News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by awakeasleep on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:49AM (#18945886)
In the USA, we decided that we're willing to make that trade off.

We have 'protected characteristics' and we don't hire and fire people based on those characteristics, or proxies of those characteristics.

It might be less efficient for businesses, in some cases, but through the courts and our legislature, and within the bounds of our constitution we've decided it's a good trade-off for society.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @05:24AM (#18946308)
Declaring protected classes is the easy part, but how do companies are to deal with it in an effective manner?

Say a company has to fire 10% of it's work force and the people who are least fit for the culture and provide value happen to be over X years old. Should they fire n number of people under X too to balance it out? should they go halve-halve? don't fire and wait for bankruptcy?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ajross on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:59AM (#18946818)
That logic only works in isolation, and because the particular class under discussion doesn't "feel like" discrimination. Seriously, would you really willing to go on the internet and explain how women aren't a "fit for the culture" or how south asian workers don't "provide value"?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by omeid2 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @08:29AM (#18946939)
But there is no data that shows women or south asian workers are less productive.

However, there is data for age, so much that in many countries there is mandatory driving test with ever shorter intervals as you grow older. This isn't discrimination or a risk factor that jumps overnight once you pass certain age, it is simply decline of cognitive and physical capacity as we age.

I am not saying people should be fired because of their age, but if people who are subject to firing happen to be mostly aged, what is the solution?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ajross on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:08AM (#18947112)
We're talking about programmers in their 40's here, not retired drivers with dementia. Please cite the study where these workers are less productive. I'll wait.

You're just taking on faith that these employers are making completely rational judgements that just "accidentally" affect a disadvantaged group. First, that's shockingly naive: what they're really doing is preferentially terminating these people because they are paid more (i.e. punishing them for being part of the system that gave them those raises in the first place).

Second, it's directly refuted by the linked article! IBM didn't accidentally fire a bunch of older workers. They fired a bunch of old workers, knew what they had done, and tried to hide it.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:46AM (#18947561)
The same issue works the opposite direction. If you're so sure she discrimination is harmful to the companies doing it, why do you have a problem with them biasing themselves out of business?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ajross on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:53AM (#18947591)
...because I'm more concerned with the welfare of the employees fired than I am with the abstract darwinian fitness of their employers?

I mean, it's not abstract: I'm in that demographic. And while my job seems stable right now, I'd like not to be fired because I'm 47, thank you very much.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @11:06AM (#18947652)
What are you willing to give up in exchange? If the employer can't end the relationship because they got a better offer, are you willing to offer the same in return? If you get better hours and more money, can we decide you're not allowed to take that offer?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by ajross on Saturday January 19, 2019 @12:11PM (#18947933)
My salary is renegotiated every year. If my employer truly thinks they can get a better offer they can reduce my salary to whatever they think my market rate is. Obviously they don't, because that kind of strategy is, well, completely batshit if you want to run a successful business.

Yet you're saying that the same thing is just fine if the business waits for a "lay-off" and then preferentially fires me for reasons having nothing to do with performance?

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:17PM (#18948653)
I'm saying either of you should be able to terminate the relationship at any moment for any reason. You can discriminate in any way towards your employer if you're racist, sexist, ageist, etc.

These kinds of policies subsidize relatively wealthy, disproportionately white workers at the expense of poorer and increasingly minority workers.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by eropple on Saturday January 19, 2019 @11:28AM (#18947746)
Uh. No? The people working at a business matter more than that business. This just is not that hard to noodle out.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by Consultant32452 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @02:09PM (#18948603)
It's confusing to me that you want to subsidize a relatively wealthy demographic at the expense of the young and relatively poor.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by sodosopa on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:17AM (#18947150)
That's a huge jump from mandating driver reevaluations in > 70 year olds to cutting a 50 year old programmer to make room for two 25 year old entry level javascript developer.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by jacksnipe on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:09AM (#18947117)
Make it illegal, which the U.S. has done, and prosecute companies which do it.

There is a very long history of exploiting labor in the U.S. This country was built on it (slavery, railroads, etc...). If this behavior is not curtailed, history tells us that it will be exploited more than it is engaged in innocently.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by conanbatt on Saturday January 19, 2019 @05:33PM (#18949639)
In practice, compaines end up doing signaling: have a rock-climbing wall, go-karts, different marketing.

You cant make people do things they dont want to do. You can force them to pretend , or to not do them. But if there is a will, there is a way.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by coldtea on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:43AM (#18947261)
Don't fire and wait for bankruptcy. If it's illegal for every other company to do such firings, then it's a level playing field, and just the cost of doing business.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by tomjen3 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:32AM (#18945991)
But then businesses will keep doing so secretly and indirectly, which will just hurt people who share correlating traits with the disadvantages hires, e.g women with no interest in having children.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by jhall1468 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:42AM (#18946015)
I'm not sure advocating that we remove the law in order to prevent businesses from quietly breaking it is really solving the problem here.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by matz1 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:45AM (#18946744)
Its cost vs benefit. Trying to remove the law seems way more expensive and difficult compare to doing it secretly and indirectly.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by tomjen3 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:43AM (#18946022)
At least if that was the case we would be able to quantify it, and people would know which industries it was worst in, and how much (eg. you should expect your income to peak at 42 years, save accordingly).
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by jhall1468 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @03:45AM (#18946033)
Sure, we can also legalize murder and learn a lot more about people that do it, why and a whole bunch of other data, but we don't do that for obvious reasons.

This is just a less fantastical example of that. And you can see how successful their attempt at hiding it was.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by nsgi on Saturday January 19, 2019 @07:34AM (#18946715)
Why would age discrimination be easier to quantify if it was legal?
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by analog31 on Saturday January 19, 2019 @09:42AM (#18947254)
Here's a thought experiment: Legislate a cutoff age right before the next election.
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by your-nanny on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:00AM (#18947349)
don't tax people because they'll just find ways to avoid paying them. don't set worker safety rules because companies will just bribe the inspectors. dont punish thieves because they'll just find wats to hide their thievery. don't punish murderers because they'll just do it less openly. don't set fuel efficiency standards because companies will cheat and lie to meet them. don't require good security hygiene because hackers will just find more devious means of hacking. don't outlaw discrimination in hiring and firing because they'll just find other indirect ways to do the same thing. /s
Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by reaperducer on Saturday January 19, 2019 @10:33AM (#18947501)
To you and me, that’s sarcasm. But there are regions of the world, and even entire nations, where that is not only popular thought, but public policy.

Given the international nature of HN, I wouldn’t be surprised if some of the bewildered comments in this thread come from people who grew up in that kind of culture.

Re:Former IBM exec says company told her to hide layoff age ... by your-nanny on Monday January 21, 2019 @02:45PM (#18962988)
where?