The prosecutorial advantage is even bigger in grand juries (ie. the juries that decide whether the suspect will be charged or "indicted" with a crime), where only the prosecution's side is heard and the standard used to indict is much lower than the "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard used in a real trial. The running joke being that a good prosecutor could indict a ham sandwich.
It's after indictment but before trial that the prosecution pressures the defendant to take a plea deal (ie. plead guilty to reduced charges) to avoid risking going to jail for a much longer time and bearing the insane expenses of a trial.
To my memory, in the US only something like 6% of indictments actually go to trial, where (as you point out) the prosecutors have a huge advantage. 94% of the time inicted defendants plead guilty and never actually get a trial. In some cases, like with Aaron Swartz, they commit suicide.
So for the overwhelming majority of cases, it's not what happens at trial that matters (as they never get a trial), but rather what happens in the even more skewed for prosecutorial advantage grand jury that matters -- a grand jury where defendants and defense attorneys are not even present and where their side is not heard.
>90% percent of defendants plead guilty before trial because 90%+ of defendants are actually guilty of the crimes they've been charged with. In most cases, the defendants accept their guilt and are simply trying to get the best deal (i.e., least prison/jail time) as they can.
Except that a disproportionate percentage of poor defendants (who can't afford expensive lawyers) plead guilty before trial because their overworked and underpaid public defenders advise them to.
Logic is that pleading guilty before trial gets you a shorter sentence than going to trial. The alternative is going to trial and being incorrectly found guilty and getting a larger sentence for a crime you didn't commit (your public defender has limited time/resources to make a great case for you).
The American Justice system is particularly unjust to the poor.
Edited for clarity
No, a disproportionate percentage of poor defendants plead guilty because they're actually guilty and their underpaid public defenders have advised them its not worth the effort to fight the charges--for the PD or the defendant.
Especially since, as you helpfully pointed out, the DA is less willing to give shorter sentences to guilty defendants who demand a trial. In this context, "shorter" meaning shorter than the likely sentence imposed by the judge after trial, usually even shorter than the statutory range imposed if the defendant is found guilty at trial. This is why defendants plead before trial--in many jurisdictions its the only way you can get a sentence less than the range unless you have a fantastically expensive lawyer (like the lawyer for Brock Turner, the Stanford Student Rapist).
The alternative is going to trial and being incorrectly found guilty and getting a larger sentence for a crime you didn't commit (your public defender has limited time/resources to make a great case for you).
You appear to have a Law & Order understanding of how criminal defense works. In the real world, even private attorneys spend most of a case attacking the DA's case, not building their own case. The Defendant doesn't need to prove anything.
Every part of the American justice system pushes people towards confessions:
a. People are sent to jail pre-trial. This automatically disrupts their lives, as even a few days in jail will often cost them their jobs. [1]
b. People can be kept in jail for months pre-trial, costing them their houses and possessions as well.
c. The government can freeze or seize a defendant's assets (effectively without cause), rendering them incapable of defending themselves. They can (and do) hold these assets hostage to coerce a confession. Thankfully, the worst of these practices have been struck down recently [2]
d. Being unable to pay for your own defense lawyer gives you at best an overburdened public defender (poor defense), and at worst no legal representation whatsoever (no defense) [3]
e. Bail eliminates the only remaining way to avoid jail for the poor or those with frozen/seized assets [4]
f. Overly harsh penalties make it too easy to completely destroy someone's life forever. Even 10 years is ridiculously high, especially considering there's no path to reintegration into society in America. You're pushed outside and left, destitute, to your own devices. It's far preferable to start with a scarlet letter now than in x years, older, less employable, with zero assets.
g. Plea deals, while well intentioned, have become de-facto extortion due to the other problems in the American system. "Take the deal or else we'll keep you in jail, and maybe even tack on a bunch of extra charges to keep you here for decades". Even without this problem, plea deals are a corruption of justice. Either someone is guilty and deserves the punishment, or they don't.
A conviction rate above 80% is automatically suspicious, simply because no police department is that efficient. America's conviction rate rose from 75% in 1972, to 93% in 2012, and is still rising. Couple that with an incarceration rate rivaled only by authoritarian regimes, and I'm VERY suspicious of statements like "90% of defendants are guilty".
[1]
https://www.americasquarterly.org/aborn-prisons
[2]
http://www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/court_says_crimin...
[3]
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/inside-new-orleans-public-defen...
[4]
https://eu.tallahassee.com/story/news/2018/08/23/federal-jud...
https://eu.usatoday.com/story/opinion/policing/spotlight/201...
Article is a quick read and does a good job explaining the mindest of people who plead guilty to crimes they did not commit: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/inside-new-orleans-public-defen...
While in THEORY it should give them more time to prepare, more than likely you'll get 20~30 minutes of prep time either way on the day of your trial but spend longer in jail just waiting.
If you have a private defender, it might make a lot of sense to waive, since they can use that additional time to assemble enough evidence for either court or a better deal.
But in modern US "justice" even if you're innocent expect to take a plea. That's just how it works now.
That makes sense, but there's a coordination problem. If everyone invoked their right to a speedy trial, the system would indeed collapse under its own weight. But the first set of people to use that strategy would be at a disadvantage since their own lawyers would have less time to prepare. Everyone wants to take advantage of this right but no one wants to be the sacrificial lamb, especially since there's not even a guarantee that enough other people will follow suit (your "sacrifice" might really be for naught).
Yes, and it is glorious...from the perspective of a defense lawyer. Because as soon as the DA realizes they can't just railroad defendants, they start getting realistic about the plea bargains they offer and which cases to triage due to lack of evidence.
I've seen it happen before (the entire local defense bar refused to wave speedy trial rights) and the DA held out for about 1.5 days before buckling.
But professional judges oversee jury trials. I sat on an 8 week trial and the judge very tightly controls prosecutorial conduct, with usually the defense raising objections.
Also just from the plot summary I fail to see how it could even be relevant.
(Also: Like Camus' The Stranger, Kafka's Metamorphosis is an extended metaphor, so a plot summary won't help much.)
There were acquittals in 3/5, mostly on the basis of the prosecution doing a poor job of questioning their police, or the police playing dumb for reasons unknown. In one case it was hard to acquit as I think the defendant committed a serious crime, but the prosecution case sucked.
I'd love to see the differences between counties and type of defense representation and jury selection. How much of this is due to awful public defender practices or other abusive practices?
The public defender is key as jury selection is critical.
If you’re a defendant and you think you have a better shot with a jury, you choose a jury trial. If you think you have an unsympathetic but legally justified case, you pick a bench trial. Either way, it’s your choice, and I have difficulty understand how it could be inferior to a system where you’re deprived of the choice and subjected solely to the judgement of an unelected permanent bureaucracy.
I can assure people that years of legal dedication and training and the connections to get a judgeship does not by any means mean that someone is a good judge, and I’m becoming increasing convinced it has a pernicious impact on the legal system as a whole.
The only cases I ever lost were bench trials (before judges, no juries) where the judges refused to accept scientific challenges (backed by actual research) to the prosecution's pseudo-science evidence.
And therein lies the problem. In every trial, you have professionals (lawyers) playing against novices (jurors), and since the prosecution automatically gains special believability status in the eyes of jurors, they hold the upper hand. To make matters worse, prosecutors have the automatic full cooperation of police, whereas the defense has no such guarantees. And since prosecutors are gauged by their wins, and high ranking prosecutors are the most likely to be voted/appointed into coveted judge seats, there is a perverse incentive to prosecute the innocent.
But since the system operates on the fiction that all members are equal (much like all sides are equal in a game of poker), it's easy to brush aside the reality that they are most certainly not equal, and that the more experienced has such a huge advantage that it's laughable to even call it fair.
In a system with professional judges, that wouldn't fly, as the trained judge would see through their shenanigans and rebuke them.