Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of...
by kstenerud on Thursday January 24, 2019 @02:49PM
(#18992248)
No, by professional judge I mean in the German style, where the judges decide the verdict, are not elected, and must undergo 5 years of schooling and a one year apprenticeship, plus have a ton of legal work experience.
Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of...
by scott_s on Thursday January 24, 2019 @03:22PM
(#18992537)
More on the German style, "Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979)", https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5059044. Although I have read that they use plea bargaining more now. While the lens of the article is on plea bargaining, it gives a good overview of the German system.
Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of...
by gamblor956 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @05:58PM
(#18993924)
The German style is horrible. Read the Metamorphosis by Kafka for a German perspective of their criminal justice system.
Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of...
by chmod775 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:13PM
(#18994021)
A 1915 book created during a time when Germany had a justice system that has since been changed significantly at least twice?
Also just from the plot summary I fail to see how it could even be relevant.
Re:American justice system ignores science in the pursuit of...
by gamblor956 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @07:04PM
(#18994304)
The German system's primary changes since Kafka's days were the introduction of US-style procedural protections. My point was that having the judge act as judge and jury in all cases is a worse option that having the option to use juries.
(Also: Like Camus' The Stranger, Kafka's Metamorphosis is an extended metaphor, so a plot summary won't help much.)
But professional judges oversee jury trials. I sat on an 8 week trial and the judge very tightly controls prosecutorial conduct, with usually the defense raising objections.