News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of... by Amezarak on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:50PM (#18994227)
For some reason every time the topic comes up, people come out of the woodwork talking about how bad the jury system is for defendants, while ignoring this exact point: the defendant has a right to a jury trial, but he can waive it and have a bench trial instead. In fact, the state would much rather you waive your right to a jury trial since they’re more expensive and much more of a procedural drain on the court system.

If you’re a defendant and you think you have a better shot with a jury, you choose a jury trial. If you think you have an unsympathetic but legally justified case, you pick a bench trial. Either way, it’s your choice, and I have difficulty understand how it could be inferior to a system where you’re deprived of the choice and subjected solely to the judgement of an unelected permanent bureaucracy.

I can assure people that years of legal dedication and training and the connections to get a judgeship does not by any means mean that someone is a good judge, and I’m becoming increasing convinced it has a pernicious impact on the legal system as a whole.

There are no comments on this comment yet.