News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by AdmiralAsshat on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:10PM (#18875565)
A mini-HDMI port seems like an odd choice. Considering most people who might use it will probably have to buy some kind of adaptor anyway, it seems like it would've been easier just to require a USB-C to HDMI adaptor and leverage the MHL Alternative Mode spec.[0] That, in my mind, would be preferable to adding another port that hardly anyone will use to the phone. Pretty much every smartphone/tablet I've ever owned supported some form of MHL, even when most of them only had MicroUSB.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobile_High-Definition_Link#US...

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by thebosz on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:43PM (#18876620)
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by kgwxd on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:05PM (#18876248)
I wish they'd just drop the idea of external monitor support. We desperately need an open phone in our pockets. Everyone keeps trying to make an all-purpose device and the gimmick features keep holding the projects back and killing them. Just make a thing that supports the built-in screen, can handle calls/text, and that's it. I'll buy it, for a lot of money. Increment from there.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by chrisseaton on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:17PM (#18876370)
> can handle calls/text, and that's it

The number of people who just want a phone to call and text is I'd imagine vanishingly small now. It won't replace anyone's proprietary smartphone like that.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by ploxiln on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:40PM (#18877289)
True, but good video drivers, and good calls/texts, are often the very hardest parts for an open-source phone project. The rest can be improved later, by community contributors even.

Historically the case has often been "well it can do wifi and browse the web, has some built-in chat apps, it's just a bit slow to scroll around, cellular data kinda works sometimes ... not worth trying to call with it, maybe next rev will have better modem support". Without calls and texts you really need another phone, so the project never gets a big enough community.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by voltagex_ on Friday January 11, 2019 @12:30AM (#18881231)
It's got a low res screen and a slower processor than 2018 phones, and it costs $700 US - I don't think it's going to get a big community.

I owned an OpenMoko and a N900, too - but sometimes you just need to get stuff done.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by kgwxd on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:54PM (#18877423)
Sorry, data too. I figured that's a given. So, more specifically, Linux with a touchscreen, wi-fi and cell data/call/text. Anything else is unnecessary to get me to buy one. And it doesn't have to replace my existing phone right away.

There's a trend of people opting for feature phones instead of iPhone/Android. That is what I'm going for next if something like Librem doesn't make it out soon. Now is the time to just get something out, while people are weary of the whole corporate-controlled smartphone thing, because, if that trend fades, no one outside of the Linux community is buying a Linux phone, no matter what it comes with. Just get it out, no gimmicks, not even a camera (one less thing to secure), sell it at a premium price and let the community figure out where to go from there.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by jay_kyburz on Thursday January 10, 2019 @09:52PM (#18880635)
Yes, but this thing is $700. A feature phone is $50. The Librem 5 needs to be something special.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by kungtotte on Friday January 11, 2019 @08:13AM (#18883300)
Being free and open is something special...

This is more about providing freedom in an otherwise totally un-free market instead of competing with the latest iPhone.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by nerdponx on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:10PM (#18876954)
This is probably true, but how many people need a mini-HDMI port?
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by adontz on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:41PM (#18877292)
But what else do you need? Facebook App?
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by chrisseaton on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:00PM (#18877485)
I would imagine most people hardly use phone calls or SMS.

People need maps, a browser, WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Twitter, Instagram. They consider these absolute basics of a phone these days. Before you say 'all I use my phone for is phoning' well that's not what most people do by any stretch.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by baroffoos on Thursday January 10, 2019 @07:18PM (#18879884)
The librem 5 is not a phone for most people. Its a phone for mini stallmans who want to still be contactable. I doubt anyone who spends $1000 on this phone with the specs of a $300 phone is planning to install Instagram on it.

The core features people care about on this device is open source firmware, encrypted messaging, open source OS, replaceable parts, headphone jack, and sd card slot.

This is the phone for the people who are not being represented by all the devices made for "most people"

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by adontz on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:06PM (#18877550)
I will say, why you need open phone if you install Facebook and WhatsApp into it?
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by noobermin on Thursday January 10, 2019 @09:40PM (#18880585)
Why the need for purity? Firefox released an add-on to sandbox facebook tabs, you can easily make things better without having to turn yourself into a hermit.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by marcosdumay on Thursday January 10, 2019 @06:30PM (#18879560)
Just because you have Facebook software running at it does not automatically mean Facebook can do anything with the phone.

Getting Facebook sandboxed can be a great reason to get an open phone. It's certainly more reasonable than displaying video out.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by chrisseaton on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:29PM (#18877757)
Well you don't, do you. Not many people will need or be able to use an open phone.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by cmsimike on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:54PM (#18878660)
>I wish they'd just drop the idea of external monitor support.

One of the biggest selling points for me is the external monitor support. Of course this phone isn't going to have features like carplay/android auto (and coming from carplay, I would be very sad to lose this functionality) but since this phone has a way to connect an external display, I plan on doing something to plug my phone into my car's head unit (via hdmi) and have it display GPS maps and possibly media player (through kodi).

Looking forward to having the freedom to do whatever I want (hopefully) with this phone!!

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by voltagex_ on Thursday January 10, 2019 @05:27PM (#18878950)
I wonder if you'd be able to use the same code that https://getcrankshaft.com/ is using to replace Android Auto.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by j45 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @05:05PM (#18878731)
If a phone could be reasonably docked on a daily basis with the desktop functionality and performance of a last gen MacBook air, there will be a lot of interest.

Devices are fast enough today where previous attempts to do this were not. This is only a software problem needing solving now.

A litmus test for any phone's success including this will be whether it can deliver a great (not good, not excellent) camera experience. The Essential was a great phone, minus the camera. While librem may not be a mainstream play it will be able to capture some power users.

I have a pixel instead of another andoird phone for ease of updates and excellent photos. I may not take the most photos but take far more than I used to... And imagine those who take lots of photos (social, family, etc) would value it.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by solarkraft on Friday January 11, 2019 @03:45AM (#18881869)
The librem 5 camera will not be great, almost certainly. Maybe not even good. From my experience on Android, open source drivers for this stuff are terrible. No support or outright hostility from camera module vendors. They'll really have to try - but then again they have some financial power. I have strong doubts about the camers.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by j45 on Friday January 11, 2019 @10:52AM (#18884319)
I'm hoping the financial power will help too.

Essential was able to have a decent camera, but the imaging software was rough and didn't improve quickly enough.

I'd like to believe there is someone who's worked on the closed source software for cameras who will learn how valuable their work actually is.. And might freelance to build the OSS code that may be needed.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by rsync on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:39PM (#18877282)
"I wish they'd just drop the idea of external monitor support."

Isn't this just the dev kit ? I would find an HDMI port on an end-user phone to be a little odd but very useful for development ...

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by beatgammit on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:45PM (#18877332)
I need a bit more than calls and text, but not that much more. If it supports Firefox and I can build stuff for it on my own (developer tools), I'll consider buying. If I can make calls and texts over WiFi with my regular number and without touching the cell chip, even better. If I can do all of that with a good user experience (meaning, stuff like Netflix, YouTube, and WebGL demos work in the browser), I'm sold.

I'll be watching the project and hopefully all of my concerns about stability and bugs will be resolved. However, I think it's very likely I'll wait for the next gen of the phone.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by freedomben on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:54PM (#18877422)
> However, I think it's very likely I'll wait for the next gen of the phone.

This is definitely my instinct too, but I worry that there may not be a next gen version if we don't buy the first. Would hate to see it abandoned because initial sales were so dismal and they took such a loss.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by hinkley on Thursday January 10, 2019 @05:44PM (#18879118)
At this point the more commercially viable option is to ditch the phone for a better quality mobile hotspot.

Pair that to a smart watch that doesn't require a phone, a mini tablet, and the ability to hand off calls to the watch or tablet.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by _red on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:20PM (#18877680)
Agreed. My "happiest" days were with my old Blackberry. I honestly just want: Secure OS, Phone, Text/Message, and Web Browser.

I don't have need for 2000 botnet apps.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by nerdponx on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:10PM (#18876948)
Indeed. I would rather see a standalone libre/open Roku alternative than some kind of all-in-one solution.

That said, if it works it works.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by jniedrauer on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:36PM (#18875894)
USB-C definitely seems like the way forward. But we're in a weird in-between state where it's not fully supported by the ecosystem yet.

USB-C support on Linux is still pretty odd. If I disconnect my displays from USB-C and then re-connect them, Wayland treats them as new displays, ie. disconnecting DP-1 and reconnecting it turns it into DP-2, etc.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by izacus on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:06PM (#18876258)
Thing is though, USB-C dongles have gotten really common and easy to find. Not to mention versatile - I can plug my S9 into the MacBook dongle and I get monitor output, sound, keyboard, mouse and Ethernet working just like on the Mac.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by j45 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @05:09PM (#18878771)
Samsung's Dex experience is really impressive and speaks to how much longer than everyone else they've been working on a mobile docking solution.

In the past the Android phones weren't fast enough and the software was lacking.

While Samsung's desktop experience is improving.. Samsungs inadequate commitment to regular (and up to date) patches on a monthly basis will remain to be their Achilles heel at a professional and consumer level.

I prefer my Galaxy Note to a Pixel but can't compared to a phone that is honestly and regularly updated.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by zozbot123 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @06:36PM (#18879595)
> Samsung's Dex experience is really impressive

The dock is nice. The software-driven desktop experience is extremely subpar, and I'm confident that the Librem OS will be vastly better than that.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by j45 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @06:45PM (#18879659)
I really hope some desktop first experience from librem will do it.

The only other new device that captured my attention little was the essential, but their camera did their phone in. I hope Librem can get past that.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by zozbot123 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @06:48PM (#18879671)
That and the lack of a headphone jack.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by detaro on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:46PM (#18877355)
They say the finished phone will have USB-C. the mini-HDMI is just for the dev kits.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by onli on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:38PM (#18875928)
That seems to work just fine under X...
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by jniedrauer on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:45PM (#18876012)
Wayland definitely seems like the way forward. But we're in a weird in-between state where it's not fully supported by the ecosystem yet.

Etc.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by chmln on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:57PM (#18876150)
Wayland is not the default on most Linux distributions for a reason and likely won't be for a while. Surprised to see it picked as a foundation as it is not mature at all, despite the protocol being around for a decade now.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by jniedrauer on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:19PM (#18876388)
Wayland is the default on Fedora. I've been using it exclusively for around 2 years now. Every time I go back to X, I'm reminded of why I use Wayland full time.

The sooner adoption happens, the sooner the edge cases will be worked out.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by chmln on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:59PM (#18877479)
> Every time I go back to X, I'm reminded of why I use Wayland full time.

Why's that? Genuinely curious as I always have the exact opposite experience.

I've found both gnome wayland and sway matching neither x11's features nor performance

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by jniedrauer on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:05PM (#18878155)
The main reason for me is HiDPI support. Scaling works extremely well in wayland, and I can set scaling per-display. HiDPI support on X is an afterthought at best.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by ndnxhs on Thursday January 10, 2019 @07:27PM (#18879941)
Does fractional scailing work yet. I have 1080p on a small laptop and the text is too small to read but 2x is huge. Currently I just have large text enabled in accessibility mode.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by jniedrauer on Thursday January 10, 2019 @08:56PM (#18880382)
It does, yes. Quite well. I have one of my displays at 1.5x scale.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by rhodysurf on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:44PM (#18878560)
Its so much smoother for me as long as I dont use an NVIDIA laptop
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by AsyncAwait on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:12PM (#18877609)
At least on my AMD box, Wayland is considerably smoother than X.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by gh02t on Friday January 11, 2019 @01:33AM (#18881451)
It makes more sense when you remember that they are building the whole software stack, or at least have a lot of control over it. A lot of Wayland's issues are with backwards compatibility, but Librem doesn't have to deal with that as much, plus they have a defined set of hardware so driver support issues are much less of a problem.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by _emacsomancer_ on Friday January 11, 2019 @01:01AM (#18881341)
My only device actually running Wayland is my AsteroidOS watch.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by abrowne on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:59PM (#18876177)
"The Librem 5 will be using native Wayland applications exclusively"

Source: https://puri.sm/posts/librem5-progress-report-13/

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by floatboth on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:42PM (#18876601)
If "DP-1 turns into DP-2", that's certainly a problem way below the X/Wayland layer.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by onli on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:39PM (#18877866)
It sounds like an udev issue. But re-connecting displays works for me with USB-C. And Wayland has still very strange bugs, for example, on my workstation the login (powered by Wayland under Ubuntu) freezes upon selecting the user and again when entering a password until you move the mouse long enough in circles [0]. So somehow the user input treatment (and, secondary, rendering) is linked to the mouse input. If wayland can manage that, it can mess up on the xrandr layer equivalent and change the display enumeration.

[0]: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/mutter/+bug/177856..., I reported the bug

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by hinkley on Thursday January 10, 2019 @05:38PM (#18879062)
One of my SBCs now has a usb-c connector for HDMI. I have never understood the really tiny HDMI connectors. I had at one point a portable projector with a mini-HDMI connector and SBCs with a micro-HDMI connector. The cabling to connect them was ridiculous.

Also, rigid dongles are not compatible with tiny connectors. I'm sure that's why all the Apple adapters have tails. Too much leverage otherwise.

Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by toast0 on Friday January 11, 2019 @01:31AM (#18881444)
Smaller than normal HDMI would be great for running in wall (less bulk to run into stuff; the active, thinner cables are pretty nice, but the connectors need big holes drilled), but I wasn't able to find any keystone jacks with normal on the outside and small on the inside.
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by teekert on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:30PM (#18877198)
Hmm, mini-HDMI and a bluetooth mouse/keyboard seem pretty fool prove. If I'd get a decent desktop on a large screen, this could be my next laptop. (I don't really do anything on it I couldn't already do an raspberry pi anyway.)
Re:How We Designed the Librem 5 Dev Kit with Free Software by chx on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:46PM (#18876658)
While I do not have exact data, I believe micro HDMI is more widespread than mini HDMI not that either is widely used. Just out of my own devices, the Kobo Arc 7 and the One Mix 2S Yoga both have micro.