News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by chasingthewind on Thursday January 24, 2019 @01:22PM (#18991349)
Unions would very likely increase game prices. I will happily pay more for games in exchange for better conditions for game developers.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Wohlf on Thursday January 24, 2019 @01:57PM (#18991748)
Game prices have already increased via less consumer friendly practices. Predatory monetization schemes like lootboxes (i.e. gambling), DLC (mixed bag), cosmetics, always online DRM, company specific storefronts, digital sales, "early access" and releasing unfinished games have all reduced costs and increased profits while sticker prices remain static. Sticker prices have even gotten better sometimes since many games go on deep discounts quickly.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by astura on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:38PM (#18992132)
Looking at the bigger picture, as a whole, adjusted for inflation, looks like games have actually gotten a bit cheaper. An NES game was $30-$40 in 1988[1], that's $65-$85 in 2018 dollars.

You also have a whole category of "basic" games (like phone games or indy games) that are nominally (unadjusted) cheaper than a retail NES game for the full version. I'm not an expert on this category by any means but I bought a few games from the Switch store that are very comparable to an NES game for $5-20. That's only a max of $9 in 1988 dollars!!

I'd agree that "consumer [un]friendly practices" are still a problem though. (could be a case of a few "whales" making large purchases on stuff like loot boxes subsidizing everyone else)

[1] http://videogamecomicads.blogspot.com/2012/12/sears-nintendo...

DISCLAIMER: I only play single player console games.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by toufiqbarhamov on Thursday January 24, 2019 @04:04PM (#18992950)
Don’t buy the industry bullshit. They’re making record profits through gambling and micro transactions.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/mattperez/2018/05/08/electronic...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pHSso2vufPM

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by astura on Thursday January 24, 2019 @04:18PM (#18993055)
Perhaps you're replying to the wrong comment? I certainly didn't say, nor imply, they weren't. Nor am I "buy[ing] the industry bullshit" (whatever that means), I'm speaking as an end consumer.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by devwastaken on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:49PM (#18992243)
Have to adjust for amount of buyers too though, and the cost of different kinds of games.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by astura on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:12PM (#18992457)
When someone says "X has gotten cheaper" they mean when you walk into a store and buy X you pay less than you did in the past, either in real (adjusted for inflation) or nominal (unadjusted for inflation) dollars.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by tapoxi on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:28PM (#18992042)
They've also decreased, a $60 game in 2006 should cost ~$75 today. Prices haven't kept up with inflation.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by nightski on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:36PM (#18992117)
Most games have $80-$120 editions that include all of the actual content. $60 is usually the bare bones experience. That is on top of monetization in game.

But prices don't exist in a vacuum either. The gaming market has exploded and is vastly larger than it was back in 2006.

Steam found games were typically much more profitable when heavily discounted than when full price in general.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by root_axis on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:40PM (#18992157)
This is not typical of "most" games. Some games, usually AAA titles from major publishers do this, but the content is usually unimportant to the game as a whole.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by nightski on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:47PM (#18992224)
The discussion is about unionization. I'd assume that means we are primarily talking about AAA here. But I could of been more explicit.

How much of content offered is sort of irrelevant. A better metric would be how many gamers buy these things. I'd guess quite a few since they keep going all in on the model (it's getting worse).

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by lozenge on Thursday January 24, 2019 @05:37PM (#18993757)
I always got the impression it was to give gaming journalists something to write about. I never met anybody actually buying these special editions.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by shittyadmin on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:41PM (#18992177)
Except now they have an additional "season pass" for nearly the same cost of the game for what used to be included for free.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Thaxll on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:08PM (#18992420)
This is wrong because you assume that content from the season pass is already ready when the game releases. Season pass is a different term for expansions that you used to pay in the past.

I've seen that on Reddit as well, you think companies have a year worth of content and holding onto it ... The content is just not ready / created.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by shittyadmin on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:10PM (#18992443)
What? No where did I suggest that content was ready to go - I'm simply stating that a finished game now has less quality content for the same price than it used to.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Thaxll on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:20PM (#18992520)
Again do you have proof for that? Because I'm pretty sure game have more content nowdays than they had 20 years ago,
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by TheGRS on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:23PM (#18992541)
I really can't agree with that. A small minority of games are like this yes, Battlefront 2 being the shining example of bad monetary practices. But something like RDR2 or just about any RPG is packed with content.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Thaxll on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:27PM (#18992579)
How so? BF2 has a ton of content for $60 and you don't have to pay for it.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by TheGRS on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:44PM (#18992736)
I won't argue if you thought it was a lot.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by tapoxi on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:48PM (#18992237)
I can't think of games in 2006 that offered additional, free content. They sold them individually as map packs or weird, one-off add-ons (Horse Armor).
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by shittyadmin on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:49PM (#18992249)
Horse Armor was basically the start of the bullshit, I'm not referring to additional free content, - but to match older games in terms of quality play time you often need that season pass.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by cwyers on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:57PM (#18992323)
Play time is a terrible measure for cost of creating a game. Yes, maybe the average playtime of old NES games was shorter, but the amount of artists involved was minimal and they didn't do it by having more content, they did it by stealing coin-sucking GAME OVERs from arcades.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by shittyadmin on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:03PM (#18992374)
I care about quality play time over just about any other metric. How long is a game actually enjoyable - maximizing that seems like it should be the clear goal, no?
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by tapoxi on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:02PM (#18992370)
I can't think of a game that is shorter than its predecessors and requires a season pass purchase, or really any 'essential' DLC for a single player game at all. With regard to multiplayer games, they don't have a cap on playtime and traditionally sold expansions (for example Battlefield 1942 Road to Rome).
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by shittyadmin on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:04PM (#18992391)
Multiplayer games are often particularly brutal about this though - if you want to be able to play with the largest population you need to buy the latest content expansion - this didn't used to be the case, compare Call of Duty 4 with the newer Black Ops series for example.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by dijit on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:47PM (#18992230)
Example of a $60 season pass?
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by sovietmudkipz on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:57PM (#18992319)
Battlefield games and call of duty games come to mind. You can buy the DLC a la carte when it’s released or spend on a season pass to get all DLC when it’s released.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by tapoxi on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:04PM (#18992387)
Battlefield games no longer have a season pass.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by shittyadmin on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:06PM (#18992410)
Fallout 4 on release had a $60 season pass - last one I ever paid for. But many games are still doing it, I see black ops 4 has one of similar price, as does Civ 6.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by dijit on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:15PM (#18992479)
Fallout 4 had a $49.99 season pass which was an increase from the previous $29.99[0].

Black ops 4 had one for $40[1]. Can't seem to find historical info about civ6, but I know a "large expansion" was not included in the season pass.

[0]: https://ew.com/article/2016/02/17/fallout-4-season-pass-pric...

[1]: https://www.polygon.com/2018/6/13/17447600/call-of-duty-blac...

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by shittyadmin on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:22PM (#18992534)
Maybe it was after release but I seem to remember the prices matched of the title and the season pass, I'm not in the states though so perhaps an international pricing difference, you get the point though, $50 is still nuts. I've edited the parent appropriately. I suppose the ~$100 range is more correct than the $120 range for a full game these days.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Mirioron on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:32PM (#18994125)
Every single game does not have this.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by SolaceQuantum on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:17PM (#18991959)
I would be incredibly supportive of a game developer union in which developers can push back against being made to practice these unethical behaviors.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by starik36 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:35PM (#18992107)
Unions traditionally are there to defend the interests of its members, not to address consumer related unethical behaviors.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by tivert on Thursday January 24, 2019 @04:25PM (#18993136)
> Unions traditionally are there to defend the interests of its members, not to address consumer related unethical behaviors.

Many unions and guilds have codes of professional ethics. A quick google finds this example:

https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibili...

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by SolaceQuantum on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:41PM (#18992172)
I guess I was thinking more like a guild, then? I licensing boards? "Sorry I can't shove random RNG-for-money, boss, I'll lose my membership/license".
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Apocryphon on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:20PM (#18992516)
These union-skeptical comments like the GP rely upon the assumption that unions a hypothetical tech union would look identical to failed unions of the past, and are incapable of doing anything different.

Example of a modern non-American union where workers exert control to better the company over management decisions:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13986889

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by mikepurvis on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:13PM (#18991913)
I've really appreciated Skill Up's commentary on this, particularly in the context of his AC: Odyssey and COD: Black Ops 4 reviews:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOrKtZsoy30

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HL8HfoCzCB0

Both are thoughtfully argued and well worth watching.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by dragonwriter on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:57PM (#18992324)
> Game prices have already increased via less consumer friendly practices. Predatory monetization schemes like lootboxes

I suspect loot boxes decrease the price of a game to the median player. I suspect that in many cases, they've reduced the modal and often even median price to $0.

The probably also increase the mean price, though.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by jressey on Thursday January 24, 2019 @01:54PM (#18991716)
Labor cost does not determine a product's sale price. That is a disastrous myth. Demand changes selling price. If a company cannot price to sell to their demand because of capital or labor costs, the free market has stated that the business is not viable.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Wohlf on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:01PM (#18991803)
You are correct, but I would caveat that labor cost is just one of many factors in determining the minimum price a product can be profitably sold at.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by jakeinspace on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:15PM (#18991926)
For any particular company or even country to some extent (since the games industry is quite globalized), this is true. However, if there were widespread unionization among many of the biggest studios then that could conceivably lead to a market-wide price hike, which would be largely absorbed by consumers due to a lack of suitable substitutes. Yes, the supply/demand equilibrium point would shift and demand would likely drop somewhat, but I think it's quite likely that the market demand for top-tier games isn't perfectly elastic.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Retric on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:22PM (#18991991)
The optimal selling price for a game does to change becase developers add a fixed cost.

Suppose you have 1 Billion in fixed costs and 1$ in per unit cost and are given two options. The equation is just (number sold) * (unit price - unit costs) and that 1 Billion dollar fixed cost is irrelevant when maximizing profit (or minimizing loss).

What it would do is reduce the number of games created, as the industry becomes slightly less profitable. Which would then spread consumer spending over fewer titles and thus recuperate the burden of a union.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by TheGRS on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:27PM (#18992575)
This is the current problem with the game market. There was a race to the bottom in game prices over the course of the last 8 years that's caused many titles to barely break even. Throw in an over-saturation of developers who are willing to price their products for less and you have an industry that is sustained through people chasing their dreams while eating ramen for dinner.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by redorb on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:22PM (#18991995)
Labor / Employee costs is a lot of the times the most significant costs to a company. It's not the sole determination but it's definitely one of the top 3 factors Labor (forever and growing) > Infrastructure (large but incremental) and R&D (medium and ongoing)
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by jressey on Friday January 25, 2019 @02:30PM (#19001543)
Right, and if the costs of running your business are greater than the revenue you can generate from market demand, then you are not running a viable business.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by walshemj on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:58PM (#18992885)
Depends on industry film has a high labour cost because you pay actors a lot - I suspect the % of film labour costs due to Bectu/ ISATSU members is not that big.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by jshowa3 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:32PM (#18992078)
It really doesn't matter what the market bears because software is so malleable that companies spend dozens of hours creating loot box systems, marketplace systems, data driven pricing models etc. to squeeze every last dollar out of the customer, regardless of whether the demand is high for these things or not. It doesn't matter if their product is half broken or is barely a product at all, as long as they can create 50,000 skins. Then again, I'm not sure what demand for these systems are, but considering how universally detested they are, I would assume not much.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by darawk on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:15PM (#18991931)
> Labor cost does not determine a product's sale price. That is a disastrous myth

It's not a myth. It just depends on whether the pricing is demand driven or supply driven. Commodity products absolutely have their prices set by costs (labor among them).

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by naravara on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:40PM (#18992158)
Maybe. It’s also possible that being less able to offload the costs of bad project management onto your workers will just make them pursue more realistic project plans.

I see lots of AAA games loaded down with unnecessary cruft that adds little value to the overall experience and it makes me sad to think a bunch of poor devs probably had to grind through crunch to add it.

I expect it’ll be a little from both columns.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by astura on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:02PM (#18992368)
Genuinely curious as to what you consider "unnecessary cruft."
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by klodolph on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:22PM (#18992533)
If you look at most AAA games from a structural perspective, they are generally composed of many systems and modes of play. Compare to indie games, which typically have a much smaller number of different systems and modes.

Think of a first-person shooter. You can add the ability to upgrade weapons and armor (a system) and add a fishing minigame to provide resources for upgrades (a new mode of play).

Specifically, look at Just Cause 4. Your basic systems core to the gameplay are shooting things, the grappling hook, the parachute, the wingsuit, and vehicles. The unnecessary cruft is stuff like your ability to upgrade the grappling hook, the deployment of squads to capture territory, and supply drops.

My impression is that AAA studios aren't stupid... they know that these extra systems and modes don't contribute much to the game. But they do contribute to customer's evaluation of whether the game is worth spending $60, and this contribute's to the bottom line. This is the same reason why manufacturers pack needless features into a product and skimp on core functionality. People are more likely to shop on the basis of feature lists than on the quality of core functionality.

This is why I'm skeptical... the unnecessary cruft is there because it drives purchasing decisions, so it's not going away unless you change the way people purchase games.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by naravara on Thursday January 24, 2019 @04:05PM (#18992960)
Others have mentioned RDR2 and the upgrade systems in Just Cause. They're both right and symptomatic of the larger problems.

I think Ubisoft games are the worst at this. Tons of experimental or different game elements that don't contribute to the core game. You can play chess or other board games in the middle of Assassin's Creed III. It does nothing. They had this whole city-building subgame that added nothing. They had an inchoate pirate game in there that was actually engaging enough that they made an entire sequel centered on it, but it added nothing to the actual ACIII game itself.

I can see evidence of all sort of "wouldn't it be cool if. . ." features that really don't need to be there and I can't help but think that if PMs actually had to think through what they're trying to do with their game they wouldn't do this as much. Bioware actually admitted to this after Mass Effect 3, claiming that they had never managed with so many resources at hand before and they couldn't really resist the impulse to bite off more than they can chew. This led to them adding in a bunch of extraneous side-quests and stuff that they didn't really get a chance to put enough time in to do it justice or make it worth anyone's while.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Jare on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:24PM (#18992549)
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by TheGRS on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:28PM (#18992592)
Well, RDR2 for sure. So much in that game is there to make the game world realistic and beautiful (and it succeeds greatly!), but not a lot of attention to lasting gameplay.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Jach on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:02PM (#18991815)
I'll happily pay the lowest price they'll sell the game to me for, and routinely wait for years after a game's initial release to get that low price. Nothing stops you from buying multiple copies of a game you like and want to support. Or going to https://www.mobygames.com/ and looking up the Credits for a game you like to find the devs to contribute to directly.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by jonathankoren on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:33PM (#18992086)
How do you contribute to a dev directly? Also, how do you decide who to contribute to?

When it comes to AAA games (which is who is really exploiting their employees rather than indies) it sounds like you're picking someone at random, (e.g. "Today's your lucky day Shading Engineer #4, please accept this venmo.")

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by TheGRS on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:21PM (#18992525)
We pay so little for games these days. Even the big titles still sell at $60. They inflate the price through DLC and other add-ons, but it does seem like something like a RDR2 should cost at least $80-100 these days.

The unfortunate side-effect is that smaller studios often charge much less for their titles than what they should in an effort to please customers who are conditioned to pay very little, and then can't make up for price in volume.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by TulliusCicero on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:25PM (#18992562)
> We pay so little for games these days.

It's true. A lot of people complain about $60, but that's significantly cheaper than what NES games cost back in their heyday (adjusted for inflation).

And just look at not just team size and effort (probably 50-100x comparing modern AAA games to NES titles), but amount of content: most NES games used difficulty to pad out their length greatly; a gamer who's reasonably skilled at, say, Contra, can beat it in like 30-60 minutes. In comparison, a game these days with a 6 hour campaign is thought of as pretty short, and usually they have other content other than campaign: challenge modes, multiplayer, minigames, etc.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by TheGRS on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:35PM (#18992647)
Its a weird industry. If you're there for appeasing people who enjoy art, story and gameplay, there's now a market for that. And those people don't mind either paying a little more for the title nor a 2-3 hour long game, as long as the experience is great.

But if you're there to chase teenagers for their parent's money, or even just the lowest common denominator of gamer, you'll probably have a bad time. Those customers want very long campaigns, AAA graphics and as low of a price point as possible.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by reading-at-work on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:34PM (#18992639)
This is pure speculation, but I'd imagine they would increase game quality too. Many AAA games are heavily marketed but lacking in depth and features; it would make sense that if game designers had more power in the organizations they work for, they might be able to push back against unrealistic publisher-driven deadlines which lessen game quality.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by cazum on Thursday January 24, 2019 @01:35PM (#18991497)
Game prices are going to increase anyway.

Last year, EA made over a billion dollars in profits. If they aren't using that money to improve the working conditions of developers, what makes you think the solution is to give them more money?

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Rebelgecko on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:02PM (#18991809)
When you look at the prices of the games themselves, they're fairly cheap today. For the last couple console generations, the cost of a new AAA game has been consistently around $60. A NES game 30 years ago could cost $50, but when you take into account inflation that's about $100 in today's money. Companies like EA seem to make up for that by selling more copies of games, having deluxe editions, and jamming in microtransactions.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by falcolas on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:16PM (#18991936)
Only the most bare-bones version of a AAA quality title will cost you $60; the absolute minimum of content which could still be called a game. To get access to all of the content (frequently including story content), you're looking at a $100 starting point ($70-$90 for the "deluxe" edition, $30 for a "season pass"), going ever-upwards with the more in-game content and physical ephemera you want.

And that doesn't include any in-game transactions.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by maccard on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:04PM (#18992389)
>Only the most bare-bones version of a AAA quality title will cost you $60; the absolute minimum of content which could still be called a game

That's fairly disingenuous - the last game I bought at full price was Spiderman. A quick Google says the the average user on the default difficulty clears the story in about 20 hours.

Sper metroid came out in 1994 (25 years ago), and the same quick search says that most people will clear it in 8 hours or so.

Single player games today are also regularly putting out free balance patches (nioh), large free content updates(Gran Turismo) and smaller chunks of paid content that rival the size of other games for very reasonable amounts (Witcher 3).

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by zeroname on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:46PM (#18992755)
The production value behind those "bare bones" titles is still magnitudes larger than what you had back then, while the "play time" is at least comparable.

Statistics show that most people never finish the games anyway (I certainly don't) so it's only fair that those people who must really play everything pay extra.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by manfredo on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:05PM (#18991845)
Developers will probably just move development to Asia or Eastern Europe. At the end of the day, unionized devs will be at a substantial competitive disadvantage against ones that are willing to put in more work.

We all say we'll happily pay more for the same product. But those words often aren't backed up by actions.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by otikik on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:38PM (#18992130)
"Unionized" is not the same as "not willing to put in more work". It's more about "not willing to put up with more bullshit".

Developers who actually sleep and spend weekends with their families produce a better product than those who just accept dead marches. If managers are aware that they can not get away with those shenanigans it's possible that we'll actually get better games.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by manfredo on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:49PM (#18992776)
> "Unionized" is not the same as "not willing to put in more work". It's more about "not willing to put up with more bullshit".

The point is, though, many people are willing to put up with that "bullshit" (which, judging by what you say later, mostly revolves around working hours contrary to what you write in this first paragraph). As much as we try to convince ourselves that crunch time and long hours don't work, plenty of studios demonstrate that is does. RDR2 is probably one of the best games of 2018 and it relied on crunch time. At the end of the day, a studio that can't demand crunch time is going to be at a disadvantage compared to those that can.

In an ideal world we'd all have well paying jobs in fields we love that offer good work life balance. But we don't live in the ideal world, we live in the real one. And many game developers are willing to make the sacrifice of long working hours.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by otikik on Friday January 25, 2019 @06:26AM (#18997128)
It's not work if you are just looking at your monitor like a zombie. That's just heating the chair with your butt. So yes, bullshit. If a manager doesn't realize that, he should be fired.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by zeroname on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:53PM (#18992825)
You didn't address the more important point: Managers can get away with it by moving production to cheaper places. It's already happening anyway.

What a lot of people don't realize is that unions can also cause wage suppression when they decide that more members working is better than fewer members working at higher pay.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by otikik on Friday January 25, 2019 @06:24AM (#18997120)
Managers can also get fired when they plan unrealistic goals or keep changing signposts instead of forcing the devs to solve their problems. Unions can make that happen.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by SeanBoocock on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:39PM (#18992139)
Game developers already heavily use outsourcers and freelancers, many of whom based in South America, Eastern Europe, and Southeast Asia. The biggest games will have hundreds of contributors from internal support studios in places like Romania in addition to external partners.

I expect this trend to continue along the lines sketched out by the film industry: smaller core teams with specialized support studios/groups brought onto projects as needed and heavy use of contractors to scale staffing at different points of the project. This works in Hollywood in large part due to the union protections afforded to that temporary workforce, from actors to camera operators to screen writers.

As it stands now, video game development looks a lot like the (film) VFX industry and I think both are in an untenable place for long term sustainability. Something needs to change and I think organizations like SAG are a model for that.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by normal_man on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:41PM (#18992171)
If developers could cut costs by outsourcing, they'd do it whether the workers unionized or not.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by manfredo on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:52PM (#18992811)
Many already are. Unionizing would likely accelerate that shift.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by ryandrake on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:17PM (#18992501)
Also, if developers could simply increase prices, they would, regardless of what their labor costs were.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by zeroname on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:55PM (#18992858)
They are doing it. Outsourcing has a cost unto itself though, just like unionizing has a cost.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by the-pigeon on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:15PM (#18991928)
And the game quality would suffer.

General software development gets moved overseas and comes back all the time.

Software development is hard. Pushing it to a cheaper third party usually increases costs a lot in the long term due to the increase is development complexity and generally a decrease in worker skill.

A strong union can also prevent companies from moving some jobs overseas.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by manfredo on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:22PM (#18991988)
> And the game quality would suffer

The Witcher 3 was a pretty good game (Polish developers) - many would call that an understatement. The Uncharted series since 2 or 3 relied heavily on outsourced development (especially for art assets). Arma 3 was developed by Czech devs. These countries probably produce lower budget games on average, and don't have lots of existing infrastructure to leverage. But that makes what they have accomplished all the more impressive given what they were working with.

What makes you so confident in the class that developers in countries with lower costs of living are worse than ones in wealthy countries? Do you think that Polish or Bulgarian developers are on average worse than American ones, and it so do you have something to back up that claim?

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by Jach on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:28PM (#18992038)
There's also, I dunno, all of the Japanese games that people love. Chinese companies are also starting to increase and market overseas, and some of those games are high quality. South Korea too. Asia is a powerhouse for entertainment software, even if we might argue they have a long way to go for business/enterprise/SaaS software.
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by magduf on Friday January 25, 2019 @02:24PM (#19001476)
Japan has been a powerhouse for games since the 1980s. Have people forgotten about the NES?
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by yarosv on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:58PM (#18994277)
Witcher 3 or Arma were not outsourced. They were developed in house (in Poland and Czech Republic respectively).
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by manfredo on Thursday January 24, 2019 @07:13PM (#18994362)
Moving development doesn't necessarily entail outsourcing. Publishers can contract foreign developers for the whole game. Blizzard is already doing this with Diablo Immoral, handing development off to NetEase
Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by zeroname on Thursday January 24, 2019 @04:09PM (#18992991)
> General software development gets moved overseas and comes back all the time.

General software development also isn't unionized. As soon is it is, moving overseas becomes vastly more attractive.

> Software development is hard. Pushing it to a cheaper third party usually increases costs a lot in the long term due to the increase is development complexity and generally a decrease in worker skill.

What's actually harder about outsourcing is management and quality control. The developers in cheaper countries aren't somehow inherently worse.

Many publishers have studios around the world, working on entire games by themselves. Why keep funding an expensive studio in the US that's getting unionized? That better be high caliber, which most studios aren't.

> A strong union can also prevent companies from moving some jobs overseas.

Maybe in a big monolithic company, but that's not how game publishers operate.

Re:Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize by hawski on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:53PM (#18992287)
I would guess that maybe just less games would be made.