News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:16AM (#18945778)
I am afraid I am risking to be misunderstood, but I think, it is a question worth asking and considering.

One's outlook and productivity changes with time and age, just like an athlete's fitness. I suppose the hard question is, if a productivity and alignment with organization attitude and culture index correlates indirectly with age, what is to be done?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by awakeasleep on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:49AM (#18945886)
In the USA, we decided that we're willing to make that trade off.

We have 'protected characteristics' and we don't hire and fire people based on those characteristics, or proxies of those characteristics.

It might be less efficient for businesses, in some cases, but through the courts and our legislature, and within the bounds of our constitution we've decided it's a good trade-off for society.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @05:24AM (#18946308)
Declaring protected classes is the easy part, but how do companies are to deal with it in an effective manner?

Say a company has to fire 10% of it's work force and the people who are least fit for the culture and provide value happen to be over X years old. Should they fire n number of people under X too to balance it out? should they go halve-halve? don't fire and wait for bankruptcy?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ajross on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:59AM (#18946818)
That logic only works in isolation, and because the particular class under discussion doesn't "feel like" discrimination. Seriously, would you really willing to go on the internet and explain how women aren't a "fit for the culture" or how south asian workers don't "provide value"?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:29AM (#18946939)
But there is no data that shows women or south asian workers are less productive.

However, there is data for age, so much that in many countries there is mandatory driving test with ever shorter intervals as you grow older. This isn't discrimination or a risk factor that jumps overnight once you pass certain age, it is simply decline of cognitive and physical capacity as we age.

I am not saying people should be fired because of their age, but if people who are subject to firing happen to be mostly aged, what is the solution?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ajross on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:08AM (#18947112)
We're talking about programmers in their 40's here, not retired drivers with dementia. Please cite the study where these workers are less productive. I'll wait.

You're just taking on faith that these employers are making completely rational judgements that just "accidentally" affect a disadvantaged group. First, that's shockingly naive: what they're really doing is preferentially terminating these people because they are paid more (i.e. punishing them for being part of the system that gave them those raises in the first place).

Second, it's directly refuted by the linked article! IBM didn't accidentally fire a bunch of older workers. They fired a bunch of old workers, knew what they had done, and tried to hide it.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:46AM (#18947561)
The same issue works the opposite direction. If you're so sure she discrimination is harmful to the companies doing it, why do you have a problem with them biasing themselves out of business?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ajross on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:53AM (#18947591)
...because I'm more concerned with the welfare of the employees fired than I am with the abstract darwinian fitness of their employers?

I mean, it's not abstract: I'm in that demographic. And while my job seems stable right now, I'd like not to be fired because I'm 47, thank you very much.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @11:06AM (#18947652)
What are you willing to give up in exchange? If the employer can't end the relationship because they got a better offer, are you willing to offer the same in return? If you get better hours and more money, can we decide you're not allowed to take that offer?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ajross on Saturday January 19, 2019 @12:11PM (#18947933)
My salary is renegotiated every year. If my employer truly thinks they can get a better offer they can reduce my salary to whatever they think my market rate is. Obviously they don't, because that kind of strategy is, well, completely batshit if you want to run a successful business.

Yet you're saying that the same thing is just fine if the business waits for a "lay-off" and then preferentially fires me for reasons having nothing to do with performance?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:17PM (#18948653)
I'm saying either of you should be able to terminate the relationship at any moment for any reason. You can discriminate in any way towards your employer if you're racist, sexist, ageist, etc.

These kinds of policies subsidize relatively wealthy, disproportionately white workers at the expense of poorer and increasingly minority workers.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by eropple on Saturday January 19, 2019 @11:28AM (#18947746)
Uh. No? The people working at a business matter more than that business. This just is not that hard to noodle out.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:09PM (#18948603)
It's confusing to me that you want to subsidize a relatively wealthy demographic at the expense of the young and relatively poor.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by sodosopa on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:17AM (#18947150)
That's a huge jump from mandating driver reevaluations in > 70 year olds to cutting a 50 year old programmer to make room for two 25 year old entry level javascript developer.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by jacksnipe on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:09AM (#18947117)
Make it illegal, which the U.S. has done, and prosecute companies which do it.

There is a very long history of exploiting labor in the U.S. This country was built on it (slavery, railroads, etc...). If this behavior is not curtailed, history tells us that it will be exploited more than it is engaged in innocently.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by conanbatt on Saturday January 19, 2019 @05:33PM (#18949639)
In practice, compaines end up doing signaling: have a rock-climbing wall, go-karts, different marketing.

You cant make people do things they dont want to do. You can force them to pretend , or to not do them. But if there is a will, there is a way.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by coldtea on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:43AM (#18947261)
Don't fire and wait for bankruptcy. If it's illegal for every other company to do such firings, then it's a level playing field, and just the cost of doing business.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by tomjen3 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:32AM (#18945991)
But then businesses will keep doing so secretly and indirectly, which will just hurt people who share correlating traits with the disadvantages hires, e.g women with no interest in having children.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by jhall1468 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:42AM (#18946015)
I'm not sure advocating that we remove the law in order to prevent businesses from quietly breaking it is really solving the problem here.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by matz1 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:45AM (#18946744)
Its cost vs benefit. Trying to remove the law seems way more expensive and difficult compare to doing it secretly and indirectly.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by tomjen3 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:43AM (#18946022)
At least if that was the case we would be able to quantify it, and people would know which industries it was worst in, and how much (eg. you should expect your income to peak at 42 years, save accordingly).
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by jhall1468 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:45AM (#18946033)
Sure, we can also legalize murder and learn a lot more about people that do it, why and a whole bunch of other data, but we don't do that for obvious reasons.

This is just a less fantastical example of that. And you can see how successful their attempt at hiding it was.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by nsgi on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:34AM (#18946715)
Why would age discrimination be easier to quantify if it was legal?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by analog31 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:42AM (#18947254)
Here's a thought experiment: Legislate a cutoff age right before the next election.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by your-nanny on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:00AM (#18947349)
don't tax people because they'll just find ways to avoid paying them. don't set worker safety rules because companies will just bribe the inspectors. dont punish thieves because they'll just find wats to hide their thievery. don't punish murderers because they'll just do it less openly. don't set fuel efficiency standards because companies will cheat and lie to meet them. don't require good security hygiene because hackers will just find more devious means of hacking. don't outlaw discrimination in hiring and firing because they'll just find other indirect ways to do the same thing. /s
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by reaperducer on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:33AM (#18947501)
To you and me, that’s sarcasm. But there are regions of the world, and even entire nations, where that is not only popular thought, but public policy.

Given the international nature of HN, I wouldn’t be surprised if some of the bewildered comments in this thread come from people who grew up in that kind of culture.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by your-nanny on Monday January 21, 2019 @02:45PM (#18962988)
where?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by nate_meurer on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:25AM (#18945809)
I think you mean inversely.

The question is a bit of a red herring. By all means, get rid of unproductive and troublesome employees. But if you try to use age as a simplistic predictive proxy for productivity or attitude, I think evidence shows that you'll fire a lot of the wrong people, as well as court the wrath of labor attorneys.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by killaken2000 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:38AM (#18946729)
Indirect (negative) correlation is used when something goes up but the thing under discussion goes down.

I think you were thinking of inversely proportional.

Searching Wikipedia, inverse correlation is also valid but I've always heard it called indirect or negative.

I knew what you meant and you were on the right track.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:42AM (#18945864)
> I think you mean inversely.

No.

> But if you try to use age a simplistic predictive proxy...

Well, that is obviously the wrong thing to do, but I am not sure how that relates to my question.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by jsivakumaran on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:50AM (#18945889)
Your comment above would make more sense had you said inversely.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by nate_meurer on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:07AM (#18945927)
Ok, then I have no idea what you were asking. Can you state it in a different way?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by User23 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:17AM (#18945953)
Bluntly stated, young fools who work 80+ hours a week provide a greater short term return for employers than older persons who have a life and a family that also makes demands on their time.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by smbullet on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:46AM (#18947000)
I don't think omeid was talking about time spent in the office but rather cognitive ability.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:01AM (#18946825)
>> One's outlook and productivity changes with time and age, just like an athlete's fitness.

According to the former exec's claim, the workers laid off were over 40. The following is a list of 40 athletes over 40:

http://www.espn.com/espn/feature/story/_/id/14799377/who-cal...

Which should lay to rest any sweeping assumption about the fitness of athletes that are older than some arbitrary cut-off point after which it's all "downhill from there".

And that's not before pointing out what a huge assumption it is that your ability to perform office work declines at the same rate as muscle fitness. Or that having say 10 years of experience in an industry is rather more valuable than having firm biceps.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:10AM (#18946864)
"process x is temporal like y" does not suggest that they follow the exact rate or trajectory.

My intention was not to suggest that cognitive skills decline the same rate as muscle fitness, though, physical fitness certainly does impact cognitive health.

Nor I suggested that 40 or any age as a cut off point, but age related cognitive decline is a fact, specially in relation to complex tasks, so it is given that as people get older there will be a higher change in their productivity.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4767530/

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4015335/

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2683339/

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:01AM (#18947078)
There are many reasons to be cautious when drawing any conclusions from the three studies you quote.

The first is a neuroimaging study that is rather inconclusive and even poitns out that some cognitive abilities are thought to deteriorate with age, while others are thought to improve. The second is a discussion of various assumptions and results and asserts that the decline of cognitive abilities can be averted by engaging in certain activities. The last concludes that changes in cognitive abilities in the same individual over time do not necessarily reflect the results of aging ("maturation").

In other words, those studies do not support your assertion that "age related congitive decline is a fact". None of the studies discusses "productivity" (or "outlook" as per your earlier comment).

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Retric on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:18AM (#18946896)
Cognitive function is not a single thing. Look at the highest ranked Go players and they are not nessisarily young. At the same time Starcraft players peak very yong.

Business is not about twitch reflexes.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by noitsnot on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:57AM (#18946074)
It sounds more like a budget issue more than anything else. If companies want to exploit young, cheap labor for free 'overtime' then maybe it's a business ethics problem.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by lhinds on Saturday January 19, 2019 @04:06AM (#18946105)
> One's outlook and productivity changes with time and age

On what data do you make this statement? A quick cursory search shows its completely false and based on not much more than ignorance or prejudice.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by OliverJones on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:59AM (#18946819)
True. We gain in experience, knowledge, and webs of relationships as we age. When somebody proposes a project, we sometimes know enough to say "we tried something like that on the frobozz contract. Here's what we learned about the pitfalls."

Productivity: Maybe older workers can't / won't pull lots of all-nighters. The same is true of working mothers. But we plan ahead and get our work done.

The anti-discrimination laws aren't supposed to shackle companies to pointless costs and dead-weight people. They're intended to promote company culture that values people for what they bring to the table.

What is a company to do when external forces throw it into relentless decline? It takes a lot of guts to exit entire businesses or markets and refocus. Closing an office or shutting down an entire department isn't age discrimination. It's still nasty.

Look, western culture allows companies to have limited liability (to be corporations). The culture grants them patents for their inventions (hi IBM!). We trust them to take lots of risks to build their businesses, and give good rewards for success.

In return it's reasonable to expect compliance with laws.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @05:36AM (#18946338)
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by perfmode on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:23AM (#18946674)
Cognitive decline is not the same as drop in productivity.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by anticensor on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:32AM (#18946709)
It is correlated as aging also slows reaction. Slower reaction and worsened cognition together put a ceiling on how fast you can produce.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by coldtea on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:48AM (#18947288)
>It is correlated as aging also slows reaction. Slower reaction

Slower reaction in terms of milliseconds and for reflexes.

Not for thinking and programming -- which experience helps you improve, understand computer systems more holistically, know to recognize tons of patterns that emerge again and again, and deep thinking is what makes the difference.

So unless programmers in your company also have to juggle balls or avoid daggers, the "slower reaction" is irrelevant.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by sifoobar on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:48AM (#18946755)
Produce what, exactly?

Because anything beyond pushing a button N times per hour is going to benefit from experience, and it gets more important with task complexity.

I would much rather have someone with 30 years of experience writing code I depend on than a 20-something who can type 10 times as fast.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 19, 2019 @12:16PM (#18947965)
Realistically cognitive decline, especially that sort, isn't the reason developers in their 40's and 50's are more frequently worth laying off. I'd rather hire the me of my 40's and 50's than the me of my 20's. (I'm in my 30's.)

I wonder how much of it is that bad younger developers are more likely to attrition themselves, but older ones stay. So you get these old guys who, after five to ten years, it's really obvious they've got to go.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by chillwaves on Saturday January 19, 2019 @11:48AM (#18947836)
I feel like I am taking crazy pills as I read down these thread chains. Exactly what kind of jobs are you all doing? Is everyone on here a professional gamer? Nothing about my job requires me to have heightened reflexes or high APM.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by tertius on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:55AM (#18946799)
Because you say so? Because you feel it's intuitive?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:01AM (#18946824)
This Handwavy denial of a biological process does not help the discussion or anyone on the long term.

Reaction time and reasoning skills are cognitive skills that declines with age, specially in relation to complex tasks.

The studies are worth reading or skimming thorough at least, more importantly, everyone should look into how they can manage aging tax on cognitive skills, you can't stop it, but you can slow it down, just like physical health.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by coldtea on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:50AM (#18947297)
Reaction time is irrelevant in programming -- at any specific rate of decline in one's 40s and 50s and even 60s.

Cognitive skills are not, but they're not declining in any significant rate to make any difference (some of the best programmers are old), and are balanced by experience.

Also, let's see what tune you will sing 10 or 20 years down in your career.

What the companies mostly want is to eliminate people who have personal lives, and don't care for constant death marches and bro-ing it away at the office.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by mikeash on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:51AM (#18947029)
Experience increases with age. That is also a concrete biological fact. If you want to claim that your argument is based on fact rather than opinion, you need to prove that the factors you mention outweigh experience. I don’t believe it’s true, and certainly isn’t proven.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:11AM (#18947127)
Experience is not a biological aspect, it is "knowledge or practical wisdom gained from what one has observed, encountered, or undergone".

More importantly, I am yet to get my hands on any research that shows there is conclusive correlation between age and wisdom or experience. I would be keen to read up some!

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by mikeash on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:16AM (#18947149)
Experience is just what happens to your brain with more exposure to things. Time is a fundamental part of it, so it clearly must correlate with age.

If you’re going to argue that experience and age may be uncorrwlated then I have to conclude that you’re not making a sincere argument.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:23AM (#18947177)
You need time to experience things but time alone is not enough. Not only it is possible to have an older person with less experience at any given task or job, there is also no correlation between wisdom and age either[0].

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1080/016502599383739...

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by mikeash on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:42AM (#18947256)
Of course you can find counterexamples. “Correlated” does not mean “every single instance follows this relation.”

Consider a more obvious example. It is possible, even easy, to find a pair of people such that the older person has spent less time living in France than the younger person. Despite this, time spent living in France is highly correlated with age.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by tertius on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:32AM (#18947491)
If you base your argument on a sub-section of data then you are only trying to support an opinion.

Is 'reaction time' relevant? Is 'cognitive decline' relevant on an individual basis?

What are the other variables that prove relevant to performance you're ignoring? And what is performance?

The reason I ask if this is your opinion or intuition is because of your simplistic argument. It looks like you're trying to defend an opinion. So I ask.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by perfmode on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:29AM (#18946935)
Experience counts for nothing?

If you agree that experience counts for something, how do you find the equilibrium between experience and cognitive decline? Do you purport to know this without evidence? How can you make these claims?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by perfmode on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:11PM (#18948906)
Your argument produces holes at a greater rate than they can be patched.

You’re assuming that rate of production and reaction time are the relevant factors under consideration.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by mikeash on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:46AM (#18946999)
Let me ask a slightly modified version of that question: if alignment with organizational attitude and culture correlated with being white, what is to be done?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:58AM (#18947618)
This is only a problem if you believe that racial bias provides real economic value to the ones doing the biasing. Otherwise, why do you care if a bunch of racists make their businesses less economically efficient? Someone else who is otherwise equal but not racist will eat their lunch with all these high quality people hired at a discount because the original group biased against them.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by mikeash on Saturday January 19, 2019 @11:15AM (#18947690)
That’s a nice theory but conflicts strongly with how this has actually worked in the real world.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @06:19PM (#18949848)
There are two axioms in my previous post:

1. Minorites are just as valuable as white workers

2. Relatively economically efficient companies tend to prosper compared to inefficient ones

Which theory/axiom do you disagree with?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by mikeash on Saturday January 19, 2019 @06:30PM (#18949913)
There is at least one more: 3. the combination of 1 and 2 will overcome everything else and is enough to force racist companies out of business. That is the one I disagree with.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @06:39PM (#18949955)
What is "everything else"?

It sounds like trying to force people with $bad ideas to become even more wealthy and powerful by legislating they make better business decisions. That seems like the opposite of what I'd want to do.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by mikeash on Saturday January 19, 2019 @06:46PM (#18949990)
Let me ask you something along the same lines as what you asked me.

You laid out two axioms. You’re claiming, if I understand correctly, that those axioms imply that racism can’t persist in business.

Racism demonstrably does persist in business. There are tons of examples throughout time and space. How do you explain that?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:27AM (#18952529)
It depends on which aspect of business you're referring to. Unlike you, I wont dodge the question, and will try to pick one aspect of business and answer the question to the best of my ability: wage bias.

Theories based on simple worker based racism fall apart because they should result in an equilibrium of segregation within industries... for example some all white firms and some all black firms. However, this is generally not the case. Further evidence against the worker based theory is seen if we examine wages of managers. Let's assume (perhaps acknowledge?) that there are more white managers for historical reasons and (assume) that whites have a preference for working with whites. It should follow that any manager willing to work with black subordinates should be able to demand a higher wage for this (in the mind of the white racists) "less desirable work." Or conversely, (racist) white subordinates should be able to demand a premium for working under a black manager. However, that's simply not the case.

I think this is also evidence against the Marxian models of divide and conquer which suggest that there are micro-economic efficiencies/benefits to racial discrimination. The argument here is that racial segregation reduces the market power of both whites and blacks, therefore reducing the wages of all workers. Even though whites are a larger group and therefore have greater market power to demand higher wages, it could still make sense to deny hiring a lower wage minority because the group of whites + minorities would have even greater market power to demand higher wages. While I think there might be some merit to this theory, I think the lack of aforementioned market segmentation -- all white firms and all black firms -- is strong evidence against this being our primary culprit.

We didn't discuss shareholders, but the anonymous shareholders who are not involved in day to day interactions at large enterprises surely have no incentive to discriminate. Their preference is going to be closer to the model of simple profit maximization. Racist workers certainly exist, but basic economic theory and observed realities contradict such a simplistic explanation, aggregation of individual racist workers should result in a different labor market than the one we see as explained above.

East Asians also confound the racism based theories of wage bias, since they're simultaneously a racial minority and outperform whites in virtually any economic measure you can think of including wages. Asians do not have exactly the same historical experience with racism in the US as blacks obviously, but there's plenty of racism against them and they do have a history that includes indentured servitude, the near slave-like conditions building the trans-continental railroads, etc. And yet again, they outperform whites in wages on average.

In short, I acknowledge racism exists, but I don't think it sufficiently explains the wage market. Instead, I think the best explanation is likely the network model of labor allocation. Simply put, a huge number of positions are filled from people's existing social networks and not random members of the labor market. To the extent that racial preferences impact social networks, it can be said that this is racism. But it's not racism in the sense that I think most people who talk about racist business practices/employers/etc are meaning. Also, I believe network effects have real economic benefit in the workplace. People who are more familiar with each other will have fewer communication barriers, etc. And that is why this behavior which results in the appearance of racial discrimination persists so broadly, because the network effects are economically valuable. Again, I'm not denying the existence of racial discrimination, only that racial discrimination is not a viable explanation for the wage market today.

Okay, your turn. What is "everything else?"

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by mikeash on Sunday January 20, 2019 @07:40PM (#18956643)
It’s all the factors that keep less efficient businesses going even when faced with more efficient competition: monopolies, irrational customers, exclusive ownership of important resources, capital, or IP, regulatory capture, etc.

Maybe racial discrimination is not a viable explanation for the current wage market, but that’s pretty far from the claim that we don’t need to care about racism in business because racist businesses are bound to fail. There are too many examples where that just didn’t happen.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by tomjen3 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:41AM (#18946013)
In the cases where you have an indirect correlation, all you have to do is make it easier to measure the source that actually causes your undesired effect.

E.g if your customers assume only your male retail workers can help them with their electronics, you can make sure everybodies name badge says "Certified $PRODUCT expert".

The problem is when you have a situation like this, where the protected trait is likely the cause of issue (we all get slower and less intelligent as we age), or where you have government idiots say that you can't discriminate on traits that are correlated with a protected trait.

In the latter situation businesses will do so anyway, they will just do it secretly and try to cover it up.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by coldtea on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:41AM (#18947250)
>One's outlook and productivity changes with time and age, just like an athlete's fitness.

Statistically, as the world currently is (even if it's due to cultural or economic reasons), it might also change with race and sex.

Should companies also hire less blacks/women/etc?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by sbov on Saturday January 19, 2019 @04:08AM (#18946108)
> "I was very surprised that such a high percentage of my group was laid off, because my group was running under budget and was exceeding its performance targets."

Under budget, exceeding targets, so when you say changes with time and age, do you mean gets better? Or what?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by radicalbyte on Saturday January 19, 2019 @05:25AM (#18946314)
Clearly worse.

As a consulting company IBM makes more money when their customer's projects are running over budget whilst being under performance targets.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:58AM (#18946814)

    "my group" is always the best.
    -- every group ever.
But when I say changes with time and age, I mean the well establish notion of age-related cogitative decline and increased family responsibilities that taxes job commitment.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Aeolun on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:22AM (#18947454)
The only thing family responsibilities tax is ‘time in office’. That doesn’t correlate with commitment at all.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:57PM (#18950924)
I don't buy that, family responsibilities can cloud your mind all day long. Family like other social and personal responsibilities are not something that you can simply switch off.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Aeolun on Sunday January 20, 2019 @08:06PM (#18956745)
In that case it’s irrelevant if those ‘responsibilities’ that clog your mind come from family or friends.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by TomK32 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:03AM (#18946590)
Maybe old-timers could sell their brains with decades of knowledge and experience to the company who then implant that brain into a 20yr-old? It doesn't guarantee loyalty so the kid might be gone to the competition in two years (it thinks the avg is even less for some programmer roles) but who cares long-term?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by acct1771 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:31AM (#18945821)
Stop tying compensation to seniority, and start giving it upon completion of tasks/improvement of business...?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by paganel on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:40AM (#18945857)
The task thing is questionable, because that way you just create incentives for the people involved to introduce more (most of them un-needed) tasks into the system, tasks which will show up on the performance reviews as being completed. A lot of the senior guys solve un-created tasks, so to speak, by saying stuff like YAGNI or KISS or by eliminating potential bugs (future tasks) by pointing out that going a certain development route will create those bugs.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ThenAsNow on Saturday January 19, 2019 @04:00AM (#18946092)
There already is (and has been) knee-jerk reaction to this comment, but fundamentally I think your first clause represents territory that should be explored. I'm a huge believer in the value of retaining senior staff and making it part of their responsibility set to help mentor and develop more junior staff. However, if we take at face value the argument that it is too expensive to keep these people on staff, why not explore ideas that reduce how closely correlated compensation is to seniority rather than some measure of overall value across all dimensions of contribution?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by LoSboccacc on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:16AM (#18945951)
> Stop tying compensation to seniority

next, on hacker news: "why nobody makes children anymore"

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Someone on Saturday January 19, 2019 @06:10AM (#18946428)
The same thing we do if it is indirectly correlated with, say, skin color, gender, or being named “Smith”.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by scottlocklin on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:03AM (#18947358)
"if a productivity and alignment with organization attitude and culture index correlates indirectly with (sex/sex identity/race/eye color/blood type/religion), what is to be done?"

Asking the question with different nouns instead of "age" so you can see what is wrong with it.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by pluc on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:09AM (#18947390)
Except none of your qualifiers match what age does to an aging person. But keep pushing for political correctness where it's completely irrelevant!
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by scottlocklin on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:14AM (#18947419)
Citations needed: you don't know that. For all we know, FB and Google's best employees might be a bunch of straight white 30 year old dudes. Should they only hire such people?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Aeolun on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:19AM (#18947439)
It’s not about the fact that it happens gradually, as long as someone is doing their job perfectly there’s no legitimate reason to fire them for being old.