technical perspective, interfaces in, say, C are mostly compiled out. There is no place in a (stripped) binary where you can point to a structure definition. There is a place you can point to names of functions that are yet to be dynamically linked, but only their names, that place is different from the program code (text section) itself.
None of this is to say interfaces are not an important part of software engineering. Interfaces, APIs, internal zero-cost abstractions, tests, comments, design documents, threat models, bug triage, commit messages, code reviews, operational techniques, runbooks, monitoring and alerting systems, end-user documentation, etc. are all important work products in the discipline of software engineering. They're also all (IMO) something different from the software itself.
"Software" is code. An interface is the expectations of code.
In particular, if software X implements interface A, it is possible to write a compatible drop-in replacement of X using software Y, which does not incorporate any portion of software X, is it not?
GNU libc and Apple libc both implement the UNIX libc interface. If you claim that an interface is indistinguishable from software, is there a portion of the GNU libc software that also present in Apple libc? Where is it? Can you point to it? (The source code of both is public, so this should be easy for you to do.)
Google gave another example in the blog post: the interface of keyboard shortcuts. If I implement a text editor that uses Ctrl-X for cut, Ctrl-C for copy, and Ctrl-V for paste, have I copied the software of another text editor that uses that interface?
> An interface in all its various forums as we understand interfaces are placed in binary. From object implementations to ABI's and API's.
An API, an "application programming interface," is distinguished from an ABI, an "application binary interface," precisely because it does not mandate what appears in the binary.
If you think that there is in fact a way where you can point to a structure definition in a compiled C object file, please identify where it is in this object: https://godbolt.org/z/SVhsJk
What does Oracle, who practically prints money, expect to get out of this other than exercising a fleet of expensive lawyers? At best the case was always iffy and even if they "win" it's unclear what that really means for them given the inevitable subsequent legal maneuvers. Even more puzzling is how are they making the argument that Google has, in any way, harmed their business?
It's just mind boggling. A slip-and-fall insurance scam makes more rational sense to me.