Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of...
by staticautomatic on Thursday January 24, 2019 @01:32PM
(#18991449)
I agree with some of your points but if you think judges are the answer I'd guess you haven't met many judges.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of...
by gamblor956 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:00PM
(#18993938)
I agree. Juries are far better at understanding science than judges.
The only cases I ever lost were bench trials (before judges, no juries) where the judges refused to accept scientific challenges (backed by actual research) to the prosecution's pseudo-science evidence.
Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of...
by staticautomatic on Thursday January 24, 2019 @07:21PM
(#18994403)
Yeah. Jury consultant here. Juries definitely have their problems but a lot of the scary bad things I've seen happen in trials have stemmed from bad rulings by the judge. I'm reminded of a case I had where the judge refused to DQ an expert economist who produced a damages model with a p value of 0.5 (yeah, not 0.05). Basically all the defendants had to settle because it had the judge's imprimatur and they wouldn't be able to convince the jurors it was bullshit. It's easy to blame juries when there are bad outcomes but a lot of the time their bad decisions are precipitated by bad rulings.