News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by 40acres on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @02:14PM (#18858554)
I think we need to reassess how we treat data generated by users via phones, devices and our digital activities. We had the concept of private and public property long before intellectual property became codified by law. I believe that we are entering a new phase which may require the development of a new type of jurisprudence around things like location data.

I'm definitely not a lawyer, but I'm starting to believe there is an argument that despite the fact that mobile phones and devices facilitate the generation of location data, that does not necessarily mean that the device manufacture 'owns' that data and can transact with it as they please.

This may all be moot because most of us agree to Privacy Policy contacts, but maybe a mind shift in treating data you generate as a type of property that is covered by property law is required to change behavior.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @06:05PM (#18860654)
How about we start with not allowing people to legally kidnap individuals?

I never understood the whole concept of “bounty hunters” in the US it’s not the Wild West anymore.

The problem here is that “fugitive recovery” doesn’t need to meet any of the standards normal law enforcement does and unless they kill someone or injure bystanders there likely won’t be an investigation into their conduct and even if there is one the result is often that at worse that could happen is then loosing their license. Criminal investigations against fugitive recovery agents are pretty darn rare and there is no internal affairs or any body that really investigates their conduct on a regular basis.

I’m pretty sure that a large amount of these people violate much more than the privacy of their targets on a regular basis.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:41PM (#18861839)
> it’s not the Wild West anymore

They didn't get that memo. The mentality and folklore is that it still is. Laws, politics, government, privacy, policing, social mores, business and especially foreign policy all seem to retain the idea they are a frontier society blessed with Manifest Destiny. Their way, however flawed, is the only way etc etc.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by me_again on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @08:31PM (#18861544)
The person writing the article was able to obtain data despite not even being a "real bounty hunter" (whatever that is). And it seems entirely plausible for a stalker/abusive ex/etc) to obtain the same data. So I think the collection and resale of the data remains an issue regardless of the bail bond/bounty hunter aspect.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by casefields on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @06:39PM (#18860898)
The US can still issue letters of marque and reprisal:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_of_marque

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by mhb on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:10AM (#18862439)
The Fugitive: Evidence on Public Versus Private Law Enforcement from Bail Jumping

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18862432

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by endymi0n on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @08:52AM (#18864640)
Know what's even more effective and cheap than Private Law Enforcement? Torturing suspects until they confess and shooting them on the spot if they are guilty.

My point is, this is not about effectiveness, but about legality. A constitutional democracy needs to stay constitutional and legal in its ways of delivering justice, otherwise it's not a constitutional democracy anymore but an anarchy.

Giving private individuals the right to legally kidnap people, as well as massive privacy violations like stated in the OP's article — without any oversight — at least to me looks like a massive violation of the Fourth Amendment.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by User23 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:02PM (#18861054)
The vast majority of bounty hunting cases are going to the addict/drunk’s door and reminding him he’s got a hearing to be at. The kind of glorifications you see on the teevee are virtually nonexistent.

As for the privacy aspect, well online privacy is observably a fiction and it always has been. Only naifs and fools believe otherwise in the face of overwhelming evidence. Sure there ought to be privacy online in some idealistic sense, but there isn’t in reality so act accordingly.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:14PM (#18861125)
>The vast majority of bounty hunting cases are going to the addict/drunk’s door and reminding him he’s got a hearing to be at. The kind of glorifications you see on the teevee are virtually nonexistent.

I somehow doubt that's what they make the money on because they make money on bail skippers usually a percentage of the set bail.

In any case if you need someone to appear in court there is something we call a police force which should be used.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by User23 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @08:01PM (#18861382)
You do realize the fugitives in question voluntarily entered into a contract with the bondsman right? Frankly, getting driven to the court appearance is a mild and totally appropriate response to the default. It’s way better for the fugitive than having the marshals called in.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @11:35AM (#18866069)
As far as I am aware the marshals are called only in federal cases or cases where state lines are crossed, in all other cases it would be your local sherif department.

We have contract law for a reason any contract can be made illegal regardless if someone has went into it of their own volition or not.

By this definition we can also legalize slavery or indentured servitude, not to mention that I wouldn't call a situation were the choice is either debt or prison having freedom.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by Semaphor on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @10:20PM (#18861995)
There are one or two bounty hunters live streaming their job at twitch. The vast majority of their job is sitting in a car, driving. But it usually doesn't seem to involve showing up at an "addict/drunk’s door"
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by adrianN on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @05:07AM (#18863641)
I agree with you, but that seems to be a different issue. We'd have to think about data even if bounty hunters wouldn't exist.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by zorga on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:12PM (#18861109)
> How about we start with not allowing people to legally kidnap individuals?

Then you'd have to give up being able to afford bail; without bounty hunters, bondsman would have no recourse when you didn't show up to court and thus not much incentive to loan you bail money. You're not being legally kidnapped, you agreed to those terms when you borrowed the bond money for bail.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:47PM (#18861315)
The bail system itself is abhorrent if there isn’t a reason to lock you up until trial then you shouldn’t be locked up, if there is you shouldn’t be able to buy your way out.

Most other countries have figured out how to serve justice without a system that discriminates against the poor.

Too many people can’t afford the down payment or can offer a collateral to get a bail financed those who can end up being indebted to them you are advocating for the legalization of loan sharks.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by vsl on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @10:46AM (#18865572)
Bail is a common mechanism outside of US too.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by Legogris on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @11:59AM (#18866346)
Depositing money as part of bail is only really a practice in the U.S. and Philippines.

https://www.politifact.com/california/statements/2018/oct/09...

> "Only Duterte’s Philippines and Trump’s United States of America have money bail."

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by p0ckets on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @03:07PM (#18868302)
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @03:50PM (#18868731)
It’s not about the amount of bail but rather the price of a bond.

If the bond costs 10% then you can’t pay bail if it’s set to 10 million or even a million or even lower for most people, if it’s capped at say $100 something that even some US states do then it’s not as much of a problem.

If you look at the US bondsman industry it’s focused on the states not with the highest average bail set but those with the highest prices on bail bonds.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by zorga on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:48PM (#18861325)
Most other countries don't have our intractable political system; bondsman solve a problem, they let people get out of jail when the government is being absurd.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:53PM (#18861347)
And do you think the bondsmen don’t have an incentive to keep the status quo?

It’s a multi billion dollar industry which effectively taxes the poor.

Make bounties illegal and it fill fall, once it falls the entire bail system in the US will have to be rethought as there isn’t a way to lock so many people up, more judges will release them until trial without setting a bail which they can already legally do and do so for minor offenses.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by rootusrootus on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:38PM (#18861828)
Bounty hunters are not universal. For example, here in Oregon they are illegal.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:46PM (#18861858)
There is also no private bail in Oregon afaik, but I think only 5 states or so are like that.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by rootusrootus on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @10:07AM (#18865185)
Yep, we set a bond, and you can pay 10% to the court to bail yourself out. If you skip, the sheriff is the one who will come for you. Though in practice most people are released on their own recognizance, no bond is set except for serious cases.

Also, Oregon doesn't just outlaw bounty hunters as part of our own process, we outlaw them altogether. Bounty hunting is classified as kidnapping.

While there are many things Oregon could do better, there are a whole bunch of things, like this, which I think we are absolutely right on.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by zorga on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @08:03PM (#18861395)
You're putting the cart before the horse; until you change the government and thus the bail system, we need bondsman. Making bounties illegal won't stop judges from setting bails people can't afford and is thus not a valid solution.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:48PM (#18861866)
There are several states with no private bail including Oregon and Massachusetts somehow I doubt that offenders in those states are worse off.

In a country where judges are elected a multi billion dollar has a lot of power in determining how bail is set by the courts.

If you think that judges that get donations from bondsmen don’t take that into account when setting bail you are very naive.

This is the exact same problem as private prisons the justice system should not be monetized for profit.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by pinot on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @02:09AM (#18862890)
You finally explained a mystery to me why growing up in Oregon, I've never seen a bailbond place with its flashy neon signs and general run-down areas outside of courthouses. Something I became fairly familiar with moving around California.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dingoegret on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:00PM (#18861668)
Very dumb argument. There is no cart and there is no horse. Eliminate the bail system and something has to fill the void.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by Klover on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:30PM (#18866669)
I remember seeing one in LA. I thought it was fake! Like a tourist attraction.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by kakarot on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @11:12AM (#18865838)
I grew up in a town where the mayor was the bail bondsman. His son was the district prosecutor.

A perfect, no-frills example of the typical dynamic between bail bondsmen and government.

How strange that I received the maximum possible bail amount for a crime that I didn't even commit. Surely there couldn't have been an incentive for the son of the guy who makes the laws to illegally prosecute and fine a minor whose only way to finish graduating high school is to pay the damn fine, so that the guy who makes the laws could collect that fine... That would just be corrupt.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by pjc50 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:32PM (#18861230)
The bail money isn't an essential part of the system either. Most other countries have radically different systems; in the U.K. it's unconditional and free for minor offenses with escalating conditions (and violence may result in no bail at all).

https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/bail

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by zorga on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:44PM (#18861303)
It's essential in a system where changes to how government operates largely aren't possible due to partisan divides; bondsman are a free market solution to absurd government policies on bail. When you can't fix the government, you go around them.

btw, that wasn't me that down voted you.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dogma1138 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:49PM (#18861331)
The majority of bail isn’t prescribed at the federal level plenty of states can go way with it if they wanted too.

The whole concept of bail shouldn’t have a place in a modern society.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by zorga on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:50PM (#18861335)
No one said anything about the federal government; state governments are just as absurd and just as divided.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by learc83 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @10:58PM (#18862127)
The majority of states are completely controlled by one party (the majority of the legislature and the governor are belong to the same party), and only one state has a split legislature.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by daveFNbuck on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @01:07AM (#18862679)
> Then you'd have to give up being able to afford bail

California did this last year. People still get released pending trial, they just aren't required to pay a private party for the privilege.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by jka on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:54AM (#18862628)
Perhaps other legal systems exist around the world which have been able to deal with this over the course of history?
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by michaelmrose on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @08:11AM (#18864421)
How come this doesn't apply to any other sort of debt this is really bad logic.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by jijji on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @10:37PM (#18862056)
making a citizens arrest is not the same as kidnapping... anyone can make a citizens arrest if a crime is being committed, this is perfectly legal. Kidnapping is when you detain someone who has not committed a crime.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by jmickey on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @03:16PM (#18859227)
No need to invent new jurisprudence - if the location data can be used to identify an individual, it is personal data under the GDPR and enjoys all the rights and protections enabled by the regulation.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by kokokokoko on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @05:33PM (#18860431)
In the US it is actually a big deal because data is not a "creative work" so it is not covered by copyright protection.

Because of this, black market re-sellers can operate with relative impunity. Most data brokers have a TOS that prohibits the re-selling of their data, but there isn't any copyright protection.

For example, if a company has location data, the only way for them to be held liable is for a particular company to prove they obtained that data directly from them. Once the data has reached a minimum of two parties, everyone now has plausible deniability. If this data was under copyright, the original copyright owner would always have a claim and it would be each parties responsibility to prove they had a right to hold and distribute it.

The lack of a copyright style concept of original owner allows data to flow freely even if that transfer is violating a specific TOS.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by greglindahl on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @06:14PM (#18860738)
You're trying to use the wrong kind of law for the problem at hand.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by coldtea on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @06:18PM (#18860766)
>In the US it is actually a big deal because data is not a "creative work" so it is not covered by copyright protection.

It doesn't need (and shouldn't be) "copyrighted".

It's enough that the law classifies it as private info, and protects it from any third party without an immediate consent.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by kokokokoko on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @06:50PM (#18860982)
As someone who has worked with a couple data aggregation startups, I find it surprising I am unaware of the laws that classify it as private info(or even the legal definition of what "private info" is).

With that said, I am certainly not a lawyer and was never directly involved. Which particular laws are you referring to?

Edit: I should mention I am aware of laws preventing the collection of certain types of data. But unaware of laws about possession of that data.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by coldtea on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:20PM (#18861161)
>As someone who has worked with a couple data aggregation startups, I find it surprising I am unaware of the laws that classify it as private info(or even the legal definition of what "private info" is).

As a European, I wasn't saying that you have laws that classify it as "private info".

I'm saying that you _should_ have (or get) some such laws.

Including laws about the "possession of that data" -- GDPR for example covers both collection and possession, and which cases either brushes against the law.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by kokokokoko on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @10:37PM (#18862058)
Ah, my apologies. I misunderstood that and thank you for clarifying. I absolutely agree. I hope we, in the US, come to a point where we treat personal info in a similar way. Best regards from across the pond.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by schaefer on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @03:28PM (#18859328)
some of us are in the USA, (including article's author). The privacy realities we face are drastically different than in the EU.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by crankylinuxuser on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @03:29PM (#18859338)
That's fine for you Europeans under GDPR. (Sure, there's careouts for weird exceptions.)

That doesn't do diddly for us US citizens living in the US. Our data policy is "we will sell your data, too bad so sad".

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by jlarocco on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @03:52PM (#18859564)
It is kind of our own fault, though.

Judging by the sentiment on HN when GDPR was coming into effect, if something like it came up for a vote in the US, a lot of HN users and other tech people would vote against it.

There was no shortage of angry geeks posting articles about their service turning away EU users rather than complying with GDPR.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by Tsubasachan on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @05:13PM (#18860266)
If you work in tech or marketing your salary comes from eroding privacy. There is a lot of money at stake here and people don't vote against their interests.

Europeans aren't inherently better: if Facebook and Google were companies founded in Germany or France who knows if GDPR would exist.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by icebraining on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:05PM (#18861069)
Europeans aren't inherently better: if Facebook and Google were companies founded in Germany or France who knows if GDPR would exist.

The Data Protection Directive, which the GDPR merely extends and updates, is older than Google and almost as old as the web itself, and was an attempt to unify even older national laws regarding personal data. It's not a reaction to having "lost" the privacy-eroding race.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by andrei_says_ on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @11:17PM (#18862209)
European politicians don’t have to spend 70% of their time begging corporations for campaign donation. I believe this is much more of a determining factor.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by jlarocco on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @05:51PM (#18860570)
I don't know if I'd say that. "Tech" is a really big field, and most areas don't have anything to do with eroding privacy.

Unfortunately, many areas that would have been "safe" years ago, like games and standalone applications, are moving in the direction of violating privacy by phoning home and sending "telemetry" data, but there's still a lot of areas that are good.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by crankylinuxuser on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @08:56AM (#18864675)
I'm a sysad for a small company. We have an on-prem solution and a social media app.

We don't sell our data. We don't trade it. And we adhere to a fedramp medium (in spirit), even though the social media site wasn't checked for that.

Users have control over their profile, and we admins cant even read it (unless we read raw DB, and we dont). And deletion requests entail in zeroing out all user's data. The next day, zeroed data is then purged completely.

Seriously, companies can do this right. And I work for one that absolutely does this right.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by laumars on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @02:58AM (#18863089)
Europe has had data protection laws long before Facebook and Google we’re a thing. The concept of GDPR wasn’t invented because the EU were angry at American companies; it exists because there is a need for it. Just as previous incarnations of data protection laws existed in the EU before the web was a thing too.

Also I resent being told that anyone who works in tech gets their salary from eroding peoples privacy. I can guarantee you that hasn’t been the case for any of the jobs I’ve had in my career.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by Zecar on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:27PM (#18861787)
Hi I work for a printing company as a full-stack developer. My work involves things like writing API wrappers to ingest order flow so our customers can print brochures, or building web UI tools to create and order print resources. The last algorithm I wrote was to generate 5000 unique BINGO cards. Please explain to me how my salary comes from eroding privacy.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by divideby0829 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @11:53PM (#18862368)
I think we can agree that what you do and what your salary "come from" can be distinct and can be influenced by other things. There are engineers at FB whose sole job is maintaining REACT.js but they are paid from the money made from selling data.

Further, and I want to make it clear that I don't mean this as a value statement, but is a printing company what most of us really think of a the "tech" industry? and by extension does that really make you the subject of what you are replying to?

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by Zecar on Thursday January 10, 2019 @09:50PM (#18880627)
There is a huge amount of tech in the print industry, believe it or not
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by thewarrior on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @09:49AM (#18865022)
The demand from these mega companies and their pay keeps your pay high.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by Zecar on Thursday January 10, 2019 @09:50PM (#18880628)
No it doesn't. We don't sell to any tech companies. We do like, manuals for baby seats and stuff like that.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by thewarrior on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @06:22AM (#18910357)
It does indirectly because their demand inflated demand for programmer talent.

The money they have to acquire companies raises the valuation of all startups.

I’m surprised most people don’t realize this.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by renholder on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @02:11AM (#18862896)
>If you work in tech or marketing, your salary comes from eroding privacy.

Your own inherent weakness in morality doesn't implicitly infer that this is the inherent truth for everyone else in the tech or marketing industry. (Perhaps, moreso for tech than marketing but I digress.)

Not everyone in either industry is inherently on the "I'm just in it for the money" bandwagon.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by irrational on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @06:21PM (#18860788)
I work in tech, but my and my companies work definitely doesn't involve eroding anyone's privacy.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by zaarn on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @10:49AM (#18865599)
People living in Germany and France think differently, if Facebook had been invented there, there is IMO a good possibility it would be less privacy-invading.

That plus there are good historical reasons for our strong privacy laws.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by foobiekr on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @11:47PM (#18862350)
Not all tech comes from slinging ads.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by thisisweirdok on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:00PM (#18859651)
I would hope that those people would at this point realize that the upset about the GDPR was completely overblown?
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by dylan604 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @05:50PM (#18860560)
Were these people that actively work on projects that depend on this data for their business to remain viable?
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by rock_hard on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:18PM (#18859800)
This is a double edged sword...in the EU it doesn't matter because they didn't have a internet economy to begin with but here in the US a lot is at stake.

So if you want better privacy laws in the US then they have to be much more clever than GDPR to not destroy the economy and global competitiveness!

BTW: Personally I think it is possible to do better than GDPR here in the US.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by wahern on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @01:00AM (#18862649)
As a percentage of GDP the so-called "digital economy" isn't much less in the EU than in the U.S. See, e.g., https://www.imf.org/~/media/Files/Publications/PP/2018/02281...

Excluding the U.K. and Ireland (tax haven) the difference between the EU and U.S. is greater, but (eyeballing) only on the order of 30-50%--e.g. ~4% vs ~6%.

What's more surprising is how small the share of GDP is the digital economy in the U.S.

That said, "digital economy" may be a poor proxy for understanding the impact of privacy regulations. It's a superset of tech industries, including much more than those parts which broker private information and to that extent would overestimate the impact. OTOH, I presume "digital economy" excludes large parts of non-tech industries (i.e. traditional sales and marketing companies, TV and newspaper ads, etc) and thus underestimates the potential impact.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by rock_hard on Tuesday January 15, 2019 @04:38PM (#18915633)
I guess it depends on your definition of digital economy...I was referring to companies of the size and influence like Apple, Amazon, Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Oracle, Airbnb, Tesla, SpaceX, etc
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by closeparen on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @06:34PM (#18870138)
The subject’s location is necessary for the performance of the bond. As long as it’s clearly disclosed, there should be no problem signing over those rights as part of the contract. If there is, the bondsman can just make you wear a tracking anklet.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by DoctorOetker on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @07:39PM (#18861274)
relevant clip:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GOkFHTGgao8&t=68m36s

on a more serious note, even if such data is not resold commercially, and even if more detailled surveillance by a real human analyst only occurs when automated red flags are raised, and the system was designed to only allow the analyst access to the detailed data if enough or the right combination of red flags are raised there is a remaining problem: if your job consists of interpreting all day long the details surrounding red flags concerning an individual case by case, and an individual piques your interest (legitimately or not) and if your access to detailed surveillance on this individual expires when the red flags expire (in order to keep the analyst workforce focussed on their job, not their pet theories), then it becomes trivial for the analyst to "tag" an individuall of choice (out of curiousity, fascination) or a previous target (to prolong detailed surveillance): just arrange for an automated red flag concerning this individual to go off! you don't need to guess what types of automated red flags exist since you are constantly handling cases of individuals, and the red flags that were triggered!

(Oct 15) A few months back, my sister visited me in the city I live, and at one point she asked if I could use a prepaid sim card that was soon to get expired (16 days later or valid till including Oct 31), I said I don't really need it, but if she couldn't think of anyone else I would probably use it to call some of my more remote friends (I usually text). She remarked it was stupid that she had forgotten to bring the card. I remember asking why she bought it if she didn't use it?? But she said something along the lines of "I'm not really sure", I had the impression she didn't buy it, but in turn somebody had given her the card... I also said it's OK if she gave it to someone else. At that point I assumed that was what would happen, and simply forgot about her mentioning the SIM card.

Here in Belgium, the mail is delivered "D+1", so pretty quickly..

(Oct 24) Nine days after my sister visited me, I am staring out my living room out on the street, and I see the postman going through the street and crossing to enter the apartment building I am in. After a while I notice him at the end of the street, so he already passed.

I go down to check the mail, and there's a notification card, telling me about a letter with insufficient postage, that I wasn't home, and that I can go to the post office if I wish to pay and receive it nonetheless...

Here the weight for a single post stamp is 50 grams. So thats quite a letter. I had forgotten about the SIM card and started fantasizing about a (long) loveletter from N (a girl from the past).

Obviouly I go to the post office, I say I want to pay for the postage, and I ask who the letter was from. The employee looks at me as if I don't understand the postage system and says: "If it had a return adress, it would have gone straight back to the sender. So the envellope did not state a sender, in which case the recipient can elect to pay for sufficient postage." I suddenly had a flashback to elementary school, and these once-deeply-studied facts long ignored immediately sprang alive. "Of course!" I said...

I ask when I will receive it, and he says it depends if I want to go pick it up today at the main post depot, or if I wish to receive it by mail, and in that case in just a few days. I tell him they can send it by mail.

From then on, the first thing I do upon awaking, is run down to get "N's loveletter". However no letter marked with "insufficient postage" stamp arrives.

(Nov 1) The SIM card expires.

I distinctly remember one day noticing it had already been exactly 2 weeks and I still didn't get the letter. That same day (Nov 7) I read in the papers that the national postage system starts a strike, and mail already underway will be on tine, but new mail may get delayed.

The strike is still ongoing about 2 days later, when I finally receive the letter marked with the "insufficient postage" stamp. Immediate dissapointment: it's not from N but from my sister, and it's the SIM card.

Immediately more inconsistencies pop up: 1) my sister did of course as always state her name and return address on the letter 2) the whole envellope, greeting card, unopend prepaid SIM card weigh less than 20 grams, let alone 50 grams!

So I fire up my abductive reasoning skills.

Of the hundreds of letters I receive:

What is the probability or how often do I receive a letter that is insufficiently stamped? it was my very first such letter!

Moreover what is the probability that a letter is incorrectly marked with "insufficient postage"?

Moreover what is the probability that a letter with return address is sent on to the recipient if it has "insufficient postage" ?

Those co-incident probabilities are very low indeed. And it is also the first letter I receive that contains a prepaid SIM card. Bingo! obviously authorities do not want people mailing unused prepaid SIM cards! That may re-anonymize any over-the-counter de-anonymization, like paying with card!

Probably criminals (perhaps also investigative journalists) create demand for clean SIM cards, where the cleanliness to the buyer is illustrated by the prepaid SIM card package still being unopened...

So the motive to detect and intercept SIM cards in mail exists.

Now I obviously get curious, how did they detect this in the benign case of my sister sending me her almost expiring SIM card?

The actual SIM card is to be broken out of the larger card, which states the PIN and PUK code...

This larger card has the same dimensions as credit/smart cards...

They both contain a chip under the contacts...

Some credit cards contain RFID for contactless payments...

So I postulate abductively that the larger card with PIN and PUK code contains an RFID coil, and when breaking out the SIM card, it's connection to the coil is broken!

Are these RFID tags visible with off the shelf commercial RFID readers? or are their also "secret" tags that the readers refuse to identify by design? If so, and someone finds a way to detect this secret class of RFID tags, then we may find more of these in unexpected places/locations...

I will see my sister back in a few weeks, and she will obviously ask if I made use of the SIM card. Now I hate lying, and I also hate dissappointing people when something is not really my fault, since the unjustified inssuficient postage delay caused the card to expire. Then I will ask if she actually bought the card herself, was given the card, or if she somehow found the card, for example mysteriously in her mail box...

Everybody has their own SIM card, nobody really needs an extra one, and my sister is not very sociable, she wouldn't know who to give a surplus card about to expire.

So if an analyst wanted to tag me (or her), it is entirely predictable she would ask her younger brother if he perhaps could use it! And that she would send it by mail (since we live in different cities).

Any future analyst will come to believe this red flag in the record is genuine, and not a placed one! It is entirely conceivable that there are some very unlucky people with a boatload of flags on their record, which convince the new analyst that this individual needs more tracking even if the last flag expires... so they place a new flag! and after this analyst's second term of observing the individual, he gives up, ... until next time a new analyst observes the person's record, is amazed with the richly filled flags in the past, and perhaps does the same....

Now apart from being overzealous and having pet theories, what other motivation could the analyst have to bypass the agency focus mechanism by placing tags? What about pure boredom? The first time you investigate a bunch of neo-nazi scum you are all excited, and the first time you investigate some angry muslim lowlife, you are similarily excited... but after a few weeks/months/years you realize there is nothing exciting, just the endless stream of boring as hell hitler greetings, and the boring as hell angry muslim's communicating things like "the infidel whore!" etc... It's like working at the zoo, when you are small it seems awesome, and the public part of the zoo is nice, but when you actually work there, the non-public part of the zoo is just grim walls, and shovelling different kinds of excrement. Of course the analyst / zoo employee tries to make quick work of the shoveling part, so he can spend some time checking out the lizards or whatever kind of people really fascinate him in an entertaining way!!

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by snazz on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:13PM (#18861729)
This is:

a) the longest comment I’ve ever read all the way through on HN

b) an interesting anecdote

but c) most likely a coincidence.

I agree that the likelihood of such a thing happening is miniscule. However, I’ve had all sorts of strange postage-system-related issues in my time (granted, I’m in the US, which has likely a much worse system) and it doesn’t seem that far out to me that such a letter would have been mishandled by what is likely an automated system.

Maybe if you buy a SIM card and send it to someone else, you can get more conclusive evidence about whether prepaid SIMs are genuinely slowed in transit or if you were just very unlucky. One occurrence does not a trial make.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by DoctorOetker on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:33PM (#18861811)
a) I didn't realize how long my post had gotten in the tiny entry box, until after I had posted it... but I will gladly accept the dubious Cup of "Longest readable HN comment in the Guinnes Book of Records"

b) Yes I also think it's very interesting. Initially before coming to these suspicions, I was pissed off about having to dissapoint my sister next time I see her, and the money that was lost buying the SIM card etc, ... but the longer I thought about it and noticed all the inconsistencies in what had happened, it's actually a nice puzzle/gift to receive! Turns out the journey really is the reward after all

c) I have also thought about possible mistakes, but really there is little that can go wrong with a strain gauge! And even if the strain gauge somehow broke, there would have been a long run of letters suddenly appearing for redirection, surely this would be noticed and the letters reweighted... And even if it is incorrectly marked with "insufficient postage" both the sorting which is supposed to redirect it to the return address, as the eventual post man who did not ring failed to see the return address! And with D+1, a delay of ~20 days is totally unheard of (counting up till Nov 7th when the strike was anounced)...

in my response to a sibling of your comment I describe we can simply dissolve a fresh prepaid SIM card to detect the presence of a possible RFID loop antenna

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by megablast on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @08:43PM (#18861597)
I have no idea what your story is trying to say.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by DoctorOetker on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:06PM (#18861692)
I am saying I believe the creditcard-sized card that contains a fresh prepaid SIM card, probably contains an RFID loop antenna.

This is trivial to verify or falsify, just buy some acetone in the hardware store:

https://learn.adafruit.com/rfid-iphone/dissolve-the-card

I already bought the acetone, but I did not yet dissolve the SIM card, I want to do this in front of my sister, so she understands why I attach importance to finding out the origin of the unused expired SIM card she sent.

The card is supposedly expired anyway (well to be honest the validity date is printed on a sticker on the outside of the plastic foil package, so in theory it may be a still valid card with a fake early expiration date to encourage my sister to hurry with giving it away...).

I did not yet dissolve the card, but I feel pretty certain there is an RFID coil inside, and that is how they detected and stalled the letter without opening it. Stalled to determine if it is OK or not to allow the card to be sent on or not. "insufficient postage" to increase the possibility of the recipient deciding not to want the letter.

If you can't wait a couple of weeks to hear back from me if there is an RFID tag inside, you can try buying a prepaid SIM card and dissolving in acetone yourself. If you or someone tries this before february, I would like to know the result.

The whole story got me thinking that the human analysts that process and interpret red flags can easily build a repertoire of tricks to arrange for a red flag concerning a person to go off.

If my sister provides me with a name (perhaps even an address) of whoever gave her the card, I could consider tagging the person back (by sending the SIM card to him).

However I think it is unwise:

1) the person who gave it to her would not necessarily be the analyst, it may be an informant (perhaps a criminal turned informant, in which case I am effectively tagging myself into association with a criminal!)

2) if the person who gave it to her was the analyst, and I addressed the letter to Mr [name] "The Tagging Spook" [surname], and possibly arrange for the letter to have insufficient postage, while hilarious that my case file would then contain a red flag associating me with the analyst called out as a spook, it's unclear how he would react. Any future analyst could notice the burnt name of a colleague. He might need to self-report his bypassing of the automated system raising supposedly spontaneous red flags... Also, I estimate it would not be wise of me to go and poke the hornets nest. So I think I will stay with just observing and learning...

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by salawat on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @11:37AM (#18866086)
http://www.dslreports.com/forum/r28362704-RFID-sim-cards-goo...

https://patents.google.com/patent/US7784693B2

Neat read, and Godspeed.

Not sure whether your theories on there actually being an infrastructure for doing these sorts of things is correct, but even a 5 minute google search seems to suggest it is well within technical capabilities to do so.

Might do some more searching for ISO's and other Engineering standards related to them. Telephony is highly dependent on uniform technical standard adherence, so it's out there somewhere. I doubt that the RFID is in the plastic containg the card, it's probably in the card itself.

The unusual coincidences should be pretty easy to replicate with a P.O. Box, and could be consistent with holding times for information propagation or authorization.

Definitely seems like something to mess with if you are bored!

You'll be amazed the things you can find out when you start to peel back the layers, but don't be disappointed if it's just a coincidence.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by DoctorOetker on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @02:43PM (#18868077)
>Not sure whether your theories on there actually being an infrastructure for doing these sorts of things is correct, but even a 5 minute google search seems to suggest it is well within technical capabilities to do so.

The infrastructure would just be an (perhaps surveillance grade) RFID reader and a small office or locker where the suspect letters end up at each post sorting facility, so a security officer or perhaps just the branch manager can store these until the surveillance state replies what to do with the letter.

I also believe it is probable the standards are visible somewhere, just like I remember the bulk of the surveillance state in Europe was/is visible pre-snowden in very high detail through the ETSI (european technology and standards institute) standards.

> I doubt that the RFID is in the plastic containg the card, it's probably in the card itself.

I may have used the incorrect word with "contain", so first the SIM card and the PIN and PUK card are one and the same card, before breaking out the SIM card. I mereley suspect the larger PIN/PUK card to contain the RFID coil, because the perforated C-shape around the SIM has the open part of the C directed at the closest edge. Of course it is possible that the RFID coil is in the smaller piece of SIM card itself, but I don't think so because: the contact pads would provide shielding to the coil, and to have the same total area as a 4 turns in a Credit Card size, the coil would need many more loops. As a designer I would prefer putting the RFID loop in the larger card.

So I did not mean to say that the coil is in the plastic wrap or anything, in case that was how you understood me.

It may seem weird that (if I am right) the surveillance state designed the SIM cards so the connection with the RFID coil breaks, why not design it monolithically such that you can also track used SIM cards in the mail? I simply predict that there is demand for clean SIM cards on the market, and unopened prepaid packages are considered clean, but then the coil is not broken yet... so used SIM card's may turn out safer (if the previous usage was clean)...

I agree the holding times would be roughly reproducible, but I don't want to cram my file full of red flags...

Yeah, spying involves lots of deceit, and as everyone (hopefully) rememmbers from kindergarten, the web of lies only grows (and the observable inconsistencies grow with them)

If it hadn't been stalled, I would probably have ended up calling some friends from university time, probably only spent 2/3's of the call credit before it expires, then simply went on with my life. It's their reckless tradecraft that betrayed them. I have no problem talking openly about what I suspect, I am pretty sure plenty of actual criminals have noticed this before me, but they probably don't talk about it in public fora...

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by salawat on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @04:57PM (#18869375)
Oh,no worries. I just think that SIM and handset manufacturer's are going the route of integrating NFC into handsets to support SIM stored payment credentials. I know for a fact it's a hot item in the FinTech industry.

Odds are, you could get a generic reader to get a chirp out of an RFID even without the PIN/PUK card that wouldn't be present in any other package.

IF I were an evil surveillance state taking an interest in mail borne SIM cards in ANY state (I mean think about this, if you could automate it, figuring out the networks of people who often send SIM's to each other in and of itself is a useful data point) I'd exploit using a small machine that can be innocuously placed on the sorting line to get that chirp.

Biggest problem I imagine would be possible tipping off through damage caused to EMF/RF sensitive packages, but I've not really looked up the math or engineering involved enough to make an educated guess.

Like I said. Interesting problem, and I seriously hope you're not right. That's levels of cyberpunk dystopia that just shouldn't be possible in anything remotely resembling a healthy society.

[dead]
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by nothrabannosir on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:10PM (#18861714)
I'm afraid you accidentally posted your canned response about the GDPR next to an article that directly refutes it.

The opening paragraph of the article:

> Nervously, I gave a bounty hunter a phone number. He had offered to geolocate a phone for me, using a shady, overlooked service intended not for the cops, but for private individuals and businesses. Armed with just the number and a few hundred dollars, he said he could find the current location of most phones in the United States.

Do you own a phone?

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by zorga on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @03:15AM (#18863162)
And? That doesn't refute anything I said. And no it wasn't a canned response.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by rypskar on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @07:44AM (#18864272)
> It's not your data, it's my data about you, I own it, it's in my databases

And there you have the main difference between European and US laws and mindset. Because it is my data, you are only allowed to store it in your database as long as I say you can, and you can only use it for what I have agree on. Since it is my data you cannot give or sell it to anyone else

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by zorga on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:03PM (#18866385)
No, it isn't; the product of my labor belongs to me. Whether it's photographs of public spaces or data logged in public spaces, the data I put in the labor to collect belongs to me. If I write a book about you, it belongs to me, it doesn't matter that it contains data about you: you don't own everything that happens to be about you.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by jgalt212 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:36PM (#18859964)
I don't think it's enough or sufficient to make "bad" actions against the law. It's better and more comprehensive to make it difficult to take "bad" actions and "easy" to take good ones.

People break the law all the time, and if you're high enough up the food chain Eric Holder will leave you be.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by cabaalis on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @03:33PM (#18859362)
> More specifically, the screenshot showed a location in a particular neighborhood—just a couple of blocks from where the target was.

What gets me is that the writing on wall appears to be that this data did not come from an app on the phone but from the phone company themselves, data collection that is required by the government.

"A couple of blocks from where the target was" implies to me that it was locating the nearest tower. Lat/Long coordinates of the phone within 300 meters is required by the FCC to be received by the telephone companies for Phase II of Enhanced 911. They might be snapping the lat/long to the tower, and then calling that de-identified enough to sell.

If a bounty hunter can get your snapped lat/long on demand because of E911 requirements, you better believe a TLA can as well--and probably unsnapped.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by roywiggins on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @05:19PM (#18860321)
The government is supposed to need a warrant post-Carpenter:

https://www.lawfareblog.com/summary-supreme-court-rules-carp...

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by cabaalis on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @08:36PM (#18861565)
Thanks for that. The point I'm trying to make is that they create the framework for this stuff in seemingly obvious and necessary laws and regulations. Then, when it's needed, "Well look-a here! Good thing we forced that other unrelated thing. That's a nice personal locator you've got there."

Meaning: Thanks to e911, a seemingly perfectly acceptable requirement, we now carry around devices that can be used to locate us. Warrant or not. Because "Let's require everyone to carry around a transponder" doesn't work whereas "We are just trying to protect you!" does.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by roywiggins on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:35AM (#18862546)
Phone companies were able to triangulate phones before e911, right? e911 just makes it mandatory to have the triangulation hardware/software actually deployed and linked up with 911 call centers, but (GPS aside) I would have thought telcos could have done that on their own with or without e911.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by walshemj on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @05:36PM (#18860455)
So an offence against the espionage act then - it would probably be one under the official secrets act in the UK (unless your a tabloid journalist)
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by quicklime on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:34PM (#18859938)
Maybe we should think about location data in a similar way to photographs. Both are generated by smartphone hardware and software, but the person who presses the shutter button legally owns the copyright to the photo, not the device manufacturer or carrier.

Why don't I own the copyrights to my location data, and why doesn't the carrier need to license it from me in order to sell on to these bounty hunters?

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by baroffoos on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @09:15PM (#18861744)
The data is created by the phone towers that you connect to. Its a similar situation to when you visit a website and the server logs your request.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by rocqua on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:37PM (#18859980)
Regarding the actual copyright question: copyright requires 'creativity'.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by bluGill on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:45PM (#18860046)
The creative act here is my movement. If I go to an open space and walked the outline of an airplane I have created something, even if it can only be viewed in the data that the phone has collected, the creative act was mine.
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by michaelmrose on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @08:59AM (#18864691)
One cannot copyright facts else the first one to blurt out a truth would be the only one allowed to speak it. The fact that the truth contains facts about an artistic endeavor doesn't make the actual data about reality an artistic endeavor as the recording of those facts is in no way creative.

If you filmed yourself walking around like an airplane you would own the clip. Blog about it and you own the article. But the space you occupied at 10:35AM last Thursday is a singular indisputable fact with not an ounce of creativity. In fact more to the point even what they have is actually facts about their own equipment like which tower you were close to at that time which its hard to imagine you owning.

There are laws designed keep people from collecting and misusing your data in countries not run by morons. There is no reasonable way you are going to acquire this same privacy and protection by trying to misuse copyright creatively. I'm sure actual lawyers are likely to regard interesting legal theories the same way engineers regard interesting theories on how to make engines run forever for free via magnets.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by quicklime on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:51PM (#18860095)
Exactly. There are a lot of people out there doing Strava art, which to me is undoubtedly a creative work, and more creative than a typical selfie or vacation shot. I believe copyright covers all photographs, regardless of their artistic merit. Why not also location data?

For those unfamiliar with Strava art: https://www.cyclingweekly.com/news/latest-news/five-best-str...

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by eitland on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @02:07AM (#18862885)
I've been saying for a while (check my profile) that user data should be treated in much the same way as nuclear raw materials.

Meaning small amounts properly contained (i.e. in a smoke detector) is fine and if you need to collect and especially concentrate larger amounts you should need to go through a whole lot of useful hoops to weed away less serious companies.

Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by closeparen on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @06:29PM (#18870105)
Even if the subject had legal ownership and control over their cellular location data, they would certainly have to sign it over to the bondsman. Just like you sign over the right to hunt you down and physically capture you (which could otherwise be grounds for a lawsuit against the bounty hunter).
Re:Mobile customer location data is ending up in the hands o... by kmlx on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:30AM (#18862520)
“We had the concept of private and public property”

maybe in the western world. in a lot of other places the whole “privacy” thing is fuzzy.